Paper: arXiv 2410.21110
Authors: Leonardo Perotti, Lech A. Grzelak, Cornelis W. Oosterlee
Abstract
Prepayment risk embedded in fixed-rate mortgages forms a significant fraction of a financial institution’s exposure, and it receives particular attention because of the magnitude of the underlying market. The embedded prepayment option (EPO) bears the same interest rate risk as an exotic interest rate swap (IRS) with a suitable stochastic notional. We investigate the effect of relaxing the assumption of a deterministic relationship between the market interest rate incentive and the prepayment rate. A non-hedgeable risk factor is modeled to capture the uncertainty in mortgage owners’ behavior, leading to an incomplete market. We prove under natural assumptions that including behavioral uncertainty reduces the exposure’s value. We statically replicate the exposure resulting from the EPO with IRSs and swaptions, and we show that a replication based on swaps solely cannot easily control the right tail of the exposure distribution, while including swaptions enables that. The replication framework is flexible and focuses on different regions in the exposure distribution. Since a non-hedgeable risk factor entails the existence of multiple equivalent martingale measures, pricing and optimal replication are not unique. We investigate the effect of a market price of risk misspecification and we provide a methodology to generate robust hedging strategies. Such strategies, obtained as solutions to a saddle-point problem, allow us to bound the exposure against a misspecification of the pricing measure.
Complexity vs Empirical Score
- Math Complexity: 8.0/10
- Empirical Rigor: 3.0/10
- Quadrant: Lab Rats — high math complexity, limited empirical testing
Why this score: The paper involves advanced mathematical modeling of incomplete markets and robust hedging via saddle-point problems, but lacks empirical validation (e.g., backtests, datasets, or statistical metrics) and focuses on theoretical replication frameworks.
Research Flowchart
flowchart TD A["Research Goal:<br>Model & replicate EPO<br>with behavioral uncertainty"] --> B["Methodology:<br>Stochastic model for<br>behavioral uncertainty"] B --> C["Data/Inputs:<br>Market rates, mortgage features,<br>behavioral parameters"] C --> D["Computational Process:<br>Solve incomplete market model<br>under multiple martingale measures"] D --> E["Computational Process:<br>Static replication using<br>IRSs and Swaptions"] E --> F["Outcome 1:<br>Behavioral uncertainty<br>reduces exposure value"] E --> G["Outcome 2:<br>IRS-only replication fails<br>to control right tail risk"] E --> H["Outcome 3:<br>Swaptions enable robust<br>tail risk management"] E --> I["Outcome 4:<br>Robust hedging via<br>saddle-point optimization"]
Evidence Card
What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card
Proposes
The paper proposes a valuation framework for the mortgage prepayment option that incorporates a stochastic non‑hedgeable risk factor to capture behavioral uncertainty and uses static replication with swaps and swaptions.
Source sentence
We have proposed a framework for the valuation of the prepayment option embedded in mortgages (EPO).
Assumes 6
- Pricing is performed under a risk‑neutral measure Q. model
Source sentence
Consistently with the standard pricing literature, the EPO value process is evaluated under a risk‑neutral measure Q and requires knowledge of the risk‑neutral dynamics for the two risk factors r(t) and b(t).
- The market risk factor r(t) follows the Hull‑White short‑rate model. model
Source sentence
The model choice for the market risk factor r(t) is the well‑known Hull‑White short rate model [Hull and White, 1990]
- The behavioral risk factor b(t) follows an Ornstein–Uhlenbeck process. model
Source sentence
the dynamics for b(t) are modeled as an Ornstein–Uhlenbeck (OU) process [Uhlenbeck and Ornstein, 1930]
- In the baseline pricing experiments the market price of risk for b(t) is set to zero. market
Source sentence
In Sections 5.1.1 and 5.2, the market price of risk for b(t) is assumed to be zero, λ(t) = 0.
Show 2 more
- Amortization schemes are either interest‑only (bullet) or linear with one payment per year. data
Source sentence
The amortization scheme used in the experiments is either interest‑only (also said bullet), or linear. The details are reported in Table 3.
- The initial mortgage notional is set to 10⁴ and the fixed rate to 3.1 %. data
Source sentence
For reference, the initial notional of the mortgage contract is set to Nc,0 = 10⁴
Data
- Swaption volatility cube options unknown
Source sentence
These choices correspond to realistic coefficients for the Hull‑White model, obtained from calibration on a market‑realized swaption volatility cube.
- Realistic prepayment data alternative unknown
Source sentence
The coefficients in Equation (3.7) are computed with MLE and are based on a time series for b(t) calibrated on realistic prepayment data (see Figure 4).
Costs
Not applicable
Finds 5
- Including behavioral uncertainty reduces the value of the prepayment exposure. theoretical
Source sentence
we prove under natural assumptions that including behavioral uncertainty reduces the exposure’s value.
- Static replication with swaps alone cannot control the right tail of the exposure distribution, while adding swaptions does. performance
Source sentence
a replication based on swaps solely cannot easily control the right tail of the exposure distribution, while including swaptions enables that.
