Paper: arXiv 2311.03538

Authors: Anne Mackay, Marie-Claude Vachon

Abstract

We study an optimal stopping problem with an unbounded, time-dependent and discontinuous reward function. This problem is motivated by the pricing of a variable annuity contract with guaranteed minimum maturity benefit, under the assumption that the policyholder’s surrender behaviour maximizes the risk-neutral value of the contract. We consider a general fee and surrender charge function, and give a condition under which optimal stopping always occurs at maturity. Using an alternative representation for the value function of the optimization problem, we study its analytical properties and the resulting surrender (or exercise) region. In particular, we show that the non-emptiness and the shape of the surrender region are fully characterized by the fee and the surrender charge functions, which provides a powerful tool to understand their interrelation and how it affects early surrenders and the optimal surrender boundary. Under certain conditions on these two functions, we develop three representations for the value function; two are analogous to their American option counterpart, and one is new to the actuarial and American option pricing literature.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 8.0/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 2.0/10
  • Quadrant: Lab Rats — high math complexity, limited empirical testing

Why this score: The paper presents advanced mathematical analysis of an optimal stopping problem with discontinuous reward functions, using concepts like free-boundary problems and Itô’s formula, but lacks any empirical validation, backtesting, or numerical implementation details.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
  A["Research Goal<br>Optimal Stopping with Discontinuous Reward"] --> B{"Methodology"}
  B --> C["Alternative Value Function<br>Representation"]
  B --> D["General Fee & Charge<br>Functions"]
  C --> E["Analytical Properties<br>& Surrender Region Analysis"]
  D --> E
  E --> F["Computational Process<br>Numerical Solution via PDE"]
  F --> G{"Outcomes"}
  G --> H["Condition for<br>Optimal Maturity Surrender"]
  G --> I["Characterization of<br>Surrender Region"]

Evidence Card

What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card

Proposes

The paper proposes a condition under which it is never optimal to surrender before maturity and provides three representations for the value function, including a new continuous‑reward representation.

Source sentence
We consider a general fee and surrender charge function, and give a condition under which optimal stopping always occurs at maturity. The main contributions of this paper are summarized below. • We give a condition under which it is never optimal for the policyholder to surrender before maturity of the VA contract. • We present an alternative representation for the value function of the VA contract in terms of a

Assumes 3

  • The fee function c(t,x) is such that the drift µ(t,x) = (r‑c(t,x))x is continuous and globally Lipschitz in the account value. model
    Source sentence
    (i) The fee function c is such that µ is continuous and globally Lipschitz in x, that is, there exists K ≥0 such that for all x, y ∈R+, t ≥0, |µ(t, x) −µ(t, y)| ≤K|x −y|.
  • For all x, the fee function is locally Hölder continuous in time. model
    Source sentence
    (ii) For all x, the function t 7→c(t, x) is locally Hölder continuous. Assumption 4.2.
  • The market follows the Black‑Scholes dynamics for the underlying account value. market
    Source sentence
    6. Conclusion In this paper, we perform a rigorous theoretical analysis of the value function involved in the pricing of a variable annuity contract with guaranteed minimum maturity benefit under the Black-Scholes setting with general fee and surrender charge functions.

Data

No dataset named in the text.

Costs

Not applicable The paper reports no trading or execution result.

Finds 5

  • If the surrender charge parameter k satisfies k ≥ c̄ (the constant fee rate), then early surrender incentives are eliminated. theoretical
    Source sentence
    To eliminate the incentive to surrender, it suffices to choose k and ¯c such that (9) holds; a quick calculation yields k ≥¯c. In this setting, it suffices to set k at or above the fee rate ¯c to eliminate optimal early surrenders.
  • The surrender region can be disconnected and the optimal surrender boundary may be discontinuous. theoretical
    Source sentence
    In particular, we show that the surrender region can be a disconnected set and that the optimal surrender boundary can be discontinuous, thus further highlighting the complex-ity of this optimal stopping problem. These two representations are used in Section 4.4 to characterize the (non-) emptiness of the surrender region.
  • The value function is continuous on the whole domain [0,T]×R⁺ when expressed via the continuous‑reward representation. theoretical
    Source sentence
    The value function v is continuous on [0, T] × R+. Proof.
  • The value function is convex in the state variable and Lipschitz in the account value. theoretical
    Source sentence
    We also prove its convexity in the state variable, its Lipschitz property in x and characterize its continuity in t.
  • The (non‑)emptiness of the surrender region depends on an explicit condition expressed solely in terms of the fee and surrender‑charge functions. theoretical
    Source sentence
    We show that the (non-)emptiness of the surrender region depends on an explicit condition that is expressed solely in terms of the fee and the surrender charge functions.

Checked by others

Supported by

  • On variable annuities with surrender charges (2024)
    On the question: Do large surrender charges (k≥c̄ or K≥c) eliminate early surrender incentives?
    Compare the findings

    This paper: If the surrender charge parameter k satisfies k ≥ c̄ (the constant fee rate), then early surrender incentives are eliminated.

    That paper: Large surrender charges (K≥c) completely disincentivise early surrender, making the contract never surrendered.

    Both findings agree that when the charge parameter meets or exceeds the fee rate (k≥c̄, K≥c), early surrender is fully disincentivized; no differing market or sample noted.

Contradicted by

  • On variable annuities with surrender charges (2024)
    On the question: What is the continuity and shape of the optimal surrender boundary in variable annuity surrender problems?
    Compare the findings

    This paper: The surrender region can be disconnected and the optimal surrender boundary may be discontinuous.

    That paper: The optimal surrender boundary is non‑monotonic but continuous and regular in the diffusion sense.

    A finds the surrender region can be disconnected and the boundary may be discontinuous, while B finds a continuous, non‑monotonic, regular boundary.

Cited by 1 paper in the archive (1 by independent authors)

Code

No repository by the authors found in the paper.

Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.