Paper: arXiv 2509.09415
Authors: Marcel Ausloos, Probowo Erawan Sastroredjo, Polina Khrennikova
Abstract
Pre-taxation analysis plays a crucial role in ensuring the fairness of public revenue collection. It can also serve as a tool to reduce the risk of tax avoidance, one of the UK government’s concerns. Our report utilises pre-tax income (\(PI\)) and total assets (\(TA\)) data from 567 companies listed on the FTSE All-Share index, gathered from the Refinitiv EIKON database, covering 14 years, i.e., the period from 2009 to 2022. We also derive the \(PI/TA\) ratio, and distinguish between positive and negative \(PI\) cases. We test the conformity of such data to Benford’s Laws,- specifically studying the first significant digit (\(Fd\)), the second significant digit (\(Sd\)), and the first and second significant digits (\(FSd\)). We use and justify two pertinent tests, the \(χ^2\) and the Mean Absolute Deviation (MAD). We find that both tests are not leading to conclusions in complete agreement with each other, - in particular the MAD test entirely rejects the Benford’s Laws conformity of the reported financial data. From the mere accounting point of view, we conclude that the findings not only cast some doubt on the reported financial data, but also suggest that many more investigations be envisaged on closely related matters. On the other hand, the study of a ratio, like \(PI/TA\), of variables which are (or not) Benford’s Laws compliant add to the literature debating whether such indirect variables should (or not) be Benford’s Laws compliant.
Complexity vs Empirical Score
- Math Complexity: 3.0/10
- Empirical Rigor: 7.0/10
- Quadrant: Street Traders — empirical and applied, lower math complexity
Why this score: The paper applies standard statistical tests (χ² and MAD) to real financial data from a specific database, but the mathematics is relatively simple and descriptive rather than advanced or novel.
Research Flowchart
flowchart TD A["Research Goal: Test conformity of FTSE-listed companies' financial data<br>to Benford's Law to assess data integrity and tax avoidance risk"] --> B["Data Collection & Preparation"] B --> C["Key Inputs: 567 FTSE All-Share companies<br>2009-2022 (14 years)<br>Refinitiv EIKON Database"] C --> D["Variables Derived"] D --> D1["Pre-tax Income PI"] D --> D2["Total Assets TA"] D --> D3["Ratio PI/TA"] D --> E["Computational Process"] E --> E1["Statistical Tests Applied"] E1 --> E1a["Chi-square test χ²"] E1 --> E1b["Mean Absolute Deviation MAD"] E1 --> E1c["Focused on Digits: Fd, Sd, FSd"] E1a --> F["Key Findings & Outcomes"] E1b --> F F --> F1["Inconsistent Results: χ² and MAD tests disagree<br>MAD test completely rejects Benford conformity"] F --> F2["Accounting Implications: Raises doubts about<br>reported financial data integrity"] F --> F3["Research Contribution: Adds to literature debate<br>on compliance of ratio variables to Benford's Law"]
Evidence Card
What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card
Proposes
The paper proposes to assess the conformity of pre‑tax income, total assets and their ratio (PI/TA) for UK FTSE‑listed companies to Benford's Laws using two statistical tests, the chi‑square (χ²) test and the Mean Absolute Deviation (MAD) test.
Source sentence
We test the conformity of such data to Benford's Laws,- specifically studying the first significant digit ($Fd$), the second significant digit ($Sd$), and the first and second significant digits ($FSd$). We use and justify two pertinent tests, the $χ^2$ and the Mean Absolute Deviation (MAD).
Assumes 3
- The Refinitiv EIKON data for pre‑tax income and total assets are sufficiently accurate for Benford analysis, despite some missing values and outliers. data
Source sentence
Secondly, we have encountered a lot of missing data. To main-tain the authenticity of the dataset, we leave these data points blank in our "Master Data Bank".
- Benford's Laws can be applied to derived variables such as the PI/TA ratio. statistical
Source sentence
Therefore, we also calculated PI/TA when possible, i.e., when both PI and TA data are reported for a company in a given year. Since the validity and applicability of Benford’s laws (BLs) is still debated, in particular on indirect measures, we have also derived the PI/TA data set.
- The null hypothesis of conformity to Benford's Laws is testable with the χ² and MAD statistics for the given sample size. statistical
Source sentence
We run two null hypothesis significance testing methods to investigate conformity to BLs. More precisely, as measures to assess the discrepancy 4 between the empirical and the theoretical Benford distributions, we use the χ2 test and the MAD test as described in detail in Section 4.
Data
- Pre‑tax income (PI) and Total assets (TA) fundamentals commercial
Source sentence
Our report utilises pre-tax income ($PI$) and total assets ($TA$) data from 567 companies listed on the FTSE All-Share index, gathered from the Refinitiv EIKON database, covering 14 years, i.e., the period from 2009 to 2022. 6 3 Data Acquisition and Study Methodology 3.1 Data Acquisition We utilise data from Refinitiv EIKON, focusing on pre-tax income (PI) and the total assets (TA) as pre-taxation indicators from
- PI/TA ratio other unknown
Source sentence
We also derive the $PI/TA$ ratio, and distinguish between positive and negative $PI$ cases. Therefore, we also calculated PI/TA when possible, i.e., when both PI and TA data are reported for a company in a given year.
Costs
Not applicable
Finds 3
- The MAD test entirely rejects Benford's Laws conformity for the reported financial data. statistical
Source sentence
We find that both tests are not leading to conclusions in complete agreement with each other, - in particular the MAD test entirely rejects the Benford's Laws conformity of the reported financial data. Interestingly, we find that the MAD test entirely rejects the Benford’s Laws conformity of the reported financial data, whence the relevant null hypothesis.
- The χ² test results are ambiguous; some cases show χ² below the critical value while others are close, and no PI/TA ratio passes the 5% χ² criterion. statistical figure from elsewhere in the paper
Source sentence
Indeed, we find that both χ2 test and MAD tests are not leading to conclusions in complete agreement with each other. In contrast, conclusions from the χ2 tests are more ambiguous.
- Both χ² and MAD tests do not lead to completely agreeing conclusions, leading to rejection of the null hypothesis of Benford conformity. statistical
Source sentence
Indeed, we find that both χ2 test and MAD tests are not leading to conclusions in complete agreement with each other. Thereby, one rejects the null hypothesis.
Checked by others
No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 9 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.
Code
No repository by the authors found in the paper.
Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.