Paper: arXiv 2505.05646

Authors: Xin Tian

Abstract

This report presents a comprehensive evaluation of three Value-at-Risk (VaR) modeling approaches: Historical Simulation (HS), GARCH with Normal approximation (GARCH-N), and GARCH with Filtered Historical Simulation (FHS), using both in-sample and multi-day forecasting frameworks. We compute daily 5 percent VaR estimates using each method and assess their accuracy via empirical breach frequencies and visual breach indicators. Our findings reveal severe miscalibration in the HS and GARCH-N models, with empirical breach rates far exceeding theoretical levels. In contrast, the FHS method consistently aligns with theoretical expectations and exhibits desirable statistical and visual behavior. We further simulate 5-day cumulative returns under both GARCH-N and GARCH-FHS frameworks to compute multi-period VaR and Expected Shortfall. Results show that GARCH-N underestimates tail risk due to its reliance on the Gaussian assumption, whereas GARCH-FHS provides more robust and conservative tail estimates. Overall, the study demonstrates that the GARCH-FHS model offers superior performance in capturing fat-tailed risks and provides more reliable short-term risk forecasts.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 7.0/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 6.5/10
  • Quadrant: Holy Grail — high math complexity, high empirical rigor

Why this score: The paper employs advanced statistical models like GARCH and filters like FHS, which involve complex time-series mathematics, but also implements empirical backtesting with breach frequency analysis and visual diagnostics, making it both mathematically dense and data/implementation-heavy.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
  A["Research Goal: Comparative Evaluation of VaR Models<br>HS, GARCH-N, GARCH-FHS"] --> B["Data Input<br>Daily Returns for In-sample & Forecasting"]
  B --> C["Methodology: VaR Computation (5%)<br>1. Historical Simulation (HS)<br>2. GARCH-Normal (GARCH-N)<br>3. Filtered Hist. Sim. (GARCH-FHS)"]
  C --> D["Assessment: Accuracy & Breach Frequency<br>Compare Empirical Breaches vs 5%"]
  D --> E["Multi-Period Analysis (5-day)<br>Simulate Cumulative Returns<br>Compute VaR & Expected Shortfall"]
  E --> F["Key Findings & Outcomes"]
  F --> F1["HS & GARCH-N: Severe Miscalibration<br>High Breach Rates"]
  F --> F2["GARCH-FHS: Superior Performance<br>Aligns with Theoretical Levels"]
  F --> F3["GARCH-N: Underestimates Tail Risk<br>(Gaussian Assumption)"]
  F --> F4["GARCH-FHS: Robust Tail Estimates<br>Recommended for Risk Management"]

Evidence Card

What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card

Proposes

The paper proposes using the GARCH‑FHS method for risk management and 1‑week ahead forecasting.

Source sentence
We recommend the FHS method for practical applications in risk management, particularly in volatile market environments and high‑confidence settings.

Assumes 3

  • GARCH‑N relies on a Gaussian (normal) distribution for standardized residuals. model
    Source sentence
    GARCH‑N underestimates tail risk due to its reliance on the Gaussian assumption
  • Historical Simulation assumes a static historical return distribution. model
    Source sentence
    the assumption of a static historical distribution becomes invalid
  • Return volatility is heteroskedastic, making identically distributed returns within the estimation window problematic. statistical
    Source sentence
    if return volatility is heteroskedastic—as is often the case in financial markets—then assuming identically distributed returns within the estimation window is itself problematic

Data

No dataset named in the text.

Costs

Not applicable The paper reports no trading or execution result.

Finds 5

  • Historical Simulation and GARCH‑N show severe miscalibration with empirical breach rates far exceeding theoretical 5% and 1% levels. performance
    Source sentence
    Our findings reveal severe miscalibration in the HS and GARCH‑N models, with empirical breach rates far exceeding theoretical levels at both 5% and 1% confidence thresholds.
  • Filtered Historical Simulation consistently aligns with theoretical expectations and shows desirable statistical and visual behavior. performance
    Source sentence
    In contrast, the FHS method consistently aligns with theoretical expectations and exhibits desirable statistical and visual behavior.
  • GARCH‑N underestimates tail risk because of its Gaussian assumption. negative
    Source sentence
    Results show that GARCH‑N underestimates tail risk due to its reliance on the Gaussian assumption
  • GARCH‑FHS provides more robust and conservative tail estimates than GARCH‑N. performance
    Source sentence
    whereas GARCH‑FHS provides more robust and conservative tail estimates
  • GARCH‑FHS outperforms GARCH‑N for multi‑day VaR and Expected Shortfall estimation at extreme quantiles. performance
    Source sentence
    Overall, the GARCH + FHS method outperforms GARCH + Normal in terms of accuracy and robustness for estimating multi‑day VaR and ES at extreme quantiles.

Checked by others

Supported by

  • Portfolio Stress Testing and Value at Risk (VaR) Incorporating Current Market Conditions (2024)
    On the question: Do Gaussian‑based VaR methods underestimate tail risk compared to non‑Gaussian approaches?
    Compare the findings

    This paper: GARCH‑N underestimates tail risk because of its Gaussian assumption.

    That paper: Gaussian‑parametrized VaR is lower than Historical Simulation VaR for the 97.5% confidence level because the Gaussian distribution does not capture heavy tails.

    Both find Gaussian‑based VaR is lower: A shows Gaussian VaR < Historical Simulation VaR at 97.5% confidence, and B shows GARCH‑N underestimates tail risk due to its Gaussian assumption.

Qualified by

  • Reliability-Aware ETF Tail-Risk Monitoring (2026)
    On the question: Which VaR approach yields breach rates closest to the intended confidence level?
    Compare the findings

    This paper: Historical Simulation and GARCH‑N show severe miscalibration with empirical breach rates far exceeding theoretical 5% and 1% levels.

    That paper: The 252‑day historical VaR benchmark is conservative (breach rate 4.42%), whereas the EWMA‑normal benchmark remains under‑covered (5.75%).

    A shows severe miscalibration (breaches far above 5%/1%); B shows 252‑day historical VaR is conservative at 4.42% while EWMA‑normal is under‑covered at 5.75%.

Code

No repository by the authors found in the paper.

Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.

Cited References (1)

  1. A LaTeX package to create plots. — link

0 of 1 cited works are in the corpus; resolved via arXiv source bundles, Semantic Scholar and OpenAlex. Corpus-wide: 2596 linked papers.