Paper: arXiv 2406.13789

Authors: John C. Stevenson

Abstract

Income inequality and redistribution policies are modeled with a minimal, endogenous model of a simple foraging economy. Significant income inequalities emerge from the model for populations of equally capable individuals presented with equal opportunities. Stochastic income distributions from the model are compared to empirical data from actual economies. The impacts of redistribution policies on total wealth, income distributions, and inequality are shown to be similar for the empirical data and the model. These comparisons enable detailed determinations of population welfare beyond what is possible with total wealth and inequality metrics. I

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 3.5/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 4.5/10
  • Quadrant: Philosophers — conceptual discussion, lower math and empirical scores

Why this score: The paper uses a relatively simple agent-based model (Sugarscape) and basic statistical fits (lognormal/Pareto), showing moderate empirical validation against real data but no complex mathematical derivations or backtesting code, placing it in the Philosophers quadrant.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
  A["Research Goal:<br>Can a minimal endogenous model<br>explain real economic inequality?"]
  
  B["Methodology:<br>Develop stochastic model of<br>simple foraging economy"]
  
  C["Data/Input:<br>Empirical income data<br>from real economies"]
  
  D["Computational Process:<br>Simulate income distributions<br>under equal opportunities"]
  
  E["Key Finding 1:<br>Significant inequalities emerge<br>even with equal individuals"]
  
  F["Key Finding 2:<br>Redistribution policies impact<br>total wealth & inequality similarly<br>in model and reality"]
  
  G["Welfare Analysis:<br>Detailed determinations of<br>population welfare beyond<br>total wealth & inequality metrics"]
  
  A --> B
  B --> C
  C --> D
  D --> E
  D --> F
  E --> G
  F --> G

Evidence Card

What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card

Proposes

The paper proposes a minimal, endogenous model of a simple foraging economy to study income inequality and redistribution policies.

Source sentence
Income inequality and redistribution policies are modeled with a minimal, endogenous model of a simple foraging economy.

Assumes 3

  • Populations consist of equally capable individuals with equal opportunities. model
    Source sentence
    Significant income inequalities emerge from the model for populations of equally capable individuals presented with equal opportunities.
  • Income data are represented by lognormal or hybrid (lognormal + Pareto) distributions. statistical
    Source sentence
    (Ns is the number of samples for each data set, GCa, GCL and GCH are the Gini Coefficients for the em-pirical data, lognormal, and hybrid distributions respectively, σ2 L is the variance and µL is the mean of the lognormal only distribution, and α is the Pareto shape factor and xm is the threshold for the Pareto regime, rmsL and rmsH are fit errors for lognormal and hybrid distributions, respectively.) Large RMS errors
  • Pareto shape factor and threshold are calibrated by fitting the tail of empirical data. statistical
    Source sentence
    The process of fitting a discrete Pareto function to the empirical data entails specifying the Pareto shape factor α, the Pareto regime threshold xm and the length of the (finite) Pareto tail as represented by the maximum income xmax. Setting the income level where the lognormal fit has not yet suffered large RSS errors as xm, then α and xmax are solved for the minimum RSS error for the remaining empirical data points.

Data

  • UK mean disposable incomes 2018 (£1K bins 0‑79K) macro public
    2018 · UK households
    Source sentence
    The first data set considered provides mean disposable incomes for the UK in 2018 with £1K bins from £0 to £79K (number of samples Ns = 80) [34]. Therefore, £79K is the reported maximum disposable income.
  • UK mean gross income by decile 2002 macro public
    2002 · UK households
    Source sentence
    The next dataset, mean gross income by decile for the UK in 2002 [33], attempts to cover the entire mean gross income spectrum, including all the highest incomes in the tenth decile (Ns = 10).
  • US Census gross income levels 2023 · United States Census macro public
    2023 · US households
    Source sentence
    From the United States Census for 2023, data levels of gross income that certain percentages of the population fall at or under were acquired. These gross income levels are at every 10% of the population plus a level at 95% (NS = 10) [52].

Costs

Not applicable The paper reports no trading or execution result.

Finds 5

  • Significant income inequalities emerge from the model even with equally capable individuals and equal opportunities. theoretical
    Source sentence
    Significant income inequalities emerge from the model for populations of equally capable individuals presented with equal opportunities.
  • Redistribution by income tax (excluding the top 5% bracket) for the no‑FL scenario reduces inequality by up to 30%, comparable to the mean OECD reduction of 29%. statistical
    Source sentence
    Redistribution by income tax (excluding the 5% bracket) for no FL reduces inequality by up to 30%, similar to the mean OECD reduction value of 29% [6, 18].
  • The FL inherit scenario yields inequality reductions no larger than 12%, while the FL no‑inherit scenario yields no inequality reductions. statistical
    Source sentence
    The FL inherit scenario sees reductions no larger than 12% while the FL no inherit sees no inequality reductions.
  • Adding FL without inheritance (100% estate tax) significantly reduces inequality without reducing total surplus compared to no FL. statistical
    Source sentence
    The addition of FL without inheritance (100% estate tax) results in a significant reduction in inequality without a reduction in total surplus when compared to no FL.
  • Income taxes proportional to income reduce total surplus in the model. theoretical
    Source sentence
    The model shows income taxes proportionality reduce total surplus.

