Paper: arXiv 2309.00390

Authors: Esther Cabezas-Rivas, Felipe Sánchez-Coll, Isaac Tormo-Xaixo

Abstract

The aim of this paper is to analyse the Bitcoin in order to shed some light on its nature and behaviour. We select 9 cryptocurrencies that account for almost 75% of total market capitalisation and compare their evolution with that of a wide variety of traditional assets: commodities with spot and futures contracts, treasury bonds, stock indices, growth and value stocks. Fractal geometry will be applied to carry out a careful statistical analysis of the performance of the Bitcoin returns. As a main conclusion, we have detected a high degree of persistence in its prices, which decreases the efficiency but increases its predictability. Moreover, we observe that the underlying technology influences price dynamics, with fully decentralised cryptocurrencies being the only ones to exhibit self-similarity features at any time scale.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 6.5/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 4.0/10
  • Quadrant: Lab Rats — high math complexity, limited empirical testing

Why this score: The paper employs advanced fractal geometry and the R/S method with statistical inference tests, representing substantial mathematical density. However, its empirical rigor is moderate, relying on historical price data and statistical analysis rather than backtesting a specific trading strategy or implementing complex data pipelines.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
  A["Research Goal<br>Analyze nature of Bitcoin & cryptocurrencies"] --> B["Data Selection<br>9 top cryptocurrencies<br>+ Traditional assets"]
  B --> C["Methodology<br>Fractal Geometry & Statistical Analysis"]
  C --> D{"Computational Process<br>Analyze price returns<br>at multiple time scales"}
  D --> E["Persistence detected<br>High degree in prices"]
  D --> F["Efficiency vs. Predictability<br>Persistence decreases efficiency<br>Increases predictability"]
  D --> G["Technology Influence<br>Fully decentralized coins show<br>self-similarity at all scales"]
  E --> H["Key Outcomes<br>Bitcoin nature: Chaotic but predictable<br>Tech dictates fractal behavior"]
  F --> H
  G --> H

Evidence Card

What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card

Proposes

The paper proposes to apply fractal geometry, specifically the robust R/S method with additional inference tests, to analyse Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies and compare them with traditional assets.

Source sentence
Fractal geometry will be applied to carry out a careful statistical analysis of the performance of the Bitcoin returns. CHANCE OR CHAOS? FRACTAL GEOMETRY AIMED TO INSPECT BTC 3 About the techniques we apply to drive the above conclusions, despite they are quite classical going back to Mandelbrot original development of fractal geometry, we enhance them with a proper rigorous mathematical approach by including a

Assumes 6

  • The return series are stationary, which is required for the R/S analysis. statistical
    Source sentence
    Test for stationarity as prerequisite for R/S analysis. Despite this step is often skipped, to be rigorous, one needs to check that the assumptions of a method are fulfilled before applying it, in this case, that all time series are stationary.
  • The R/S method’s minimal requirements are satisfied by the data (e.g., no need for normality). statistical
    Source sentence
    Likewise, regardless of the more sophisticated statistical tools in the recent literature (as dfa or mf-dfa), as highlighted in [40], most of them assume that the variables creating time series follow a normal distribution, even knowing that this is typically not the case. To avoid this restriction, we have chosen the robust R/S method [35, 5] to com-pute the fractal dimension, since it has minimal requirements,
  • Cryptocurrency price series are independent of macro‑economic variables, allowing focus on technology‑driven effects. model
    Source sentence
    Our results upgrade the previous literature in several directions: we pioneer in disclosing that it is the underlying technology, instead of the capitalization, the crucial element influencing cc prices; we also open a new research line that challenges the widely accepted impermeability of the cc market to the macroeco-nomic environment.
  • All selected cryptoassets represent at least 0.5% of market volume and together account for roughly 74‑75% of total market capitalisation. data
    Source sentence
    Regarding the selection of cc, we applied the Pareto principle to their capi-talisation, according to which 80% of the results are due to 20% of the variables 8 E. CABEZAS-RIVAS, F. S´ANCHEZ-COLL, I. TORMO involved. Although the 9 selected cc “only” accumulate approximately 74% of the total market capitalisation (see Table 2), we have ruled out cc with volume percentages below 0.5%, which we consider to be
Show 2 more
  • The underlying consensus protocol (decentralised vs centralised) is the key factor influencing price dynamics. model
    Source sentence
    Our results upgrade the previous literature in several directions: we pioneer in disclosing that it is the underlying technology, instead of the capitalization, the crucial element influencing cc prices; we also open a new research line that challenges the widely accepted impermeability of the cc market to the macroeco-nomic environment. Up to our knowledge, we pioneer in stressing that it is the underlying
  • The selected 9 cryptocurrencies are representative of five different consensus protocols. data
    Source sentence
    Let us stress that we have chosen archetypes of five different consensus protocols to enable our aim of comparing cc on the basis of their underlying technology.

