Paper: arXiv 2609.18019
Authors: Vincent Maciejewski
Abstract
Automated execution algorithms are organized into schedule-based and liquidity-seeking families. This paper concerns the first, whose members – Time-Weighted Average Price (TWAP), Volume-Weighted Average Price (VWAP), Percentage of Volume (POV) and Implementation Shortfall – are all model-based: each derives its decisions from an explicit model, forecast, schedule or control rule. We introduce Shadow-PPOV, a passive POV whose order-placement rate is set from observed order flow rather than from traded volume. Placing a passive order to fill efficiently conventionally involves an order-book model and a fill prediction. Shadow-PPOV replaces that prediction with tracking: on observing a third-party add, it may transmit its own limit order at the same price on the same venue, recording a single association between the observed order’s exchange identifier and its own. Cancellation is then identifier-driven – the shadow is withdrawn when the order it follows ends, at once on a cancel and after a brief grace window on a trade. The placement decision is thus model-free: price and venue are read off the observed order. Model-free is not information-free. Shadow-PPOV reads every order-book message and places only where a participant has just committed capital, while computing nothing from what it reads. Information is inherited from the flow rather than derived from a model. We evaluate Shadow-PPOV on a full calendar year of replayed Chicago Mercantile Exchange (CME) ES futures in a deterministic market-replay simulator, reporting its slippage and latency sensitivity and comparing it against the aggressive equivalent POV. We propose it as a model-free benchmark for passive-order placement, against which a predictive placement model can be scored. The algorithm and the order-book simulator are implemented in the open-source kaspar-hft project.
Complexity vs Empirical Score
- Math Complexity: 4.0/10
- Empirical Rigor: 6.0/10 (capped from 8.0: no out-of-sample test; see penalty flags)
- Quadrant: Street Traders — empirical and applied, lower math complexity (effective empirical rigor capped from 8.0)
Why this score: This paper presents a highly novel, model-free approach to passive execution with strong empirical validation using a full year of market replay data. While the mathematical complexity is moderate, the rigorous testing and open-source implementation contribute to a high overall score.
Research Flowchart
flowchart TD
A["Research Goal: Develop Model-Free Passive Execution"] --> B{"Key Methodology: Shadow-PPOV"};
B -- Order Placement Strategy --> C["Data/Inputs: Real-time Order Flow (Third-party Additions)"];
C -- Cancellation Strategy --> D["Computational Processes: Identifier-Driven Shadow Tracking"];
D -- Evaluation --> E["Evaluation Data: CME ES Futures (Full Year)"];
E -- Comparison --> F["Key Findings: Slippage & Latency Sensitivity, Comparison to Aggressive POV"];
F -- Outcome --> G["Outcome: Model-Free Benchmark for Passive-Order Placement"];
Evidence Card
What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card
Proposes
The paper proposes Shadow-PPOV, a simple model‑free benchmark for passive order placement that shadows third‑party orders.
Source sentence
We propose Shadow-PPOV as a simple, model-free benchmark for passive-order placement, built on participant shadowing: on observing a third-party add, Shadow-PPOV places a passive order at that add’s price and venue, attaches it to the arriving order by exchange identifier, and ties its lifecycle to that order.
Assumes 5
- The market replay does not model the market’s reaction to Shadow-PPOV’s own orders. market
Source sentence
The replay does not model the market’s reaction to Shadow-PPOV’s own orders.
- Fill gaps are modeled as independent exponential random variables. model
Source sentence
we assume the market volume that must trade before a child fills is Exponential(ρ) with mean 1/ρ for a target participation rate ρ
- The empirical study is limited to a single instrument (ES futures). data
Source sentence
The study is a single instrument: ES is a one-tick book for most of the session
- Latency is applied uniformly to order, cancel, and market‑data feed paths. execution
Source sentence
The delay is applied to all three paths at once — the outbound order, the outbound cancel, and the inbound market-data feed
Show 1 more
- Participation rate is a realized quantity subject to tracking error. statistical
Source sentence
the delivered participation is a realized quantity, a recognized source of tracking error and execution risk
Data
- CME ES futures replay order-book proprietary
Source sentence
We evaluate Shadow-PPOV on a full calendar year of replayed Chicago Mercantile Exchange (CME) ES futures in a deterministic market-replay simulator
Nasdaq TotalView-ITCH
Costs
Modeled
Passive Shadow-PPOV costs +0.0955 ± 0.0130 ticks per contract (≈$1.19) against the arrival mid; aggressive equivalent costs +0.0952 ± 0.0135 ticks.
Source sentence
Over 9,592 completed passive windows a round trip of 100 contracts bought and 100 sold costs +0.0955 ± 0.0130 ticks per contract against the arrival mid — under a tenth of a tick, or $1.19 per contract on ES
Finds 4
- Shadow-PPOV executes close to the mid price, costing +0.0955 ± 0.0130 ticks per contract and beating immediate execution by 0.4236 ticks. performance
Source sentence
... and beats immediate execution (crossing the spread) by 0.4236 ticks.
- Passive and aggressive POV have statistically indistinguishable costs at zero latency (+0.0955 vs +0.0952 ticks). performance
Source sentence
At matched participation the aggressive equivalent returns +0.0952±0.0135 against passive’s +0.0955, and −0.4239 against −0.4236 relative to immediate execution
- Cost rises monotonically with round‑trip latency; passive cost goes from +0.097 to +0.150 ticks between 0 and 5 ms, still beating immediate execution. performance
Source sentence
Passive Shadow-PPOV goes from +0.097 to +0.150 ticks per contract between zero and five milliseconds, still beating immediate execution by 0.371 ticks at the far end
- Latency degrades both passive and aggressive styles, with non‑overlapping confidence intervals across the latency range. performance
Source sentence
Cost rises monotonically with round‑trip delay in both styles, with non‑overlapping intervals from end to end.
Checked by others
No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 19 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.
Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.