Paper: arXiv 2410.07749

Authors: John Armstrong, James Dalby

Abstract

We mathematically demonstrate how and what it means for two collective pension funds to mutually insure one another against systematic longevity risk. The key equation that facilitates the exchange of insurance is a market clearing condition. This enables an insurance market to be established even if the two funds face the same mortality risk, so long as they have different risk preferences. Provided the preferences of the two funds are not too dissimilar, insurance provides little benefit, implying the base scheme is effectively optimal. When preferences vary significantly, insurance can be beneficial.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 9.0/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 2.0/10
  • Quadrant: Lab Rats — high math complexity, limited empirical testing

Why this score: The paper employs advanced continuous-time stochastic optimal control, HJB PDEs, and Epstein–Zin preferences, representing dense mathematics. However, it focuses on theoretical derivations with limited numerical implementation and no backtesting or real-world data, placing it low on empirical rigor.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
  A["Research Goal<br>Determine optimal mutual insurance<br>against systematic longevity risk"] --> B["Methodology<br>Mathematical modeling of two collective<br>pension funds with differing risk preferences"]
  B --> C["Key Inputs<br>Systematic longevity risk assumption<br>Disparate risk preferences"]
  C --> D["Computational Process<br>Establish a market clearing condition<br>to facilitate the insurance exchange"]
  D --> E{"Comparison"}
  E -- "Preferences are<br>similar" --> F["Outcome<br>Little benefit from insurance<br>Base scheme is effectively optimal"]
  E -- "Preferences are<br>dissimilar" --> G["Outcome<br>Mutual insurance is beneficial"]
  F --> H["Final Finding<br>Insurance market exists even with<br>identical risks if preferences differ"]
  G --> H

Evidence Card

What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card

Proposes

The paper develops a mathematical model for optimal consumption, investment, and insurance purchase strategies for two collective pension funds that mutually insure each other against systematic longevity risk.

Source sentence
We mathematically demonstrate how and what it means for two collective pension funds to mutually insure one another against systematic longevity risk. The key equation that facilitates the exchange of insurance is a market clearing condition.

Assumes 6

  • The financial market follows a Black–Scholes model with drift μ, volatility σ, and a risk‑free asset with constant interest rate r. market
    Source sentence
    Our market model is given by (2.1b) i.e. the Black–Scholes model with drift µ, volatility σ and W 1 is a Brownian motion. As the second term in equation (2.1a) indicates, we are also assuming that their is a risk-free asset with constant interest rate r.
  • The force of mortality follows a diffusion process driven by a Brownian motion W₂ independent of the asset Brownian motion W₁. model
    Source sentence
    The force of mortality is given by (2.1c), where W 2 is a Brownian motion independent of W 1.
  • One of the funds is finite while the other is infinite, reducing the PDE dimension. model
    Source sentence
    This a difficult task, so we focus on a simple sub-case of this most general problem, in which one of the funds is finite and the other infinite. This reduces the dimension of the PDEs from three to one, making them solvable, whilst still allowing us to quantify the maximal possible benefit insurance can provide.
  • The two funds have Epstein–Zin preferences that may differ; if preferences are not too dissimilar, insurance provides little benefit. other
    Source sentence
    Provided the preferences of the two funds are not too dissimilar, insurance provides little benefit, implying the base scheme is effectively optimal. When preferences vary significantly, insurance can be beneficial.
Show 2 more
  • Insurance contracts are priced by the infinite fund and fully matched to demand from the finite fund. execution
    Source sentence
    The infinite fund sets the price of the insurance contracts and matches all demand for these contracts from the small fund without altering its position. Hence, this situation yields the maximum possible benefit a fund can achieve from buying/selling insur-ance with another fund.
  • Fund sizes affect wealth proportionally, allowing the problem to be expressed in terms of the wealth ratio w₂/w₁. model
    Source sentence
    For example, we can ignore the fund sizes (n1, n2) as variables, since a change in them should have the 6 same effect as a change in wealth for a fixed number of individuals. This suggests we express the equation in term of the wealth ratio w2/w1, so we obtain a two-dimensional prob-lem.

Data

Synthetic data only.

Costs

Not applicable The paper reports no trading or execution result.

