Paper: arXiv 2312.10739

Authors: Francesco Cesarone, Manuel Luis Martino, Federica Ricca, Andrea Scozzari

Abstract

Sustainable Investing identifies the approach of investors whose aim is twofold: on the one hand, they want to achieve the best compromise between portfolio risk and return, but they also want to take into account the sustainability of their investment, assessed through some Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) criteria. The inclusion of sustainable goals in the portfolio selection process may have an actual impact on financial portfolio performance. ESG indices provided by the rating agencies are generally considered good proxies for the performance in sustainability of an investment, as well as, appropriate measures for Socially Responsible Investments (SRI) in the market. In this framework of analysis, the lack of alignment between ratings provided by different agencies is a crucial issue that inevitably undermines the robustness and reliability of these evaluation measures. In fact, the ESG rating disagreement may produce conflicting information, implying a difficulty for the investor in the portfolio ESG evaluation. This may cause underestimation or overestimation of the market opportunities for a sustainable investment. In this paper, we deal with a multi-criteria portfolio selection problem taking into account risk, return, and ESG criteria. For the ESG evaluation of the securities in the market, we consider more than one agency and propose a new approach to overcome the problem related to the disagreement between the ESG ratings by different agencies. We propose a nonlinear optimization model for our three-criteria portfolio selection problem. We show that it can be reformulated as an equivalent convex quadratic program by exploiting a technique known in the literature as the k-sum optimization strategy. An extensive empirical analysis of the performance of this model is provided on real-world financial data sets.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 7.0/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 6.0/10 (capped from 7.0: transaction costs not modelled; see penalty flags)
  • Quadrant: Holy Grail — high math complexity, high empirical rigor (effective empirical rigor capped from 7.0)

Why this score: The paper introduces a novel nonlinear optimization model reformulated as a convex quadratic program using k-sum optimization, demonstrating significant mathematical density. It also conducts extensive empirical analysis on real-world financial datasets, comparing out-of-sample performance against benchmarks, indicating high implementation and data requirements.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
  A["Research Goal: Develop Portfolio Model<br>Managing ESG Rating Disagreement"] --> B{"Data & Inputs"};
  B --> C["Multi-Agency ESG Ratings<br>Financial Data: Risk & Return"];
  C --> D["Methodology: Nonlinear<br>Multi-Criteria Optimization Model"];
  D --> E["Computational Process:<br>k-sum Optimization Reformulation"];
  E --> F["Result: Convex Quadratic<br>Programming Solution"];
  F --> G["Key Outcomes:<br>Robust SRI Portfolio Selection<br>Resolved ESG Disagreement"];

Evidence Card

What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card

Proposes

The paper proposes a nonlinear three‑criteria portfolio optimization model that is reformulated as a convex quadratic program using a k‑sum optimization strategy.

Source sentence
We propose a nonlinear optimization model for our three-criteria portfolio selection problem. We show that it can be reformulated as an equivalent convex quadratic program by exploiting a technique known in the literature as the k-sum optimization strategy.

Assumes 3

  • There are n risky assets and m rating agencies, each providing an ESG measure on a bounded real scale. data
    Source sentence
    Assume that there are n risky assets and m different rating agencies and that each agency evaluates the sustainability of each asset according to its own method and producing its ESG measure, which is a real number ranging between a minimum and a maximum value.
  • The ESG scores from different agencies can be standardized to a common scale. model
    Source sentence
    To address this problem, the first step is to standardize the data.
  • The ε‑constraint approach can be applied to the three‑objective portfolio selection model. model
    Source sentence
    In view of Theorem 1, we apply the ε‑constraint approach to our original three‑objective portfolio selection model (12) by considering σ2P (x) as the objective function.

