Paper: arXiv 2410.23404
Authors: Matthew Willetts, Christian Harrington
Abstract
Automated Market Makers (AMMs) hold assets and are constantly being rebalanced by external arbitrageurs to match external market prices. Loss-versus-rebalancing (LVR) is a pivotal metric for measuring how an AMM pool performs for its liquidity providers (LPs) relative to an idealised benchmark where rebalancing is done not via the action of arbitrageurs but instead by trading with a perfect centralised exchange with no fees, spread or slippage. This renders it an imperfect tool for judging rebalancing efficiency between execution platforms. We introduce Rebalancing-versus-rebalancing (RVR), a higher-fidelity model that better captures the frictions present in centralised rebalancing. We perform a battery of experiments comparing managing a portfolio on AMMs vs this new and more realistic centralised exchange benchmark-RVR. We are also particularly interested in dynamic AMMs that run strategies beyond fixed weight allocations-Temporal Function Market Makers. This is particularly important for asset managers evaluating execution management systems. In this paper we simulate more than 1000 different strategies settings as well as testing hundreds of different variations in centralised exchange (CEX) fees, AMM fees & gas costs. We find that, under this modeling approach, AMM pools (even with no retail/noise traders) often offer superior execution and rebalancing efficiency compared to centralised rebalancing, for all but the lowest CEX fee levels. We also take a simple approach to model noise traders & find that even a small amount of noise volume increases modeled AMM performance such that CEX rebalancing finds it hard to compete. This indicates that decentralised AMM-based asset management can offer superior performance and execution management for asset managers looking to rebalance portfolios, offering an alternative use case for dynamic AMMs beyond core liquidity providing.
Complexity vs Empirical Score
- Math Complexity: 7.5/10
- Empirical Rigor: 8.0/10
- Quadrant: Holy Grail — high math complexity, high empirical rigor
Why this score: The paper presents a novel metric (RVR) with mathematical extensions for multi-asset portfolios and advanced AMM mechanics (TFMM), demonstrating high theoretical depth. It is grounded in extensive empirical simulation, testing over 1000 strategy settings and hundreds of parameter variations for CEX fees, AMM fees, and gas costs, making it highly backtest-ready and data/implementation-heavy.
Research Flowchart
flowchart TD
A["Research Goal:<br>Rebalancing Efficiency in AMMs vs CEX"] --> B["Methodology<br>Simulation of 1000+ Strategy Settings"]
B --> C["Data Inputs<br>CEX Fees, AMM Fees, Gas Costs"]
C --> D["Key Models<br>LVR vs RVR Benchmark"]
D --> E{"Computational Process<br>Compare AMM vs RVR Execution"}
E --> F["Key Finding 1<br>AMM superior for most fee levels"]
E --> G["Key Finding 2<br>Noise traders boost AMM performance"]
F --> H["Outcome<br>Decentralized Asset Management viable"]
G --> H
Evidence Card
What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card
Proposes
The paper proposes Rebalancing‑versus‑Rebalancing (RVR), a higher‑fidelity benchmark model that captures centralised rebalancing frictions.
Source sentence
We introduce Rebalancing-versus-rebalancing (RVR), a higher-fidelity model that better captures the frictions present in centralised rebalancing.
Assumes 5
- No slippage is assumed; the market provides infinite liquidity at bid and ask prices. market
Source sentence
We assume that the market provides infinite liquidity at the bid and ask prices, i.e. we maintain the assumption from LVR that there is no slippage.
- Commission fees on CEX trades are modeled as a simple proportional fee on the outgoing leg. model
Source sentence
A simple model for commission fees is to charge a fee amount on the outgoing leg of the trade from the CEX. We will parameterise the fees as τcex, (τcex = 1 −γcex).
- Arbitrage trades must generate profit exceeding a threshold USD amount to cover gas costs. execution
Source sentence
We require that the arbitrage trade has to produce a profit greater than a threshold USD amount, which we will vary in our analysis.
- Noise traders are modeled as a small amount of volume equal to arbitrage volume. model
Source sentence
We choose to be conservative and introduce a deliberately low amount of noise trade volume, just 1× arbitrage volume.
Show 1 more
- Arbitrage discovery period is set to 5 blocks (~1 minute) to avoid immediate arbitrage. execution
Source sentence
we apply a 5 block discovery period, which for ETH mainnet amounts to one minute.
Data
- Binance market data market-prices public
Source sentence
We run simulations of pools with these constituents using Binance market data from Jan 2021 to June 2024, 3 and a half years at minute-level resolution.
Costs
Modeled
Commission fees (τcex) and spread are modeled for CEX trades; gas costs are included as a profit threshold; AMM fees are also modeled.
Source sentence
A simple model for commission fees is to charge a fee amount on the outgoing leg of the trade from the CEX. We will parameterise the fees as τcex
Finds 4
- AMM pools (even without retail/noise traders) often provide superior execution and rebalancing efficiency compared to centralised rebalancing, except at the lowest CEX fee levels. performance
Source sentence
We find that, under this modeling approach, AMM pools (even with no retail/noise traders) often offer superior execution and rebalancing efficiency compared to centralised rebalancing, for all but the lowest CEX fee levels.
- Introducing a small amount of noise trading further improves AMM performance, making CEX rebalancing hard to compete. performance
Source sentence
We also take a simple approach to model noise traders & find that even a small amount of noise volume increases modeled AMM performance such that CEX rebalancing finds it hard to compete.
- RVR increases for low gas costs and high CEX fees; higher AMM pool fees also tend to increase performance. performance
Source sentence
As expected, RVR increases for low gas costs and high CEX fees. Further, increasing pool fees tends to increase performance.
- Dynamic AMMs can offer superior execution efficiency for all but very high monthly volume CEX fee bands (<2 bps). performance
Source sentence
dynamic AMMs can offer superior execution efficiency for all but ¿$100m monthly volume CEX fee bands that offer less that 2bps fees.
Checked by others
No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 24 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.
1 paper in the archive : Arbitrage with bounded Liquidity
Code
No repository by the authors found in the paper.
Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.