Finds 5

  • When the two funds have similar risk preferences, mutual insurance yields little benefit, making the base scheme effectively optimal. theoretical
    Source sentence
    Provided the preferences of the two funds are not too dissimilar, insurance provides little benefit, implying the base scheme is effectively optimal.
  • When the preferences of the two funds differ significantly, mutual insurance can be beneficial. theoretical
    Source sentence
    When preferences vary significantly, insurance can be beneficial.
  • The maximal possible benefit from insurance is obtained when the infinite fund sets the price and matches all demand from the finite fund. theoretical
    Source sentence
    The infinite fund sets the price of the insurance contracts and matches all demand for these contracts from the small fund without altering its position. Hence, this situation yields the maximum possible benefit a fund can achieve from buying/selling insur-ance with another fund.
  • The larger the difference in risk aversion between the small and large fund, the greater the insurance benefit, as shown in the CBD model results. theoretical
    Source sentence
    The general trend the table reveals, is that the larger the difference in the two funds risk aversion, the greater the benefit insurance may provide.
  • Even when the median profit‑and‑loss scenario shows a loss, consumption is higher with insurance because early‑stage profit allows more risky‑asset investment, increasing lifetime utility. theoretical
    Source sentence
    Interestingly, the median profit and loss scenario actually makes a loss, yet consumption is higher with insurance than without. This can be explained by the fact that insurance does yield a profit in the early stages of retirement (up to age 80 roughly), which means more wealth can be put into the risky asset, and the increased returns from this result in a net increase in utility over the funds lifetime.

Checked by others

No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 17 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.

Cited by 2 papers in the archive

Code

No repository by the authors found in the paper.

Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.

Cited References (89)

