Paper: arXiv 2503.01629

Authors: Cedric Schuhmann, Benjamin Köhler, Anton J. Heckens, Thomas Guhr

Abstract

Traders on financial markets generate non-Markovian effects in various ways, particularly through their competition with one another which can be interpreted as a game between different (types of) traders. To quantify the market mechanisms, we empirically analyze self-response functions for pairs of different stocks and the corresponding trade sign correlators. While the non-Markovian dynamics in the self-responses is liquidity-driven, it is expectation-driven in the cross-responses which is related to the emergence of correlations. We empirically study the non-stationarity of these responses over time. In our previous data analysis, we only investigated the crisis year 2008. We now considerably extend this by also analyzing the years 2007, 2014 and 2021. To improve statistics, we also work out averaged response functions for the different years. We find significant variations over time revealing changes in the traders’ game.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 6.5/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 7.0/10
  • Quadrant: Holy Grail — high math complexity, high empirical rigor

Why this score: The paper employs advanced mathematical frameworks like response functions and correlators with formal definitions (e.g., Eq. 1-2), while being grounded in heavy empirical analysis of high-frequency TAQ data across multiple years with detailed data processing and statistical reporting.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
  Start["Research Goal:<br>Analyze traders' game dynamics<br>across different time periods"] --> DataInput["Data Input:<br>High-frequency trade data<br>Years: 2007, 2008, 2014, 2021"]
  DataInput --> Methodology["Methodology:<br>Calculate Self- & Cross-Response<br>Functions & Trade Sign Correlators"]
  Methodology --> Computation["Computation:<br>Estimate Non-Markovian Dynamics<br>and Liquidity vs. Expectation Effects"]
  Computation --> Analysis["Analysis:<br>Compare Averaged Responses<br>across different time periods"]
  Analysis --> Findings["Key Findings:<br>1. Significant variation in traders' game over time<br>2. Liquidity-driven (self) vs Expectation-driven (cross) dynamics"]
  Findings --> Outcome["Outcome:<br>Empirical evidence of non-stationary<br>market mechanisms and evolving<br>trader competition strategies"]

Evidence Card

What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card

Proposes

The paper empirically extends the analysis of self‑ and cross‑response functions and trade‑sign correlators from the crisis year 2008 to the years 2007, 2014 and 2021, providing averaged response functions and investigating their non‑stationarity over time.

Source sentence
Further details have been explored, such as the market collective response [42] and the role of asymmetric information in market impacts [43] Here, we extend the analysis of Refs. [30, 31, 32] for the year 2008 by studying the years 2007, 2014 and 2021. In doing so, we rely on the well–established and theoretically explored framework of self– and cross–response functions in returns and trade signs [30, 31, 32, 33,

Assumes 6

  • The finest available time resolution for 2007 and 2008 is one second, and non‑Markovian effects are considered relevant on time scales much larger than one second. data
    Source sentence
    For 2007 and 2008, one second is the finest available time grid resolution possible [30, 31, 32]. For the years 2014 and 2021 considerably higher temporal resolutions up to nanoseconds for 2021 are available, but anticipating later findings, we point out that the non–Markovian effects are relevant on time scales much larger than one second.
  • Trade sign zeroes are excluded from some analyses, which affects the sign of the trade‑sign series and the resulting correlations. statistical
    Source sentence
    Excluding the trade sign zero makes the analysis more similar to studying markets on a trading time scale. Only when zero trade signs are not included, Eq. (6) is a time–lagged correlation as the time series of trade signs then have unit variance.
  • Midpoint prices are used as a proxy for order‑book dynamics instead of trade prices. market
    Source sentence
    We use the midpoint price mi(t) = ai(t) + bi(t) 2 as average of the best as ai(t) and best bid bi(t) for stock i in the order book where t runs in one–second steps. Here, we use the midpoint prices instead of the trade prices as we are also interested in the dynamics of the order book near the midpoint between consecutive trades.
  • Averaging across all stocks and stock pairs yields representative market‑wide response functions. statistical
    Source sentence
    4.1 and 4.3, we work out the responses and trade sign correlations for the whole market by averaging across all individual stocks and stock pairs, respectively. Market Response Functions We obtain a better statistical significance for the estimation of market self– and cross– impact by averaging across all self–responses R s(τ) = ⟨⟨Rii(τ)⟩i⟩i (7) and across all cross-responses R c(τ) = ⟨⟨Rij(τ)⟩j⟩i , for i̸ = j (8)
Show 2 more
  • The set of 99 stocks selected for 2008 can be used as a common universe for the other years after replacing delisted stocks with high‑liquidity equivalents. data
    Source sentence
    To compare different years, our focus is on selecting the same 99 stocks as in 2008 for all years. We replace the stocks delisted in a respective economic sector by high–liquid stocks from the same economic sector, i.e by stocks with a high trading value.
  • The trade sign self‑correlator and cross‑correlator can be approximated by power‑law functions over the examined time lags. model
    Source sentence
    The power law trend is fitted very well by the function Θ κ(τ) = ϑ κ (1 + (τ/τ κ)2)γ κ/2 , κ = s, c . (11) We list the fit parameters ϑ κ, τ κ and γ κ, κ = s, c, in Tab. 2.

