Paper: arXiv 2407.13908

Authors: Maciej Wysocki, Robert Ślepaczuk

Abstract

This research presents a comprehensive evaluation of systematic index option-writing strategies, focusing on S&P500 index options. We compare the performance of hedging strategies using the Black-Scholes-Merton (BSM) model and the Variance-Gamma (VG) model, emphasizing varying moneyness levels and different sizing methods based on delta and the VIX Index. The study employs 1-minute data of S&P500 index options and index quotes spanning from 2018 to 2023. The analysis benchmarks hedged strategies against buy-and-hold and naked option-writing strategies, with a focus on risk-adjusted performance metrics including transaction costs. Portfolio delta approximations are derived using implied volatility for the BSM model and market-calibrated parameters for the VG model. Key findings reveal that systematic option-writing strategies can potentially yield superior returns compared to buy-and-hold benchmarks. The BSM model generally provided better hedging outcomes than the VG model, although the VG model showed profitability in certain naked strategies as a tool for position sizing. In terms of rehedging frequency, we found that intraday hedging in 130-minute intervals provided both reliable protection against adverse market movements and a satisfactory returns profile.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 7.0/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 6.0/10 (capped from 8.5: no out-of-sample test; see penalty flags)
  • Quadrant: Holy Grail — high math complexity, high empirical rigor (effective empirical rigor capped from 8.5)

Why this score: The paper involves advanced mathematics including partial differential equations (BSM), Levy processes (Variance-Gamma), and Fourier transform methods, scoring high on math complexity. It is extremely rigorous empirically, using high-frequency 1-minute data (2018-2023), realistic transaction cost models, specific rehedging intervals (130 minutes), and comparative backtests against benchmarks, making it highly backtest-ready.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
  A["Research Goal: Evaluate systematic<br>index option-writing strategies"] --> B["Data Collection:<br>S&P500 Options & Index 1-min data<br>2018-2023"]
  B --> C["Model Calibration:<br>BSM & Variance-Gamma Models"]
  C --> D["Hedging Engine:<br>Delta & VIX-based Sizing<br>130-min Rehedging"]
  D --> E{"Performance Benchmarks"}
  E --> F["Buy & Hold"]
  E --> G["Naked Option Writing"]
  D --> H["Cost Integration:<br>Transaction Costs"]
  H --> I["Outcome: Risk-Adjusted Metrics<br>BSM superior hedging<br>VG useful for naked sizing"]

Evidence Card

What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card

Proposes

The paper evaluates systematic S&P500 index option‑writing strategies and compares hedging using the Black‑Scholes‑Merton model versus the Variance‑Gamma model.

Source sentence
This research presents a comprehensive evaluation of systematic index option-writing strategies, focusing on S&P500 index options.

Assumes 6

  • Buy and sell orders are executed at the midpoint of the bid‑ask spread, covering half of the spread. execution
    Source sentence
    We adopted a stringent assumption regarding order fills, considering that buy and sell orders are executed at the midpoint of the bid and ask prices, covering half of the bid-ask spread.
  • Delta is calculated using the last available implied volatility from the previous minute. model
    Source sentence
    at each timestamp t, when delta was required, we utilized σIV i,t−1, which denotes the i-th option’s BSM implied volatility from timestamp t −1, essentially from the previous minute.
  • Model parameters are recalibrated every 30 minutes during each trading session. model
    Source sentence
    Calibration was performed every 30 minutes during each trading session to ensure t…
  • Hedging adjustments are made at fixed intervals (30 min, 130 min, or daily). execution
    Source sentence
    In the case of hedged strategies, the options positions were hedged every 30 minutes, 130 minutes, 1 day.
Show 2 more
  • The delta‑hedging instrument is the ETF that tracks the underlying index. execution
    Source sentence
    The delta hedging procedure involves buying and selling the ETF tracking the underlying index.
  • Buy‑and‑hold and naked option‑writing strategies are used as benchmarks. other
    Source sentence
    ... Additionally, we presented results of naked strategies, which were the same

Data

  • 1‑minute S&P500 index quotes and options · CBOE options commercial
    2018‑2023 · S&P500 index options
    Source sentence
    The study employs 1‑minute data of S&P500 index options and index quotes spanning from 2018 to 2023.
  • VIX Index macro public
    Source sentence
    Two sizing methods, based on delta and the VIX Index, were designed.

Recognised sources: Cboe

Costs

Modeled Costs are part of the reported headline results.

Commissions reflect Interactive Brokers fees; order fills assumed at midpoint covering half the spread.

