Paper: arXiv 2507.10052

Authors: Huisheng Wang, H. Vicky Zhao

Abstract

Investment herding, a phenomenon where households mimic the decisions of others rather than relying on their own analysis, has significant effects on financial markets and household behavior. Excessive investment herding may reduce investments and lead to a depletion of household consumption, which is called the crowding-out effect. While existing research has qualitatively examined the impact of investment herding on consumption, quantitative studies in this area remain limited. In this work, we investigate the optimal investment and consumption decisions of households under the impact of investment herding. We formulate an optimization problem to model how investment herding influences household decisions over time. Based on the optimal control theory, we solve for the analytical solutions of optimal investment and consumption decisions. We theoretically analyze the impact of investment herding on household consumption decisions and demonstrate the existence of the crowding-out effect. We further explore how parameters, such as interest rate, excess return rate, and volatility, influence the crowding-out effect. Finally, we conduct a real data test to validate our theoretical analysis of the crowding-out effect. This study is crucial to understanding the impact of investment herding on household consumption and offering valuable insights for policymakers seeking to stimulate consumption and mitigate the negative effects of investment herding on economic growth.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 7.5/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 3.0/10
  • Quadrant: Lab Rats — high math complexity, limited empirical testing

Why this score: The paper employs advanced optimal control theory to derive analytical solutions, which is mathematically dense. However, the empirical validation is limited to a single real data test described in the abstract, lacking detailed backtesting procedures, dataset specifics, or code, which reduces its empirical rigor.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
  A["Research Goal:<br>Quantify Crowding-Out Effect of<br>Investment Herding on Consumption"] --> B["Methodology: Formulate Optimization Problem<br>Using Optimal Control Theory"]
  B --> C["Data/Inputs:<br>Real Data & Key Parameters<br>Interest Rate, Excess Return, Volatility"]
  C --> D["Computational Process:<br>Solve Analytical Solutions for<br>Optimal Investment & Consumption Paths"]
  D --> E{"Key Outcomes"}
  E --> F["Theoretical Finding:<br>Existence of Crowding-Out Effect<br>Investment Herding Reduces Consumption"]
  E --> G["Parametric Analysis:<br>Impact of Interest Rate,<br>Excess Return, Volatility"]
  E --> H["Empirical Validation:<br>Real Data Test Confirms<br>Theoretical Analysis"]

Evidence Card

What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card

Proposes

The paper formulates and solves an optimal investment and consumption problem for households under investment herding using optimal control theory, providing analytical solutions and analyzing the crowding‑out effect.

Source sentence
In this work, we investigate the optimal investment and consumption decisions of households under the impact of investment herding. To address these issues, in this work, we first formulate the optimal investment and consumption problem under the impact of investment herding and solve for the optimal in-vestment and consumption decisions of households based on the optimal control theory.

Assumes 6

  • The financial market consists of one risk‑free asset with interest rate r and one risky asset with excess return v and volatility σ. market
    Source sentence
    Finally, Section 6 concludes the paper. arXiv:2507.10052v1 [q-fin.PM] 14 Jul 2025 2 Problem Definition In this work, we assume that the financial market consists of one risk-free asset with an interest rate r and one risky asset with an excess return rate v and volatility σ.
  • There are two households, a leading household H2 and a following household H1 whose investment decisions are unidirectionally influenced by H2 due to herding. model
    Source sentence
    We con-sider two households, H1 and H2, where H1 is the following household and H2 is the leading household whose invest-ment decisions unidirectionally influence those of H1 due to investment herding.
  • Each household’s consumption decision is always positive. model
    Source sentence
    We assume that Hi’s consumption decision {Ci(t)}t∈T is always positive.
  • The market is frictionless with continuous trading and no transaction costs. execution
    Source sentence
    (8) For tractability, we assume a frictionless market with con-tinuous trading and no transaction costs.
Show 2 more
  • External shocks such as macroeconomic downturns or regulatory changes are not modeled. other
    Source sentence
    Additionally, ex-ternal shocks such as macroeconomic downturns or sudden regulatory changes are not explicitly modeled, allowing us to focus on the endogenous effects of investment herding on household decisions.
  • Households maximize the expected utility of terminal wealth (and cumulative consumption utility) over a finite horizon. model
    Source sentence
    During the time horizon T , both households aim to maxi-mize the expected utilities of their terminal funds. Different from the investment-only problem that focuses on their terminal funds, both households consider the cumu-lative utility over the time horizon T when making their con-sumption decisions.

