Paper: arXiv 2512.19621

Authors: Jherek Healy

Abstract

This article provides a list of counterexamples, where some of the popular fx option interpolations break down. Interpolation of FX option prices (or equivalently volatilities), is key to risk-manage not only vanilla FX option books, but also more exotic derivatives which are typically valued with local volatility or local stochastic volatilility models.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 7.5/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 8.0/10
  • Quadrant: Holy Grail — high math complexity, high empirical rigor

Why this score: The paper employs advanced mathematical derivations (e.g., local variance denominator, SVI parameterization, spline theory) but is heavily grounded in real-world market data and implementation issues, with specific numerical examples, calibration procedures, and direct backtesting implications for FX options interpolation.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
  A["Research Goal:<br>Identify breakdown cases in<br>FX Options Interpolation"] --> B["Methodology:<br>Analyze popular interpolation<br>techniques (Vol & Price)"]
  B --> C["Data/Inputs:<br>Selected FX option market data<br>with specific volatility smiles"]
  C --> D["Computational Process:<br>Apply interpolations & test for<br>arbitrage (e.g. negative vol/cdf >1)"]
  D --> E["Key Findings:<br>Counterexamples found where<br>interpolations produce arbitrage,<br>impacting Local Vol/SLV models"]

Evidence Card

What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card

Proposes

The paper provides a list of counterexamples where popular FX option interpolation methods break down.

Source sentence
In this article, we will provide a list of counterexamples, where some of the popular smile representation break down.

Assumes 2

  • The volatility used in the reduced delta ∆R is taken at‑the‑money only. model
    Source sentence
    In the expression of ∆R, the volatility is taken at‑the‑money only.
  • The original market quotes used in the examples contain no arbitrage. market
    Source sentence
    We stress that the original quotes do not have any arbitrage.

Data

  • AUD/NZD 7‑day FX options options unknown
    2014‑07‑02 · AUD/NZD
    Source sentence
    It consists of FX options on AUD/NZD expiring in 7 days as of 2014/07/02.
  • USD/AED 9‑month FX options options unknown
    2023‑01‑24 · USD/AED
    Source sentence
    options on USD/AED options expiring in 9 months as of 2023/01/24.
  • EURUSD 1‑month FX options · Reuters or SuperDerivatives options commercial
    2022‑03‑11 · EURUSD
    Source sentence
    Table 6 presents the implied volatilities for a dense range of vanilla put and call forward ∆for options on EURUSD of maturity 1 month as of 2022/03/11, as may be retrieved from a market data provider such as Reuters or SuperDerivatives.

Costs

Not applicable The paper reports no trading or execution result.

Finds 5

  • The SVI parameterization can produce negative probability density. negative
    Source sentence
    This example also illustrates a negative density with SVI and the constraint2 a ≥0 (Figure 5).
  • Some interpolation schemes yield a flat volatility for small and large strikes, implying all moments are finite. theoretical
    Source sentence
    they lead to a flat volatility for small and large strikes. Flattening wings are not particularly realistic, as this means that all moments are finite [Lee 2004]
  • Using a fixed‑point method to lookup volatility can cause oscillating implied volatilities and strange shapes. negative
    Source sentence
    Because of the failure to lookup properly the volatility at a given strike, and we stop the fixed point method at a finite number of iterations, the implied volatility obtained by the fixed point method has a strange shape.
  • Natural cubic splines in log‑moneyness can produce a positive slope for the put‑wing extrapolation. negative
    Source sentence
    the natural cubic spline in log‑moneyness suffers from the more important issue of a possible positive slope for the put wing extrapolation
  • Interpolations in ∆‑space generally produce too flat wings and may misprice auto‑quanto options, variance swaps of long maturities, and digital options beyond the 10∆ strikes. performance
    Source sentence
    Interpolations in ∆space lead in general to too flat wings, and may misprice auto‑quanto options and variance swaps of long maturities, as well as digital options beyond the 10∆strikes.

Checked by others

No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 37 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.

Code

No repository by the authors found in the paper.

Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.

