Paper: arXiv 2411.01950
Authors: Evgenii Onishchuk, Maksim Dubovitskii, Eduard Horch
Abstract
This empirical study presents the Decentralized Exchanges Comparison Service (DECS), a novel tool developed by 1inch Analytics to assess exchange efficiency in decentralized finance. The DECS utilizes swap transaction monitoring and simulation techniques to provide unbiased comparisons of swap rates across various DEXes and aggregators. Analysis of almost 1.2 million transactions across multiple blockchain networks demonstrates that both 1inch Classic and 1inch Fusion consistently outperform competitors. These findings not only validate 1inch’s superior rates but also provide valuable insights for continuous protocol optimization and underscore the critical role of data-driven decision-making in advancing DeFi infrastructure.
Complexity vs Empirical Score
- Math Complexity: 1.5/10
- Empirical Rigor: 6.0/10 (capped from 8.5: no out-of-sample test; see penalty flags)
- Quadrant: Street Traders — empirical and applied, lower math complexity (effective empirical rigor capped from 8.5)
Why this score: The paper focuses on empirical analysis of 1.2 million transactions across multiple blockchains to compare DEX rates, with heavy implementation details on data infrastructure and simulation techniques, but contains minimal advanced mathematics.
Research Flowchart
flowchart TD Start["Research Goal<br>Assess DEX Swap Efficiency"] --> Data["Input Data<br>1.2M Transactions across Chains"] Data --> Method["Methodology<br>Monitor & Simulate Swaps"] Method --> Comp["Computational Process<br>Compare Rates via DECS Tool"] Comp --> Find1["Outcome<br>1inch Classic consistently outperforms"] Comp --> Find2["Outcome<br>1inch Fusion consistently outperforms"] Find1 --> End["Conclusion<br>Data validates 1inch superiority &<br>guides protocol optimization"] Find2 --> End
Evidence Card
What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card
Proposes
The paper introduces the Decentralized Exchanges Comparison Service (DECS), a novel tool for near‑real‑time assessment of exchange efficiency in DeFi.
Source sentence
This empirical study presents the Decentralized Exchanges Comparison Service (DECS), a novel tool developed by 1inch Analytics to assess exchange efficiency in decentralized finance.
Assumes 5
- Liquidity state used in simulation must be within a limited block distance from the mined block. data
Source sentence
The (1) constraint ensures the correctness of the simulation: the liquidity state used in build step closely mirrors the actual market conditions at the time of user’s intended swap request
- Transactions with exact output amount are excluded because the 1inch protocol does not support them. execution
Source sentence
Transactions: excluded transactions where users specify an exact output amount, as this functionality is not supported in the 1inch protocol.
- Suitable gas price is used in post‑calculations to ensure fairness. execution
Source sentence
At the same time, an important component of the fairness in post-calculations is using suitable gas price (see Section IV.C.3).
- Parametric t‑tests are valid due to large sample sizes, invoking the Central Limit Theorem. statistical
Source sentence
While the normality assumption of parametric tests is traditionally important, the Central Limit Theorem
Show 1 more
- One‑tailed tests are appropriate for testing whether Fusion performs better than UniswapX. statistical
Source sentence
Given the directional nature of our research question - specifically investigating whether Fusion performs better than UniswapX - we employ one-tailed tests throughout our analysis.
Data
- DECS transaction dataset crypto-onchain proprietary
Source sentence
Analysis of almost 1.2 million transactions across multiple blockchain networks demonstrates that both 1inch Classic and 1inch Fusion consistently outperform competitors.
Costs
Partial
Gas price is considered for fairness in post‑calculations, but explicit fee amounts are not incorporated into the headline performance numbers.
Source sentence
At the same time, an important component of the fairness in post-calculations is using suitable gas price (see Section IV.C.3).
Finds 4
- 1inch Classic wins between 64% and 71% of trades across all volume ranges, with median uplift rising from $3.08 (3 bps) for < $10k trades to $230.75 (23 bps) for > $100k trades. performance
Source sentence
The magnitude of 1inch’s relative outperformance increases with transaction size. For winning trades, the median uplift rises from $3.08 for transactions under $10,000 (3 bps) to $230.75 for transactions over $100,000 (23 bps).
- Against UniswapX, 1inch Classic outperforms in 74.74% of sub‑$1,000 trades (median uplift 0.91%) and maintains win rates above 60% up to the $500k bucket, with a dip in median uplift for mid‑size trades. performance
Source sentence
outperformed UniswapX in 74.74% of cases, with a median (p50) uplift of 0.91%
- 1inch Fusion shows a statistically significant rate advantage over UniswapX, with mean uplift differences of 0.385%–0.721% across volume buckets (p < 1e‑6). performance
Source sentence
it is confirmed that the difference in rates is statistically significant.
- The performance advantage of Fusion persists after accounting for UniswapX’s 0.25% fee, with uplift (0.318%‑0.354%) exceeding the fee. performance
Source sentence
is already included in these comparisons, and the observed difference (0.318% - 0.354%) exceeds this fee, it can be concluded that Fusion’s performance advantage persists beyond the fee impact.
Checked by others
No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 10 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.
Code
No repository by the authors found in the paper.
Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.