Paper: arXiv 2402.08387
Authors: Martin Herdegen, David Hobson, Alex S. L. Tse
Abstract
The Merton investment-consumption problem is fundamental, both in the field of finance, and in stochastic control. An important extension of the problem adds transaction costs, which is highly relevant from a financial perspective but also challenging from a control perspective because the solution now involves singular control. A further significant extension takes us from additive utility to stochastic differential utility (SDU), which allows time preferences and risk preferences to be disentangled. In this paper, we study this extended version of the Merton problem with proportional transaction costs and Epstein-Zin SDU. We fully characterise all parameter combinations for which the problem is well posed (which may depend on the level of transaction costs) and provide a full verification argument that relies on no additional technical assumptions and uses primal methods only. The case with SDU requires new mathematical techniques as duality methods break down. Even in the special case of (additive) power utility, our arguments are significantly simpler, more elegant and more far-reaching than the ones in the extant literature. This means that we can easily analyse aspects of the problem which previously have been very challenging, including comparative statics, boundary cases which heretofore have required separate treatment and the situation beyond the small transaction cost regime. A key and novel idea is to parametrise consumption and the value function in terms of the shadow fraction of wealth, which may be of much wider applicability.
Complexity vs Empirical Score
- Math Complexity: 9.5/10
- Empirical Rigor: 2.0/10
- Quadrant: Lab Rats — high math complexity, limited empirical testing
Why this score: The paper is highly theoretical, focusing on stochastic control, singular control, and the derivation of a full verification argument using primal methods for Epstein-Zin SDU, which requires advanced mathematics (stochastic differential equations, ODEs, free-boundary problems). It lacks empirical components such as backtests, datasets, or statistical metrics, relying instead on theoretical analysis without implementation details for real-world data.
Research Flowchart
flowchart TD
A["Research Goal<br>Extend Merton Problem<br>with Transaction Costs &<br>Recursive Preferences"] --> B["Model Setup<br>Epstein-Zin SDU &<br>Proportional Transaction Costs"]
B --> C["Novel Methodology<br>Shadow Fraction of Wealth<br>Parametrization &<br>Primal Verification Argument"]
C --> D{"Key Mathematical Process<br>Solve Characteristic ODEs<br>& Verify Value Function"}
D --> E["Computational Analysis<br>Numerical Solution of<br>Boundary Conditions &<br>Comparative Statics"]
E --> F["Key Findings & Outcomes<br>1. Complete Parameter Characterization<br>2. Unified Treatment of Boundary Cases<br>3. Analytical Insights beyond Small Costs"]
Evidence Card
What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card
Proposes
The paper proposes a complete solution of the infinite‑horizon consumption‑investment problem with proportional transaction costs and Epstein‑Zin stochastic differential utility, including full well‑posedness characterisation and the introduction of the shadow fraction of wealth as a key variable.
Source sentence
In this paper, we study this extended version of the Merton problem with proportional transaction costs and Epstein-Zin SDU. Our main contributions are as follows: (a) First, we give a complete solution of the consumption-investment problem in the case of EZ-SDU which is valid for all levels of transaction costs.
Assumes 4
- θ > 0 (Standing Assumption 1) model
Source sentence
Throughout the paper, we make the following standing assumption 5 Standing Assumption 1. We assume θ ∈(0, ∞).
- λ ≠ 0, i.e., market price of risk is non‑zero (Standing Assumption 2) market
Source sentence
Standing Assumption 2. We assume λ̸ = 0. Note that Standing Assumption 2 implies in particular that the Merton ratio qM = λ σR is non-zero.
- Black–Scholes–Merton financial market with infinite horizon market
Source sentence
9 Concluding remarks In this paper we studied the optimal investment-consumption problem over the infinite horizon in a Black–Scholes–Merton financial market.
- Proportional transaction costs on buying and selling, possibly different execution
Source sentence
(b) Unlike most other authors we allow for different transaction costs on buying and selling; often the literature assumes that these costs are the same, or that the transaction cost on selling is zero. Whilst there is a straightforward transformation between the various parameterisations of transaction costs, covering the general case facilitates an easy comparison to the individual cases.
Data
No dataset named in the text.
Costs
Not applicable
Finds 5
- A complete solution for the EZ‑SDU consumption‑investment problem is obtained for all levels of transaction costs, together with exact conditions for well‑posedness. theoretical
Source sentence
Our main contributions are as follows: (a) First, we give a complete solution of the consumption-investment problem in the case of EZ-SDU which is valid for all levels of transaction costs. This includes giving exact conditions for when the problem is well-posed.
- The introduction of the shadow fraction of wealth as the primary variable simplifies the problem to a one‑dimensional free‑boundary ODE. theoretical
Source sentence
(b) Second, we introduce a new key variable, namely the shadow fraction of wealth. If we make this the underlying variable (in preference, say, to the shadow price) then all other quantities can be expressed in a simple fashion in terms of this single variable.
