Paper: arXiv 2407.07100
Authors: Eberhard Mayerhofer
Abstract
We propose a general approximation method for determining optimal trading strategies in markets with proportional transaction costs, with a polynomial approximation of the residual value function. The method is exemplified by several problems from optimally tracking benchmarks, hedging the Log contract, to maximizing utility from terminal wealth. Strategies are also approximated by practically executable, discrete trades. We identify the necessary trade-off between trading frequency and trade sizes to have satisfactory agreement with the theoretically optimal, continuous strategies of infinite activity.
Complexity vs Empirical Score
- Math Complexity: 9.0/10
- Empirical Rigor: 2.0/10
- Quadrant: Lab Rats — high math complexity, limited empirical testing
Why this score: The paper is heavily math-centric, featuring advanced asymptotic methods, free boundary problems, and reflected diffusions without any empirical backtests, datasets, or implementation details.
Research Flowchart
flowchart TD
A["Research Goal: Approximate optimal trading strategies with transaction costs"] --> B{"Methodology: Polynomial Approximation"}
B --> C["Input: Market models & cost structure"]
B --> D["Input: Objective function e.g. utility or tracking error"]
C & D --> E["Process: Solve DP/HJB for residual value"]
E --> F["Process: Approximate solution via polynomial expansion"]
F --> G["Outcome: Discrete executable trading strategy"]
G --> H["Key Finding: Optimal trade-off between frequency and size"]
Evidence Card
What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card
Proposes
The paper proposes a general approximation method for determining optimal trading strategies in markets with proportional transaction costs, using a polynomial approximation of the residual value function.
Source sentence
We propose a general approximation method for determining optimal trading strategies in markets with proportional transaction costs, with a polynomial approximation of the residual value function.
Assumes 6
- A proportional bid‑ask spread ε>0 is present, with the risky asset sold at (1‑ε)S_t. market
Source sentence
We introduce a relative bid-ask spread ε > 0, ensuring that the risky asset is sold at (1 −ε)St. In markets with frictions, trading strategies need to be modified so to ensure solvency.
- The risk‑free asset has continuous compounding at rate r≥0 and the risky asset follows dS_t/S_t = (μ+r)dt + σ dB_t. model
Source sentence
2 Materials and Methods In our financial market model, there are two tradable assets: a risk-free asset with continuous compounding at a rate r ≥0 and a risky asset S with ask price St, governed by the dynamics dSt St = (µ + r)dt + σdBt, S0, σ > 0, µ ≥0, 3 where B denotes a standard Brownian motion.
- In the presence of transaction costs, only finite‑variation trading strategies are viable to ensure solvency. execution
Source sentence
In the presence of transaction costs, solvency constraints dictate that only finite-variation trading strategies are viable.3 Let Xt be the safe position and Yt the risky position.
- Trading strategies are approximated by finite‑activity jump processes (pure jump type) rather than reflected diffusions. model
Source sentence
First, we employ finite activity strategies to approximate control limit policies. In contrast to reflected diffusions, these strategies can be implemented in a real trading environment.
Show 2 more
- The process η used in the analysis is a Markov process on a bounded interval with ergodic stationary density. statistical
Source sentence
By construction, η is a Markov process on [η−, η+].6 By Itô’s formula, for any f ∈C2([η−, η+]), f(ηt) = f(η0) + Z t 0 σf ′(ηs)dWs + Z t 0 Af(ηs)ds (3.10) + (f(η⋆) −f(η−))|{s ≤t : ∆Ls > 0} −(f(η+) −f(η⋆))|{s ≤t : ∆Us > 0}. The process η is ergodic, with stationary density φ(η) = ( a1 + b1eαη for η−≤η ≤η⋆, a2 + b2eαη for η⋆≤η ≤η+, (3.11) 9 where α = 2M/Σ2 −1 and a1 = −b1eαη−, a2 = −b2eαη+, b1 = eαη⋆−eαη+
- Small fixed‑size trades are used to re‑align the portfolio statistic with its frictionless target. execution
Source sentence
They involve trades of fixed size aimed at re-aligning a portfolio statistic with its frictionless target, such as adjusting the proportion of wealth πt in the risky asset when reaching π±.