Data

  • EuroStoxx50 market-prices unknown
    EuroStoxx50 constituents
    Source sentence
    In the following tables we provide the computational results obtained in the application of our model (13) to the EuroStoxx50 and NASDAQ100 data sets
  • NASDAQ100 market-prices unknown
    NASDAQ100 constituents
    Source sentence
    In the following tables we provide the computational results obtained in the application of our model (13) to the EuroStoxx50 and NASDAQ100 data sets

Costs

Not modeled A trading or execution result is reported without costs.

Finds 3

  • The proposed ESG‑aware optimization method outperforms standard portfolio selection methods and a single‑agency approach. performance
    Source sentence
    the results show that our new method outperforms the others.
  • The k‑Worst NonESG model exhibits the highest out‑of‑sample VaR5 loss among the tested strategies. negative
    Source sentence
    The only weakness of our models is related to the maximum out‑of‑sample loss measured by index VaR5 which for “Sust 4 kWorst” is the highest.
  • The approach is versatile, effective and computationally tractable for ESG‑inclusive portfolio selection. other
    Source sentence
    Globally it is versatile, effective and computationally tractable.

Checked by others

No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 27 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.

Code

No repository by the authors found in the paper.

Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.

Cited References (253)

  1. Non-contour efficient fronts for identifying most preferred portfolios in sustainability investing (2023)
  2. Parallel GRASP with path-relinking for job shop scheduling (1984)
  3. Spectral measures of risk: a coherent representation of subjective risk aversion (2002)
  4. On the coherence of expected shortfall (2002)
  5. Portfolio optimization with spectral measures of risk (2002)
  6. Spectral risk measure and portfolio selection (2008)
  7. A simple algorithm to incorporate transactions costs in quadratic optimisation (1994)
  8. Performance of the efficient frontier in an emerging market setting (2002)
and 245 more
  1. Passive ESG portfolio management-the benchmark strategy for socially responsible investors (2021)
  2. The mean–variance cardinality constrained portfolio optimization problem: An experimental evaluation of five multiobjective evolutionary algorithms (2011)
  3. A comparison of \uppercase MAD and \uppercase CV a\uppercase R models with real features (2008)
  4. MAD Risk Parity portfolios (2021) — link
  5. Coherent Measures of Risk (1999)
  6. Least-Squares Approach to Risk Parity in Portfolio Selection (2013)
  7. Least-squares approach to risk parity in portfolio selection (2016)
  8. VaR without correlations for portfolios of derivative securities (1999)
  9. Backtesting derivative portfolios with Filtered Historical Simulation (FHS) (2002)
  10. Portfolio analysis under uncertain means, variances, and covariances (1974)
  11. Optimal Rules for Ordering Uncertain Prospects (1975)
  12. Estimation risk and optimal portfolio choice (1979)
  13. An evolutionary heuristic for the index tracking problem (2003)
  14. Generalized quantiles as risk measures (2014)
  15. Naive diversification strategies in defined contribution saving plans (2001)
  16. Using medians in portfolio optimization (2015)
  17. Aggregate confusion: The divergence of ESG ratings (2022)
  18. ESG disclosure and portfolio performance (2021)
  19. Portfolio construction through mixed-integer programming at Grantham, Mayo, Van Otterloo and Company (1999)
  20. Robust discrete optimization and network flows (2003)
  21. The Price of Robustness (2004)
  22. Shortfall as a risk measure: properties, optimization and applications (2004)
  23. Algorithms for cardinality-constrained quadratic optimization (2009)
  24. Sensitivity analysis for mean-variance portfolio problems (1991)
  25. On the sensitivity of mean-variance-efficient portfolios to changes in asset means: some analytical and computational results (1991)
  26. Heuristic for finding the efficient frontier in cardinality constrained portfolio optimization (2003)
  27. Inside the ESG ratings:(Dis) agreement and performance (2021)