Cited References (58)

  1. Algorithm 748: Enclosing zeros of continuous functions (1995)
  2. Finite difference techniques for arbitrage free SABR (2017)
  3. Fine-tune your smile: Correction to Hagan et al (2007) — link
  4. Strike from volatility and delta-with-premium (2020)
  5. An Arbitrage-Free Interpolation of Class $\mathcal C ^2$ for Option Prices (2021)
  6. Local variance gamma revisited (2017)
  7. Local variance gamma and explicit calibration to option prices (2017)
  8. An expanded local variance gamma model (2018) — link
and 50 more
  1. Geometric Local Variance Gamma Model (2019)
  2. Algorithm 716: TSPACK: Tension spline curve-fitting package (1993)
  3. Spezielle rationale splinefunktionen (1973)
  4. Volatility and dividends-volatility modelling with cash dividends and simple credit risk (2010)
  5. Smooth-curve interpolation: A generalized spline-fit procedure (1966)
  6. Levenberg-Marquardt methods for constrained nonlinear equations with strong local convergence properties (2004)
  7. Let’s be rational (2015)
  8. Prices of state-contingent claims implicit in option prices (1978)
  9. More than you ever wanted to know about volatility swaps (1999)
  10. Iterative procedures for nonlinear integral equations (1965)
  11. Volatility interpolation (2011)
  12. The volatility surface: a practitioner’s guide (2006)
  13. The hybrid most likely path (2006)
  14. Local volatility: Smooth calibration and fast Usage (2012)
  15. Anderson acceleration for fixed-point iterations (2011)
  16. Pricing with a smile (1994)
  17. An arbitrage-free interpolation of volatilities (2004)
  18. On shape preserving quadratic spline interpolation (1983)
  19. GN–a Simple and Effective Nonlinear Least-Squares Algorithm for the Open Source Literature. (2013) — link
  20. The pricing of options and corporate liabilities (1973)
  21. Clamping Down on Arbitrage (2014)
  22. OSQP : An Operator Splitting Solver for Quadratic Programs (2017) — link
  23. CVXOPT: A Python package for convex optimization (2013)
  24. quadprog: Functions to solve quadratic programming problems (2007)
  25. Closed form option valuation with smiles (1999)
  26. Model-free stochastic collocation for an arbitrage-free implied volatility: Part I (2019)
  27. Model-free stochastic collocation for an arbitrage-free implied volatility, part II (2019)
  28. Towards a theory of volatility trading (2001)
  29. Robust replication of volatility derivatives (2008)
  30. A practical guide to splines (1978)
  31. Applied Quantitative Finance for Equity Derivatives (2019)
  32. Arbitrage in the Perfect Volatility Surface (2018)
  33. Negative Butterflies and Why We Check Butterfly Arbitrage by a Non-Negative Probability Density (2022)
  34. Pricing Event Risk: Evidence from Concave Implied Volatility Curves (2021)
  35. Managing smile risk (2002)
  36. Arbitrage in the Perfect Volatility Surface (2017)
  37. Foreign exchange option pricing: A practitioner’s guide (2011)
  38. FX volatility smile construction (2012)
  39. Option-implied probability distributions and currency excess returns (1997)
  40. Using FX Volatility Skew to Assess the Implied Probability of Hard Brexit (2018)
  41. The moment formula for implied volatility at extreme strikes (2004)
  42. Convergence of Heston to SVI (2011)
  43. Quasi-explicit calibration of Gatheral’s SVI model (2009)
  44. Robust calibration and arbitrage-free interpolation of SSVI slices (2019)
  45. FX options and structured products (2017)
  46. The Quadratic Local Variance Gamma Model: an arbitrage-free interpolation of class C3 for option prices — → 2305.13791
  47. Slope Matters to Land on the Right Price (2023)
  48. FX options and smile risk (2010)
  49. MODEL-FREE IMPLIED VOLATILITY: FROM SURFACE TO INDEX (2011) — link
  50. Calibration of the SABR model in illiquid markets (2005)

1 of 58 cited works are in the corpus; resolved via arXiv source bundles, Semantic Scholar and OpenAlex. Corpus-wide: 2596 linked papers.