Paper: arXiv 2311.06476
Authors: Meng Wang, Tai-Ho Wang
Abstract
The problem of order execution is cast as a relative entropy-regularized robust optimal control problem in this article. The order execution agent’s goal is to maximize an objective functional associated with his profit-and-loss of trading and simultaneously minimize the execution risk and the market’s liquidity and uncertainty. We model the market’s liquidity and uncertainty by the principle of least relative entropy associated with the market volume. The problem of order execution is made into a relative entropy-regularized stochastic differential game. Standard argument of dynamic programming yields that the value function of the differential game satisfies a relative entropy-regularized Hamilton-Jacobi-Isaacs (rHJI) equation. Under the assumptions of linear-quadratic model with Gaussian prior, the rHJI equation reduces to a system of Riccati and linear differential equations. Further imposing constancy of the corresponding coefficients, the system of differential equations can be solved in closed form, resulting in analytical expressions for optimal strategy and trajectory as well as the posterior distribution of market volume. Numerical examples illustrating the optimal strategies and the comparisons with conventional trading strategies are conducted.
Complexity vs Empirical Score
- Math Complexity: 9.0/10
- Empirical Rigor: 3.0/10
- Quadrant: Lab Rats — high math complexity, limited empirical testing
Why this score: The paper is highly theoretical, featuring advanced stochastic calculus, a relative entropy-regularized Hamilton-Jacobi-Isaacs (rHJI) equation, and analytical solutions derived under linear-quadratic and Gaussian assumptions, resulting in high mathematical complexity. Empirical rigor is low as it only mentions numerical examples and comparisons with conventional strategies without presenting backtests, performance metrics, or implementation details.
Research Flowchart
flowchart TD A["Research Goal<br>Formulate robust optimal execution<br>using relative entropy regularization"] --> B["Methodology<br>Cast problem as stochastic differential game<br>with relative entropy penalty"] B --> C["Key Theoretical Derivation<br>Apply dynamic programming<br>Derive rHJI equation"] C --> D["Assumptions & Simplification<br>Linear-Quadratic model<br>Gaussian prior on market volume"] D --> E["Computational Process<br>Reduce rHJI to Riccati & linear DEs<br>Assume constant coefficients"] E --> F["Closed-Form Solution<br>Derive analytical expressions for:<br>Optimal strategy<br>Optimal trajectory<br>Posterior market volume"] F --> G["Key Outcomes<br>Optimal execution strategy found<br>Comparison with conventional strategies<br>Illustrated via numerical examples"]
Evidence Card
What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card
Proposes
The paper proposes a relative entropy‑regularized robust optimal control framework for order execution, including a market impact model that incorporates a permanent impact component from the averaged market trading rate.
Source sentence
The problem of order execution is cast as a relative entropy-regularized robust optimal control problem in this article. To take into account the liquidity and uncertainty risk from market trading rate when executing orders, we propose a price impact model as follows.
Assumes 6
- The prior distribution of the market trading rate is Gaussian with mean mt and precision st. model
Source sentence
The “prior” distribution π0 t is Gaussian with mean mt and precision st.
- The execution problem is linear‑quadratic with Gaussian prior, leading to Riccati and linear ODEs. model
Source sentence
Under the assumptions of linear-quadratic model with Gaussian prior, the rHJI equation reduces to a system of Riccati and linear differential equations. The following assumptions are imposed in order for the problem (3.2) to remain in a Gaussian and LQ structure though other choices are by all means possible. A1.
- The coefficient Raa satisfies st + βRaa > 0 for all t. model
Source sentence
Moreover, the coefficient Raa is further assumed satisfying st +βRaa > 0 for all t, where recall that st is the precision for the prior Gaussian distribution π0 t given in Assumption A1.
- The market liquidity and uncertainty risk are captured by the average market trading rate ⟨a⟩, factored out of the diffusion term. market
Source sentence
In this paper, we factor it out from the diffusion term so as to assess the market’s liquidity and uncertainty risk in order execution.
Show 2 more
- Coefficients are constant over time to obtain closed‑form solutions. model
Source sentence
Further imposing constancy of the corresponding coefficients, the system of differential equations can be solved in closed form, resulting in analytical expressions for optimal strategy and trajectory as well as the posterior distribution of market volume. Further assuming time independent coefficients, the solution to the aforementioned system of ODEs can be obtained in closed form, yield-ing closed form
- The efficient price is a martingale when buy and sell orders even out on average. market
Source sentence
Also if buy and sell orders even out in average, apart from the possible permanent impact incurred from the agent’s trading, the efficient price is a martingale.
Data
Synthetic data only.
Costs
Modeled
Price impact model includes permanent impact from market trading rate and stochastic components; costs are embedded in the objective via the R term.
Source sentence
To take into account the liquidity and uncertainty risk from market trading rate when executing orders, we propose a price impact model as follows. The efficient price St is assumed governed by the stochastic differential equation 4 M. WANG AND T.-H. WANG (SDE) dSt = γdXt + γM⟨a⟩tdt + σS t dW S t , (2.1) where ⟨·⟩t denotes averaging over πt, i.e., ⟨a⟩t = R aπt(a)da and σS t = qR ˜σ2(a)πt(a)da for some ˜σ.
Finds 3
- Under constant coefficients the rHJI equation reduces to closed‑form analytical expressions for the optimal trading strategy and posterior distribution of market volume. theoretical
Source sentence
Further imposing constancy of the corresponding coefficients, the system of differential equations can be solved in closed form, resulting in analytical expressions for optimal strategy and trajectory as well as the posterior distribution of market volume. Further assuming time independent coefficients, the solution to the aforementioned system of ODEs can be obtained in closed form, yield-ing closed form
- Numerical examples show that the optimal strategies outperform conventional TWAP (and VWAP) strategies, achieving lower variance and better performance. performance
Source sentence
Heuristics can be that, as mentioned earlier that TWAP implementation does not take dynamic of market environment into account, when exposed to extreme market conditions, it performs much more wildly compared to the optimal. Overall, the optimal strategies outperform, in some cases much better, and incurring lower variance as opposed to their TWAP counterparties as shown in the figures. 8.
- The proposed model yields a robust control solution that accounts for execution risk, market liquidity, and uncertainty risk. theoretical
Source sentence
The order execution agent's goal is to maximize an objective functional associated with his profit-and-loss of trading and simultaneously minimize the execution risk and the market's liquidity and uncertainty. In addition to execution risk, the model takes into account market’s liquidity and uncertainty risk.
Checked by others
No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 20 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.
Code
No repository by the authors found in the paper.
Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.