  28. The Asset Structure of Individual Portfolios and Some Implications for Utility Functions (1975) — link
  29. Pseudo-boolean optimization (2002)
  30. Asset allocation with Conditional Value-at-Risk budgets (2013)
  31. Backtesting Value-at-Risk: a comparison between filtered bootstrap and historical simulation (2012)
  32. Risk Management in an Asset Management Company: A Practical Case (2001)
  33. The effects of environmental, social and governance disclosures and performance on firm value: A review of the literature in accounting and finance (2018)
  34. A new stochastic dominance approach to enhanced index tracking problems (2012)
  35. No arbitrage and a linear portfolio selection model (2013)
  36. Portfolio optimization under expected shortfall: contour maps of estimation error (2015) — link
  37. Mixed-integer programming approaches for index tracking and enhanced indexation (2008)
  38. Efficient Algorithms For Mean-Variance Portfolio Optimization With Hard Real-World Constraints (2008)
  39. Efficient Algorithms For Mean-Variance Portfolio Optimization With Hard Real-World Constraints (2009)
  40. Portfolio selection problems in practice: a comparison between linear and quadratic optimization models (2010)
  41. A new method for mean-variance portfolio optimization with cardinality constraints (2013)
  42. Linear vs. quadratic portfolio selection models with hard real-world constraints (2014)
  43. Equal Risk Bounding is better than Risk Parity for portfolio selection (2016)
  44. CVaR Equal Risk Contribution model for portfolio selection (2016)
  45. A Quick Tool to Forecast VaR Using Implied and Realized Volatilities (2016)
  46. A quick tool to forecast value-at-risk using implied and realized volatilities (2016)
  47. Publications and reports (2016) — link
  48. Data sets for portfolio selection problems (2016) — link
  49. Equal risk bounding is better than risk parity for portfolio selection (2017)
  50. Minimum risk versus capital and risk diversification strategies for portfolio construction (2017)
  51. Comparing SSD-efficient portfolios with a skewed reference distribution (2022)
  52. Does ESG impact really enhance portfolio profitability? (2022)
  53. Mean-Variance-VaR portfolios: MIQP formulation and performance analysis (2023)
  54. Heuristics for cardinality constrained portfolio optimization (2000)
  55. Optimization-based methods for multiobjective decision-making-an overview (1983)
  56. Do ratings of firms converge? Implications for managers, investors and strategy researchers (2016)
  57. Efficient Algorithms for Computing Risk Parity Portfolio Weights (2012)
  58. Drawdown measure in portfolio optimization (2005)
  59. Semi-absolute deviation rule for mutual funds portfolio selection (2003)
  60. The effect of errors in means, variances, and covariances on optimal portfolio choice (1993)
  61. Toward maximum diversification (2008)
  62. Properties of the most diversified portfolio (2013)
  63. Why is corporate virtue in the eye of the beholder? The case of ESG ratings (2022)
  64. A Risk Based Approach to Tactical Asset Allocation (2011)
  65. Empirical properties of asset returns: stylized facts and statistical issues (2001)
  66. Optimization methods in finance (2007)
  67. Optimal versus naive diversification: How inefficient is the 1/N portfolio strategy? (2009)
  68. Portfolio selection with robust estimation (2009)
  69. A generalized approach to portfolio optimization: Improving performance by constraining portfolio norms (2009)
  70. The eco-efficiency premium puzzle (2005)
  71. Hybrid metaheuristics for constrained portfolio selection problems (2011)
  72. A concave optimization-based approach for sparse portfolio selection (2012)
  73. Markowitz versus the Talmudic portfolio diversification strategies (2009)
  74. Estimating the dependence structure of share prices–implications for portfolio selection (1973)
  75. Simple criteria for optimal portfolio selection (1976)
  76. Improved estimates of correlation coefficients and their impact on optimum portfolios (2006)
  77. Dynamic equicorrelation (2012)
  78. Multicriteria optimization (2005)
  79. Handling CVaR objectives and constraints in two-stage stochastic models (2008)
  80. Diversification: Should we be Diversifying Trends? (2010)
