Paper: arXiv 2512.22858

Authors: Abdulrahman Qadi, Akash Sharma, Francesca Medda

Abstract

Binary Shariah screens vary across standards and apply hard thresholds that create discontinuous classifications. We construct a Continuous Shariah Compliance Index (CSCI) in \([“0,1”]\) by mapping standard screening ratios to smooth scores between conservative ``comfort’’ bounds and permissive outer bounds, and aggregating them conservatively with a sectoral activity factor. Using CRSP/Compustat U.S. equities (1999-2024) with lagged accounting inputs and monthly rebalancing, we find that CSCI-based long-only portfolios have historical risk-adjusted performance similar to an emulated binary Islamic benchmark. Tightening the minimum compliance threshold reduces the investable universe and diversification and is associated with lower Sharpe ratios. The framework yields a practical compliance gradient that supports portfolio construction, constraint design, and cross-standard comparisons without reliance on pass/fail screening.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 4.5/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 8.0/10
  • Quadrant: Street Traders — empirical and applied, lower math complexity

Why this score: The paper uses weighted geometric means and multiplicative aggregation for the compliance index, which involves algebraic functions but not advanced stochastic calculus or machine learning. However, it demonstrates strong empirical rigor with a comprehensive backtest using CRSP/Compustat data from 1999-2024, monthly rebalancing, and analysis of risk-adjusted returns, Sharpe ratios, and factor exposures.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
  A["Research Goal: Continuous Shariah Compliance Index"] --> B["Methodology: Construct CSCI 0-1"]
  B --> C["Data: CRSP/Compustat US Equities<br>1999-2024, Monthly Rebalancing"]
  C --> D["Process: Map Ratios to Scores<br>Aggregate with Sectoral Factors"]
  D --> E["Analysis: CSCI-based Portfolios<br>vs. Binary Benchmark"]
  E --> F["Key Findings: Continuous Index<br>Enables Gradient Analysis & Optimization"]

Evidence Card

What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card

Proposes

The paper proposes a Continuous Shariah Compliance Index (CSCI) that aggregates multiple Shariah screening standards into a single transparent measure on the unit interval.

Source sentence
This paper develops a Continuous Shariah Compliance Index (CSCI) on [0, 1] that embeds the published business-activity and financial-ratio thresholds of six leading standards in a single transparent measure.

Assumes 6

  • Annual financial statements become investable with a six‑month lag after fiscal year‑end. data
    Source sentence
    we assume that annual financial statements become investable with a lag of six months after the fiscal year-end, following standard practice
  • CSCI scores are computed using information available at t‑1 for portfolio formation. execution
    Source sentence
    ... A Shariah‑admissible universe UCSCI>0t = {i ∈Uall t : CSCIi,t‑1 > 0}.
  • Baseline transaction costs are 25 basis points round‑trip. execution
    Source sentence
    Baseline transaction costs are 25 basis points (round‑trip).
  • CSCI is treated as exogenous to expected returns. model
    Source sentence
    The paper treats CSCI as exogenous to expected returns.
Show 2 more
  • Value‑weighted portfolios are formed monthly and held for one month. execution
    Source sentence
    Portfolios are value‑weighted, formed at month‑end t‑1, held during month t, and rebalanced monthly.
  • Sector screens exclude firms in listed non‑permissible SIC codes. data
    Source sentence
    Firms whose primary SIC codes fall in these sectors are assigned a sectoral compliance factor of zero.

Data

Backtest sample: 1999 – 2024 · US equities (CRSP/Compustat) · equities · monthly

  • CRSP monthly stock file · CRSP via WRDS market-prices public
    1999‑2024 · U.S. common stocks listed on NYSE, AMEX, NASDAQ
    Source sentence
    Price and return data are obtained from the CRSP monthly stock file (CRSP MSF)
  • Compustat annual fundamentals · Compustat via WRDS fundamentals public
    1998‑2024 (fiscal year‑ends) · U.S. industrial firms (INDFMT = ‘INDL’)
    Source sentence
    Accounting data are taken from Compustat’s annual fundamental file for industrial firms (INDFMT = ‘INDL’) reporting consolidated, domestic, standard‑format financial statements.
  • CRSP–Compustat merged link table · CRSP/Compustat via WRDS other public
    Source sentence
    We link CRSP and Compustat using the standard CRSP–Compustat merged (CCM) link table.

Recognised sources: CRSP Compustat WRDS

Costs

Modeled Costs are part of the reported headline results.

Baseline transaction costs are 25 basis points (round‑trip).

Source sentence
Baseline transaction costs are 25 basis points (round‑trip).

Finds 5

Reported performance (CSCI-based long-only portfolio (τ=0.50 threshold)): Sharpe 0.95 (benchmark 0.89) · annual return 17.7% · max drawdown 39.5%

  • Binary Shariah standards map to distinct regions of a common compliance scale, so firms with the same pass/fail label can differ materially in compliance strength. theoretical
    Source sentence
    First, existing binary standards map to distinct regions of a common compliance scale, so firms that receive the same pass/fail label can still differ materially in compliance strength.
  • CSCI‑threshold portfolios allow varying compliance intensity while preserving diversification; baseline risk‑adjusted performance declines modestly as thresholds tighten. performance
    Source sentence
    CSCI‑threshold portfolios provide a transparent way to vary compliance intensity while retaining economically meaningful diversification, although baseline risk‑adjusted performance declines modestly as thresholds tighten.
  • The September 2023 DJIM/S&P methodology change admitted firms with materially lower CSCI scores than firms that remained compliant under both old and new rules. performance
    Source sentence
    the September 2023 DJIM/S&P methodology change admits firms with materially lower CSCI scores than firms that remained compliant under both the old and new rules.
  • In cross‑sectional return tests, CSCI is not reliably associated with higher expected returns once standard characteristics are controlled for. negative
    Source sentence
    CSCI is not reliably associated with higher expected returns once standard characteristics are controlled for.
  • Binary Islamic benchmarks deliver strong risk‑adjusted returns (annualised excess returns 23.5%‑26.3% and Sharpe ratios ~1.3‑1.4). performance
    Source sentence
    Annualised excess returns lie between 23.5% and 26.3%, with Sharpe ratios in the range 1.32–1.37.

Checked by others

No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 39 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.

Code

No repository by the authors found in the paper.

Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.