Paper: arXiv 2509.16912
Authors: Shuto Endo, Takanobu Mizuta, Isao Yagi
Abstract
Order book imbalance (OBI) - buy orders minus sell orders near the best quote - measures supply-demand imbalance that can move prices. OBI is positively correlated with returns, and some investors try to use it to improve performance. Large orders placed at once can reveal intent, invite front-running, raise volatility, and cause losses. Execution algorithms therefore split parent orders into smaller lots to limit price distortion. In principle, using OBI inside such algorithms could improve execution, but prior evidence is scarce because isolating OBI’s effect in real markets is nearly impossible amid many external factors. Multi-agent simulation offers a way to study this. In an artificial market, individual actors are agents whose rules and interactions form the model. This study builds an execution algorithm that accounts for OBI, tests it across several market patterns in artificial markets, and analyzes mechanisms, comparing it with a conventional (OBI-agnostic) algorithm. Results: (i) In stable markets, the OBI strategy’s performance depends on the number of order slices; outcomes vary with how the parent order is partitioned. (ii) In markets with unstable prices, the OBI-based algorithm outperforms the conventional approach. (iii) Under spoofing manipulation, the OBI strategy is not significantly worse than the conventional algorithm, indicating limited vulnerability to spoofing. Overall, OBI provides a useful signal for execution. Incorporating OBI can add value - especially in volatile conditions - while remaining reasonably robust to spoofing; in calm markets, benefits are sensitive to slicing design.
Complexity vs Empirical Score
- Math Complexity: 6.5/10
- Empirical Rigor: 4.0/10
- Quadrant: Lab Rats — high math complexity, limited empirical testing
Why this score: The paper employs a complex agent-based simulation model with detailed mathematical formulations for agent behavior and market mechanisms, but it uses artificial data in a simulated environment rather than real historical backtests or live trading data.
Research Flowchart
flowchart TD A["Research Goal:<br>Assess OBI's impact<br>on execution algorithms"] --> B["Methodology:<br>Multi-agent simulation<br>in artificial markets"] B --> C["Inputs:<br>Market conditions<br>(Stable, Volatile, Spoofing)"] C --> D["Process:<br>Compare OBI-strategy<br>vs. Conventional algorithm"] D --> E["Outcome 1:<br>Stable markets: Performance<br>depends on order slicing"] D --> F["Outcome 2:<br>Volatile markets:<br>OBI strategy outperforms"] D --> G["Outcome 3:<br>Spoofing: OBI shows<br>limited vulnerability"]
Evidence Card
What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card
Proposes
The paper proposes an execution algorithm that incorporates order book imbalance (OBI) and evaluates its performance in artificial market simulations.
Source sentence
this study builds an execution algorithm that accounts for OBI, tests it across several market patterns in artificial markets, and analyzes mechanisms, comparing it with a conventional (OBI-agnostic) algorithm.
Assumes 6
- Normal agents (NAs) are assumed to be general investors designed to replicate real market characteristics. model
Source sentence
NAs are assumed to be general investors in the real world and are designed to be able to replicate the characteristics of the real markets.
- The fundamental price is constant over time. market
Source sentence
The fundamental price, which is constant over time.
- The market uses a continuous double auction with price and time priority. market
Source sentence
Thus, the rules of price priority and time priority are applied in the continuous double auction used in our experiment.
- Algorithm agents start submitting orders after time step 100,000. execution
Source sentence
Furthermore, the algorithm agents start submitting orders after time step 100,000.
Show 2 more
- The number of normal agents is set to 990 and algorithm agents to 10. model
Source sentence
The number of normal agents (NAs) was set to 990, and the number of algorithm agents was set to 10.
- OBI is measured as the difference between buy depth and sell depth within a certain price range. other
Source sentence
An OAA compares the buy depth (the number of buy orders within a certain range below the best bid) with the sell depth (the number of sell orders within a certain range above the best ask) and if the buy depth is greater than the sell depth, then the OAA submits a market buy order.
Data
- Artificial market simulation synthetic unknown
Source sentence
a market in which spoofing manipulation occurs (spoof market).
Costs
Modeled
TC = (1/nbuy) Σ (p_buy - Pf), where nbuy is the total number of purchases and p_buy is the price of each purchase.
Source sentence
Following Hoshino et al. [13], we define the trading cost TC as the degree to which algorithm agents buy at prices higher than the fundamental price Pf, expressed as the average deviation of the buy price from the fundamental price, as follows: TC = 1/nbuy Σ
Finds 5
- In stable markets with low order frequency, OBI-aware algorithm agents (OAAs) achieve lower trading costs than conventional agents (AAs). performance
Source sentence
For stable markets in which algorithm agents place orders at low frequency, our results demonstrated lower trading cost for the OAAs than for the AAs.
- In stable markets with high order frequency, OAAs incur higher trading costs due to price increases induced by their own orders. negative
Source sentence
For stable markets with high order frequency, the OAAs suffer from the consequences of market price increases induced by their own orders, resulting in increased trading cost.
- In crash and surge markets, OAAs obtain lower trading costs than AAs. performance
Source sentence
In both crashing and surging markets, the OAAs obtain lower trading costs than the AAs.
- In spoofing markets, there is no significant difference in trading costs between OAAs and AAs. negative
Source sentence
In a spoofing market, we found no significant difference between trading costs obtained using AAs and using OAAs.
- The performance of OAAs worsens as order frequency increases, a phenomenon that may also appear in crash, surge, or spoof markets. performance
Source sentence
Our results indicate that, for stable markets, the performance of the OAAs worsens as the frequency of orders placed by algorithm agents increases.
Checked by others
No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 42 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.
Code
No repository by the authors found in the paper.
Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.
Cited References (24)
- Asset pricing under endogenous expectations in an artificial stock market (1997)
- The information content of an open limit-order book (2009)
- Algorithmic and High-frequency Trading (2015)
- A closed-form execution strategy to target volume weighted average price (2016)
- Enhancing trading strategies with order book signals (2018)
- Agent-based economic models and econometrics (2012)
- The impact of heterogeneous trading rules on the limit order book and order flows (2009)
- Empirical properties of asset returns: Stylized facts and statistical issues (2001)
and 16 more
- The price impact of order book events (2014)
- Implementation of real data for financial market simulation using clustering, Deep Learning, and artificial financial market (2021)
- Trade arrival dynamics and quote imbalance in a limit order book (2013) — link
- FX execution algorithms and market functioning (2020)
- Do dark pools stabilize markets and reduce market impacts? investigations using multi-agent simulations (2014)
- Effect of Trading Halt System on Market Functioning: Simulation Analysis of Market Behavior with Artificial Shutdown (1999)
- Statistical Arbitrage Using Limit Order Book Imbalance (2015)
- FX trade execution: complex and highly fragmented (2019)
- Characterization of financial time series (2011)
- The micro-price: A high frequency estimator of future prices (2017)
- Impact of high-frequency trading with an order book imbalance strategy on agent-based stock markets (2023)
- Do price limits hurt the market? (2013) — link
- Are price limits effective? An examination of an artificial stock market (2016)
- Impact of an execution algorithm with an order book imbalance strategy on the financial market using an artificial market (2023)
- How does the performance of algorithm traders change when they take into account order book imbalance? (2023) — link
- Effectiveness of Maker-Taker Fees to Total Trading Costs and Market Liquidity Using an Agent-based Model (2021) — link
0 of 24 cited works are in the corpus; resolved via arXiv source bundles, Semantic Scholar and OpenAlex. Corpus-wide: 2596 linked papers.