Paper: arXiv 2609.18975
Authors: Arati Uday Kamat
Abstract
On-chain studies of memecoin launchpads usually rely on one data-collection pipeline, yet whether differently configured pipelines observe the same tokens is rarely measured. This paper compares the output mint sets of two separately configured pipelines from one research programme on the Solana pump.fun launchpad: a cohort-detection pipeline that flags coordinated early-buyer wallets, and a rejection-filtering pipeline that logs a trader-side observer’s pre-trade filter decisions. Two consecutive, non-overlapping windows are analysed (v1: June 2026; v2: June-July 2026); in each, the rejection data are restricted to the interval spanned by the cohort detections under four timestamp rules. Only raw counts, observed proportions and Jaccard/Dice indices are reported. In v2, where the rejection stream covers the whole 17.5-day window, the cohort set contains 623 mints and the rejection set 1,742, with 5 overlapping mints (0.803% of cohort; 0.287% of rejection). In v1 a collection gap means the rejection stream covers only the final 14.25 hours (4.4%) of the 13.4-day cohort window; the 20,162 cohort and 53 rejection mints share 1 mint, and within the covered interval none, a count too small to be informative. Both windows show nearly disjoint outputs, agreeing in direction but not in magnitude. Collector configuration, not only market behaviour, therefore shapes which tokens an on-chain study observes, and the paper proposes reporting cross-collector overlap and collector coverage as a routine check. Data and a script that re-derives every number are openly available.
Complexity vs Empirical Score
- Math Complexity: 2.0/10
- Empirical Rigor: 8.0/10
- Quadrant: Street Traders — empirical and applied, lower math complexity
Why this score: This paper presents a highly rigorous empirical comparison of on-chain data pipelines with strong reproducibility. While the mathematical complexity is low, the novel finding of pipeline-dependent token observation is significant for on-chain research. The paper is well-written and thorough in its analysis and discussion.
Research Flowchart
flowchart TD
A["Research Question: Do different on-chain observation pipelines see the same tokens?"] --> B{"Methodology: Compare mint sets from two pipelines on Solana pump.fun"};
B --> C1["Input: Cohort-detection pipeline output (mint sets)"];
B --> C2["Input: Rejection-filtering pipeline output (mint sets)"];
C1 & C2 --> D["Process: Analyze two time windows (v1, v2) for overlapping mints"];
D --> E["Process: Calculate Jaccard/Dice indices, raw counts, observed proportions"];
E --> F{"Key Finding: Pipelines show nearly disjoint outputs"};
F --> G["Outcome: Collector configuration significantly shapes observed tokens, not just market behavior"];
G --> H["Recommendation: Report cross-collector overlap and coverage as routine check"];
Evidence Card
What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card
Proposes
The paper proposes reporting cross-collector overlap and collector coverage as a routine check.
Source sentence
the paper proposes reporting cross-collector overlap and collector coverage as a routine check.
Assumes 2
- Low overlap could be due to temporal non‑overlap rather than population separation, so the authors test for a time‑window artifact. data
Source sentence
If the two datasets cover materially different time periods, low overlap could reflect temporal non-overlap rather than population separation.
- The two detection pipelines observe different token universes because of collector configuration, not solely market behaviour. model
Source sentence
Collector configuration, not only market behaviour, therefore shapes which tokens an on-chain study observes
Data
- RED-COHORT-2026 sniper-cohort dataset crypto-onchain public
Source sentence
Using the RED-COHORT-2026 sniper-cohort dataset produced by…
- rejection‑outcomes dataset crypto-onchain public
Source sentence
For each replication window we restrict the rejection dataset to rows whose rejectTs or sampleTs falls within the corresponding cohort observation window
Costs
Not applicable
Finds 4
- In the v2 window the cohort set contains 623 mints and the rejection set 1,743 unique mints, with 5 overlapping mints (0.803% of cohort, 0.287% of rejection). statistical
Source sentence
Within the v2 cohort observation window (2026-06-29 to 2026-07-16): Cohort dataset (v2): 623 unique mints Rejection dataset (windowed): 1,743 unique mints Set overlap: 5 mints
- Both pipelines yield sub‑1‑percent cohort‑to‑rejection overlap, confirming that collector configuration drives token coverage. statistical
Source sentence
Both pipelines yield sub-1-percent cohort-to-rejection overlap.
- Cross‑cohort overlap between v1 and v2 cohort mints is zero, indicating entirely non‑overlapping token populations across windows. statistical
Source sentence
Set overlap between v1 cohort mints and v2 cohort mints is zero.
- The magnitude difference in overlap rates (0.010% vs 0.803%) is 80‑fold, illustrating limits of exact‑rate replication in decentralized‑exchange research. statistical
Source sentence
The magnitude difference between v1 and v2 overlap rates (0.010 percent versus 0.803 percent) is a useful case study in the limits of exact-rate replication
Checked by others
No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 20 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.
Code
No repository by the authors found in the paper.
Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.