  1. Rates of weak convergence and asymptotic expansions for classical central limit theorems (1971)
  2. Continuous-time stochastic control and optimization with financial applications (2009)
  3. Lifetime portfolio selection under uncertainty: The continuous-time case (1969)
  4. Complex analysis (2010)
  5. Substitution, Risk Aversion, and the Temporal Behavior of Consumption and Asset Returns: A Theoretical Framework (1989) — link
  6. Temporal resolution of uncertainty and dynamic choice theory (1978)
  7. An axiomatic characterization of preferences under uncertainty: Weakening the independence axiom (1986)
  8. Axiomatic utility theories with the betweenness property (1989)
and 81 more
  1. Risk aversion with many commodities (1974)
  2. Stationary ordinal utility and impatience (1960)
  3. The structure of intertemporal preferences under uncertainty and time consistent plans (1985)
  4. Nonexpected utility preferences in a temporal framework with an application to consumption-savings behaviour (1990)
  5. Health and (Other) Asset Holdings (2012)
  6. Chapter 21 - Household Finance: An Emerging Field (2013) — link
  7. Household Finance and the Value of Life (2017) — link
  8. Asset Pricing with Limited Risk Sharing and Heterogeneous Agents (2008)
  9. Optimal Life-Cycle Asset Allocation: Understanding the Empirical Evidence (2005)
  10. A Rank-Dependent Utility Model of Uncertain Lifetime (2015)
  11. Stochastic Finance: an Introduction in Discrete Time (2011)
  12. Theory of Games and Economic Behavior (1953)
  13. Classifying Markets up to Isomorphism (2018) — link
  14. A Theory of Justice (1971)
  15. Convex Analysis (2015)
  16. Numerical methods for stochastic control problems in continuous time (2013)
  17. Numerical methods for controlled H amilton- J acobi- B ellman PDE s in finance (2007)
  18. Intertemporal substitution in consumption (1988)
  19. Pensions: challenges and choices: the first report of the pensions commission (2004)
  20. Government Response to the Consultation: Delivering Collective Defined Contribution Pension Schemes (2019)
  21. Cross-country heterogeneity in intertemporal substitution (2015)
  22. Disentangling intertemporal substitution and risk aversion under the expected utility theorem (2019)
  23. Risk aversion and the elasticity of substitution in general dynamic portfolio theory: Consistent planning by forward looking, expected utility maximizing investors (2009) — link
  24. What level of pension contribution is needed to obtain an adequate retirement income? (2013)
  25. CDC: International insights (2022)
  26. What is CDC and how might it work in the UK ? (2018)
  27. Risk Sharing Pension Plans: The Canadian Experience (2014)
  28. Risk Sharing Pension Plans: The Dutch Experience (2014)
  29. Supplementary forecast information release: Long-term economic determinants – March 2019 (2019)
  30. Personal Incomes Statistics 2016-17 (2019)
  31. The DC Future Book: 2018 Edition (2018)
  32. Working Paper 119. CMI Mortality Projections Model: CMI_2018 (2019)
  33. Optimization by vector space methods (1997)
  34. Collectivised post-retirement investment (2019) — link
  35. Collectivised Pension Investment with Exponential K ihlstrom– M irman Preferences (2019) — link
  36. Consumption–investment optimization with E pstein– Z in utility in incomplete markets (2017)
  37. E pstein- Z in Utility Maximization on Random Horizons (2019) — link
  38. Risks for the long run: A potential resolution of asset pricing puzzles (2004)
  39. Long-run risks and financial markets (2007)
  40. Explaining asset pricing puzzles associated with the 1987 market crash (2011)
  41. The levered equity risk premium and credit spreads: A unified framework (2009)
  42. Stochastic differential utility (1992)
  43. Optimal lifetime consumption-portfolio strategies under trading constraints and generalized recursive preferences (2003)
  44. Consumption and portfolio decisions when expected returns are time varying (1999)
  45. New Dutch pension contracts and lessons for other countries (2019)
  46. Can collective pension schemes work in the United Kingdom? (2012)
  47. Backward stochastic differential equations and integral-partial differential equations (1997)
  48. BSDE s with default jump (2016)
  49. Mathematical methods for financial markets (2009)
  50. Sharing risk: the N etherlands’ new approach to pensions (2009)
  51. Saving and investing over the life cycle and the role of collective pension funds (2007)
  52. King William’s Tontine: why the retirement annuity of the future should resemble its past (2015)
  53. Tontine pensions (2014)
  54. The analytics of a single-period tontine (2016)
  55. Fair tontine annuity (2010)
  56. Intergenerational risk-sharing and risk-taking of a pension fund (2008)
  57. Measuring time preferences (2016)
  58. Theory of interest: as determined by impatience to spend income and opportunity to invest it (1930)
  59. Uncertain lifetime, life insurance, and the theory of the consumer (1965)
  60. Uncertain lifetime and intertemporal choice: risk aversion as a rationale for time discounting (2006)
  61. Consumption and portfolio choice over the life cycle (2005)
  62. Optimal collective investment: an analysis of individual welfare (2023)
  63. Optimal consumption and portfolio choice for pooled annuity funds (2008)
  64. The simple analytics of a pooled annuity fund (2005)
  65. Optimal risk-sharing in pension funds when stock and labor markets are co-integrated (2018)
  66. Intergenerational risk sharing within funded pension schemes (2011)
  67. Can internal swap markets enhance welfare in defined contribution plans? (2010)
  68. Equitable retirement income tontines: Mixing cohorts without discriminating (2016)
  69. Optimal retirement income tontines (2015)
  70. Options on tontines: An innovative way of combining tontines and annuities (2019)
  71. On the optimal combination of annuities and tontines (2019)
  72. A new approach for satisfactory pensions with no guarantees (2020)
  73. A Two-Factor Model for Stochastic Mortality with Parameter Uncertainty: Theory and Calibration (2006)
  74. Optimal consumption and investment with Epstein–Zin recursive utility (2017)
  75. The infinite-horizon investment–consumption problem for Epstein–Zin stochastic differential utility. I: Foundations (2023)
  76. An Introduction to Computational Stochastic PDEs (2014)
  77. Systematic longevity risk: to bear or to insure? (2020)
  78. Optimal post-retirement investment under longevity risk in collective funds — → 2409.15325
  79. Numerical Methods for Controlled Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman PDEs in Finance (2007)
  80. Optimal Investment (2013)
  81. Substitution, risk aversion, and the temporal behavior of consumption and asset returns: A theoretical framework (1989)

1 of 89 cited works are in the corpus; resolved via arXiv source bundles, Semantic Scholar and OpenAlex. Corpus-wide: 2596 linked papers.