Paper: arXiv 2507.09196

Authors: Nader Karimi, Erfan Salavati

Abstract

Assuming frictionless trading, classical stochastic portfolio theory (SPT) provides relative arbitrage strategies. However, the costs associated with real-world execution are state-dependent, volatile, and under increasing stress during liquidity shocks. Using an Ito diffusion that may be connected with asset prices, we extend SPT to a continuous-time equity market with proportional, stochastic transaction costs. We derive closed-form lower bounds on cost-adjusted relative wealth for a large class of functionally generated portfolios; these bounds provide sufficient conditions for relative arbitrage to survive random costs. A limit-order-book cost proxy in conjunction with a Milstein scheme validates the theoretical order-of-magnitude estimates. Finally, we use intraday bid-ask spreads as a stand-in for cost volatility in a back-test of CRSP small-cap data (1994–2024). Despite experiencing larger declines during the 2008 and 2020 liquidity crises, diversity- and entropy-weighted portfolios continue to beat the value-weighted benchmark by 3.6 and 2.9 percentage points annually, respectively, after cost deduction.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 9.2/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 6.0/10 (capped from 6.8: no out-of-sample test; see penalty flags)
  • Quadrant: Holy Grail — high math complexity, high empirical rigor (effective empirical rigor capped from 6.8)

Why this score: The paper relies heavily on advanced stochastic calculus (Itô diffusions, Milstein scheme, Fernholz theory) and presents a non-trivial extension of stochastic portfolio theory to stochastic costs with formal proofs and inequalities. Empirically, it includes a 30-year backtest using CRSP data, an intraday cost proxy (bid-ask spreads), and quantitative performance metrics (2.9-3.6% annual alpha after costs), demonstrating substantial data and implementation effort.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
  A["Research Goal: Does SPT relative arbitrage survive stochastic transaction costs?"] --> B["Methodology: Ito diffusion & Stochastic Costs"]
  B --> C["Data: CRSP Small-Cap 1994-2024 & Intraday Spreads"]
  C --> D["Computation: Limit-Order-Book Proxy & Milstein Scheme"]
  D --> E["Key Finding: 3.6% & 2.9% annual alpha after costs"]

Evidence Card

What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card

Proposes

The paper extends stochastic portfolio theory to include proportional stochastic transaction costs and derives a cost‑adjusted master inequality providing lower bounds for functionally generated portfolios.

Source sentence
we extend SPT to a continuous-time equity market with proportional, stochastic transaction costs. We derive closed-form lower bounds on cost‑adjusted relative wealth for a large class of functionally generated portfolios; these bounds provide sufficient conditions for relative arbitrage to survive random costs.

Assumes 6

  • Asset prices follow an Itô diffusion with drift b_t and nonsingular volatility matrix σ_t. market
    Source sentence
    with drift b_t and nonsingular volatility matrix σ_t.
  • Trading incurs a proportional cost κ_t per unit turnover, where κ_t follows a mean‑reverting stochastic process. execution
    Source sentence
    Trading incurs proportional cost κ_t per unit turnover, where dκ_t = α (¯κ −κ_t) dt + η dB_t, κ_0 > 0, and B may be correlated with the market Brownian motion W.
  • Portfolios are rebalanced piecewise‑constant on a mesh Δ (e.g., weekly). model
    Source sentence
    Exploiting piecewise‑constant rebalancing, we derive a cost‑adjusted master inequality (Theorem 3.1) that is valid pathwise and isolates the tug‑of‑war between excess growth and stochastic cost erosion.
  • The excess‑growth integral ∫_0^T γ_t dt diverges almost surely (market is ε‑diverse). statistical
    Source sentence
    Step 1: Divergence of the drift term. By assumption (i) DT :=
Show 2 more
  • Cost erosion grows sub‑linearly, of order √T. other
    Source sentence
    A Milstein Monte‑Carlo experiment confirms the theoretical O(√T) cost growth.
  • The CRSP small‑cap sample excludes stocks with zero or extreme (>500 bps) spreads and days with missing quotes. data
    Source sentence
    The panel is filtered for zero and extreme (>500 bps) spreads and for days with missing quotes, leaving a balanced sample of 981 permnos.