Data

  • Binance cryptocurrency price dataset · Binance market-prices commercial
    20/8/2020 to 24/2/2023 · BTC and eight other cryptocurrencies
    Source sentence
    We have worked with a dataset (obtained from Binance) containing the prices of btc and eight other cc (see Table 1) over the time period from 20/8/2020 to 24/2/2023, considering CHANCE OR CHAOS? FRACTAL GEOMETRY AIMED TO INSPECT BTC 7 opening values every 15 minutes (N = 88,060 observations), 1 hour (N = 22,019) and 1 day (N = 919).
  • Bloomberg daily price series · Bloomberg market-prices commercial
    20/8/2020 to 24/2/2023 · Gold, crude oil, wheat, silver, 10‑year US Treasury futures, Nasdaq, EuroStoxx, Tesla, Net
    Source sentence
    In order to compare with other assets traded on traditional financial markets, time series have been selected from Bloomberg with daily values of: ◦3 commodities with futures contracts (gold, crude oil and wheat), ◦one spot commodity (silver), ◦a 10-year US Treasury bond futures contract (FC), ◦2 stock market indices (Nasdaq and EuroStoxx), ◦3 growth stocks (Tesla, Netflix and Amazon), and 3 value stocks (The

Recognised sources: Binance Bloomberg

Costs

Not applicable The paper reports no trading or execution result.

Finds 5

  • Bitcoin exhibits a high degree of persistence and long memory, indicating self‑similar fractal behaviour across frequencies and time intervals. statistical
    Source sentence
    As a main conclusion, we have detected a high degree of persistence in its prices, which decreases the efficiency but increases its predictability. Via the Hurst values (H), we confirm that the btc dynamics are not independent, but have long memory, even if we change the time interval or the frequency of data collection.
  • Purely decentralised cryptocurrencies show clear signs of chaoticity and self‑similarity, unlike centrally‑controlled cryptoassets and traditional assets. statistical
    Source sentence
    As highlights of our findings, for all cc with purely decentralized technologies (that is, that really get rid of intermediaries or audit control) we detect clear signs of chaoticity, which do not fit under any traditional Gaussian patterns. Further-more, the computation of the fractal dimension under different time frames and scales certainly reveals that these cc present long memory and self similarity properties.
  • Technical analysis based on past data is justified for Bitcoin, but changing the scale does not improve prediction accuracy. predictive-accuracy
    Source sentence
    Hence technical analysis of past data is well-founded but shifting the scale is helpless to get finer predictions.
  • Bitcoin does not act as a safe‑haven or diversification tool; its correlation with conservative assets is weak, and it moves similarly to other cryptoassets and growth stocks. performance
    Source sentence
    Moreover, we conclude that btc is far from acting like the more conservative safe haven products for investors, as no no correlation with them arose. If we now restrict to the interrelations within the cryptosphere, all cc are very tightly correlated as expected (see Tables 18 and 19 for the full matrices of the full 20 E. CABEZAS-RIVAS, F. S´ANCHEZ-COLL, I. TORMO period and the first subinterval, respectively).
  • The underlying technology, rather than market capitalisation, determines differences in cryptocurrency performance. theoretical
    Source sentence
    Our results upgrade the previous literature in several directions: we pioneer in disclosing that it is the underlying technology, instead of the capitalization, the crucial element influencing cc prices; we also open a new research line that challenges the widely accepted impermeability of the cc market to the macroeco-nomic environment. Up to our knowledge, we pioneer in stressing that it is the underlying

Checked by others

Supported by

  • Cryptocurrencies Are Becoming Part of the World Global Financial Market (2023)
    On the question: Does Bitcoin serve as a hedge or safe‑haven for stock market investments?
    Compare the findings

    This paper: Bitcoin does not act as a safe‑haven or diversification tool; its correlation with conservative assets is weak, and it moves similarly to other cryptoassets and growth stocks.

    That paper: Bitcoin and Ethereum cannot serve as a hedge or safe haven for stock market investments, both during Covid‑19 turbulence and the recent tech‑stock bear market.

    Both A and B find Bitcoin fails as a hedge/safe‑haven; A notes this during Covid‑19 turbulence and the recent tech‑stock bear market, B reports weak correlation with conservative assets and similar moves to other crypto

  • Multifractality in Bitcoin Realised Volatility: Implications for Rough Volatility Modelling (2025)
    On the question: Does Bitcoin exhibit fractal or multifractal temporal structure in its price and realised volatility?
    Compare the findings

    This paper: Bitcoin exhibits a high degree of persistence and long memory, indicating self‑similar fractal behaviour across frequencies and time intervals.

    That paper: Multifractal Detrended Fluctuation Analysis, log‑log moment scaling, and wavelet leaders consistently indicate a robust multifractal temporal structure in Bitcoin realised volatility.

    Both findings report a high degree of persistence and a robust multifractal temporal structure, confirming fractal behaviour across frequencies and in realised volatility.

Contradicted by

  • Cryptocurrency co-investment network: token returns reflect investment patterns (2023)
    On the question: What factor primarily drives cryptocurrency performance?
    Compare the findings

    This paper: The underlying technology, rather than market capitalisation, determines differences in cryptocurrency performance.

    That paper: The evolution of cryptocurrency market capitalization is highly correlated with the size of institutional investments.

    A links performance to market‑cap and institutional investment size, B links it to underlying technology; the two explanations contradict each other.

Code

No repository by the authors found in the paper.

Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.