Paper: arXiv 2611.26200

Authors: Ahmad Qadi, Thomas Schröder, Francesca Medda

Abstract

This paper builds a scenario engine that maps a yield-curve path into a distribution of macro-financial outcomes. A three-factor Hull-White model generates arbitrage-free curves whose factors are simulated under the physical measure, with an estimated and reported market price of risk. A Minnesota-prior VARX maps the simulated curves into weekly equity returns, the federal funds rate, the Weekly Economic Index, inflation and a bank Marginal Expected Shortfall proxy, with a sign-restricted policy shock adapted to weekly data. Evaluated out of sample from 2017 to 2024, the term-structure block has the lowest forecast error in 13 of 20 maturity and horizon cells, and the density forecasts are well calibrated for the continuously moving variables. At weekly frequency the curve carries no incremental information about these variables once their own lags are controlled for, so the engine’s value lies in conditioning on a specified curve path, which no benchmark can do.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 8.0/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 8.0/10
  • Quadrant: Holy Grail — high math complexity, high empirical rigor

Why this score: The paper demonstrates high mathematical sophistication in its Hull-White model and VARX framework, coupled with robust out-of-sample empirical evaluation. Its novel integration of arbitrage-free term structure modeling with macro-financial stress forecasting under the physical measure is a significant contribution. The clarity and completeness of the exposition are also commendable.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
    A["Research Goal: Build Scenario Engine Mapping Yield-Curve Path to Macro-Financial Outcomes"] --> B{"Key Methodology: Hull-White & VARX Models"};
    B --> C{"Inputs: Yield Curve Data, Macro-Financial Time Series"};
    C --> D["Process: Generate Arbitrage-Free Curves via 3-Factor Hull-White Model"];
    D --> E["Process: Map Curves to Macro-Financial Outcomes via Minnesota-Prior VARX"];
    E --> F{"Key Findings: Lower Forecast Error for Term Structure, Well-Calibrated Density Forecasts, Engine Value in Conditioning on Curve Path"};

Evidence Card

What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card

Proposes

The paper builds a transparent, reproducible scenario engine that converts a yield‑curve path into a conditional macro‑financial distribution.

Source sentence
This paper builds the missing piece: a transparent, reproducible engine that converts a yield-curve path into a conditional macro-financial distribution, and evaluates it to the standard normally applied to forecasting models.

Assumes 6

  • A three‑factor Gaussian Hull‑White model is used to generate arbitrage‑free curves. model
    Source sentence
    The first is a three-factor Gaussian Hull–White model (Hull and White, 1990).
  • The Hull‑White factors are simulated under the physical (P) measure, estimated from fifteen years of weekly curve history. model
    Source sentence
    Its curves are priced under the risk-neutral measure, so they are arbitrage-free and reproduce the observed discount curve exactly, but the factors that drive them are simulated under the physical measure, estimated from fifteen years of weekly curve history.
  • An explicitly estimated market price of risk links the risk‑neutral and physical measures. model
    Source sentence
    An explicitly estimated market price of risk links the two. This paper keeps both: curves are priced risk-neutrally, so they are arbitrage-free, and the factors are simulated under the physical measure, with an explicit market price of risk joining the two.
  • Macro‑financial variables are modeled in first differences to ensure stationarity. statistical
    Source sentence
    The VARX endogenous block contains five weekly vari-ables, all in first differences for stationarity: the S&P 500 weekly log return (mkt_ret); the 6 weekly change in the effective federal funds rate, in decimals (dffr); the weekly change in the Weekly Economic Index of Lewis et al. (2022) (dwei); the weekly change in year-on-year CPI inflation, forward-filled from monthly releases (dinf);
Show 2 more
  • The splice‑week factor change from the LIBOR–OIS basis adjustment is set to zero in the differenced series. data
    Source sentence
    The jump is an artefact of the change of curve, not a market move, and it is kept out of every estimate that uses weekly changes: the splice-week factor change is set to zero in the differenced series, which is equivalent to level-adjusting the SOFR curve to the LIBOR curve at the splice date for that purpose, and the transition across the splice is excluded from the factor-dynamics and volatility estimates.
  • The VARX structural identification uses sign restrictions and a relevance filter on the policy‑rate loading. model
    Source sentence
    3.5 Structural Identification A contractionary monetary-policy shock is identified by sign restrictions (Uhlig, 2005; Rubio-Ramírez et al., 2010), which do not pin down a single shock but a set of admissible ones, augmented by a relevance filter on the policy-rate loading and by magnitude caps.