Checked by others

No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 13 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.

Code

No repository by the authors found in the paper.

Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.

Cited References (64)

  1. Local Sharing and Sociality Effects on Wealth Inequality in a Simple Artificial Society (2023) — link
  2. Towards Eusociality Using an Inverse Agent Based Model (2022) — link
  3. Pareto models for top incomes and wealth (2022) — link
  4. Causes and Consequences of Income Inequality – An Overview (2021) — link
  5. Dynamics of Wealth Inequality in Simple Artificial Societies (2021) — link
  6. Agentization of Two Population-Driven Models of Mathematical Biology (2021) — link
  7. The association between income inequality and adult mental health at the subnational level—a systematic review (2021) — link
  8. Population and Inequality Dynamics in Simple Economies (2021) — link
and 56 more
  1. Growing Income Inequality in the United States and Other Advanced Economies (2020) — link
  2. The Income Gap in Voting: Moderating Effects of Income Inequality and Clientelism (2020) — link
  3. On single point forecasts for fat-tailed variables (2020) — link
  4. The threat of social decline: income inequality and radical right support (2020) — link
  5. The impact of monetary and tax policy on income inequality in Japan (2019) — link
  6. Complexity and Evolution: Toward a New Synthesis for Economics (2019) — link
  7. Income Redistribution through Taxes and Transfers across OECD Countries (2017) — link
  8. Wealth inequality: Theory, measurement and decomposition (2017) — link
  9. Gini estimation under infinite variance (2017) — link
  10. How to (Not) Estimate Gini Coefficients for Fat Tailed Variables (2015) — link
  11. Global Fertility and Population Trends (2015) — link
  12. Human population reduction is not a quick fix for environmental problems (2014) — link
  13. Income inequality in the developing world (2014) — link
  14. Occupy the Tax Code: Using the Estate Tax to Reduce Inequality and Spur Economic Growth (2013)
  15. The systemic nature of the rise in inequality in developed economies (2010) — link
  16. Income Inequality and Social Dysfunction (2009) — link
  17. The Welfare Enhancing Effects of a Selfish Government in the Presence of Uninsurable, Idiosyncratic Risk (2006) — link
  18. Why is Wealth Inequality Rising (2004)
  19. Extinction in population dynamics. (2003) — link
  20. Exponential and power-law probability distributions of wealth and income in the United Kingdom and the United States (2001) — link
  21. Mechanisms of Maintenance of Species Diversity (2000) — link
  22. Why Forecasts Fail: The Limits and Potential of Forecasting in International Relations and Economics (1999) — link
  23. Income Inequality, Social Cohesion, and Class Relations: A Critique of Wilkinson’s Neo-Durkheimian Research Program (1999) — link
  24. Adaptive computation in ecology and evolution: a guide for future research (1996)
  25. Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action (1993) — link
  26. REASSESSING THE ROLE FOR WEALTH TRANSFER TAXES (1992) — link
  27. Database (1985) — link
  28. The latent roots of certain Markov chains arising in genetics: A new approach, I. Haploid models (1974) — link
  29. Random processes in genetics (1958) — link
  30. Cours d’economie politique (1950) — link
  31. CIRCULAR CAUSAL SYSTEMS IN ECOLOGY (1948) — link
  32. Income of the United States. (1923) — link
  33. Competitive exclusion in an artificial foraging ecosystem (2023)
  34. Mathematical biology (2021) — link
  35. Das Kapital (2019) — link
  36. Not all inequality measures were created equal-The measurement of wealth inequality, its decompositions, and an application to European household wealth (2019)
  37. Wealth and Inheritance Taxation: An Overview and Country Comparison (2018)
  38. Elements Of Mathematical Ecology (2016)
  39. A Brief History of Equality (2014)
  40. The ever-emerging markets: Why economic forecasts fail (2014)
  41. Death, Taxes, and Property (Rights): Nozick, Libertarianism, and the Estate Tax (2013)
  42. Wealth, Income, and Power (2011)
  43. Census (2011) — link
  44. The laffer curve revisited (2011)
  45. Demographic collapse (2009)
  46. Mathematical population genetics: theoretical introduction, vol. 1 (2004)
  47. Why do americans work so much more than europeans? (2004)
  48. Office for National Statistics: Household disposoable income (2003)
  49. Growing Artificial Societies from the Bottom Up (1996)
  50. Atheory of justice (1971)
  51. The tragedy of the commons. The population problem has no technical solution; it requires a fundamental extension in morality. (1968)
  52. The economic effects of inheritance taxes (1927)
  53. Gini index
  54. Global wealth databook
  55. The world fact-book:country comparisons - real gdp per capita
  56. Gdp ppp per capita

0 of 64 cited works are in the corpus; resolved via arXiv source bundles, Semantic Scholar and OpenAlex. Corpus-wide: 2596 linked papers.