Paper: arXiv 2406.12098
Authors: Peter Klimek, Maximilian Hess, Markus Gerschberger, Stefan Thurner
Abstract
The steel industry is a major contributor to CO2 emissions, accounting for 7% of global emissions. The European steel industry is seeking to reduce its emissions by increasing the use of electric arc furnaces (EAFs), which can produce steel from scrap, marking a major shift towards a circular steel economy. Here, we show by combining trade with business intelligence data that this shift requires a deep restructuring of the global and European scrap trade, as well as a substantial scaling of the underlying business ecosystem. We find that the scrap imports of European countries with major EAF installations have steadily decreased since 2007 while globally scrap trade started to increase recently. Our statistical modelling shows that every 1,000 tonnes of EAF capacity installed is associated with an increase in annual imports of 550 tonnes and a decrease in annual exports of 1,000 tonnes of scrap, suggesting increased competition for scrap metal as countries ramp up their EAF capacity. Furthermore, each scrap company enables an increase of around 79,000 tonnes of EAF-based steel production per year in the EU. Taking these relations as causal and extrapolating to the currently planned EAF capacity, we find that an additional 730 (SD 140) companies might be required, employing about 35,000 people (IQR 29,000-50,000) and generating an additional estimated turnover of USD 35 billion (IQR 27-48). Our results thus suggest that scrap metal is likely to become a strategic resource. They highlight the need for a massive restructuring of the industry’s supply networks and identify the resulting growth opportunities for companies.
Complexity vs Empirical Score
- Math Complexity: 3.5/10
- Empirical Rigor: 7.0/10
- Quadrant: Street Traders — empirical and applied, lower math complexity
Why this score: The paper employs statistical modeling and linear regression with fixed effects, which is moderately advanced but not highly dense mathematically. It is heavily data-driven, using large trade and business datasets, performing topic modeling, and providing specific numerical forecasts, making it highly backtest-ready and implementation-focused.
Research Flowchart
flowchart TD A["<b>Research Goal:</b><br>Quantify scrap metal's strategic role<br>in European steel's circular transition"] --> B["<b>Methodology:</b><br>Trade & Business Intelligence Analysis"] B --> C["<b>Data Inputs:</b><br>Global Scrap Trade Data<br>EU Business Intelligence<br>EAF Capacity Statistics"] C --> D["<b>Computational Process:</b><br>Statistical Modelling &<br>Causal Extrapolation"] D --> E["<b>Key Findings:</b><br>1. Scrap imports ↓, exports ↓ with EAF growth<br>2. 1,000t EAF capacity → 550t import increase<br>3. 1 scrap company → 79,000t EU steel production"] D --> F["<b>Outcomes:</b><br>730 new companies needed<br>35,000 new jobs<br>$35B additional turnover<br>Scrap = Strategic Resource"]
Evidence Card
What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card
Proposes
The paper proposes a quantitative model that combines comprehensive trade data with business‑intelligence data on scrap‑related companies to assess how the European steel industry's shift to electric arc furnaces will reshape scrap trade and the underlying firm ecosystem.
Source sentence
Here, we show by combining trade with business intelligence data that this shift requires a deep restructuring of the global and European scrap trade, as well as a substantial scaling of the underlying business ecosystem.
Assumes 6
- The observed correlations between EAF capacity, scrap trade flows and the number of scrap‑related firms are causal. model
Source sentence
By assuming that these observed correlations are causal and extrapolating these relationships to currently planned EAF capacity [4], we quantify the changes required in the scrap trade and underlying companies.
- Planned EAF capacity will be realized. execution
Source sentence
In doing so, we make several assumptions, namely (1) that the planned EAF capacity will be realized, (2) that there will be sufficient steel demand to operate these facilities at similar capacity levels as today, and (3) that there is indeed a causal relationship in which EAF capacity drives the number of scrap companies, i.e., that most of the business of these companies actually consists of transporting scrap to
- There will be sufficient steel demand to operate the new EAF facilities at similar capacity levels as today. market
Source sentence
In doing so, we make several assumptions, namely (1) that the planned EAF capacity will be realized, (2) that there will be sufficient steel demand to operate these facilities at similar capacity levels as today, and (3) that there is indeed a causal relationship in which EAF capacity drives the number of scrap companies, i.e., that most of the business of these companies actually consists of transporting scrap to
- EAF capacity drives the number of scrap‑related companies, i.e., most of their business consists of transporting scrap to EAF facilities. other
Source sentence
In doing so, we make several assumptions, namely (1) that the planned EAF capacity will be realized, (2) that there will be sufficient steel demand to operate these facilities at similar capacity levels as today, and (3) that there is indeed a causal relationship in which EAF capacity drives the number of scrap companies, i.e., that most of the business of these companies actually consists of transporting scrap to
Show 2 more
- The planned EAF installations will be operated with the same capacity and productivity as the currently installed EAF facilities. model
Source sentence
This implicitly assumes that this planned EAF installations will be operated with the same capacity and productivity as the currently installed EAF facilities.
- Operating revenue and employee numbers of additional firms can be sampled from the empirical distribution functions of existing firms. statistical
Source sentence
Therefore, in order to estimate the additional revenue and employees of the additional scrap companies, we sample these values for each country from their empirical distribution function.
Data
- BACI dataset macro commercial
Source sentence
Data on bilateral trade flows for about 200 countries going back to 2007 are used, as provided by the BACI dataset [18].
