Paper: SSRN 7290621

Authors: Sheimy Paz

Abstract

Zarattini, Aziz, and Barbon (2025) present an intraday momentum strategy for SPY that achieves an annualized return of 19.6% and a Sharpe Ratio of 1.33 over the period 2007-2024. This paper independently replicates their strategy using IQFeed 1-minute data and evaluates its performance on approximately two years of out-of-sample data (May 2024 to March 2026). Our in-sample replication closely matches the original results, confirming the reproducibility of the strategy (Sharpe Ratio 1.34 over 2015-2024). However, out-of-sample performance deteriorates substantially: the strategy achieves a total return of only 9.4% versus 29.5% for a passive buy-and-hold, with a Sharpe Ratio of 0.39. The decline in risk-adjusted returns is statistically significant. We examine potential explanations for this degradation, including changing market microstructure, the proliferation of zero-days-to-expiration (0-DTE) options, and the possibility that the observed underperformance falls within historical drawdown norms. Our findings highlight the importance of out-of-sample validation for intraday trading strategies and contribute to the ongoing discussion about the persistence of momentum anomalies at high frequencies.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 5.0/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 9.0/10
  • Quadrant: Holy Grail — high math complexity, high empirical rigor
  • Basis: provisional. Scored from the abstract alone because the full text was not available, so both scores reflect what the abstract claims, not a reading of the paper.

Why this score: This paper demonstrates strong empirical rigor through independent replication and extensive out-of-sample validation, which is crucial for intraday strategies. Its novelty lies in the critical re-evaluation of a published strategy and the investigation of performance degradation factors. The methodology is clear and the results are highly reproducible.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
    A["Research Goal: Replicate & Out-of-Sample Validate Intraday Momentum Strategy"] --> B{"Methodology: Independent Replication & Out-of-Sample Evaluation"};
    B --> C["Data: IQFeed 1-Min SPY Data (2007-2026)"];
    C --> D{"Computational Process: Strategy Implementation & Performance Metrics (Returns, Sharpe)"};
    D --> E["Outcome 1: In-Sample Replication Confirmed (Sharpe 1.34)"];
    D --> F["Outcome 2: Out-of-Sample Deterioration (Total Return 9.4%, Sharpe 0.39)"];
    F --> G["Analysis: Examine Degradation Causes (Market Microstructure, 0-DTE, Drawdowns)"];
    G --> H["Conclusion: Highlights Importance of OOS Validation & Persistence of Momentum Anomaly Debate"];

Evidence Card

What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card

Proposes

The paper proposes an intraday momentum strategy for the S&P 500 ETF (SPY) and evaluates its performance out-of-sample.

Source sentence
Zarattini, Aziz, and Barbon (2025) present an intraday momentum strategy for SPY that achieves an annualized return of 19.6% and a Sharpe Ratio of 1.33 over the period 2007-2024. This paper independently replicates their strategy using IQFeed 1-minute data and evaluates its performance on approximately two years of out-of-sample data (May 2024 to March 2026).

Assumes

No explicit assumptions found in the text.

Data

Backtest sample: 2007 – 2024 · S&P 500 ETF (SPY) · equities · intraday

  • IQFeed 1-minute data · IQFeed market-prices commercial
    May 2024 to March 2026 · SPY
    Source sentence
    This paper independently replicates their strategy using IQFeed 1-minute data and evaluates its performance on approximately two years of out-of-sample data (May 2024 to March 2026).

Costs

Unclear The classifier was not confident.

Finds 4

Reported performance (intraday momentum strategy for SPY): Sharpe 1.34 · annual return 19.6% · total return 9.4%

  • Out-of-sample performance deteriorates substantially, achieving a total return of 9.4% versus 29.5% for a passive buy-and-hold, with a Sharpe Ratio of 0.39. performance
    Source sentence
    However, out-of-sample performance deteriorates substantially: the strategy achieves a total return of only 9.4% versus 29.5% for a passive buy-and-hold, with a Sharpe Ratio of 0.39.
  • In-sample replication closely matches the original results, confirming reproducibility with a Sharpe Ratio of 1.34 over 2015-2024. performance
    Source sentence
    Our in-sample replication closely matches the original results, confirming the reproducibility of the strategy (Sharpe Ratio 1.34 over 2015-2024).
  • The decline in risk-adjusted returns is statistically significant. statistical
    Source sentence
    The decline in risk-adjusted returns is statistically significant.
  • The original intraday momentum strategy achieves an annualized return of 19.6% and a Sharpe Ratio of 1.33 over 2007-2024. performance
    Source sentence
    Zarattini, Aziz, and Barbon (2025) present an intraday momentum strategy for SPY that achieves an annualized return of 19.6% and a Sharpe Ratio of 1.33 over the period 2007-2024.

Checked by others

Supported by

  • Beat the Market An Effective Intraday Momentum Strategy for S&P500 ETF (SPY) (2024)
    On the question: What are the annualized return and Sharpe ratio of the intraday momentum strategy for SPY from 2007 to 2024?
    Compare the findings

    This paper: The original intraday momentum strategy achieves an annualized return of 19.6% and a Sharpe Ratio of 1.33 over 2007-2024.

    That paper: From 2007 to early 2024 the intraday momentum portfolio achieved a total return of 1,985% (net of costs), an annualized return of 19.6%, and a Sharpe Ratio of 1.33.

    Both findings report a 19.6% annualized return and a Sharpe Ratio of 1.33 over 2007‑2024; Finding A additionally notes a total net‑of‑costs return of 1,985%.

  • "Beat the Market" Revisited An Independent Replication and Statistical Audit of an Intraday Momentum Strategy (2026)
    On the question: Does the intraday momentum strategy for SPY produce a high Sharpe ratio and large total return?
    Compare the findings

    This paper: In-sample replication closely matches the original results, confirming reproducibility with a Sharpe Ratio of 1.34 over 2015-2024.

    That paper: Independent replication reproduces almost exactly a total return of 1,989% and Sharpe Ratio of 1.317 on the original window.

    Both replications find a Sharpe around 1.34 (A: 1.34, B: 1.317) and B confirms the original total return of 1,989%.

  • Market Intraday Momentum (2014)
    On the question: Does the intraday momentum signal generate positive returns across multiple ETFs, including SPY?
    Compare the findings

    This paper: The original intraday momentum strategy achieves an annualized return of 19.6% and a Sharpe Ratio of 1.33 over 2007-2024.

    That paper: The intraday momentum pattern is also present for ten other most actively traded domestic and international ETFs.

    Both findings confirm intraday momentum’s effectiveness: B quantifies a 19.6% annualized return and 1.33 Sharpe for SPY (2007‑2024), while A notes the same pattern in ten other active ETFs.

Code

No repository by the authors found in the paper.

Extracted 2026-11-15 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.