Paper: arXiv 2507.01993

Authors: Aaron Abrams, Skip Garibaldi

Abstract

We give a criterion under which the expected return on a ticket for certain large lotteries is positive. In this circumstance, we use elementary portfolio analysis to show that an optimal investment strategy includes a very small allocation for such tickets.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 7.5/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 3.0/10
  • Quadrant: Lab Rats — high math complexity, limited empirical testing

Why this score: The paper employs advanced mathematics including portfolio theory and probabilistic modeling to derive theoretical criteria for lottery investments, but lacks empirical backtesting, implementation details, or statistical validation, focusing instead on theoretical results.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
  A["Research Question:<br>When is a lottery ticket<br>a good bet?"] --> B["Key Methodology:<br>Portfolio Analysis"]
  B --> C{"Data & Inputs:<br>Lottery Parameters &<br>Market Rates"}
  C --> D["Computation:<br>Expected Return &<br>Risk Allocation"]
  D --> E["Outcome 1:<br>Positive Expected Return<br>under specific conditions"]
  D --> F["Outcome 2:<br>Optimal Strategy:<br>Very small allocation"]

Evidence Card

What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card

Proposes

The paper proposes a criterion under which the expected return on a lottery ticket is positive and shows that the optimal investment strategy allocates only a very small portion to such tickets.

Source sentence
We give a criterion under which the expected return on a ticket for certain large lotteries is positive. In this circumstance, we use elementary portfolio analysis to show that an optimal investment strategy includes a very small allocation for such tickets.

Assumes 5

  • Other lottery players select their tickets randomly. model
    Source sentence
    Throughout this paper, we are assuming that the other lottery players select their tickets randomly.
  • Drawings with small ticket sales relative to the jackpot (N/J < 1/5) can have positive rates of return once the jackpot exceeds a computed threshold. model
    Source sentence
    We show, roughly speaking, that drawings with “small” ticket sales (rela-tive to the jackpot; the measurement we use is N/J, which should be less 2 than 1/5) offer positive rates of return, once the jackpot exceeds a certain easily-computed threshold.
  • Drawings with large ticket sales relative to the jackpot (N/J > 1) always have negative rates of return. model
    Source sentence
    On the other hand, drawings with “large” ticket sales (again, this means N/J is larger than a certain cutoff, which is slightly larger than 1) will always have negative rates of return.
  • Investors are risk‑averse, preferring higher expected return and lower variance (mean‑variance preferences). other
    Source sentence
    We assume: (1) When you decide whether or not to invest in an asset, the only at-tributes you consider are its expected rate of return, the variance in that rate, and the covariance of that rate with the rates of return of other assets.g (2) You prefer portfolios with high rate of return and low variance over portfolios with low rate of return and high variance. (This is obvious.) From these assumptions, we can give
Show 1 more
  • Federal tax on winnings is approximated by a flat 25% rate. other
    Source sentence
    Currently, gambling winnings over $600 are subject to federal income tax, and winnings over $5000 are withheld at a rate of 25%; see [14] or [4]. Since income tax rates vary from gambler to gambler, we use 25% as an estimate of the tax rate.c For example, the winner of the largest non-jackpot prize for the Mega Millions lottery receives not the nominal $250,000 bMost notably, in California all prizes are

Data

  • New Jersey lottery drawings 2007 · New Jersey Lottery other public
    2007
    Source sentence
    During 2007, the New Jersey lottery had no drawings with J > J0.
  • Powerball ticket sales estimates · Powerball press releases other public
    Source sentence
    In the case of Powerball, we estimated N by using the number of tickets that won a prize, as reported in press releases.
  • Mega Millions ticket sales estimates · Mega Millions website other public
    Source sentence
    For Mega Millions, we used the number of tickets that won either of the two smallest fixed prizes, as announced on the lottery website.
  • Lotto Texas ticket sales · [23] other public
    Source sentence
    For Lotto Texas, the number of tickets sold is from [23].

Costs

Not applicable The paper reports no trading or execution result.

Finds 5

  • When the jackpot exceeds the cutoff J0, lotteries with small ticket‑sales fractions can have a positive expected rate of return. theoretical
    Source sentence
    We show, roughly speaking, that drawings with “small” ticket sales (rela-tive to the jackpot; the measurement we use is N/J, which should be less 2 than 1/5) offer positive rates of return, once the jackpot exceeds a certain easily-computed threshold. And furthermore, you should only do so when the jackpot is unusually large— certainly the jackpot has to be bigger than the jackpot cutoff J0 defined in (3.3).
  • To obtain a positive expected return, investors should avoid Mega Millions and Powerball and instead buy tickets in lotteries where ticket sales are a small fraction of the jackpot. performance
    Source sentence
    Positive return If you just want a positive expected rate of return, then our results in Section 8 say to avoid Mega Millions and Powerball. Instead, you should buy tickets in lotteries where the ticket sales are a small fraction of the jackpot.
  • Even when a lottery offers a positive rate of return, the optimal portfolio allocation to such tickets is very small. theoretical
    Source sentence
    In this circumstance, we use elementary portfolio analysis to show that an optimal investment strategy includes a very small allocation for such tickets.
  • Empirical data suggest that no future drawing of Mega Millions or Powerball will offer a positive expected rate of return. negative
    Source sentence
    We now argue that in all likelihood, no future drawing of either of these lotteries will ever offer a positive expected rate of return. 8.1. Mega Millions / Powerball.
  • The Small Ticket Sales example provides concrete criteria guaranteeing a positive rate of return for a drawing. theoretical
    Source sentence
    To underline these results, we point out that the Small Ticket Sales example 7.1 gives concrete criteria that guarantee that a lottery drawing has a positive rate of return.

Checked by others

No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 13 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.

Code

No repository by the authors found in the paper.

Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.