- Investing 28 bps in swaptions cuts the cumulated exposure more than sixfold relative to a swaps‑only hedge. performance
Source sentence
with an investment of 28 bps of the mortgage portfolio notional in swaptions, we can reduce the cumulated exposure as defined in (3.12) more than six times compared to the hedge based on sole swaps (see Table 5).
- Robust hedging that includes expected shortfall reduces the 90 % ES measure by over 27 % at the cost of higher hedging expense. performance
Source sentence
we may reduce LES+ 0.9 – a measure of the cumulated expected shortfall over time –
- Misspecification of the market price of risk can have a significant impact on EPO valuation and leads to a complex hedging problem. theoretical
Source sentence
Particularly, we showed that a misspecification of the market price of risk may have a significant
Checked by others
No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 33 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.
Code
No repository by the authors found in the paper.
Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.
Cited References (59)
- On the modelling of nested risk neutral stochastic processes with applications in insurance (2017)
- Robustness, detection and the price of risk (2000)
- Kalman filtering of generalized Vasicek term structure models (1999)
- Towards a general theory of good-deal bounds (2006) — link
- Beyond arbitrage: Good-deal asset price bounds in incomplete markets (2000) — link
- Time series and cross-section information in affine term-structure models (2000)
- Pricing swaptions and coupon bond options in affine term structure models (2006)
- The affine arbitrage-free class of Nelson–Siegel term structure models (2011)
and 51 more
- A structural risk-neutral model of electricity prices (2009) — link
- Arbitrage Theory in Continuous Time (2019) — link
- Martingales and stochastic integrals in the theory of continuous trading (1981)
- Methods of mathematical finance (1998)
- Martingale methods in financial modelling (2006)
- Pricing and Hedging Prepayment Risk in a Mortgage Portfolio (2022) — link
- Machine Learning–Based Systematic Investing in Agency Mortgage-Backed Securities (2022) — link
- Prepayment modeling and valuation of D utch mortgages (2003) — link
- Mathematical modeling and computation in finance: with exercises and Python and MATLAB computer codes (2019) — link
- Interest Rate Models – Theory and Practice: With Smile, Inflation and Credit (2006) — link
- Measuring and Managing Liquidity Risk (2013) — link
- Implementation of a mortgage backed security ( MBS ) pricing model (2007) — link
- A study of mortgage prepayment risk (2001) — link
- An equilibrium characterization of the term structure (1977)
- Bond pricing and the term structure of interest rates: A new methodology for contingent claims valuation (1992)
- Pricing interest-rate-derivative securities (1990) — link
- Hedging of contingent claims under incomplete information (1991)
- Option hedging for semimartingales (1991)
- D-TIPO: Deep time-inconsistent portfolio optimization with stocks and options — → 2308.10556
- An exact bond option formula (1989)
- Valuing A merican options by simulation: A simple least-squares approach (2001) — link
- Hedging of non-redundant contingent claims (1985)
- Martingales and arbitrage in multiperiod securities markets (1979)
- On transforming a certain class of stochastic processes by absolutely continuous substitution of measures (1960)
- On randomization of affine diffusion processes with application to pricing of options on vix and s&p 500 (2022) — link
- On square integrable martingales (1967)
- Pricing and hedging in incomplete markets with model uncertainty (2020) — link
- Stochastic Calculus: An Introduction Through Theory and Exercises (2017) — link
- Fixed income mathematics (2005)
- Introduction to Mortgages and Mortgage Backed Securities (2014) — link
- Prepayments of fixed-rate mortgage-backed securities (1989) — link
- On the theory of the B rownian motion (1930)
- Indifference Pricing: Theory and Applications (2009) — link
- Utility indifference pricing: An overview (2004)
- Optimal prepayment of D utch mortgages (2007) — link
- Prepayment behavior of D utch mortgagors: A n empirical analysis (2003) — link
- Pricing mortgage-backed securities and collateralized mortgage obligations (2004)
- The value of a prepayment option in a fixed rate mortgage: Insights from breakeven volatility (2017)
- Modelling prepayment risk (2005)
- An option-theoretic prepayment model for mortgages and mortgage-backed securities (2004) — link
- Pricing and hedging loan prepayment risk (1993) — link
- On the minimal martingale measure and the M "o llmer- S chweizer decomposition (1995) — link
- The minimal entropy martingale measure and the valuation problem in incomplete markets (2000)
- Modeling Behavioral Risk (2014) — link
- M odeling and R eplication of the P repayment O ption of M ortgages including B ehavioral U ncertainty (2024)
- Mortgage prepayments in the Netherlands. Explanatory research on prepayment variables and the effects on asset & liability management and securitisation (2002)
- Valuation of mortgages without prepayment penalties (2018) — link
- The market price of risk, size of market and investor’s risk aversion (1970) — link
- On time consistency for mean-variance portfolio selection (2020) — link
- The importance of income and housing wealth constraints for future residential mobility (2011) — link
- The determinants of mortgage defaults and prepayments (2010) — link
1 of 59 cited works are in the corpus; resolved via arXiv source bundles, Semantic Scholar and OpenAlex. Corpus-wide: 2596 linked papers.