Data

  • Cross‑Sectional Standard Deviation (CSSD) · CSMAR database macro commercial
    Oct 2014 – Sep 2024
    Source sentence
    We obtain quarterly CSSD data from the CSMAR database [25], covering the period from October 2014 to September 2024.
  • Per‑capita Consumption Expenditure (CE) of urban residents · National Bureau of Statistics macro public
    Oct 2014 – Sep 2024
    Source sentence
    To quantify household consumption, we use the cumula-tive per capita Consumption Expenditure (CE) of urban res-idents in China.
  • Risk‑free rate r, excess return rate v, volatility σ of the Shanghai Stock Exchange Compos · CSMAR database other commercial
    Oct 2014 – Sep 2024 · Shanghai Stock Exchange Composite Index
    Source sentence
    Additionally, we collect data on the risk-free rate r, ex-cess return rate v, and volatility σ of the Shanghai Stock Exchange Composite Index from [25] and compute their quarterly values.
  • Total Retail Sales of consumer goods (TRS) · National Bureau of Statistics macro public
    Oct 2014 – Sep 2024
    Source sentence
    To account for external factors influenc-ing household consumption, we also obtain quarterly data on the Total Retail Sales of consumer goods (TRS) from [26], which serves as an indicator of overall consumer demand in the economy.

Recognised sources: CSMAR

Costs

Unclear - sources disagree The platform classifier and the paper-text extraction give different answers, so no value is asserted.

Platform classifier: Not applicable

Paper text extraction: Not modeled

Source sentence (the authors' words)
(8) For tractability, we assume a frictionless market with con-tinuous trading and no transaction costs.

Finds 5

  • Theoretical analysis demonstrates the existence of a crowding‑out effect: investment herding reduces household consumption. theoretical
    Source sentence
    We theoretically analyze the impact of investment herding on household consumption decisions and demonstrate the existence of the crowding-out effect. Then, we theoretically analyze the impact of investment herding on household consumption and demonstrate the existence of the crowding-out effect.
  • Crowding‑out consumption C decreases with higher interest rate r and volatility σ, and increases with higher excess return rate v. theoretical
    Source sentence
    From Fig. 1, we can find that the crowding-out consumption C decreases with the interest rate r and the volatility σ, and increases with the ex-cess return rate v.
  • Empirical regression shows that CSSD (herding metric) and TRS are more statistically significant for consumption than interest rate, excess return, and volatility, indicating a stronger impact of herding on the crowding‑out effect. statistical
    Source sentence
    Furthermore, from the t-statistics, the CSSD and TRS metrics are more statistically significant than the interest rate r, the excess return rate v, and the volatility σ, which indicates that investment herd-ing exhibits a stronger impact on the crowding-out effect on household consumption compared to market parameters.
  • Higher interest rate and volatility tend to reduce the crowding‑out effect, whereas a higher excess return rate amplifies it. theoretical
    Source sentence
    We show that a higher inter-est rate and volatility tend to reduce the crowding-out effect, whereas a higher excess return rate amplifies the crowding-out effect.
  • Real‑data test validates the theoretical crowding‑out analysis. other
    Source sentence
    We validate our analysis using a real data test.

Checked by others

No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 18 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.

Code

No repository by the authors found in the paper.

Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.

Cited References (86)