Source sentence
Our commissions model reflects fees from the Interactive Brokers brokerage firm1. Furthermore, we adopted a stringent assumption regarding order fills, considering that buy and sell orders are executed at the midpoint of the bid and ask prices, covering half of the bid-ask spread.

Finds 5

  • Systematic option‑writing strategies can potentially yield superior returns compared to buy‑and‑hold benchmarks. performance
    Source sentence
    Key findings reveal that systematic option‑writing strategies can potentially yield superior returns compared to buy‑and‑hold benchmarks.
  • The BSM model generally provided better hedging outcomes than the VG model. performance
    Source sentence
    The BSM model generally provided better hedging outcomes than the VG model, although the VG model showed profitability in certain naked strategies as a tool for position sizing.
  • Intraday hedging in 130‑minute intervals offers reliable protection and a satisfactory returns profile. performance
    Source sentence
    In terms of rehedging frequency, we found that intraday hedging in 130‑minute intervals provided both reliable protection against adverse market movements and a satisfactory returns profile.
  • BSM‑hedged strategies with more frequent re‑hedging (30 min or 130 min) consistently delivered improved risk‑adjusted returns and lower volatility. performance
    Source sentence
    Strategies hedged with the Black‑Scholes‑Merton (BSM) model, especially those with more frequent rehedging intervals, consistently delivered improved risk‑adjusted returns and lower volatility.
  • VG‑hedged strategies showed competitive performance only in a few VIX‑sized systems, otherwise exhibiting greater risk exposure. performance
    Source sentence
    The VG model showed competitive performance in a few systems, mainly the VIX‑sized strategies, highlighting its suitability under specific circumstances.

Checked by others

No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 42 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.

Code

No repository by the authors found in the paper.

Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.

Cited References (32)

  1. Does Algorithmic Trading Improve Liquidity ? (2011) — link
  2. The Shape and Term Structure of the Index Option Smirk : Why Multifactor Stochastic Volatility Models Work So Well (2009) — link
  3. The Pricing of Options and Corporate Liabilities (1973)
  4. The Theory of Rational Option Pricing (1973) — link
  5. A Closed - Form Solution for Options with Stochastic Volatility with Applications to Bond and Currency Options (1993)
  6. COS method for option pricing under a regime-switching model with time-changed Lévy processes (2018) — link
  7. A generalized European option pricing model with risk management (2020) — link
  8. Reviewing the hedge funds literature II : Hedge funds’ returns and risk management characteristics (2016)
and 24 more
  1. Financial Market Spillovers during the Quantitative Easing Programmes of the Global Financial Crisis (2007-2009) and the European Debt Crisis (2018) — link
  2. Choosing the right options trading strategy: Risk -return Trade -off and Performance in Different Market Conditions (2022) — link
  3. On profitability of volatility trading on S & P 500 equity index options: The role of trading frictions (2018) — link
  4. Option Pricing Models : From Black - Scholes - Merton to Present (2022) — link
  5. An Empirical Examination of the Variance ‐ Gamma Model for Foreign Currency Options (2005) — link
  6. Efficient Option Pricing by Frame Duality with the Fast Fourier Transform (2015) — link
  7. The Variance Gamma Process and Option Pricing (1998)
  8. Options trading driven by volatility directional accuracy (2007) — link
  9. Option spread and combination trading (2003) — link
  10. Anticipating Uncertainty : Straddles Around Earnings Announcements (2017) — link
  11. Case study of event risk management with options strangles and straddles (2022) — link
  12. The Cash -secured PutWrite Strategy and Performance of Related Benchmark Indexes (2009) — link
  13. Finding Alpha via Covered Index Writing (2006) — link
  14. 35- Year Performance Analysis of Cboe S & P 500 Option - Selling Indices (2022) — link
  15. Robust hedging performance and volatility risk in option markets: Application to Standard and Poor ’s 500 and Taiwan index options (2015) — link
  16. An empirical test of the variance gamma option pricing model (2002) — link
  17. Delta hedging bitcoin options with a smile (2023)
  18. Skewness and Kurtosis in S&P 500 Index Returns Implied by Option Prices (1996)
  19. Delta hedging and volatility-price elasticity: A two-step approach (2023) — link
  20. Option hedging with risk averse reinforcement learning (2021) — link
  21. The impact of option hedging on the spot market volatility (2022) — link
  22. Empirical deep hedging (2023) — link
  23. Optimal delta hedging for options (2017) — link
  24. An improved framework for approximating option prices with application to option portfolio hedging (2016) — link

0 of 32 cited works are in the corpus; resolved via arXiv source bundles, Semantic Scholar and OpenAlex. Corpus-wide: 2596 linked papers.