Paper: arXiv 2512.03123
Authors: Amit Kumar Jha
Abstract
This paper develops a comprehensive theoretical framework that imports concepts from stochastic thermodynamics to model price impact and characterize the feasibility of round-trip arbitrage in financial markets. A trading cycle is treated as a non-equilibrium thermodynamic process, where price impact represents dissipative work and market noise plays the role of thermal fluctuations. The paper proves a Financial Second Law: under general convex impact functionals, any round-trip trading strategy yields non-positive expected profit. This structural constraint is complemented by a fluctuation theorem that bounds the probability of profitable cycles in terms of dissipated work and market volatility. The framework introduces a statistical ensemble of trading strategies governed by a Gibbs measure, leading to a free energy decomposition that connects expected cost, strategy entropy, and a market temperature parameter. The framework provides rigorous, testable inequalities linking microstructural impact to macroscopic no-arbitrage conditions, offering a novel physics-inspired perspective on market efficiency. The paper derives explicit analytical results for prototypical trading strategies and discusses empirical validation protocols.
Complexity vs Empirical Score
- Math Complexity: 9.0/10
- Empirical Rigor: 2.0/10
- Quadrant: Lab Rats — high math complexity, limited empirical testing
Why this score: The paper employs advanced mathematical concepts from stochastic thermodynamics, including Itô calculus, convex analysis, large deviation theory, and rigorous proofs of structural theorems, leading to a high math complexity score. However, it presents only theoretical frameworks and analytical derivations with no data, code, backtests, or implementation details for empirical validation, resulting in low empirical rigor.
Research Flowchart
flowchart TD
A["Research Goal: Model Price Impact & Arbitrage<br>via Stochastic Thermodynamics"] --> B["Key Methodology<br>Thermodynamic Trading Cycle Framework"]
subgraph B ["Methodology"]
direction TB
M1["Import Stochastic Thermodynamics<br>to Financial Processes"]
M2["Treat Price Impact as Dissipative Work<br>& Market Noise as Thermal Fluctuations"]
M3["Define Gibbs Measure for<br>Trading Strategy Ensemble"]
end
B --> C["Computational Processes & Data<br>Derivation of Theoretical Bounds"]
subgraph C ["Computational Processes"]
direction TB
P1["Derive Financial Second Law<br>Convex Impact → Non-Positive Expected Profit"]
P2["Apply Fluctuation Theorem<br>Bound P(Profitable Cycle) vs Dissipation"]
P3["Perform Free Energy Decomposition<br>Connect Cost, Entropy, & Market Temp"]
end
C --> D["Key Findings & Outcomes"]
subgraph D ["Outcomes"]
direction TB
F1["Structural No-Arbitrage Constraint"]
F2["Testable Microstructural Inequalities"]
F3["Physics-Inspired Market Efficiency View"]
end
Evidence Card
What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card
Proposes
The paper proposes a stochastic thermodynamics framework that models price impact as dissipated work and characterizes round‑trip arbitrage as a thermodynamic cycle.
Source sentence
This paper develops a comprehensive theoretical framework that imports concepts from stochastic thermodynamics to model price impact and characterize the feasibility of round-trip arbitrage in financial markets.
Assumes 3
- I(0) = J(0) = 0. model
Source sentence
The impact functions satisfy: (i) I(0) = J (0) = 0.
- The composite functional f(v) = J(v)v is strictly convex and positive for v ≠ 0. model
Source sentence
(ii) The composite functional f(v) := J (v)v is strictly convex and f(v) > 0 for v̸ = 0.
- Linear permanent impact: I(v) = λ v for some constant λ ≥ 0. model
Source sentence
(iii) Linear Permanent Impact: I(v) = λv for some constant λ ≥0.
Data
- High‑frequency trade‑and‑quote (TAQ) data from liquid markets market-prices unknown
Source sentence
Data Collection: High-frequency trade-and-quote (TAQ) data from liquid markets, following protocols in [Has07, CJP15]. 2.
Costs
Not applicable
Finds 4
- Financial Second Law: under the convexity and linear permanent impact assumptions, any round‑trip strategy has non‑positive expected profit, with equality only for the trivial strategy. theoretical
Source sentence
Under Assumption 1, for any round-trip strategy v ∈AT : E[ΠT ] = −W[v] ≤0, (7) with equality if and only if vt = 0 almost everywhere. Proof.
- Fluctuation theorem: the probability of a profitable round‑trip is exponentially suppressed in the ratio of dissipated work to market volatility. theoretical
Source sentence
This structural constraint is complemented by a fluctuation theorem that bounds the probability of profitable cycles in terms of dissipated work and market volatility.
- For a triangular round‑trip strategy the P&L is Gaussian with mean –α v̄² T (negative) and variance σ² v̄² T³/12, confirming that expected loss equals the work dissipated. theoretical
Source sentence
The round-trip P&L for the triangular strategy is Gaussian: ΠT ∼N −α¯v2T, σ2 ¯v2T 3 12 . (31) Proof.
- A smooth ramping strategy reduces impact cost by a factor of three compared with the abrupt triangular strategy (Wramp = 1/3 Wtri). theoretical
Source sentence
Comparing this to the triangular strategy (Wtri = α¯v2T), we see that Wramp = 1 3Wtri.
Checked by others
No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 14 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.
Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.