Data

Backtest sample: 1994 – 2024 · CRSP small-cap US equities · equities · monthly

  • CRSP small‑cap daily database · CRSP market-prices commercial
    1994‑2024 · one thousand smallest U.S. common stocks
    Source sentence
    We use the CRSP daily database to extract the one thousand smallest U.S. common stocks
  • Synthetic Monte‑Carlo simulation synthetic unknown
    50‑stock small‑cap universe
    Source sentence
    Table 1 summarises the baseline parameters. Stock volatilities are drawn i.i.d. from Unif(15%, 35%) and kept constant across paths...

Recognised sources: CRSP NYSE TAQ

Costs

Modeled Costs are part of the reported headline results.

Proportional cost κ_t per unit turnover with stochastic dynamics dκ_t = α(¯κ−κ_t)dt + η dB_t; spreads are measured from intraday NBBO bid‑ask quotes.

Source sentence
Trading incurs proportional cost κ_t per unit turnover, where dκ_t = α (¯κ −κ_t) dt + η dB_t, κ_0 > 0, and B may be correlated with the market Brownian motion W.

Finds 4

Reported performance (Diversity-weighted functionally generated portfolio (p = 0.7)): annual return 10.7% · max drawdown 65.0%

  • Diversity‑ and entropy‑weighted functionally generated portfolios beat the value‑weighted benchmark by 2.9–3.6 percentage points annually after cost deduction. performance
    Source sentence
    diversity- and entropy-weighted portfolios continue to beat the value-weighted benchmark by 3.6 and 2.9 percentage points annually, respectively, after cost deduction.
  • Monte‑Carlo simulations confirm that cumulative trading cost grows at the rate O(√T), matching the theoretical bound. theoretical
    Source sentence
    A Milstein Monte‑Carlo experiment confirms the theoretical O(√T) cost growth.
  • Coarser rebalancing meshes (weekly or bi‑weekly) preserve relative arbitrage even under temporary spread spikes up to 80 bps. performance
    Source sentence
    A weekly or bi‑weekly schedule preserves relative arbitrage even under temporary spikes.
  • Cost erosion is sub‑linear (∝√t), and the excess‑growth term eventually dominates, allowing the diversity‑weighted portfolio to recover costs after about 1.5 years. theoretical
    Source sentence
    Cost erosion indeed grows sub‑linearly (∝√t), in line with the theoretical bound.

Checked by others

Supported by

  • Quantifying dimensional change in stochastic portfolio theory (2023)
    On the question: Does the excess‑growth term dominate portfolio growth and offset costs in diversity‑weighted portfolios?
    Compare the findings

    This paper: Cost erosion is sub‑linear (∝√t), and the excess‑growth term eventually dominates, allowing the diversity‑weighted portfolio to recover costs after about 1.5 years.

    That paper: Excess growth (EG) term contributes significantly to the growth in log relative wealth for diversity‑weighted portfolios, especially for smaller p values.

    Both findings show EG is significant; B quantifies cost erosion ∝√t and recovery after ~1.5 years, confirming A’s EG impact for small p values.

Code

No repository by the authors found in the paper.

Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.

Cited References (20)

  1. Stochastic portfolio theory: an overview (2009)
  2. Trading Strategies Generated by Lyapunov Functions (2017)
  3. Adaptive universal portfolios (2015)
  4. How efficiency shapes market impact (2013)
  5. Model-Free Hedging of Impermanent Loss in Geometric Mean Market Makers with Proportional Transaction Fees (2024)
  6. The impact of proportional transaction costs on systematically generated portfolios (2020)
  7. Optimal execution of portfolio transactions (2001)
  8. Optimal trading strategy and supply/demand dynamics (2013)
and 12 more
  1. A stochastic optimal stopping model for storable commodity prices (2024)
  2. Optimal order placement in limit order markets (2017)
  3. Stochastic portfolio theory (2002)
  4. The problem of regulatory arbitrage: A transaction cost economics perspective (2021)
  5. Empirical performance of an ESG assets portfolio from US market (2024)
  6. Key features of the financial sectors in EU accession countries (2002)
  7. Diversification in financial and crypto markets (2023)
  8. Liquidity uncertainty and Bitcoin’s market microstructure (2018)
  9. Why do equally weighted portfolios beat value-weighted ones? (2023)
  10. Dynamic Trading with Predictable Returns and Transaction Costs (2013)
  11. Limit Order Book as a Market for Liquidity (2005)
  12. Exchange‐Traded Funds, Market Structure, and the Flash Crash (2012)

0 of 20 cited works are in the corpus; resolved via arXiv source bundles, Semantic Scholar and OpenAlex. Corpus-wide: 2596 linked papers.