Paper: arXiv 2405.10917

Authors: Shuxin Guo, Qiang Liu

Abstract

It is a challenge to estimate fund performance by compounded returns. Arguably, it is incorrect to use yearly returns directly for compounding, with reported annualized return of above 60% for Medallion for the 31 years up to 2018. We propose an estimation based on fund sizes and trading profits and obtain a compounded return of 31.8% before fees. Alternatively, we suggest using the manager’s wealth as a proxy and arriving at a compounded growth rate of 25.6% for Simons for the 33 years up to 2020. We conclude that the annualized compounded return of Medallion before fees is probably under 35%. Our findings have implications for correctly estimating fund performance.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 6.5/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 3.0/10
  • Quadrant: Lab Rats — high math complexity, limited empirical testing

Why this score: The paper employs advanced financial mathematics (compounding formulas, proportional profit allocation, and volatility calculations) but relies on a simplified model with assumed parameters rather than real transactional data or backtesting.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
  A["Research Goal:<br>Estimate Medallion's True Annualized Compounded Return"] --> B

  subgraph B ["Methodology & Data Inputs"]
      B1["Method 1: Fund Size & Profits<br>31 years (1988-2018)"] --> C1
      B2["Method 2: Manager's Wealth<br>33 years (1988-2020)"] --> C2
      B3["Challenge: Avoiding Direct<br>Annual Return Compounding"] --> D
  end

  C1 --> D["Computational Processes"]
  C2 --> D

  subgraph D
      direction LR
      D1["Est. Fund AUM &<br>Trading Profits"] --> D2["Compound Growth<br>Calculation"]
      D3["Simons' Wealth<br>Growth Rate"] --> D2
  end

  D --> E["Key Findings & Outcomes"]
  
  subgraph E
      E1["Method 1: ~31.8% return<br>(Pre-fees)"]
      E2["Method 2: ~25.6% return<br>(Manager Wealth)"]
      E3["Conclusion: True annualized<br>compounded return is likely<br>under 35%"]
      E4["Implications: Highlights<br>correct performance<br>estimation methods"]
  end

Evidence Card

What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card

Proposes

The paper proposes estimating Medallion's annualized compounded return using fund sizes and total trading profits, and also using the manager’s net wealth as a proxy.

Source sentence
We propose an estimation based on fund sizes and trading profits and obtain a compounded return of 31.8% before fees.

Assumes 4

  • Interest on un‑reinvested profit is ignored. other
    Source sentence
    interest is ignored in this short paper.
  • Time value of money is not considered in the compounding formula. other
    Source sentence
    From the previous analysis, we propose to estimate an annualized compounded return for an N-year fund as follows without considering the time value of money
  • Simons held 70% equity in Medallion (50%+10%+10%). data
    Source sentence
    we assume that Simons had 70% equity (50%+10%+10%) or 14 million capital.
  • A hypothetical example assumes a 50% stake for Simons, a 10 billion fund size, 60% annual trading profit and a 40% profit cut. other
    Source sentence
    Assume a 50% stake for Simons, a 10 billion size for Medallion, an annual trading profit of 60%, and a 40% cut for the profit.

Data

  • Medallion fund size and trading profit data · Zuckerman (2019) other unknown
    1988-2018 · Medallion fund
    Source sentence
    trading profits between 1988 and 2018, taken from Appendix 1 of Zuckerman (2019), in Table 1.
  • Annual net returns for Medallion · Zuckerman (2019) other unknown
    1988-2018 · Medallion fund
    Source sentence
    Using Formula (1) and net returns in Table 1, we obtain a naïve compounded return of 63.2%.

Costs

Unclear - sources disagree The platform classifier and the paper-text extraction give different answers, so no value is asserted.

Platform classifier: Not applicable

Paper text extraction: Not modeled

Source sentence (the authors' words)
We ignore the 5% annual expense here.

Finds 4

  • A better estimation yields an annualized compounded return of 31.8% before fees for Medallion (31 years to 2018). performance
    Source sentence
    This leads to an estimated annualized compounded return of
  • The naïve compounded return using yearly net returns is about 63.2%, which the authors deem incorrect. negative
    Source sentence
    Using Formula (1) and net returns in Table 1, we obtain a naïve compounded return of 63.2%, quite close to the 63.3% of Cornell (2020).
  • Using the manager’s wealth as a proxy gives an estimated compounded growth of 25.6% for Simons over 33 years. performance
    Source sentence
    For Simons, the estimated annualized compounded growth is 25.6% for the 33 years up to 2020.
  • The authors conclude that Medallion’s annualized compounded return is probably under 35%. theoretical
    Source sentence
    We conclude that the annualized compounded return of Medallion before fees is probably under 35%.

Checked by others

No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 14 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.

Code

No repository by the authors found in the paper.

Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.