Paper: arXiv 2501.03269
Authors: Barbara Iannone, Pierdomenico Duttilo, Stefano Antonio Gattone
Abstract
This study investigates the resilience of Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) investments during periods of financial instability, comparing them with traditional equity indices across major European markets-Germany, France, and Italy. Using daily returns from October 2021 to February 2024, the analysis explores the effects of key global disruptions such as the Covid-19 pandemic and the Russia-Ukraine conflict on market performance. A mixture of two generalised normal distributions (MGND) and EGARCH-in-mean models are used to identify periods of market turmoil and assess volatility dynamics. The findings indicate that during crises, ESG investments present higher volatility in Germany and Italy than in France. Despite some regional variations, ESG portfolios demonstrate greater resilience compared to traditional ones, offering potential risk mitigation during market shocks. These results underscore the importance of integrating ESG factors into long-term investment strategies, particularly in the face of unpredictable financial turmoil.
Complexity vs Empirical Score
- Math Complexity: 7.0/10
- Empirical Rigor: 8.0/10
- Quadrant: Holy Grail — high math complexity, high empirical rigor
Why this score: The paper employs advanced econometric models like mixture of generalized normal distributions (MGND) and EGARCH-in-mean to identify turmoil and volatility dynamics, indicating high math complexity. It uses daily returns from specific European markets (Germany, France, Italy) over a defined period (Oct 2021–Feb 2024) with detailed analysis of resilience during crises, showing high data usage and backtest-ready methodology.
Research Flowchart
flowchart TD
A["Research Goal:<br>Assess Resilience of ESG vs Traditional<br>Equities in European Markets<br>During Turmoil"] --> B["Data & Period<br>Daily Returns (Oct 2021 - Feb 2024)<br>Markets: DE, FR, IT"]
B --> C["Methodology"]
subgraph C
C1["MGND Model<br>Identify Turmoil Periods"] --> C2["EGARCH-in-Mean<br>Volatility Modeling"]
end
C2 --> D{"Key Findings & Outcomes"}
D --> D1["Higher Volatility in<br>Germany & Italy"]
D --> D2["ESG Outperforms<br>Traditional Indices"]
D --> D3["Recommendation:<br>ESG as Risk Mitigation<br>in Long-Term Strategies"]
Evidence Card
What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card
Proposes
The paper proposes to test that ESG indices exhibit less volatility than traditional indices using MGND and EGARCH‑in‑mean models.
Source sentence
H2: The performance of ESG indices shows less volatility than traditional indices.
Assumes 5
- Daily returns are calculated as the natural log‑difference of closing prices multiplied by 100. data
Source sentence
rt = ln(Pt −Pt−1)100, where: rt is the daily percentage return on the equity index at time t, Pt is the daily closing price of the equity index at time t, and Pt−1 is the daily closing price of the equity index at time t −1.
- The mixture of generalized normal distributions (MGND) adequately captures the return distribution’s tail behaviour and peakedness. model
Source sentence
The mixture of generalised normal distributions (MGND) overcomes these limitations with a flexible shape parameter ν, which adjusts tail behaviour and peakedness.
- EGARCH‑in‑mean models correctly identify periods of market turmoil and assess volatility dynamics. model
Source sentence
A mixture of two generalised normal distributions (MGND) and EGARCH-in-mean models are used to identify periods of market turmoil and assess volatility dynamics.
- The stable component of the MGND model dominates (π1 ≈ 0.85) indicating that most days are non‑turmoil. statistical
Source sentence
Firstly, the stable component (π1 = 0.8502) is predominant compared to the turmoil component (π2 = 0.1498).
Show 1 more
- ARCH and GARCH effects are present in the conditional volatility equation. statistical
Source sentence
The statistically significant coefficients α1 and β1 indicate the presence of ARCH and GARCH effects.
Data
- Daily returns of ESG and traditional equity indices for Germany, France, and Italy market-prices public
Source sentence
Using daily returns from October 2021 to February 2024, the analysis explores the effects of key global disruptions such as the Covid-19 pandemic and the Russia-Ukraine conflict on market performance.
