Paper: arXiv 2609.16642

Authors: Maksym Nechepurenko

Abstract

Public evidence can become sufficient to settle a prediction-market contract before the venue records its first determination, but the relevant boundary depends on the applicable rule version, exact release object, source hierarchy, correction history, and unfinished contract conditions. This paper defines two Kalshi clocks: first decidability, the earliest contemporaneous singleton in the rule-evidence mapping, and stable decidability, the retrospective earliest time after which the same singleton remains unchanged through finalization. A completed retrospective identification test establishes a narrow feasibility result. In a frozen blind pilot, all 25 identities and blinding checks passed and current rule text was recovered for all 25; no exact or bounded historical rule version and no exact or bounded official source-release object was recovered. The full historical recovery covered 152,694 ordinary tickers, 11,530 exact event identities, and 6,540 read-only official requests, with zero historically eligible events and zero historically eligible tickers. This is an observability result, not a claim that no market was decidable or that public evidence never existed. A completed prospective infrastructure shakedown established observation capability for three source programmes across 25 markets, with integrity revalidation of 781,266 lifecycle frames, 22 closed lower-bounded reconnect receipts, no unresolved reconnect gap, no due-but-missed official release, and an inactive price layer. Production evidence enrollment is active. The prospective sample is constructed only at enrollment close from prospectively frozen identities and pre-outcome fields; its frozen target size is selected mechanically under the registered full, reduced, exploratory, or no-go support disposition. No contractual-decidability clock, human-adjudication, price, or cross-venue result is reported here.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 4.0/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 6.0/10
  • Quadrant: Street Traders — empirical and applied, lower math complexity

Why this score: This paper introduces novel concepts of ‘first decidability’ and ‘stable decidability’ for prediction markets, which is a significant contribution. While the mathematical notation is present, it’s not overly complex, focusing more on definitions and propositions. The empirical rigor is demonstrated through detailed retrospective and prospective testing of the infrastructure, even if it’s an observability result rather than a direct market outcome analysis.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
    A["Research Goal: Establish First and Stable Decidability on Kalshi based on Public Evidence"] --> B{"Methodology: Define Kalshi Clocks & Test Decidability"}
    B --> C{"Retrospective Identification Test (Blind Pilot)"}
    C --> D["Data/Inputs: 152,694 Tickers, 11,530 Event Identities, 6,540 Official Requests"]
    C --> E["Computational Processes: Identify Earliest Singleton, Track Changes, Rule Text Recovery"]
    E --> F["Outcomes (Retrospective): All 25 Identities & Blinding Checks Passed; No Historical Decidable Events/Tickers Found"]
    B --> G{"Prospective Infrastructure Shakedown (Observation Capability)"}
    G --> H["Data/Inputs: 3 Source Programs, 25 Markets, 781,266 Lifecycle Frames"]
    G --> I["Computational Processes: Integrity Revalidation, Reconnect Monitoring, Production Enrollment"]
    I --> J["Outcomes (Prospective): Observation Capability Established; No Unresolved Gaps; Production Evidence Enrollment Active"]

Evidence Card

What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card

Proposes

The paper defines two Kalshi clocks—first decidability and stable decidability—and conducts feasibility tests of these clocks using historical and prospective data.

Source sentence
This paper defines two Kalshi clocks: first decidability, the earliest contemporaneous singleton in the rule-evidence mapping, and stable decidability, the retrospective earliest time after which the same singleton remains unchanged through finalization.

Assumes 2

  • A market is first-decidable when contemporaneously available admissible evidence reduces the contract’s settlement mapping to a single value and no contract‑required future condition remains. market
    Source sentence
    A market is first-decidable when contemporaneously available admissible evidence reduces the contract’s settlement mapping to one value and no contract-required future condition remains.
  • Source corrections or rule clarifications can occur after first decidability, so the stable decidability clock must remain unchanged despite possible later revisions. model
    Source sentence
    Because source corrections or rule clarifications can reopen that mapping, the paper separately defines a retrospective stable clock.