  1. Portfolio selection (1952)
  2. Lifetime portfolio selection under uncertainty: The continuous-time case (1969)
  3. Optimum consumption and portfolio rules in a continuous-time model (1975)
  4. Lifetime portfolio selection by dynamic stochastic programming (1975)
  5. A simple model of herd behavior (1992)
  6. Keeping up with the J oneses: Consumption externalities, portfolio choice, and asset prices (1994)
  7. A stochastic differential game of institutional investor speculation (1999)
  8. Herd behavior in financial markets (2000)
and 78 more
  1. Stochastic differential portfolio games (2000)
  2. An examination of herd behavior in equity markets: An international perspective (2000)
  3. Herd behavior and aggregate fluctuations in financial markets (2000)
  4. Transmission of information and herd behavior: An application to financial markets (2000)
  5. Estimation in the constant elasticity of variance model (2001)
  6. Time discounting and time preference: A critical review (2002)
  7. Existence and uniqueness of a Nash equilibrium feedback for a simple nonzero-sum differential game. (2003)
  8. Herd behaviour and cascading in capital markets: A review and synthesis (2003)
  9. Misery loves company: Equilibrium portfolios with heterogeneous consumption externalities (2004)
  10. Social interaction and stock-market participation (2004)
  11. Keeping up with the J oneses and the home bias (2004)
  12. Estimation of agent-based models: The case of an asymmetric herding model (2005)
  13. The impact of keeping up with the J oneses behavior on asset prices and portfolio choice (2007)
  14. Neighbors matter: Causal community effects and stock market participation (2008)
  15. Multi-period portfolio optimization with linear control policies (2008)
  16. Implications of Keeping-Up-with-the- J oneses Behavior for the Equilibrium Cross Section of Stock Returns: International Evidence (2009)
  17. The Effects of Risk Aversion on Optimization (2010)
  18. Confirmation bias, overconfidence, and investment performance: Evidence from stock message boards (2010)
  19. Diversification and its discontents: Idiosyncratic and entrepreneurial risk in the quest for social status (2010)
  20. Relative wealth concerns and complementarities in information acquisition (2011)
  21. Induced aggregation operators in the E uclidean distance and its application in financial decision making (2011)
  22. Asymmetric effects and the herd behavior in the A ustralian equity market (2012)
  23. Impact of social factors on individual investors’ trading behaviour (2012)
  24. Wisdom of crowds: The value of stock opinions transmitted through social media (2014)
  25. Do financial experts make better investment decisions? (2015)
  26. Optimal investment under relative performance concerns (2015)
  27. Keeping up with the J oneses and optimal diversification (2015)
  28. What explains herd behavior in the C hinese stock market? (2017)
  29. Herd behavior in the F rench stock market (2017)
  30. Herding behavior in the P akistan stock exchange: Some new insights (2017)
  31. Multiperiod asset allocation considering dynamic loss aversion behavior of investors (2018)
  32. Many-player games of optimal consumption and investment under relative performance criteria (2020)
  33. Social media and the stock markets: an emerging market perspective (2021)
  34. Do individual investors trade on investment-related internet postings? (2021)
  35. Social transmission bias and investor behavior (2022)
  36. Unintentional herd behavior via the G oogle search volume index in international equity markets (2022)
  37. Internet postings and investor herd behavior: evidence from C hina’s open-end fund market (2022)
  38. The Role of Social Media in Shaping Public Opinion and Its Influence on Economic Decisions (2023)
  39. Homophily and influence (2023)
  40. Offline RL with no ood actions: In-sample learning via implicit value regularization (2023) — link
  41. Optimal Investment with Herd Behaviour Using Rational Decision Decomposition — → 2401.07183
  42. Optimal Investment under the Influence of Decision-changing Imitation — → 2409.10933
  43. Fixed point theorems with applications to economics and game theory (1985)
  44. Differential games: a mathematical theory with applications to warfare and pursuit, control and optimization (1999)
  45. Martingale methods in financial modelling (2006)
  46. Cooperative stochastic differential games (2006)
  47. Stochastic differential equations: an introduction with applications (2013)
  48. Optimal investment (2013)
  49. Risk aversion in the small and in the large (1978)
  50. Financial blogs and information asymmetry between firm insiders and outsiders (2008)
  51. Study on random trading behavior, herd behavior and asset price volatility (2016)
  52. Estimation of geometric B rownian motion parameters for oil price analysis (2017)
  53. Risk-Sensitive Stochastic Control with Applications to An Optimal Investment Problem under Correlated Noises (2019)
  54. Detection and Estimation of Herd Behavior in Futures Market (2019)
  55. Optimal investment in a market with random interest rate for borrowing: an explicit closed-form solution (2022)
  56. A Kind of Optimal Investment Problem under Inflation and Uncertain Exit Time (2022)
  57. Optimal Investment in a Market with Borrowing and a Combined Interest Rate Model (2023)
  58. Herding behaviour in the capital market: What do we know and what is next? (2022)
  59. Investor herding behavior in social media sentiment (2022)
  60. Unpacking Financial Herding Behaviour: A Conceptual Study of Youth and Working Adults in Chongqing , China (2024)
  61. Herding in financial behaviour: A behavioural and neuroeconomic analysis of individual differences (2012)
  62. Macroeconomics (1997)
  63. Herd behavior and investment (1990)
  64. An empirical analysis of herd behavior in global stock markets (2010)
  65. Herd behavior, bubbles and social interactions in financial markets (2014)
  66. Estimating a structural model of herd behavior in financial markets (2014)
  67. Herd behavior and idiosyncratic volatility (2015)
  68. Consumer Spending in China : The Past and the Future. (2016)
  69. Equilibrium consumption and portfolio decisions with stochastic discount rate and time-varying utility functions (2018)
  70. The effect of interest rate changes on consumption: An age-structured approach (2023)
  71. Stock market wealth and consumption (2000)
  72. Stock market volatility and the US consumer expenditure (2003)
  73. Optimal control theory: An introduction (2004)
  74. S&P Dow Jones Indices
  75. Interest Rate Statistics
  76. Following the Pied Piper : do individual returns herd around the market? (1995)
  77. China Stock Market & Accounting Research Database
  78. The theory of interest as determined by impatience to spend income and opportunity to spend it (1930)

2 of 86 cited works are in the corpus; resolved via arXiv source bundles, Semantic Scholar and OpenAlex. Corpus-wide: 2596 linked papers.