Paper: arXiv 2310.02436
Authors: A. H. Nzokem
Abstract
The S&P 500 index is considered the most popular trading instrument in financial markets. With the rise of cryptocurrencies over the past years, Bitcoin has also grown in popularity and adoption. The paper aims to analyze the daily return distribution of the Bitcoin and S&P 500 index and assess their tail probabilities through two financial risk measures. As a methodology, We use Bitcoin and S&P 500 Index daily return data to fit The seven-parameter General Tempered Stable (GTS) distribution using the advanced Fast Fractional Fourier transform (FRFT) scheme developed by combining the Fast Fractional Fourier (FRFT) algorithm and the 12-point rule Composite Newton-Cotes Quadrature. The findings show that peakedness is the main characteristic of the S&P 500 return distribution, whereas heavy-tailedness is the main characteristic of the Bitcoin return distribution. The GTS distribution shows that $80.05%$ of S&P 500 returns are within \(-1.06%\) and $1.23%$ against only $40.32%$ of Bitcoin returns. At a risk level (\(α\)), the severity of the loss (\(AVaR_α(X)\)) on the left side of the distribution is larger than the severity of the profit (\(AVaR_{“1-α”}(X)\)) on the right side of the distribution. Compared to the S&P 500 index, Bitcoin has $39.73%$ more prevalence to produce high daily returns (more than $1.23%$ or less than \(-1.06%\)). The severity analysis shows that at a risk level (\(α\)) the average value-at-risk (\(AVaR(X)\)) of the bitcoin returns at one significant figure is four times larger than that of the S&P 500 index returns at the same risk.
Complexity vs Empirical Score
- Math Complexity: 8.0/10
- Empirical Rigor: 6.0/10
- Quadrant: Holy Grail — high math complexity, high empirical rigor
Why this score: The paper employs advanced numerical methods (Fast Fractional Fourier transform and quadrature) to fit a complex seven-parameter General Tempered Stable distribution, indicating high math density. It uses substantial real-world daily return data (2010-2023) for both Bitcoin and S&P 500, and calculates specific risk metrics like VaR and AVaR, demonstrating backtest-ready empirical analysis.
Research Flowchart
flowchart TD
A["Research Goal:<br>Analyze & Compare Bitcoin vs S&P 500<br>Return Distributions & Tail Risk"] --> B["Input Data:<br>Daily Return Data"]
B --> C["Methodology:<br>Fit 7-Param GTS Distribution<br>via FRFT & Newton-Cotes Quadrature"]
C --> D["Computational Process:<br>Calculate Tail Probabilities<br>& Average Value-at-Risk AVaR_α"]
D --> E{"Key Findings & Outcomes"}
E --> F["1. S&P 500: Peaked Distribution<br>80% of returns within ±1.2%"]
E --> G["2. Bitcoin: Heavy-Tailed Distribution<br>High volatility; 40% within ±1.2%"]
E --> H["3. Risk Severity<br>Bitcoin AVaR ≈ 4x larger than S&P 500<br>Higher downside risk"]
Evidence Card
What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card
Proposes
The paper proposes fitting daily Bitcoin and S&P 500 returns with a seven‑parameter General Tempered Stable distribution using an advanced Fast Fractional Fourier Transform scheme.
Source sentence
We use Bitcoin and S&P 500 Index daily return data to fit The seven-parameter General Tempered Stable (GTS) distribution using the advanced Fast Fractional Fourier transform (FRFT) scheme developed by combining the Fast Fractional Fourier (FRFT) algorithm and the 12-point rule Composite Newton-Cotes Quadrature.
Assumes 3
- The return distribution function is continuous with no point masses. statistical
Source sentence
the return distribution function is continuous; that is, there are no point masses.
- The Fourier transform of the density is zero outside a finite interval. model
Source sentence
We assume that F[f](y) is zero outside the interval [−a/2, a/2];
- F[f](x) is zero outside the interval [−a/2, a/2]. model
Source sentence
We assume that F[f](x) is zero outside the interval [−a/2, a/2]
Data
- Bitcoin price data market-prices public
Source sentence
The Bitcoin BTC price was extracted from CoinMarketCap and spanned from January 04, 2010, to June 16, 2023.
- S&P 500 index price data market-prices public
Source sentence
The S&P 500 data were extracted from Yahoo Finance. The historical prices span from April 28, 2013, to June 22, 2023, and were adjusted for splits and dividends.
Costs
Not applicable
Finds 5
- The S&P 500 return distribution is characterized by peakedness, while the Bitcoin return distribution is characterized by heavy‑tailedness. statistical
Source sentence
The findings show that peakedness is the main characteristic of the S&P 500 return distribution, whereas heavy-tailedness is the main characteristic of the Bitcoin return distribution.
- 80.05% of S&P 500 returns lie within –1.06% and 1.23%, compared with only 40.32% of Bitcoin returns. statistical
Source sentence
The GTS distribution shows that 80.05% of S&P 500 returns are within −1.06% and 1.23% against only 40.32% of Bitcoin returns.
- Bitcoin has 39.73% higher prevalence of extreme daily returns (outside ±1.06%/1.23%) than the S&P 500. statistical
Source sentence
Compared to the S&P 500 index, Bitcoin has 39.73% more prevalence to produce high daily returns (more than 1.23% or less than −1.06%).
- At any risk level α, the loss severity (AVaRα) on the left tail exceeds the profit severity (AVaR1−α) on the right tail. statistical
Source sentence
At a risk level (α), the severity of the loss (AVaRα(X)) on the left side of the distribution is larger than the severity of the profit (AVaR1−α(X)) on the right side of the distribution.
- The average value‑at‑risk of Bitcoin returns is about four times that of S&P 500 returns at the same risk level. statistical
Source sentence
the average value-at-risk (AVaR(X)) of the bitcoin returns at one significant figure is four times larger than that of the S&P 500 index returns at the same risk.
Checked by others
Supported by
- Stylized Facts of High-Frequency Bitcoin Time Series
Compare the findings
This paper: The S&P 500 return distribution is characterized by peakedness, while the Bitcoin return distribution is characterized by heavy‑tailedness.
That paper: Both periods display heavy‑tailed returns that are well captured by a q‑Gaussian distribution with q≈1.5.
4 papers in the archive : Pricing options on the cryptocurrency futures contracts
Code
No repository by the authors found in the paper.
Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.