Paper: arXiv 2411.05803
Authors: Qi Deng, Zhong-Guo Zhou
Abstract
We develop a new framework to detect wash trading in crypto assets through real-time liquidity fluctuation. We propose that short-term price jumps in crypto assets results from wash trading-induced liquidity fluctuation, and construct two complementary liquidity measures, liquidity jump (size of fluctuation) and liquidity diffusion (volatility of fluctuation), to capture the behavioral signature of wash trading. Using US stocks as a benchmark, we demonstrate that joint elevation in both liquidity metrics indicates wash trading in crypto assets. A simulated regulatory treatment that removes likely wash trades confirms this dynamic: it reduces liquidity diffusion significantly while leaving liquidity jump largely unaffected. These findings align with a theoretical model in which manipulative traders amplify both the level and variance of price pressure, whereas passive investors affect only the level. Our model offers practical tools for investors to assess market quality and for regulators to monitor manipulation risk on crypto exchanges without oversight.
Complexity vs Empirical Score
- Math Complexity: 7.0/10
- Empirical Rigor: 6.5/10
- Quadrant: Holy Grail — high math complexity, high empirical rigor
Why this score: The paper introduces novel theoretical constructs (liquidity jump/diffusion) supported by a theoretical model and relies heavily on empirical data analysis (US stocks vs. crypto, simulated regulatory treatment) to validate findings.
Research Flowchart
flowchart TD
A["Research Goal:<br>Detect wash trading in<br>crypto assets via<br>liquidity fluctuations"] --> B
subgraph B ["Data & Benchmarking"]
direction LR
B1["Real-time Crypto Data"]
B2["US Stocks Benchmark"]
end
B --> C{"Construct Complementary<br>Liquidity Measures"}
C --> C1["Liquidity Jump<br>Size of fluctuation"]
C --> C2["Liquidity Diffusion<br>Volatility of fluctuation"]
C1 --> D["Computational Process:<br>Joint Elevation Analysis"]
C2 --> D
D --> E
subgraph E ["Key Findings & Outcomes"]
direction LR
E1["Wash Trading Identified<br>by joint high metrics"]
E2["Regulatory Simulation<br>Reduces Diffusion,<br>preserves Jump"]
E3["Theoretical Model Validation<br>Manipulators amplify level & variance"]
end
Evidence Card
What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card
Proposes
The paper develops a new framework to detect wash trading in crypto assets using real-time liquidity fluctuation measures.
Source sentence
We develop a new framework to detect wash trading in crypto assets through real-time liquidity fluctuation.
Assumes 5
- Liquidity jump and liquidity diffusion are proxies for the scale and probability of wash trading. model
Source sentence
We contend that liquidity jump and liquidity diffusion serve as proxies for the scale and probability of wash trading, respectively.
- Minute‑interval trading data without order‑book information is sufficient to construct liquidity measures. data
Source sentence
Given that we use minute-interval trading data without order book (bid-ask) information, the daily version of Amihud (2002) is a natural starting point for constructing our own liquidity measures.
- Regulated US stock market data can be treated as wash‑trading‑free benchmark. market
Source sentence
By comparing that trading data from the regulated US stock market (where wash trading is non-existent) with that from the unregulated crypto markets (where wash trading is common)
- Crypto assets on unregulated exchanges are subject to wash trading. market
Source sentence
The trading of crypto assets remains largely unregulated and vulnerable to wash trading.
Show 1 more
- Liquidity measures can be normalized to be unitless and around 1 when liquidity is high. model
Source sentence
βℓ in such a way that it is a unitless liquidity measure and normalized (~1), and that when liquidity is high (amount is high)
Data
- US stock minute‑level trading data market-prices commercial
Source sentence
We collect minute-level trading data of all 1,503 constituent stocks of the SP500 (large cap), SP400 (mid cap) and SP600 (small cap) indices from the Polygon.io API. From each index, we pick the five largest stocks in terms of market cap, thus we select 15 stocks from the three indices.
- Crypto tick‑level trading data crypto-onchain public
Source sentence
... with at least four years of complete historical data (October 15, 2020 to February 7, 2025
- Market caps of US stocks fundamentals public
Source sentence
We obtain the market caps of all 1,503 stocks from the Yahoo Finance API on October 12, 2024 at the market close.
Costs
Not applicable
Finds 4
- A simulated regulatory treatment that removes likely wash trades reduces liquidity diffusion significantly while leaving liquidity jump largely unaffected. theoretical
Source sentence
A simulated regulatory treatment that removes likely wash trades confirms this dynamic: it reduces liquidity diffusion significantly while leaving liquidity jump largely unaffected.
- Treatment on wash trading lowers both liquidity jump and diffusion, but diffusion drops far more than jump. statistical
Source sentence
These results clearly point to that β&6ℓ is much more sensitive to the removal of likely wash trades than β%6ℓ.
- Crypto assets generally exhibit higher liquidity diffusion and jump than US stocks, indicating greater exposure to wash trading. statistical
Source sentence
Applying this framework to selected crypto assets, we find that, in general, crypto assets exhibit much higher liquidity diffusion and liquidity jump than stocks, suggesting exposure to wash trading.
- Large‑market‑cap crypto assets like Bitcoin show relatively low levels of wash trading compared to lower‑cap assets. statistical
Source sentence
the largest market‑cap crypto assets, such as Bitcoin (BTC), exhibit relatively low level of wash trading.
Checked by others
No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 17 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.
Code
No repository by the authors found in the paper.
Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.