Paper: arXiv 2310.14748

Authors: Jaydip Sen, Arup Dasgupta, Partha Pratim Sengupta, Sayantani Roy Choudhury

Abstract

This chapter presents a comparative study of the three portfolio optimization methods, MVP, HRP, and HERC, on the Indian stock market, particularly focusing on the stocks chosen from 15 sectors listed on the National Stock Exchange of India. The top stocks of each cluster are identified based on their free-float market capitalization from the report of the NSE published on July 1, 2022 (NSE Website). For each sector, three portfolios are designed on stock prices from July 1, 2019, to June 30, 2022, following three portfolio optimization approaches. The portfolios are tested over the period from July 1, 2022, to June 30, 2023. For the evaluation of the performances of the portfolios, three metrics are used. These three metrics are cumulative returns, annual volatilities, and Sharpe ratios. For each sector, the portfolios that yield the highest cumulative return, the lowest volatility, and the maximum Sharpe Ratio over the training and the test periods are identified.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 3.5/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 6.0/10 (capped from 8.0: transaction costs not modelled; see penalty flags)
  • Quadrant: Street Traders — empirical and applied, lower math complexity (effective empirical rigor capped from 8.0)

Why this score: The paper applies standard, well-documented optimization methods (MVP, HRP, HERC) without developing new mathematical theory, keeping math complexity low. However, it demonstrates high empirical rigor by performing a structured backtest on real, sector-specific Indian market data (NSE) over defined training/test periods using standard performance metrics.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
  Goal["<b>Research Goal:</b><br>Compare Portfolio Optimization Methods<br>for the Indian Stock Market"] --> Inputs
  subgraph Inputs ["<b>Data & Inputs</b>"]
      direction LR
      S1["Stocks: Top 3 from<br>15 NSE Sectors"]
      S2["Periods: Training<br>Jul 2019 - Jun 2022"]
      S3["Test: Jul 2022 - Jun 2023"]
  end
  Inputs --> Methods
  subgraph Methods ["<b>Methodology (3 Approaches)</b>"]
      direction LR
      M1["MVP:<br>Mean-Variance"]
      M2["HRP:<br>Hierarchical Risk Parity"]
      M3["HERC:<br>Hierarchical Equal Risk Contribution"]
  end
  Methods --> Process
  subgraph Process ["<b>Computational Process</b>"]
      P1["Train: Generate Portfolios<br>per Sector & Method"]
      P2["Test: Evaluate Performance<br>over 1 Year"]
  end
  Process --> Metrics
  subgraph Metrics ["<b>Evaluation Metrics</b>"]
      direction LR
      E1["Cumulative Return"]
      E2["Annual Volatility"]
      E3["Sharpe Ratio"]
  end
  Metrics --> Findings
  Findings["<b>Key Findings/Outcomes</b><br>Identified Optimal Portfolios per Sector<br>Based on Highest Return,<br>Lowest Volatility, Max Sharpe Ratio"]

Evidence Card

What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card

Proposes

The paper conducts a comparative study of three portfolio optimization methods—Mean‑Variance (MVP), Hierarchical Risk Parity (HRP), and Hierarchical Equal Risk Contribution (HERC)—on Indian stocks across 15 sectors.

Source sentence
This chapter presents a comparative study of the three portfolio optimization methods, MVP, HRP, and HERC, on the Indian stock market, particularly focusing on the stocks chosen from 15 sectors listed on the National Stock Exchange of India.

Assumes 5

  • There are 250 operational trading days in a calendar year for annualizing volatility. statistical
    Source sentence
    Assuming that there are 250 operational days in a calendar year, the annual volatility values for the stocks are derived by multiplying the daily volatilities by a square root of 250.
  • Daily returns are computed as percentage change of closing prices. data
    Source sentence
    For computing the daily returns, the pct_change function of Python is used.
  • Only closing prices are used to design the portfolios. execution
    Source sentence
    The close values of the stocks are used in designing the portfolios.
  • The historical price series from Yahoo Finance are accurate and complete for the selected period. data
    Source sentence
    From the Yahoo Finance website, the historical daily prices of the stocks are extracted from July 1, 2019, to June 30, 2023, using the DataReader function of the pandas_datareader module of Python.
Show 1 more
  • The top ten stocks per sector are identified by free‑float market capitalization as of June 30 2022. data
    Source sentence
    The monthly reports of the NSE identify the ten stocks with the maximum free‑float capitalization from each sector. In this work, the report published on June 30, 2022, is used for identifying the ten stocks from each of the fourteen sectors.

Data

Backtest sample: 2022-07 – 2023-06 · Indian stock market · equities · daily

  • Yahoo Finance daily price data · Yahoo Finance market-prices public
    2019-07-01 to 2023-06-30 · Top 10 stocks from each of 14 NSE sectors plus NIFTY‑50 stocks
    Source sentence
    From the Yahoo Finance website, the historical daily prices of the stocks are extracted from July 1, 2019, to June 30, 2023, using the DataReader function of the pandas_datareader module of Python.
  • NSE free‑float market‑cap report · National Stock Exchange of India (NSE) fundamentals public
    2022-06-30 · All listed stocks; top 10 per sector selected
    Source sentence
    The monthly reports of the NSE identify the ten stocks with the maximum free‑float capitalization from each sector. In this work, the report published on June 30, 2022, is used for identifying the ten stocks from each of the fourteen sectors, and the 50 stocks from NIFTY 50.

Recognised sources: Yahoo Finance

Costs

Not modeled A trading or execution result is reported without costs.

Finds 5

  • On training data, MVP portfolios achieved the highest Sharpe ratios in 8 of 15 sectors and the lowest volatilities in 14 of 15 sectors. performance
    Source sentence
    MVP portfolios outperformed the other two approaches yielding the lowest volatilities for 14 among the 15 sectors.
  • On test data, HERC portfolios delivered the highest Sharpe ratios in 8 of 15 sectors, outperforming MVP and HRP. performance
    Source sentence
    On the test data, HERC portfolios are found to be superior based on the Sharpe ratios, yielding the highest values of the ratio for 8 among the 15 sectors.
  • MVP portfolios produced the highest annual returns on test data in 7 of 15 sectors, while HERC led in 6 sectors. performance
    Source sentence
    Based on the maximization of the annual returns, MVP portfolios performed the best producing the highest returns for 7 among the 15 sectors on the test data. ... the number of sectors for which HRP and HERC portfolios yielded the highest returns are 2 and 6, respectively.
  • MVP portfolios achieved the lowest annual volatilities on test data in 10 of 15 sectors. performance
    Source sentence
    MVP portfolios outperformed their counterparts based on minimization of the annual volatilities, producing the lowest volatilities for 10 among the 15 sectors.
  • The FMCG sector showed the highest risk‑adjusted returns, NIFTY‑50 the lowest volatility, and PSU banks the highest returns on test data. performance
    Source sentence
    Based on the performance of the portfolios on the test data, it is also observed that the FMCG sector has currently the maximum prospects yielding the highest risk‑adjusted returns, the NIFTY 50 stocks have the lowest volatility, and the PSU banks stocks are most likely to yield higher returns compared to the other sec

Checked by others

No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 15 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.

Code

No repository by the authors found in the paper.

Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.