Costs
Not applicable
Finds 5
- During crises, ESG investments show higher volatility in Germany and Italy than in France. performance
Source sentence
The findings indicate that during crises, ESG investments present higher volatility in Germany and Italy than in France.
- ESG portfolios demonstrate greater resilience compared to traditional ones, offering potential risk mitigation during market shocks. performance
Source sentence
Despite some regional variations, ESG portfolios demonstrate greater resilience compared to traditional ones, offering potential risk mitigation during market shocks.
- Turmoil periods increase conditional volatility, as shown by a positive and statistically significant coefficient v1. statistical
Source sentence
Table A5 in Appendix A shows the estimated coefficients for the conditional volatility equation. The results show that the turmoil periods led to an increase in conditional volatility, as indicated by the positive and statistically significant coefficient v1.
- Traditional indices generally have a higher risk premium than ESG indices, except in Italy where they are almost identical. performance
Source sentence
Traditional indices generally exhibit a higher risk premium compared to ESG indices, with the exception of Italy, where the risk premiums are almost identical.
- No significant differences between ESG and non‑ESG indices except in France, where the traditional index suffers a greater impact on the conditional mean. statistical
Source sentence
the ESG and non-ESG indices, except in France, where the traditional index experienced a greater impact on the conditional mean than its ESG counterpart.
Checked by others
No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 54 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.
Code
No repository by the authors found in the paper.
Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.
Cited References (83)
- A generalized normal distribution (2005) — link
- Image thresholding based on the EM algorithm and the generalized Gaussian distribution (2006)
- Analytical properties of generalized Gaussian distributions (2018)
- Modeling Univariate Distributions (2011) — link
- Statistical Computing with R Second Edition (2nd ed.) (2019) — link
- Parametric generalized Gaussian density estimation (1989) — link
- A Simplex Method for Function Minimization (1965) — link
- Numerical characteristics and parameter estimation of finite mixed generalized normal distribution (2022)
and 75 more
- Maximum Likelihood from Incomplete Data Via the EM Algorithm (1977)
- Pattern Recognition and Machine Learning (Information Science and Statistics) (2006)
- Maximum likelihood estimation via the ECM algorithm: A general framework (1993)
- The EM algorithm and extensions (2008)
- On the characteristic function of the generalized normal distribution (2010) — link
- Model-based clustering and classification with non-normal mixture distributions (2013)
- Finite general Gaussian mixture modeling and application to image and video foreground segmentation (2008)
- Generalized Gaussian mixture model (2009)
- Bounded generalized Gaussian mixture model (2014)
- A Short Note on Generating a Random Sample from Finite Mixture Distributions (2024) — link
- Estimation of parameters for generalized Gaussian distribution (2014) — link
- Stock Markets (2024) — link
- A new look at the statistical model identification (1974) — link
- Estimating the Dimension of a Model (1978)
- Sulla determinazione empirica di una legge didistribuzione (1933)
- A Test of Goodness of Fit (1954) — link
- Student’s t mixture models for stock indices. A comparative study (2021) — link
- Mixtures of generalized normal distributions and EGARCH models to analyse returns and volatility of ESG and traditional investments (2023)
- Environmental, social, and governance related factors for business investment and sustainability: A scientometric review of global trends (2024)
- The Regulatory Dynamics of Sustainable Finance: Paradoxical Success and Limitations of EU Reforms (2022) — link
- The integration of environmental, social and governance criteria in portfolio optimization: An empirical analysis (2023) — link
- Corporate reputation and economic performance: The evidence from Poland (2014)
- Investing Ethical: Harder Than You Think (2021)
- Forecasting volatility by integrating financial risk with environmental, social, and governance risk (2021)
- Environmental, social, and governance (ESG) performance and financial outcomes: Analyzing the impact of ESG on financial performance (2023)
- Applying reputation data to enhance investment performance (2014)
- ESG did not immunize stocks during the COVID‐19 crisis, but investments in intangible assets did (2021)
- Return and Volatility performance comparison of Ethical and Non-ethical publicly-listed financial services companies (2016)
