Paper: arXiv 2311.06282
Authors: Jiaer He, Roberto Rivera
Abstract
Popular investment structured products in Puerto Rico are stock market tied Individual Retirement Accounts (IRA), which offer some stock market growth while protecting the principal. The performance of these retirement strategies has not been studied. This work examines the expected return and risk of Puerto Rico stock market IRA (PRIRAs) and compares their statistical properties with other investment instruments before and after tax. We propose a parametric modeling approach for structured products and apply it to PRIRAs. Our method first estimates the conditional expected return (and variance) of PRIRA assets from which we extract marginal moments through the Law of Iterated Expectation. Our results indicate that PRIRAs underperform against investing directly in the stock market while still carrying substantial risk. The expected return of the stock market IRA from Popular Bank (PRIRA1) after tax is slightly greater than that of investing in U.S. bonds, while PRIRA1 has almost two times the risk. The stock market IRA from Universal (PRIRA2) performs similarly to PRIRA1, while PRIRA2 has a lower risk than PRIRA1. PRIRAs may be reasonable for some risk-averse investors due to their principal protection and tax deferral.
Complexity vs Empirical Score
- Math Complexity: 6.5/10
- Empirical Rigor: 3.0/10
- Quadrant: Lab Rats — high math complexity, limited empirical testing
Why this score: The paper employs advanced mathematical concepts like the law of iterated expectation, total variance, and truncated normal distributions, scoring high in math complexity. However, it lacks backtests or real-time implementation details, relying on historical data analysis and theoretical modeling rather than actionable trading strategies, resulting in lower empirical rigor.
Research Flowchart
flowchart TD
A["Research Goal:<br>Model & Analyze Puerto Rico IRAs"] --> B["Data & Inputs:<br>PRIRA Historical Performance Data"]
B --> C["Methodology:<br>Parametric Modeling Approach"]
C --> D{"Computational Process:<br>Law of Iterated Expectations"}
D --> E["Calculate Conditional<br>Expected Return & Variance"]
E --> F["Extract Marginal Moments<br>from Asset Data"]
F --> G["Key Findings/Outcomes:<br>Risk-Return Analysis vs. Benchmarks"]
G --> H1["PRIRAs < Market Portfolio<br>Higher Risk vs Bonds"]
G --> H2["PRIRA2 < PRIRA1<br>Lower Risk Profile"]
G --> H3["Principal Protection + Tax Deferral<br>Viable for Risk-Averse"]
Evidence Card
What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card
Proposes
The paper proposes a parametric modeling approach for structured investment products and applies it to Puerto Rico stock market IRAs.
Source sentence
We propose a parametric modeling approach for structured products and apply it to PRIRAs.
Assumes 6
- The annual expected return of a savings account is 0.25%. market
Source sentence
We assume the annual expected return of a savings account is 0.25%.
- Annual expected return and risk for index fund, bond market fund, and diversified portfolio are estimated by sample mean and sample standard deviation. statistical
Source sentence
For the annual expected return and risk for index fund, bond market fund, and diversified portfolio, we will use the sample mean and sample standard deviation, respectively.
- Investment horizons are 10 and 30 years. model
Source sentence
We assume investment horizons of 10 and 30-years.
- Investor contributes $10,000 per year and makes no withdrawals during the investment period. execution
Source sentence
To ease the comparison of the return for each strategy, we arbitrarily assume that the investor invests $10,000 per year
Show 2 more
- Tax treatment: PRIRA portfolio value before tax equals after‑tax value; dividend tax is applied each year; capital gains tax is paid at the end. other
Source sentence
In this work, we assume that the investor exploits the compound interest effect to the fullest by not withdrawing money during the whole investing period. Thus, we just need to consider the dividend tax. After the investment period, the investor must pay capital gain taxes, as investors who own PRIRAs must.
- The 10‑yr U.S. T‑bond yield (average 5.96%) is used as the risk‑free rate for Sharpe ratio calculations. market
Source sentence
We use the 10-yr U.S. T-bond yield as the risk-free rate to calculate the Sharpe ratio. The average 10-yr U.S. T-bond over all periods is about 5.96%.
Data
- S&P 500 closing prices market-prices public
Source sentence
Closing prices of the S&P 500 were used to establish the initial index value and monthly end index value from April 1957 to March 2019 to calculate PRIRA1 returns.
- Annual return rate and dividend return rate of stock market index fund and bond market ind market-prices public
Source sentence
All the data was downloaded from Yahoo! Finance.
Costs
Unclear
Finds 4
- PRIRAs underperform direct stock market investment while still carrying substantial risk. performance
Source sentence
Our results indicate that PRIRAs underperform against investing directly in the stock market while still carrying substantial risk.
- After tax, PRIRA1's expected return is slightly greater than U.S. bonds but its risk is almost twice that of bonds. performance
Source sentence
The expected return of the stock market IRA from Popular Bank (PRIRA1) after tax is slightly greater than that of investing in U.S. bonds, while PRIRA1 has almost two times the risk.
- PRIRA2 has similar return to PRIRA1 with lower risk. performance
Source sentence
The stock market IRA from Universal (PRIRA2) performs similarly to PRIRA1, while PRIRA2 has a lower risk than PRIRA1.
- Sharpe ratios of VFINX and diversified portfolio remain positive and higher than PRIRAs, while VBMFX Sharpe ratios become negative under tax. statistical
Source sentence
Despite the reduction in expected returns in the VFINX and diversified portfolios, the Sharpe ratio of VFINX and the diversified portfolio were positive and far greater than that of PRIRAs
Checked by others
Contradicted by
- Asset Returns, Portfolio Choice, and Proportional Wealth Taxation
Compare the findings
This paper: Sharpe ratios of VFINX and diversified portfolio remain positive and higher than PRIRAs, while VBMFX Sharpe ratios become negative under tax.
That paper: The wealth tax is orthogonal to portfolio choice, preserving the Sharpe ratio of every portfolio.
Code
No repository by the authors found in the paper.
Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.