Paper: arXiv 2310.14973
Authors: Ioannis Giagkiozis, Emilio Said
Abstract
Perpetual swaps are derivative contracts that allow traders to speculate on, or hedge, the price movements of cryptocurrencies. Unlike futures contracts, perpetual swaps have no settlement or expiration in the traditional sense. The funding rate acts as the mechanism that tethers the perpetual swap to its underlying with the help of arbitrageurs. Open interest, in the context of perpetual swaps and derivative contracts in general, refers to the total number of outstanding contracts at a given point in time. It is a critical metric in derivatives markets as it can provide insight into market activity, sentiment and overall liquidity. It also provides a way to estimate a lower bound on the collateral required for every cryptocurrency market on an exchange. This number, cumulated across all markets on the exchange in combination with proof of reserves, can be used to gauge whether the exchange in question operates with unsustainable levels of leverage, which could have solvency implications. We find that open interest in Bitcoin perpetual swaps is systematically misquoted by some of the largest derivatives exchanges; however, the degree varies, with some exchanges reporting open interest that is wholly implausible to others that seem to be delaying messages of forced trades, i.e., liquidations. We identify these incongruities by analyzing tick-by-tick data for two time periods in \(2023\) by connecting directly to seven of the most liquid cryptocurrency derivatives exchanges.
Complexity vs Empirical Score
- Math Complexity: 2.5/10
- Empirical Rigor: 8.0/10
- Quadrant: Street Traders — empirical and applied, lower math complexity
Why this score: The paper’s mathematical content is relatively accessible, primarily relying on basic inequalities and descriptive analysis rather than advanced derivations, yet it demonstrates high empirical rigor through the use of real-world tick-by-tick data from seven exchanges to identify systematic misreporting of open interest.
Research Flowchart
flowchart TD A["Research Goal<br>Verify Open Interest Accuracy<br>in Perpetual Swaps"] --> B["Data Collection<br>Tick-by-Tick Data from 7 Exchanges"] B --> C["Methodology<br>Direct Exchange Connectivity"] C --> D["Computation<br>Calculate True Volume &<br>Detect Liquidation Delays"] D --> E["Comparison<br>Identify Incongruities<br>vs Reported OI"] E --> F["Key Findings<br>1. Systematic OI Misquote<br>2. Unsustainable Leverage<br>3. Delayed Liquidation Data"]
Evidence Card
What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card
Proposes
The paper proposes a methodology to detect inconsistencies between reported trading volume and open interest by defining and measuring excess open‑interest total variation over fixed time intervals.
Source sentence
This can be described more formally with the following equation relating trading volume (transactions) and changes in open interest: ti+1 X k>ti Vk ≥|Oti+1 −Oti| (1) where Vk is the size of a trade at time tk ∈(ti, ti+1] and Ot is the open interest at time t. Eqn. To aid us in the detection of any such violations we additionally define the excess open interest total variation for the time period P as: XP T V ≜max (
Assumes 4
- Open interest can only change when contracts are created, settled, or reduced, and its absolute change cannot exceed the total trading volume in the same interval. market
Source sentence
By definition, open interest can only change when the number of outstanding contracts changes. (1) is summarizing what was described above, i.e., assuming that at time ti the open interest reported for a market is Oti then the absolute change in open interest |Oti+1 −Oti| cannot be larger than the total trading volume Pti+1 k>ti Vk in that time interval (ti, ti+1].
- The analysis uses fixed, constant‑length time intervals (δ) over the study periods. data
Source sentence
In this study we consider fixed time intervals δ over a given period P and study changes in open interest in relation to traded volume. The first period is January of 2023 and the second one is July to September of 2023 (inclusive).
- The reported open‑interest values are taken as correct when computing the lower bound on missing trading volume. model
Source sentence
Said differently, assuming open interest is correct, then XP T V is a lower bound on the missing trading volume given the observed changes in open interest.
- If the reported trading volume is assumed correct, excess total variation represents an overstatement of open‑interest changes. model
Source sentence
Alternatively, if the observed volume is assumed to be correct, then XP T V is the cumulative overstatement of the absolute open interest changes.
Data
- Tick‑by‑tick data from seven cryptocurrency derivatives exchanges order-book proprietary
Source sentence
We identify these incongruities by analyzing tick-by-tick data for two time periods in $2023$ by connecting directly to seven of the most liquid cryptocurrency derivatives exchanges. The first period is January of 2023 and the second one is July to September of 2023 (inclusive).
Costs
Not applicable
Finds 4
- Open interest on ByBit is systematically misquoted, showing excess total variation in both study periods, with the required missing trading volume exceeding $128 bn in period 2. negative figure from elsewhere in the paper
Source sentence
As can be seen for period 1, only ByBit exhibits excess total variation on this scale while the rest of the exchanges seem to be reporting open interest changes that can be explained by the reported trading volume. To put the observed excess on ByBit into perspective, if the open interest reported by it in period 2 is to believed for the BTC_USDT_P market, the lower bound on the trading volume required to produce
- OKX also exhibits non‑negligible excess total variation in period 2, indicating possible misreporting of open interest or volume. negative
Source sentence
In this period, both ByBit and OKX have non-negligible excess total variation. Furthermore, in this period BTC_USD_IP on Binance starts showing signs of misreporting.
- Other exchanges (Binance, Deribit, BitMEX, HTX, Kraken) generally report open‑interest changes that can be reconciled with reported trading volume. statistical
Source sentence
In period 2 however, the results are significantly different (see Table 3). The rest of the exchanges do not seem to have excess in this period either, at least when considering the period in its entirety.
- The probability and expected magnitude of excess total variation increase in the summer period (July‑September 2023) for several exchanges, especially ByBit and OKX. statistical figure from elsewhere in the paper
Source sentence
B19 ($526.5K) 11.3% B2 ($43.75K) We can also see that the expected excess total variation seems to be increasing in period 2 (P2) compared with period 1 (P1) on some exchanges. For example, on OKX for the BTC_USDT_P market E1D[XT V |XT V > 0] is ∼4 times higher for the 1D sub-period and ∼2 times higher when considering the 1H sub-period.
Checked by others
No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 15 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.
1 paper in the archive : Resolution-Aware Perpetual Futures on Binary Prediction …
Code
No repository by the authors found in the paper.
Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.