Data

  • Daily TAQ (Trade and Quote) of the New York Stock Exchange · NYSE order-book public
    2007, 2008, 2014, 2021 · most US stocks; 99 stocks selected for consistency across years
    Source sentence
    Data set We use the Daily TAQ (Trade and Quote) of the New York stock exchange (NYSE) [44] for the years 2007, 2008, 2014 and 2021. This data set records the trading activity of most stocks on the US stock markets, i.e. the prices are listed in the trade file and best bid and ask prices in the quote file.
  • NASDAQ high‑liquidity stock sample (10 stocks per sector) · NASDAQ market-prices public
    2008 · 10 stocks with high liquidity from each of the ten GICS sectors
    Source sentence
    We also analyze the stocks as in Refs. [30, 31, 32] from the NASDAQ stock exchange for 2008, i.e. ten stocks with high liquidity from each of the ten economic sectors according to the Global Industry Classification Standard (GICS) see Tab. 1. In the case of the telecommu-nications sector, the number of available stocks is limited to nine.

Recognised sources: NYSE TAQ

Costs

Not applicable The paper reports no trading or execution result.

Finds 5

  • Significant variations in self‑ and cross‑response functions over time reveal changes in the traders’ game, with larger responses during the 2008 crisis. statistical
    Source sentence
    We find significant variations over time revealing changes in the traders' game. First, the responses for the crisis year of 2008 are larger than for the other years.
  • Self‑responses for 2014 and 2021 increase for larger time lags and remain at higher levels than in 2007, indicating a lasting effect of the crisis. statistical
    Source sentence
    The self–responses of 2014 and 2021 indicate that self–responses increasing for larger time lags are quite stable over time. The higher values in the self–responses for 2014 and 2021 compared to 2007 indicate that the crisis has had a lasting influence on the trader’s actions.
  • Both market self‑responses and cross‑responses become less concave in 2014 and 2021, suggesting a shift possibly linked to algorithmic trading. statistical
    Source sentence
    Second, both market self–responses and cross–responses are strikingly less concave. The shape of the self– and cross–responses is no longer concave for 2014 and 2021 hinting at different causes, i.e. the algorithmic trading might have changed the responses.
  • Trade‑sign self‑correlator exponents γ_s are below 0.8 in 2007 (long‑term memory) and above one in 2021 (short‑term memory), with a distinct regime change around 100–1000 s. statistical figure from elsewhere in the paper
    Source sentence
    The results for γ s and γ c are interesting as values above one indicate short–term memory and values smaller than one long–term memory [46]. For 2007, we notice values smaller than 0.8, for the other years they are larger except for the year 2014 when excluding trade sign zero.
  • Passive and active cross‑response functions show different time‑scale behavior in 2007 and 2008, but not in 2014 and 2021. statistical
    Source sentence
    The time scales of the passive and active response functions are different for 2007 and 2008, while we do not observe such behavior for 2014 and 2021.

Checked by others

No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 21 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.

Cited by 1 paper in the archive

Code

No repository by the authors found in the paper.

Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.