Data
- Simulated daily paths of η for 5‑year horizon synthetic unknown
Source sentence
The histogram gives the value of ηT for T = 5 years, from ten thousand simulated path (daily frequency). In Figure 2, the histogram of the (approximate) distribution of ηt for t = 5 years is given, along with the exact stationary distribution provided by Lemma 3.6.
Costs
Modeled
A relative bid‑ask spread ε>0 is introduced; average transaction costs are derived as ATC = σ^2 (1‑κ) κ^{3/2} 2 ε^{1/2} + O(1).
Source sentence
The risk-neutral investor faces average transaction costs ATC = σ2(1 −κ)κ3/2 2ε1/2 + O(1). (3.62) 29 Proof.
Finds 5
- A necessary trade‑off between trading frequency and trade sizes is identified to achieve satisfactory agreement with the theoretically optimal continuous strategies of infinite activity. theoretical
Source sentence
We identify the necessary trade-off between trading frequency and trade sizes to have satisfactory agreement with the theoretically optimal, continuous strategies of infinite activity.
- Finite‑activity strategies can approximate control‑limit policies and are implementable in real trading environments. theoretical
Source sentence
First, we employ finite activity strategies to approximate control limit policies. In contrast to reflected diffusions, these strategies can be implemented in a real trading environment.
- Discrete, fixed‑size trades can approximate optimal continuous strategies while remaining practically executable. theoretical
Source sentence
Strategies are also approximated by practically executable, discrete trades.
- For maximal trades, trade sizes must be of order ε^{1/3} and trading frequency is of order ε^{‑2/3}. theoretical
Source sentence
For maximal trades (Section 3.1.2 and Remark 3.10), where reasonable trade sizes ∆π must be of order ε1/3 (no larger than the size of the no-trade region), the Trading frequency (TF) is of order ε−2/3.
- Average transaction costs of near‑optimal strategies scale as ε^{2/3}, confirming the second‑order effect of proportional transaction costs. theoretical
Source sentence
This process can be iterated, yielding the scaling law (4) (cf. Golub et al. (2018) and the references therein), for trade sizes of order εα/3 and associated trading frequency ε−1 3 (α+1), where α = 1, 2, 3, . . . , resulting in the same order of average trading costs, namely ε2/3.
Checked by others
No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 30 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.
Code
No repository by the authors found in the paper.
Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.
Cited References (22)
- Almost Perfect Shadow Prices — → 2401.00970
- Leveraged funds: robust replication and performance evaluation (2023) — link
- The Alpha Engine: Designing an Automated Trading Algorithm (2017) — link
- The limits of leverage (2015) — link
- Nonlinear price impact and portfolio choice (2015) — link
- Asymptotics for fixed transaction costs (2013) — link
- THE GENERAL STRUCTURE OF OPTIMAL INVESTMENT AND CONSUMPTION WITH SMALL TRANSACTION COSTS (2013) — link
- Portfolio Choice with Transaction Costs: A User’s Guide (2012) — link
and 14 more
- Transaction costs, trading volume, and the liquidity premium (2011) — link
- Asymptotics and duality for the Davis and Norman problem (2010) — link
- The dual optimizer for the growth-optimal portfolio under transaction costs (2010) — link
- On characterisation of Markov processes via martingale problems (2006) — link
- Handbook of Brownian Motion - Facts and Formulae (1996) — link
- Optimal Investment and Consumption with Transaction Costs (1994) — link
- The Log Contract (1994) — link
- A Diffusion Model for Optimal Portfolio Selection in the Presence of Brokerage Fees (1988) — link
- Stopped Random Walks: Limit Theorems and Applications (1987)
- Capital Market Equilibrium with Transaction Costs (1986) — link
- Smooth investment (2016) — link
- ‘Why is the effect of proportional transaction costs δ 2 / 3 ? (2004)
- Stochastic differential equations with reflecting boundary condition in convex regions (1979) — link
- ii) Maximal trades: These strategies reset a portfolio statistic to its target value once it reaches these boundaries (cf. the first second plot in Figure 1
1 of 22 cited works are in the corpus; resolved via arXiv source bundles, Semantic Scholar and OpenAlex. Corpus-wide: 2596 linked papers.