Data

  • Kalshi Multivariate Event Market Materialization Dataset (KMVE) · Mendeley Data other public
    Source sentence
    Data and Code Availability The registered MVE population and hierarchy are available as the Kalshi Multivariate Event Market Materialization Dataset (KMVE), Mendeley Data, V1, doi: 10.17632/fn65786cg6.1.

Costs

Not applicable The paper reports no trading or execution result.

Finds 2

  • The completed historical test establishes that a clock may be economically well‑defined yet retrospectively unobservable from the available public historical record. theoretical
    Source sentence
    12 Conclusion The completed historical test establishes that a clock may be economically well-defined yet retrospectively unobservable from the available public historical record.
  • The prospective shakedown demonstrates source‑observation capability and active evidence enrollment across three source programmes and 25 markets. other figure from elsewhere in the paper
    Source sentence
    The prospective shakedown demonstrates source-observation capability and active evidence enrollment.

Checked by others

No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 6 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.

Code

No repository by the authors found in the paper.

Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.

Cited References (39)

  1. Prediction Markets (2004) — link
  2. Interpreting the Predictions of Prediction Markets (2006) — link
  3. Combinatorial Information Market Design (2003) — link
  4. Nonparametric Estimation from Incomplete Observations (1958) — link
  5. An Empirical Transition Matrix for Non-Homogeneous Markov Chains Based on Censored Observations (1978)
  6. Statistical Models Based on Counting Processes (1993) — link
  7. Event Studies in Economics and Finance (1997)
  8. Information Aggregation in Dynamic Markets With Strategic Traders (2012) — link
and 31 more
  1. A Coefficient of Agreement for Nominal Scales (1960) — link
  2. Principles for Financial Market Infrastructures (2012) — link
  3. ParlayMarket: Automated Market Making for Parlay-style Joint Contracts (2026) — link
  4. APMM: Automated Parlay Market Maker (2026) — link
  5. Price Discovery and Trading in Modern Prediction Markets (2026) — link
  6. Settlement Manipulation in Prediction Markets (2026) — link
  7. Semantic Non-Fungibility and Violations of the Law of One Price in Prediction Markets (2026) — link
  8. When Certainty Is Not Worth It: Capital Lock-Up and Settlement Discounting in Prediction Markets (2026) — link
  9. Market Lifecycle (2026) — link
  10. Historical Data (2026) — link
  11. Get Markets (2026) — link
  12. Get Events (2026) — link
  13. Market and Event Lifecycle (2026) — link
  14. Multivariate Market and Event Lifecycle (2026) — link
  15. Get Historical Markets (2026) — link
  16. Get Multivariate Event Collections (2026) — link
  17. Create Market in Multivariate Event Collection (2026) — link
  18. Get Trades (2026) — link
  19. Get Market Candlesticks (2026) — link
  20. Get Historical Market Candlesticks (2026) — link
  21. Get Historical Trades (2026) — link
  22. Makers or Takers: The Economics of the Kalshi Prediction Market (2026) — link
  23. Kalshi and the Rise of Macro Markets (2026) — link
  24. What Prediction Markets Can See: Market Formation, Settlement Legibility, and the Geography of Tradable Uncertainty in Africa and Latin America (2026) — link
  25. Kalshi Multivariate Event Market Materialization Dataset (KMVE) (2026) — link
  26. Outcome Determination and Settlement Finality on Kalshi: Public State Paths, Prospective Measurement, and Empirical Identification — link
  27. On-Demand Combinatorial Event Markets on Kalshi: Instantiation, Concentration, and Effective Market Breadth — link
  28. Resolution is not Settlement, Part I: Oracle Adjudication and Semantic Governance on Polymarket — link
  29. Resolution is not Settlement, Part II: Protocol Finality and Observed Redemption on Polymarket — link
  30. State-triggered Margin and Conditional-token Conversion for Event-linked Perpetual Futures — link
  31. Event-Spread Perpetuals under Asynchronous Finality: Joint-State Risk, Residual Exposure, and Settlement Design — link

0 of 39 cited works are in the corpus; resolved via arXiv source bundles, Semantic Scholar and OpenAlex. Corpus-wide: 2596 linked papers.