Cited References (56)

  1. A bibliometric review of Market Microstructure literature: Current status, development, and future directions (2024) — link
  2. When is cross impact relevant? — → 2305.16915
  3. New collectivity measures for financial covariances and correlations (2022) — link
  4. Cross-impact of order flow imbalance in equity markets (2021) — link
  5. A new attempt to identify long-term precursors for endogenous financial crises in the market correlation structures (2021) — link
  6. Order flow and price formation (2021) — link
  7. Foreign exchange markets: Price response and spread impact (2021) — link
  8. Price response functions and spread impact in correlated financial markets (2020) — link
and 48 more
  1. Uncovering the dynamics of correlation structures relative to the collective market motion (2020) — link
  2. How spread changes affect the order book: comparing the price responses of order deletions and placements to trades (2018) — link
  3. Statistical properties of market collective responses (2017) — link
  4. Grasping asymmetric information in price impacts (2017) — link
  5. Cross-impact and no-dynamic-arbitrage (2016) — link
  6. Microscopic Understanding of Cross-Responses between Stocks: a Two-Component Price Impact Model (2016) — link
  7. Dissecting cross-impact on stock markets: an empirical analysis (2016) — link
  8. Trading volume in financial markets: An introductory review (2016) — link
  9. Cross-response in correlated financial markets: individual stocks (2016) — link
  10. Average cross-responses in correlated financial markets (2016) — link
  11. A dynamical-systems interpretation of the dissipation function, T-mixing and their relation to thermodynamic relaxation (2016) — link
  12. Price response in correlated financial markets: empirical results (2015) — link
  13. High frequency market microstructure. (2015) — link
  14. Strategic Cross-Trading in the U.S. Stock Market (2015) — link
  15. Hawkes model for price and trades high-frequency dynamics (2013) — link
  16. Why Is Equity Order Flow so Persistent (2011) — link
  17. Price Dynamics in a Markovian Limit Order Market (2011) — link
  18. The Price Impact of Order Book Events (2010) — link
  19. A Theory for Market Impact: How Order Flow Affects Stock Price (2008) — link
  20. Stock price jumps: news and volume play a minor role (2008) — link
  21. Fluctuation-dissipation: Response theory in statistical physics (2008) — link
  22. Empirical Market Microstructure: The Institutions, Economics, and Econometrics of Securities Trading (2007)
  23. Theory for long memory in supply and demand. (2004) — link
  24. Random walks, liquidity molasses and critical response in financial markets (2004) — link
  25. Order imbalance and individual stock returns: theory and evidence (2004) — link
  26. Order book approach to price impact (2003) — link
  27. The Long Memory of the Efficient Market (2003) — link
  28. Fluctuations and response in financial markets: the subtle nature of ‘random’ price changes (2003) — link
  29. Order Imbalance, Liquidity, and Market Returns (2003) — link
  30. Events that Shook the Market (2002) — link
  31. A New Method to Estimate the Noise in Financial Correlation Matrices (2002) — link
  32. Random matrix approach to cross correlations in financial data. (2001) — link
  33. Commonality in Liquidity (2000) — link
  34. Noise Dressing of Financial Correlation Matrices (1998) — link
  35. What moves stock prices? (1989) — link
  36. Continuous Auctions and Insider Trading (1985) — link
  37. Bid, ask and transaction prices in a specialist market with heterogeneously informed traders (1985) — link
  38. Price impact: Information revelation or self-fulfilling prophecies? (2023)
  39. Multi-Asset Market Impact and Order Flow Commonality (2020) — link
  40. Algorithmic trading methods: Applications using advanced statistics, optimization, and machine learning techniques (2020)
  41. Agent-Based Models for Market Impact and Volatility (2018) — link
  42. Efficient Capital Markets: A Review of Theory and Empirical Work (2017) — link
  43. New York stock exchange, Daily TAQ (Trade and Quote) (2014)
  44. Informed Trading and Portfolio Returns (2013) — link
  45. CHAPTER 2 – How Markets Slowly Digest Changes in Supply and Demand (2009) — link
  46. Comments welcome (1998)
  47. Statistics for long-memory processes (1994) — link
  48. We thank Shanshan Wang for fruitful discussions, we are particularly grateful to Rüdiger Kiesel for helpful remarks on the economics literature

1 of 56 cited works are in the corpus; resolved via arXiv source bundles, Semantic Scholar and OpenAlex. Corpus-wide: 2596 linked papers.