Data

  • LSEG U.S. dollar zero‑coupon yield‑curve panel · London Stock Exchange Group market-prices commercial
    June 2010–December 2024 · U.S. dollar Treasury zero‑coupon curves
    Source sentence
    3 Methodology 3.1 Data The analysis combines macro-financial series from January 2008 with a London Stock Exchange Group (LSEG) zero-coupon yield-curve panel from June 2010. The earlier macro start date supports lagged and rolling variable construction; the VARX sample is governed by zero-curve availability and runs from July 2010 to December 2024 after Friday end-of-week alignment and differencing. Yield-curve data.
  • LIBOR swap zero‑coupon curve (up to June 2020) and SOFR OIS curve (after June 2020) · London Stock Exchange Group market-prices commercial
    up to June 2020 / after June 2020 · Swap and OIS zero‑coupon curves
    Source sentence
    The term-structure block uses LSEG U.S. dollar zero-coupon curves, a LIBOR swap zero-coupon curve up to June 2020 and a SOFR OIS curve thereafter. The switch takes effect on 19 June 2020, three years before LIBOR cessation.
  • Weekly macro‑financial series (S&P 500 returns, federal funds rate change, Weekly Economic · FRED and Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas macro public
    U.S. aggregate series
    Source sentence
    The VARX endogenous block contains five weekly vari-ables, all in first differences for stationarity: the S&P 500 weekly log return (mkt_ret); the 6 weekly change in the effective federal funds rate, in decimals (dffr); the weekly change in the Weekly Economic Index of Lewis et al. (2022) (dwei); the weekly change in year-on-year CPI inflation, forward-filled from monthly releases (dinf); and the weekly change in

Recognised sources: Refinitiv / LSEG (Datastream, Eikon, Tick History) FRED

Costs

Not applicable The paper reports no trading or execution result.

Finds 5

  • The term‑structure block (G3++) has the lowest out‑of‑sample RMSE in 13 of 20 maturity‑horizon cells, with a tie in a fourteenth cell. predictive-accuracy
    Source sentence
    G3++ has the lowest RMSE outright in 13 of 20 maturity–horizon cells and ties the random walk in a fourteenth (10Y at h = 26), with 18 the strongest performance at the 1Y, 2Y and 5Y pillars. Diebold–Mariano tests, with HAC bandwidths capped by the number of origins, do not reject equal accuracy against the random walk at the 5% level in any cell.
  • At weekly frequency, once each variable’s own lags are controlled for, the yield‑curve adds no measurable incremental information about macro‑financial variables, in either the conditional mean or the full predictive distribution. predictive-accuracy
    Source sentence
    At weekly frequency the curve carries no incremental information about these variables once their own lags are controlled for, so the engine's value lies in conditioning on a specified curve path, which no benchmark can do. Three separate tests, the Mode A comparison, the joint-pipeline decomposition and the CRPS comparison, agree that at weekly frequency, once each variable’s own lags are controlled for, the term
  • A contractionary monetary‑policy shock is associated with falling equity returns, activity, inflation and the MES proxy on impact. statistical
    Source sentence
    A contractionary policy shock is associated with falling equity returns, activity, inflation and the MES proxy on impact, and the relevance filter and magnitude caps are what make those responses usable at weekly frequency.
  • MES and a CoVaR‑inspired covariance proxy move in opposite directions under the same shock, indicating they are not substitutes as systemic‑risk indicators. other
    Source sentence
    The most informative single result is the comparison between MES and the CoVaR-inspired covariance proxy: the two move in opposite directions under the same shock, MES pushed down through the discount-rate channel while the covariance proxy rises, consistent with the risk-taking channel of Borio and Zhu (2012).
  • The G3++ forecasts are competitive but not dominant; RMSE improvements are not statistically significant versus a random walk according to Diebold‑Mariano tests. predictive-accuracy
    Source sentence
    The block is therefore a competitive curve generator rather than a dominant conditional-mean forecaster. That is the outcome its constant price of risk predicts: Duffee (2002) shows that completely affine models should not be expected to beat a random walk in level forecasts, and the pattern here, lower RMSE in most cells without significant rejections, is what that implies.

Checked by others

No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 20 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.

Code

No repository by the authors found in the paper.

Extracted 2026-11-20 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.