Paper: arXiv 2309.00632
Authors: Wayne Chen, Songwei Chen, Preston Rozwood
Abstract
Current approaches to the cryptocurrency automated market makers result in poor impermanent loss and capital efficiency. We analyze the mechanics underlying DODO Exchange’s proactive market maker (PMM) to probe for solutions to these issues, leading to our key insight of multi-token trading pools. We explore this paradigm primarily through the construction of a generalization of PMM, the multi-token token proactive market maker (MPMM). We show via simulations that MPMM has better impermanent loss and capital efficiency than comparable market makers under a variety of market scenarios. We also test multi-token generalizations of other common 2-token pool market makers. Overall, this work demonstrates several advantages of multi-token pools and introduces a novel multi-token pool market maker.
Complexity vs Empirical Score
- Math Complexity: 9.0/10
- Empirical Rigor: 3.0/10
- Quadrant: Lab Rats — high math complexity, limited empirical testing
Why this score: The paper presents dense mathematical derivations for the PMM and MPMM pricing curves and their properties, including marginal exchange rates, limits, and equilibrium dynamics, indicating high math complexity. However, it relies solely on simulations for evaluation, with no real-world backtesting, data-heavy analysis, or implementation details provided, resulting in low empirical rigor.
Research Flowchart
flowchart TD
A["Research Goal<br>Address Impermanent Loss &<br>Capital Efficiency in AMMs"] --> B["Analyze DODO's PMM<br>Core Mechanics & Limitations"]
B --> C["Key Insight & Hypothesis<br>Multi-Token Pool Paradigm"]
C --> D{"Methodology"}
D --> E1["Simulate MPMM<br>Multi-Token PMM"]
D --> E2["Simulate Generalized<br>Multi-Token 2-Token Pools"]
E1 --> F["Compare vs<br>Standard AMMs (Uniswap v3)"]
E2 --> F
F --> G["Outcomes & Findings"]
G --> H1["MPMM: Superior Impermanent<br>Loss & Capital Efficiency"]
G --> H2["Multi-Token Generalizations<br>Show Viable Advantages"]
G --> H3["Novel MPMM Market<br>Maker Introduced"]
Evidence Card
What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card
Proposes
The paper proposes the Multi-Token Proactive Market Maker (MPMM), a multi‑token generalization of DODO Exchange's proactive market maker.
Source sentence
We explore this paradigm primarily through the construction of a generalization of PMM, the multi-token token proactive market maker (MPMM).
Assumes 6
- The ratio PQ/PB remains fixed, so token balances naturally return to equilibrium. market
Source sentence
In summary, assuming the ratio PQ/PB remains fixed, token balances will naturally return to equilibrium.
- Oracles providing PB and PQ must quickly adapt to price fluctuations. model
Source sentence
A caveat is that since the PMM pricing curve uses PB and PQ provided from oracles, the oracles must quickly adapt to price fluctuations.
- Initial equilibrium balances B0 and Q0 are set equal to LPs' deposited token amounts. model
Source sentence
DODO sets their PMM B0 and Q0 equal to the token amounts deposited by LPs [14] to ensure the pool tracks a holding strategy, thus reducing impermanent loss.
- Liquidity providers can supply liquidity using a single token type. execution
Source sentence
Additionally, LPs can supply liquidity using single token types, reducing barriers to participation.
Show 2 more
- The parameter k interpolates between constant‑sum and constant‑product pricing curves. model
Source sentence
We analyze PMM’s use of a parameter k to “interpolate” an exchange rate curve between the naive constant sum (CSMM) and constant product (CPMM) market makers.
- Historical hourly price data can be linearly interpolated between daily observations to generate hourly prices. data
Source sentence
3.1 Real World Price Simulations We use hourly historical price data from a Kaggle dataset for 14 token types [9] spanning from April 8th, 2021 to September 10th, 20231 and daily per-token transaction volumes from CoinGecko to generate swapping traffic.
Data
- CoinGecko per‑token transaction volumes alternative public
Source sentence
3.1 Real World Price Simulations We use hourly historical price data from a Kaggle dataset for 14 token types [9] spanning from April 8th, 2021 to September 10th, 20231 and daily per-token transaction volumes from CoinGecko to generate swapping traffic.
CoinGecko Kaggle
Costs
Unclear
Finds 5
- Simulations show that MPMM has lower impermanent loss and higher capital efficiency than comparable market makers across a variety of market scenarios. performance
Source sentence
We show via simulations that MPMM has better impermanent loss and capital efficiency than comparable market makers under a variety of market scenarios.
- Across a range of k values, MPMM consistently achieves a lower median impermanent loss that is less volatile compared to PMM. performance
Source sentence
Anther noteworthy comparison is that MCPMM performs worse than CPMM while MPMM outperforms PMM across a range of k values (MPMM consistently has a lower median impermanent loss that is less volatile compared to PMM).
- In the real‑world price simulation, CPMM, CMPMM, CSMM, and MCSMM suffer significantly more impermanent loss than PMM and MPMM. performance
Source sentence
Overall, we see that CPMM, CMPMM, CSMM, and MCSMM all suffer significantly more than PMM and MPMM.
- During a bull‑market simulation, PMM’s impermanent loss improves markedly, while MPMM performs worse than PMM under those conditions. performance
Source sentence
Now, MCPMM and MPMM perform worse than CPMM and PMM, respectively. PMM’s impermanent loss significantly improves (e.g. −3.946e−6 vs −1.328e−5 when k = 0.05 and −3.792e−6 vs −1.450e−5 when k = 0.75 for the “bull market” vs the “real world price” simulation).
- A spike in capital‑efficiency inefficiency is observed around the 100,000th swap in the simulations. performance
Source sentence
Finally, when plotting the capital efficiency in 7, we also observe a spike in inefficiency surrounding the 100,000th swap.
Checked by others
No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 16 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.
Code
No repository by the authors found in the paper.
Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.