Paper: SSRN 189840
Authors: Tyler Shumway, Joshua D. Coval
Abstract
This paper examines expected option returns in the context of mainstream asset pricing theory. Under mild assumptions, call options have expected returns which exceed those of their underlying security and which are increasing in their strike prices. Likewise, put options have expected returns which are below the risk-free rate and which are also increasing in their strike prices. Across a variety of time periods and return frequencies, S&P 500 and 100 index option returns strongly exhibit these characteristics. Under stronger assumptions, expected option returns are a linear function of option betas. Fama-MacBeth-style option return regressions produce risk premia close to the expected market return. However, the regression intercepts are significantly below zero. As a result, zero-beta, at-the-money straddle positions produce average losses of approximately three percent per week. Zero-beta straddles in other markets also lose money consistently. These findings suggest that some additional factor, such as systematic stochastic volatility, is priced in option returns.
Complexity vs Empirical Score
- Math Complexity: 7.0/10
- Empirical Rigor: 8.0/10
- Quadrant: Holy Grail — high math complexity, high empirical rigor
- Basis: provisional. Scored from the abstract alone because the full text was not available, so both scores reflect what the abstract claims, not a reading of the paper.
Why this score: The paper presents a strong blend of theoretical derivations for expected option returns and robust empirical validation using S&P 500/100 index options. Its findings on zero-beta straddle losses suggest a significant market anomaly or unpriced factor, contributing meaningfully to the literature.
Research Flowchart
flowchart TD
A["Research Goal: Examine Expected Option Returns under Asset Pricing Theory"] --> B{"Key Methodologies: Theoretical Derivations & Empirical Analysis"};
B --> C["Data: S&P 500 & 100 Index Options"];
C --> D{"Computational Processes: Option Beta Calculation, Fama-MacBeth Regressions"};
D --> E["Key Finding 1: Call option expected returns > underlying, increasing with strike. Put expected returns < risk-free, increasing with strike."];
E --> F["Key Finding 2: Option returns linearly related to betas (under strong assumptions), but Fama-MacBeth intercepts are significantly below zero."];
F --> G["Key Finding 3: Zero-beta, at-the-money straddles consistently lose ~3% per week across markets. Suggests unpriced factor (e.g., systematic stochastic volatility)."];
Evidence Card
What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card
Proposes
The paper proposes that call options have expected returns exceeding those of the underlying security and increasing with strike, while put options have expected returns below the risk‑free rate and also increasing with strike.
Source sentence
Under mild assumptions, call options have expected returns which exceed those of their underlying security and which are increasing in their strike prices. Likewise, put options have expected returns which are below the risk-free rate and which are also increasing in their strike prices.
Assumes 2
- Mild assumptions under which call options have higher expected returns and puts have lower expected returns. model
Source sentence
Under mild assumptions, call options have expected returns which exceed those of their underlying security and which are increasing in their strike prices.
- Stronger assumptions under which expected option returns are a linear function of option betas. model
Source sentence
Under stronger assumptions, expected option returns are a linear function of option betas.
Data
S&P 500 index options · options · weekly
- S&P 500 and 100 index options options unknown
Source sentence
Across a variety of time periods and return frequencies, S&P 500 and 100 index option returns strongly exhibit these characteristics.
Costs
Unclear
Finds 5
- Call options have expected returns that exceed those of their underlying security and increase with strike. theoretical
Source sentence
Under mild assumptions, call options have expected returns which exceed those of their underlying security and which are increasing in their strike prices.
- Put options have expected returns below the risk‑free rate and increase with strike. theoretical
Source sentence
Likewise, put options have expected returns which are below the risk-free rate and which are also increasing in their strike prices.
- Under stronger assumptions, expected option returns are a linear function of option betas. theoretical
Source sentence
Under stronger assumptions, expected option returns are a linear function of option betas.
- Fama‑MacBeth‑style option return regressions produce risk premia close to the expected market return. pricing-calibration
Source sentence
Fama-MacBeth-style option return regressions produce risk premia close to the expected market return.
- Regression intercepts are significantly below zero, leading zero‑beta at‑the‑money straddle positions to lose about three percent per week. negative
Source sentence
However, the regression intercepts are significantly below zero. As a result, zero-beta, at-the-money straddle positions produce average losses of approximately three percent per week.
Checked by others
No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 18 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.
Code
No repository by the authors found in the paper.
Extracted 2026-11-15 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.