- The Impact of ESG Rating on Hedging Downside Risks: Evidence from a Weight-Tilted Hang Seng Index (2024)
- Forecasting US Stock Market Volatility: Evidence from ESG and CPU indices (2024)
- The relationship between corporate social responsibility and shareholder value: An empirical test of the risk management hypothesis (2009) — link
- Impact Investing and Responsible Investing: what Does It Mean? (2013) — link
- Behavioural biases and investment decisions during COVID-19: An empirical study of Chinese investors (2023)
- La finanza per lo sviluppo sostenibile. Tendenze, questioni in corso e prospettive alla luce dell’evoluzione del quadro regolamentare (2021)
- Social Impact Investments: Does an Alternative to the Anglo-Saxon Paradigm Exist? (2016) — link
- The importance of selected aspects of a company’s reputation for individual stock market investors—Evidence from Polish capital market (2022)
- The Impact of ESG Disclosure Score on Firm Value: Empirical Evidence From ESG Listed Company in Indonesia Stock Exchange (2024)
- Doing good and doing bad: The impact of corporate social responsibility and irresponsibility on firm performance (2017)
- The Structuring of Social Finance: Emerging Approaches for Supporting Environmentally and Socially Impactful Projects (2018) — link
- The Integration of Sustainability into the Theory and Practice of Finance: An Overview of the State of the Art and Outline of Future Developments (2013) — link
- Reputation: Some thoughts from an investor’s point of view (2006)
- Impact Investing: Funding Social Innovation (2016) — link
- Introducing Impact Investing (2016) — link
- Playing by the rules: ethical criteria at an ethical investment fund (1999) — link
- Il reddito di impresa. Scritture doppie, conti e bilanci di aziende commerciali (1937)
- Newcomer Adjustment During Organizational Socialization: A Meta-Analytic Review of Antecedents, Outcomes, and Methods (2007) — link
- Social identification and investment decisions (2015)
- Motivated monitors: The importance of institutional investors’ portfolio weights (2015) — link
- CSR Performance and the Value of Cash Holdings: International Evidence (2017) — link
- Sustainable Investing: The Art of Long-term Performance (2008) — link
- Social investment as a policy paradigm (2018) — link
- A theory of socially responsible investment (2021) — link
- Why don’t we see more action? A metasynthesis of the investor impediments to integrate environmental, social, and governance factors (2019)
- L’ipotesi del costante nella dottrina e nella gestione di azienda (1958)
- La perdurante instabilità dei mercati e delle gestioni di azienda (1959)
- Il divenire sociale (1960)
- Corporate Social Responsibility and Investment Efficiency (2018) — link
- The investment behavior of socially responsible individual investors (2018)
- The effects of environmental, social and governance disclosures and performance on firm value: A review of the literature in accounting and finance (2018)
- Exploring socially responsible investment perspectives: A literature mapping and an investor classification (2019) — link
- What is responsible investment? (2022) — link
- The Reputation QuotientSM: A Multi-stakeholder Measure of Corporate Reputation (2013) — link
- Impact analysis of environmental and social factors on early-stage COVID-19 transmission in China by machine learning (2022) — link
- Does corporate social responsibility reporting actually destroy firm reputation? (2020) — link
- The building blocks of corporate reputation: Definitions, antecedents, consequences (2012)
- Environmental sustainability orientation and corporate social responsibility influence on environmental performance of small and medium enterprises: The mediating effect of green capability (2022) — link
- Systems and systemic risk in finance and economics (2014) — link
- ESG Didn’t Immunize Stocks During the COVID‐19 Crisis, But Investments in Intangible Assets Did (2021) — link
- Institutional Investor Stewardship in Italian Corporate Governance (2022)
- Modelling finacial returns with mixture of generalized normal distributions (2024)
- Performance of negatively screened sustainable investments during crisis (2024) — link
- ESG performance and corporate volatility: an empirical exploration in an emerging economy (2024) — link
- The impact of ESG news on the volatility of the Portuguese stock market—Does it change during recessions? (2023) — link
- Does ESG implementation influence performance and riskin SMEs? (2024) — link
- Does Corporate Reputation Provide a Cushion to Companies Facing Market Volatility? Some Supportive Evidence (1998) — link
0 of 83 cited works are in the corpus; resolved via arXiv source bundles, Semantic Scholar and OpenAlex. Corpus-wide: 2596 linked papers.