Paper: arXiv 2508.10273

Authors: Drew M. Thomas

Abstract

What grounds the rule of thumb that a(n American) retiree can safely withdraw 4% of their initial retirement wealth in their first year of retirement, then increase that rate of consumption with inflation? I address that question with a discrete-time model of returns to a retirement portfolio consumed at a rate that grows by \(s\) per period. The model’s key parameter is \(γ\), an \(s\)-adjusted rate of return to wealth, derived from the first 2-4 moments of the portfolio’s probability distribution of returns; for a retirement lasting \(t\) periods the model recommends a rate of consumption of \(γ/ (1 - (1 - γ)^t)\). Estimation of \(γ\) (and hence of the implied rate of spending in retirement) reveals that the 4% rule emerges from adjusting high expected rates of return down for: consumption growth, the variance in (and kurtosis of) returns to wealth, the longevity risk of a retiree potentially underestimating \(t\), and the inclusion of bonds in retirement portfolios without leverage. The model supports leverage of retirement portfolios dominated by the S&P 500, with leverage ratios \(> 1.6\) having been historically optimal under the model’s approximations. Historical simulations of 30-year retirements suggest that the model proposes withdrawal rates having roughly even odds of success, that leverage greatly improves those odds for stocks-heavy portfolios, and that investing on margin could have allowed safe withdrawal rates \(> 6\)% per year.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 7.5/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 6.0/10
  • Quadrant: Holy Grail — high math complexity, high empirical rigor

Why this score: The paper uses advanced stochastic calculus and moment-based approximations (Taylor expansions, geometric sums) to model withdrawal rates, reflecting high math complexity. It also grounds its model in historical simulations and historical parameters (e.g., S&P 500 returns, leverage ratios), showing strong empirical backing, though it lacks implementation details or code for true backtesting.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
  A["Research Goal: What grounds the 4% withdrawal rule?"] --> B["Methodology: Discrete-time consumption model"]
  
  B --> C{"Inputs: Historical S&P 500 Data"}
  C --> D["Compute Sample Moments<br>Mean, Variance, Kurtosis"]
  
  D --> E["Calculate s-adjusted return rate γ<br>γ = f(mean, var, kurtosis)"]
  
  E --> F["Compute Consumption Rate Formula<br>c* = γ / 1 - 1-γ^t"]
  
  F --> G["Key Findings"]
  
  G --> H["4% Rule Explained:<br>High expected returns adjusted<br>down for variance, longevity risk"]
  G --> I["Optimal Leverage > 1.6x<br>for equity-heavy portfolios"]
  G --> J["Historical Simulation:<br>Safe SWR > 6% with leverage"]

Evidence Card

What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card

Proposes

The paper proposes a discrete‑time model of retirement portfolio returns that yields a closed‑form optimal withdrawal rate based on an s‑adjusted rate of return γ.

Source sentence
I address that question with a discrete-time model of returns to a retirement portfolio consumed at a rate that grows by $s$ per period.

Assumes 6

  • Returns are a stationary process with constant moments across periods. statistical
    Source sentence
    I normalize the 1 + rj terms by first assuming that r is a stationary process, which entails that r’s moments, including the expected value, are constant in all time periods.
  • Returns are independently distributed across periods. statistical
    Source sentence
    Assuming next that returns are not only stationary but independently distributed (i.e. that the return to wealth in period j provides no information about the return to wealth in any other period).
  • Leverage ratio l is non‑negative, finite and s > –1. model
    Source sentence
    Assuming s > −1, l non-negative and finite, and E[r] non-negative and finite, the first derivative is zero when the numerator of its fraction is zero...
  • ETF price series reflect actual fees and can be used as proxies for asset returns. data
    Source sentence
    Actual ETF prices offer the advantage of reflecting the actual fees charged to hold the relevant collections of assets.
Show 2 more
  • Shiller’s long‑run series provides a reliable historical return series back to 1871. data
    Source sentence
    I therefore pay more attention to the much longer, albeit coarser‑grained, time series of Shiller, which extend back through 1871.
  • Margin borrowing cost equals the effective federal funds rate plus a 100‑basis‑point spread. execution
    Source sentence
    charge 90–100 basis points per year above the annual EFFR as of mid‑2025.

Data

  • ETF monthly returns (S&P 500 and US Treasury Bonds) · Yahoo! Finance market-prices public
    spring 2024 (downloaded) · oldest ETFs representing the S&P 500 index and US Treasury Bonds
    Source sentence
    I selected the oldest ETFs I could find that represented the S&P 500 index of US equities, and US Treasury Bonds of different durations.
  • Shiller historical return series · Robert Shiller market-prices public
    1871‑present · US equities and Treasury bonds
    Source sentence
    I therefore pay more attention to the much longer, albeit coarser‑grained, time series of Shiller, which extend back through 1871.

Recognised sources: Twitter / X

Costs

Modeled Costs are part of the reported headline results.

Margin borrowing cost modeled as the effective federal funds rate plus a 100‑basis‑point spread (90–100 bps above EFFR as of mid‑2025).

Source sentence
charge 90–100 basis points per year above the annual EFFR as of mid‑2025.

Finds 5

  • The 4% rule emerges when high expected returns are adjusted down for consumption growth, variance, kurtosis, longevity risk, and bond inclusion. theoretical
    Source sentence
    γ … reveals that the 4% rule emerges from adjusting high expected rates of return down for: consumption growth, the variance in (and kurtosis of) returns to wealth, the longevity risk
  • Leverage ratios greater than 1.6 are historically optimal for portfolios dominated by the S&P 500. theoretical
    Source sentence
    The model supports leverage of retirement portfolios dominated by the S&P 500, with leverage ratios > 1.6 having been historically optimal under the model's approximations.
  • Using high‑frequency ETF data gives a first‑year withdrawal rate of about 6.4% for a 30‑year retirement, but long‑run Shiller data lower it to about 6.0% (or 5.2% for a 50/50 portfolio). performance
    Source sentence
    Switching to Shiller’s long‑run data produces a lower γ4 of 0.00356 … and
  • Optimal leverage levels depend on borrowing cost; with a 100‑bp spread the optimal l is 3.09 for a 60/40 portfolio, 1.92 for equities, and 0.10 for bonds. theoretical
    Source sentence
    the optimal ls are 3.09 for the 60/40 portfolio, 1.92 for equities alone, and just 0.10 for bonds alone.
  • Even with cheap leverage, withdrawal rates above 6.6% per year could be rendered reasonably safe in simulations. performance
    Source sentence
    could have rendered withdrawal rates of 6.6% per year or more reasonably safe.

Checked by others

No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 46 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.

Code

No repository by the authors found in the paper.

Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.