  81. Foundations of finance: Portfolio decisions and securities prices (1976)
  82. Portfolio selection using neural networks (2007)
  83. Cardinality constrained portfolio optimisation (2004)
  84. Mean-risk analysis with risk associated with below-target returns (1977)
  85. What is Portfolio Diversification? (2013)
  86. ESG and financial performance: aggregated evidence from more than 2000 empirical studies (2015)
  87. Portfolio selection with parameter and model uncertainty: A multi-prior approach (2007)
  88. Bayesian optimization of ESG (Environmental Social Governance) financial investments (2023)
  89. ESG rating disagreement and stock returns (2021)
  90. Minimizing shortfall (2013)
  91. Robust portfolio selection problems (2003)
  92. Hybrid search for cardinality constrained portfolio optimization
  93. The information ratio (1998)
  94. Income Risk, Borrowing Constraints, and Portfolio Choice (1996) — link
  95. Active Portfolio Management: A Quantitative Approach for Producing Superior Returns and Controlling Risk (2000)
  96. Asset pricing in a generalized mean-lower partial moment framework: Theory and evidence (1989)
  97. The paternity of an index (1964)
  98. Users guide for TOMLAB (2007)
  99. Simulating sensitivities of conditional value at risk (2009)
  100. A survey of alternative equity index strategies (2011)
  101. On the significance of expected shortfall as a coherent risk measure (2005)
  102. Min max normalization based data perturbation method for privacy protection (2011)
  103. Risk reduction in large portfolios: Why imposing the wrong constraints helps (2003)
  104. The performance of mutual funds in the period 1945–1964 (1968)
  105. Estimation for Markowitz efficient portfolios (1980)
  106. Computational aspects of alternative portfolio selection models in the presence of discrete asset choice constraints (2001)
  107. International portfolio diversification with estimation risk (1985)
  108. Bayes-Stein estimation for portfolio analysis (1986)
  109. Portfolio optimization with tracking-error constraints (2003)
  110. Stability analysis of portfolio management with conditional value-at-risk (2007)
  111. Selecting portfolios with fixed costs and minimum transaction lots (2000)
  112. Rank correlation methods (1970)
  113. Corporate sustainability: First evidence on materiality (2016)
  114. Shifting the Focus to Measurement: A Review of Socially Responsible Investing and Sustainability Indicators (2023)
  115. How media coverage of corporate social irresponsibility increases financial risk (2017)
  116. 60 Years of portfolio optimization: Practical challenges and current trends (2014)
  117. Noise sensitivity of portfolio selection under various risk measures (2007)
  118. Portfolio Optimization using 1 \uppercase L Risk Function, \uppercase IHSS Report (1998)
  119. Piecewise linear risk function and portfolio optimization (1990)
  120. Integer programming approaches in mean-risk models (2005)
  121. Mean-absolute deviation portfolio optimization model and its application to Tokyo stock exchange (1991)
  122. A mean-absolute deviation-skewness portfolio optimization model (1993)
  123. A mean-variance-skewness portfolio optimization model (1995)
  124. Portfolio optimization problem under concave transaction costs and minimal transaction unit constraints (2001)
  125. A Mean-Variance-Skewness Model: Algorithm and Applications (2005)
  126. A general test for SSD portfolio efficiency (2015)
  127. Nonparametric Statistics with Applications to Science and Engineering (Wiley Series in Probability and Statistics) (2007)
  128. Parameter estimation techniques, optimization frequency, and portfolio return enhancement (2001)
  129. Improved estimation of the covariance matrix of stock returns with an application to portfolio selection (2003)
  130. Honey, I shrunk the sample covariance matrix (2004)
  131. Robust performance hypothesis testing with the Sharpe ratio (2008)
  132. Diversification and time: Do investment horizons matter? (1990)
  133. Incorporating environmental and social considerations into the portfolio optimization process (2020)
  134. Optimal lot solution to cardinality constrained mean-variance formulation for portfolio selection (2006)