- Orbis database text-news commercial
Source sentence
Commercial company data from Bureau van Dijk is used, the Orbis database [20]. In the present analysis, we use a snapshot (bulk downloaded) version of the data from 2023 and focus only on European countries in the statistical modelling, where coverage of the company population is typically considered to be higher than for some other world regions [21].
Costs
Not applicable
Finds 5
- Every 1,000 t of installed EAF capacity is associated with an increase of 550 t in annual scrap imports and a decrease of 1,000 t in annual scrap exports, indicating heightened competition for scrap. statistical
Source sentence
Our statistical modelling shows that every 1,000 tonnes of EAF capacity installed is associated with an increase in annual imports of 550 tonnes and a decrease in annual exports of 1,000 tonnes of scrap, suggesting increased competition for scrap metal as countries ramp up their EAF capacity.
- Each scrap‑related company enables roughly 79,000 t of EAF‑based steel production per year in the EU. statistical
Source sentence
Furthermore, each scrap company enables an increase of around 79,000 tonnes of EAF-based steel production per year in the EU.
- Extrapolating to planned EAF capacity suggests an additional 730 (SD 140) companies, about 35,000 (IQR 29,000‑50,000) employees, and USD 35 billion (IQR 27‑48) turnover are required. statistical
Source sentence
Taking these relations as causal and extrapolating to the currently planned EAF capacity, we find that an additional 730 (SD 140) companies might be required, employing about 35,000 people (IQR 29,000-50,000) and generating an additional estimated turnover of USD 35 billion (IQR 27-48). Overall, extrapolating from the current EAF capacity suggests that the planned EAF capacity implies an additional 730 (SD 140)
- Scrap imports of European countries with major EAF installations have steadily decreased since 2007, while global scrap trade has risen in recent years. statistical
Source sentence
We find that the scrap imports of European countries with major EAF installations have steadily decreased since 2007 while globally scrap trade started to increase recently. Looking at the combined values of all (D) imports and (E) exports, we see a trend of declining trade in scrap from the first to the second period, followed by an increase in global trade from the second to the third.
- Regression of imports, exports and the number of scrap‑related firms on planned EAF capacity yields a very high fit (adjusted R² = 0.98). statistical
Source sentence
We then used a regression model to extrapolate imports, exports, and the number of scrap-related companies to planned EAF capacity in Europe, taking advantage of the observed strong correlations (adjusted R-squared of 0.98) between these variables.
Checked by others
No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 13 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.
Code
No repository by the authors found in the paper.
Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.
Cited References (40)
- Environmental ranking of European industrial facilities by toxicity and global warming potentials (2023)
- A review of CO2 emissions reduction technologies and low-carbon development in the iron and steel industry focusing on China (2021)
- Latent dirichlet allocation (2003)
- Temporal patterns of happiness and information in a global social network: Hedonometrics and Twitter (2011)
- Evaluation methods for topic models (2009)
- Private company information–Orbis.(nd). Bvd (2023)
- Coverage and representativeness of Orbis data (2020) — link
- Stochastic collapsed variational Bayesian inference for latent Dirichlet allocation (2013)
and 32 more
- Extracting the multiscale backbone of complex weighted networks (2009)
- BACI: International Trade Database at the Product-Level. The 1994-2007 Version (2010) — link
- Characteristics and community evolution patterns of the international scrap metal trade (2020)
- Renewables-based decarbonization and relocation of iron and steel making: A case study (2020)
- Interaction between electrified steel production and the north European electricity system (2022)
- Pathways to a CO2-Neutral European Steel Industry. (2019)
- Estimating the impact of arc furnaces on the quality of power in supply systems (2020)
- Modeling the effect of scrap on the electrical energy consumption of an electric arc furnace (2020)
- Increase of capacity in electric arc-furnace steel mill factories by means of a demand-side management strategy and ampacity techniques (2021)
- Data-driven modelling and optimization of energy consumption in EAF (2022)
- Assessment of hydrogen direct reduction for fossil-free steelmaking (2018)
- Scrap use in the steel industry
- Low-CO2 emissions projects in the EU steel industry
- Global Energy Monitor 2023. Pedal to the Metal. (2023)
- Critical challenges facing low carbon steelmaking technology using hydrogen direct reduced iron (2022)
- Global green hydrogen-based steel opportunities surrounding high quality renewable energy and iron ore deposits (2023)
- The steel scrap age (2013)
- Technologies to decarbonise the EU steel industry (2022)
- Corporate Responsibility Report 2021/22 (2023)
- The index of general nonlinear D A E S (1995)
- Clinical implications of dysregulated cytokine production (2000) — link
- Quasimonotonicity, regularity and duality for nonlinear systems of partial differential equations (1995)
- Algorithms for C omputer A lgebra (1992)
- Software engineering—from auxiliary to key technologies (1992)
- Conductive P olymers (1981)
- Neuromuscular blocking drugs in man (1976)
- Isolation and characterization of plasmid deoxyribonucleic acid from Streptomyces fradiae (1978)
- Global integrated drought monitoring and prediction system (GIDMaPS) data sets (2014)
- Quantum scissors: teleportation of single-mode optical states by means of a nonlocal single photon (2002)
- Mixing induced CP asymmetries in inclusive B decays (1997) — link
- deep SIP : deep learning of S upernova I a P arameters (2020)
- Dark Energy Survey Year 1 Results: Constraints on Extended Cosmological Models from Galaxy Clustering and Weak Lensing (2019) — link
0 of 40 cited works are in the corpus; resolved via arXiv source bundles, Semantic Scholar and OpenAlex. Corpus-wide: 2596 linked papers.