Paper: arXiv 2306.02764
Authors: Shiqi Gong, Shuaiqiang Liu, Danny D. Sun
Abstract
Market making plays a crucial role in providing liquidity and maintaining stability in financial markets, making it an essential component of well-functioning capital markets. Despite its importance, there is limited research on market making in the Chinese stock market, which is one of the largest and most rapidly growing markets globally. To address this gap, we employ an optimal market making framework with an exponential CARA-type (Constant Absolute Risk Aversion) utility function that accounts for various market conditions, such as price drift, volatility, and stamp duty, and is capable of describing 3 major risks (i.e., inventory, execution and adverse selection risks) in market making practice, and provide an in-depth quantitative and scenario analysis of market making in the Chinese stock market. Our numerical experiments explore the impact of volatility on the market maker’s inventory. Furthermore, we find that the stamp duty rate is a critical factor in market making, with a negative impact on both the profit of the market maker and the liquidity of the market. Additionally, our analysis emphasizes the significance of accurately estimating stock drift for managing inventory and adverse selection risks effectively and enhancing profit for the market maker. These findings offer valuable insights for both market makers and policymakers in the Chinese stock market and provide directions for further research in designing effective market making strategies and policies.
Complexity vs Empirical Score
- Math Complexity: 8.5/10
- Empirical Rigor: 6.0/10
- Quadrant: Holy Grail — high math complexity, high empirical rigor
Why this score: The paper employs advanced stochastic control theory with Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman (HJB) equations and CARA utility, indicating high mathematical complexity. It includes numerical experiments and scenario analysis based on Chinese market data (e.g., volatility, stamp duty), demonstrating moderate empirical rigor with backtest-ready components but lacking extensive live implementation details.
Research Flowchart
flowchart TD
A["Research Goal<br>Optimal Market Making in Chinese Stock Market"] --> B["Methodology: CARA Utility Model<br>with Inventory & Adverse Selection Risks"]
B --> C["Key Inputs<br>Volatility, Price Drift, Stamp Duty Rate"]
C --> D["Computational Process<br>Stochastic Control & Scenario Analysis"]
D --> E{"Outcome 1: Inventory Dynamics<br>Higher volatility increases inventory risk"}
D --> F{"Outcome 2: Stamp Duty Impact<br>Reduces market maker profit & liquidity"}
D --> G{"Outcome 3: Drift Estimation<br>Accurate estimation critical for profit"}
E & F & G --> H["Conclusions & Insights<br>For market makers & policymakers"]
Evidence Card
What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card
Proposes
The paper proposes an optimal market making framework using an exponential CARA utility function that captures price drift, volatility and stamp duty, and conducts quantitative and scenario analysis for the Chinese stock market.
Source sentence
we employ an optimal market making framework with an exponential CARA-type (Constant Absolute Risk Aversion) utility function that accounts for various market conditions, such as price drift, volatility, and stamp duty, and is capable of describing 3 major risks (i.e., inventory, execution and adverse selection risks)
Assumes 6
- The stamp duty rate ρ is fixed at 1‰ and the commission fee ε varies by brokerage but does not exceed 1‰. market
Source sentence
In the current SZSE, the stamp duty rate ρ is fixed at 1‰, while the commission fee ε varies by brokerage, with a maximum limit not exceeding 1‰.
- Daily price change limits are enforced at ±10% for most stocks and ±20% for ChiNext Board stocks. market
Source sentence
daily price change limits are enforced, typically ±10% for most stocks and ±20% for ChiNext Board stocks.
- The settlement cycle follows a T+1 rule, with funds from selling instantly available for other purchases. market
Source sentence
the SZSE follows a T+1 settlement cycle, in which securities can be sold one business day after the trade date, while funds from selling are instantly available for purchasing other stocks.
- The mid‑quote process Pt is modeled as a continuous‑state diffusion process. model
Source sentence
we assume the mid‑quote Pt follows a continuous‑state diffusion process
Show 2 more
- Independence is assumed between the mid‑quote Pt and the spread St. model
Source sentence
we relied on certain assumptions in our model and data, such as the independence between the mid‑quote Pt and spread St.
- In the baseline scenario the drift µ is set to zero to represent a worst‑case information‑less environment. model
Source sentence
For the mid‑quote process Pt in Equation (1), we assume µ = 0 to consider that traders lack information about the stock price trend in the worst‑case scenario.
Data
- SZSE high‑frequency data (snapshot, order, tick) order-book unknown
Source sentence
we reconstruct the order book using order data and tick data and mainly use snapshot data generated at a frequency of 10ms for our study.
Costs
Modeled
Stamp duty 1‰ applied on sales; commission fee between 0.1‰ and 0.3‰ per side.
Source sentence
the commission fee ε varies by brokerage, with a maximum limit not exceeding 1‰. Typically, for a market maker, the commission fee ranges between 0.1‰ and 0.3‰.
Finds 3
- Higher volatility directly increases inventory risk, prompting market makers to hold lower inventory levels. performance
Source sentence
Higher volatility leads to increased inventory risk, making it necessary for the market maker to maintain lower inventory levels in order to mitigate the risk of holding large positions.
- The stamp duty rate negatively impacts both market‑maker profit and overall market liquidity. negative
Source sentence
The stamp duty rate has a negative impact on both the profit of the market maker and the liquidity of the market.
- Accurate estimation of the stock drift improves order‑placement decisions, reduces adverse‑selection risk and raises profits. performance
Source sentence
Accurately estimating the drift is crucial for the market maker to optimize their order strategies and manage inventory effectively
Checked by others
Supported by
- 0DTEs: Trading, Gamma Risk and Volatility Propagation
Compare the findings
This paper: Higher volatility directly increases inventory risk, prompting market makers to hold lower inventory levels.
That paper: Market makers’ inventory, measured by the net gamma of their positions, is on average positive and negatively related to future intraday volatility.
Code
No repository by the authors found in the paper.
Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.