  135. Portfolio diversification (2017)
  136. The valuation of risk assets and the selection of risky investments in stock portfolios and capital budgets (1965)
  137. Riskmetrics\textsuperscript TM – technical document (1996)
  138. The investor’s guide to fidelity funds (1989)
  139. Asset pricing models: implications for expected returns and portfolio selection (2000)
  140. The Properties of Equally Weighted Risk Contribution Portfolios (2010)
  141. Heuristic algorithms for the portfolio selection problem with minimum transaction lots (1999)
  142. LP Solvable Models for Portfolio Optimization: A classification and computational comparison (2003)
  143. An exact approach for portfolio selection with transaction costs and rounds (2005)
  144. Conditional Value at Risk and related linear programming models for portfolio optimization (2007)
  145. Optimization of cardinality constrained portfolios with a hybrid local search algorithm (2003)
  146. Portfolio selection (1952)
  147. Integrated risk management with a filtered bootstrap approach (2004)
  148. The Investor’s Guide to Fidelity Funds (1989)
  149. Cardinality constrained portfolio optimization by means of genetic algorithms (2009)
  150. The efficacy of optimization modeling as a retirement strategy in the presence of estimation error (2005)
  151. Risk and asset allocation (2009)
  152. Quant nugget 2: Linear vs. compounded returns–Common pitfalls in portfolio management (2010)
  153. Managing Diversification (2009)
  154. Efficient asset management (1998)
  155. Stylized Facts on the Temporal and Distributional Properties of Daily FT-SE Returns (1997) — link
  156. A review of portfolio planning: models and systems (2003)
  157. Responsible investing and portfolio selection: a shapley-CVaR approach (2023)
  158. RiskMetrics-Technical Document (1996)
  159. Equilibrium in a capital asset market (1966)
  160. Incorporating transaction costs in models for asset allocation (1993)
  161. Asymmetric least squares estimation and testing (1987)
  162. Location theory: a unified approach (2009)
  163. Socially responsible funds and market crises (2014)
  164. A global optimality criterion for nonconvex quadratic programming over a simplex (1998)
  165. A global optimality criterion for nonconvex quadratic programming over a simplex (1998)
  166. Dual stochastic dominance and quantile risk measures (2002)
  167. Dual stochastic dominance and related mean-risk models (2002)
  168. Comparative analysis of KNN algorithm using various normalization techniques (2017)
  169. Portfolio selection and asset pricing models (2000)
  170. Comparing asset pricing models: an investment perspective (2000)
  171. Large-scale portfolio optimization (1984)
  172. Some remarks on the Value-at-Risk and the Conditional Value-at-Risk (2000)
  173. The 1/N investment strategy is optimal under high model ambiguity (2012)
  174. Mathematical programming formulations for the efficient solution of the k-sum approval voting problem (2018)
  175. The biobjective minimum-cost perfect matching problem and Chinese postman problem (2023)
  176. PRI Quarterly Signatory Update. (2023)
  177. Revisiting k-sum optimization (2017)
  178. K-sum linear programming (1992)
  179. On k-sum optimization (1996)
  180. Risk parity portfolios: Efficient portfolios through true diversification (2005)
  181. Risk Parity and Diversification (2011)
  182. Different Approaches to Risk Estimation in Portfolio Theory (2004)
  183. Advanced stochastic models, risk assessment, and portfolio optimization: The ideal risk, uncertainty, and performance measures (2008)
  184. Environmental, Social and Governance Scores from Refinitiv (2022)
  185. Optimization of Conditional Value-at-Risk (2000)
  186. Conditional Value-at-Risk for General Distributions (2002)
  187. Generalized deviations in risk analysis (2006)
  188. Mean-risk models using two risk measures: a multi-objective approach (2007)
  189. A Fast Algorithm for Computing High-Dimensional Risk Parity Portfolios
  190. Introducing Expected Returns into Risk Parity Portfolios: A New Framework for Tactical and Strategic Asset Allocation (2013)
  191. Extra-market components of covariance in security returns (1974)
  192. The arbitrage theory of capital asset pricing (1976)