- The boundaries of the no‑transaction region are determined by the start and end points of a family of ODE solutions. theoretical
Source sentence
The start and end point of this solution determine the boundaries of the no-transaction region. Other important quantities, such as the shadow price of the risky asset and the optimal consumption are given by the solutions of a further first order ODE (this time with fixed start and end points).
- If the Merton line lies in the first quadrant it is always inside the no‑transaction region; otherwise it may lie outside, making it a poor approximation. theoretical
Source sentence
4 (c) We show that if the Merton line lies in the first quadrant (i.e. in the case of zero transaction costs the optimal portfolio involves a long position in both the risky asset and the risk-less asset) then it is always inside the no-transaction region; however if the Merton line is not in the first quadrant then it can lie outside the no transaction wedge (and thus becomes a very poor approximation of a reasonable
- Higher‑order asymptotic expansions for the value function and related quantities are derived for the small transaction‑cost regime. theoretical
Source sentence
(e) We give the asymptotic expansion for the value function and other quantities in the small transaction cost regime to a higher order than has been given elsewhere.
Checked by others
Supported by
- Comparative Statics of Trading Boundary in Finite Horizon Portfolio Selection with Proportional Transaction Costs
Compare the findings
This paper: If the Merton line lies in the first quadrant it is always inside the no‑transaction region; otherwise it may lie outside, making it a poor approximation.
That paper: If the Merton line xM is non‑negative, it lies inside the no‑trading region: xs(t;λ,µ) ≤ xM ≤ xb(t;λ,µ).
Code
No repository by the authors found in the paper.
Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.
Cited References (45)
- Optimal consumption and portfolio selection with stochastic differential utility (1999)
- Stochastic differential utility (1992)
- PDE solutions of stochastic differential utility (1992)
- E pstein- Z in stochastic differential utility: Existence, uniqueness, concavity, and utility gradients (2016)
- Introduction to metric and topological spaces (1975)
- Recursive methods in economic dynamics (1989)
- The equity premium: A puzzle (1985)
- Risks for the long run: A potential resolution of asset pricing puzzles (2004)
and 37 more
- Substitution, Risk Aversion, and the Temporal Behavior of Consumption and Asset Returns: A Theoretical Framework (1989)
- Consumption–investment optimization with E pstein– Z in utility in incomplete markets (2017)
- Convex duality for E pstein– Z in stochastic differential utility (2018)
- Risk aversion, intertemporal elasticity of substitution and correlation aversion (2005)
- Optimal investment (2013)
- An elementary approach to the M erton problem (2021) — link
- Dynamic Consumption and Portfolio Choice with Stochastic Volatility in Incomplete Markets (2005)
- Efficient intertemporal allocations with recursive utility (2000)
- Consumption-based asset pricing (2003)
- Strategic asset allocation: portfolio choice for long-term investors (2002)
- Intertemporal substitution in consumption (1988)
- Consumption, income, and interest rates: Reinterpreting the time series evidence (1989)
- Consumption growth, the interest rate and aggregation (1993)
- The intertemporal elasticity of substitution: An exploration using a US panel of state data (1996)
- Asset pricing at the millennium (2000)
- The equity premium puzzle and the risk-free rate puzzle (1989)
- Controlled M arkov processes and viscosity solutions
- Continuous-time stochastic control and optimization with financial applications
- The infinite-horizon investment–consumption problem for E pstein– Z in stochastic differential utility. I : Foundations (2023)
- The infinite-horizon investment–consumption problem for E pstein– Z in stochastic differential utility. II : Existence, uniqueness and verification for $\vartheta\in(0, 1)$ (2023)
- Proper solutions for E pstein- Z in stochastic differential utility (2023)
- Optimal consumption and investment under transaction costs (2019)
- A multi-asset investment and consumption problem with transaction costs (2019)
- Dynamic economic decision problems under behavioural preferences and market imperfections (2016)
- Optimal investment and consumption with transaction costs (1994)
- Note on continuous additive functuionals of the 1-dimensional B rownian path (1963)
- Why is the effect of proportional transaction costs $O(\delta^ 2/3 )$? (2004)
- Asymptotic analysis for optimal investment and consumption with transaction costs (2004)
- Shadow prices and well-posedness in the problem of optimal investment and consumption with transaction costs (2013)
- Asymptotic analysis for M erton’s problem with transaction costs in power utility case (2014)
- Optimal consumption and investment with liquid and illiquid assets (2020)
- Asymptotics and duality for the D avis and N orman problem (2012)
- Portfolio selection with transaction costs (1990)
- Portfolio selection with transaction costs (1976)
- Lifetime portfolio selection under uncertainty: the continuous-time case (1969)
- Optimum consumption and portfolio rules in a continuous-time model (1971)
- Characterisation of optimal strategy for multi-asset investment and consumption with transaction costs (2013)
0 of 45 cited works are in the corpus; resolved via arXiv source bundles, Semantic Scholar and OpenAlex. Corpus-wide: 2596 linked papers.