  193. Safety First and the Holding of Assets (1952)
  194. Robust min–max portfolio strategies for rival forecast and risk scenarios (2000)
  195. Value-at-risk vs. conditional value-at-risk in risk management and optimization (2008)
  196. Nonparametric estimation and sensitivity analysis of expected shortfall (2004)
  197. Local search techniques for constrained portfolio selection problems (2002)
  198. A clique algorithm for standard quadratic programming (2008)
  199. A simplified model for portfolio analysis (1963)
  200. Capital asset prices: A theory of market equilibrium under conditions of risk (1964)
  201. Mutual fund performance (1966)
  202. A linear programming algorithm for mutual fund portfolio selection (1967)
  203. A linear programming approximation for the general portfolio analysis problem (1971)
  204. The Sharpe Ratio (1994)
  205. Lagrangian relaxation procedure for cardinality-constrained portfolio optimization (2008)
  206. Portfolio resampling: Review and critique (2002)
  207. Portfolio Construction and Risk Budgeting (2007)
  208. Stock price reactions to ESG news: The role of ESG ratings and disagreement (2022)
  209. Performance comparison of new adjusted min-max with decimal scaling and statistical column normalization methods for artificial neural network classification (2022)
  210. Managing downside risk in financial markets (2001)
  211. Linear programming models for portfolio optimization (1993)
  212. A heuristic algorithm for a portfolio optimization model applied to the Milan stock market (1996)
  213. An Algorithm for Computing Risk Parity Weights (2013)
  214. S$&$P Global ESG Scores Methodology (2023)
  215. ESG Risk Ratings - Methodology Abstract (2021)
  216. The Effect of Local Search on the Constrained Portfolio Selection Problem (2006)
  217. Evolutionary algorithms and the cardinality constrained portfolio selection problem (2003)
  218. Comparing Discrete and Continuous Genotypes on the Constrained Portfolio Selection Problem (2004)
  219. Transparency among S&P 500 companies: An analysis of ESG disclosure scores (2017)
  220. The fundamental theorem of linear programming: extensions and applications (2011)
  221. Expected shortfall and beyond (2002)
  222. Penalized Expectiles Optimal Portfolios (2022) — link
  223. How to use security analysis to improve portfolio selection (1973)
  224. Robust asset allocation (2004)
  225. An analysis of mean-variance portfolio selection with varying holding periods (2007) — link
  226. Tri-criterion inverse portfolio optimization with application to socially responsible mutual funds (2014)
  227. Tri-criterion modeling for constructing more-sustainable mutual funds (2015)
  228. A shrinkage approach to model uncertainty and asset allocation (2005)
  229. An improved branch and bound algorithm for mixed integer nonlinear programs (1994)
  230. Perspective cuts for a class of convex 0-1 mixed integer programs (2006)
  231. Computational experience of an interior-point SQP algorithm in a parallel branch-and-bound framework (1997)
  232. Equilibrium points of bimatrix games (1964)
  233. Comparative analyses of expected shortfall and value-at-risk: their estimation error, decomposition, and optimization (2002)
  234. Robust Portfolio Optimization and Management (2004)
  235. Simulated annealing for complex portfolio selection problems. (2003)
  236. An application of the GARCH-t model on Central European stock returns (2004)
  237. Multiple-benchmark and multiple-portfolio optimization (1999)
  238. Mean-variance-VaR based portfolio optimization (2000)
  239. The 1/n pension investment puzzle (2004)
  240. Programming Code (2016) — link
  241. Integrated simulation and optimization models for tracking indices of fixed-income securities (1994)
  242. A minimax portfolio selection rule with linear programming solution (1998)
  243. Risk analysis for asset managers: Historical simulation, the bootstrap approach and Value-at-Risk calculation (2000)
  244. Parameter-free convex equivalent and dual programs of fractional programming problems (1974)
  245. Risk parity with expectiles (2021)

0 of 253 cited works are in the corpus; resolved via arXiv source bundles, Semantic Scholar and OpenAlex. Corpus-wide: 2596 linked papers.