Paper: arXiv 2509.05760

Authors: Naftali Cohen

Abstract

The CAPM regression is typically interpreted as if the market return contemporaneously \emph{“causes”} individual returns, motivating beta-neutral portfolios and factor attribution. For realized equity returns, however, this interpretation is inconsistent: a same-period arrow \(R_{“m,t”} \to R_{“i,t”}\) conflicts with the fact that \(R_m\) is itself a value-weighted aggregate of its constituents, unless \(R_m\) is lagged or leave-one-out – the aggregator contradiction.’’ We formalize CAPM as a structural causal model and analyze the admissible three-node graphs linking an external driver \(Z\), the market \(R_m\), and an asset \(R_i\). The empirically plausible baseline is a \emph{“fork”}, \(Z \to \{"R_m, R_i\"}\), not \(R_m \to R_i\). In this setting, OLS beta reflects not a causal transmission, but an attenuated proxy for how well \(R_m\) captures the underlying driver \(Z\). Consequently, beta-neutral’’ portfolios can remain exposed to macro or sectoral shocks, and hedging on \(R_m\) can import index-specific noise. Using stylized models and large-cap U.S.\ equity data, we show that contemporaneous betas act like proxies rather than mechanisms; any genuine market-to-stock channel, if at all, appears only at a lag and with modest economic significance. The practical message is clear: CAPM should be read as associational. Risk management and attribution should shift from fixed factor menus to explicitly declared causal paths, with ``alpha’’ reserved for what remains invariant once those causal paths are explicitly blocked.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 8.0/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 7.0/10
  • Quadrant: Holy Grail — high math complexity, high empirical rigor

Why this score: The paper is mathematically dense, using advanced concepts from structural causal models (SCMs) and directed acyclic graphs (DAGs) to formalize the CAPM, demonstrating high math complexity. Empirically, it employs stylized models and large-cap U.S. equity data for validation, but it’s primarily a theoretical critique with limited backtesting or implementation-heavy analysis, so empirical rigor is strong but not extreme.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
  A["Research Goal:<br>Rethink CAPM Beta as Causal?"] --> B["Methodology:<br>Structural Causal Models SCM"]
  B --> C["Data:<br>Large-cap U.S. Equity"]
  C --> D["Computation:<br>Test Fork Graph vs. Causal Chains"]
  D --> E{"Key Finding:<br>Contemporaneous Beta = Proxy<br>Not Causal Transmission"}
  E --> F["Outcome:<br>CAPM is Associational"]
  F --> G["Implication:<br>Shift to Explicit Causal Paths"]

Evidence Card

What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card

Proposes

The paper casts the CAPM regression as a structural causal model using a minimal three‑node graph (Z, market return Rm, asset return Ri) to make explicit the assumptions and identify when beta reflects a causal effect versus an associational proxy.

Source sentence
First, we cast CAPM explicitly as a structural causal model using a minimal three-node core (𝑍, 𝑅𝑚, 𝑅𝑖), making visible the assumptions that are only implicit in standard treatments.

Assumes 6

  • The market return Rm is a value‑weighted aggregate of its constituent returns. market
    Source sentence
    Themarketreturnisavalue–weighted aggregate of its constituents; for an index such as the S&P 500, 𝑅𝑚,𝑡= ∑︁ 𝑗 𝑤𝑗,𝑡−1 𝑅𝑗,𝑡.
  • The external driver Z is exogenous and independent of the market return X (Rm) and the asset‑specific shock. model
    Source sentence
    Over a single sampling interval Δ (time indices suppressed), 4 introduce mutually independent exogenous shocks (𝑈𝑋,𝑈𝑌,𝑈𝑍) with E(𝑈·) = 0, and posit the SCM 𝑍:= 𝑓𝑍(𝑈𝑍), 𝑋:= 𝑓𝑋(𝑈𝑋), 𝑌:= 𝑓𝑌 �𝑋, 𝑍,𝑈𝑌 , (1) so that 𝑋⊥𝑍and 𝑋⊥𝑈𝑌(Fig. 1).
  • The causal graph must be acyclic (no feedback loops). model
    Source sentence
    Second, we formalize what we call the Aggregator Contradiction: because 𝑅𝑚,𝑡is defined as a value-weighted aggregate of its constituents, a same-period arrow 𝑅𝑚,𝑡→𝑅𝑖,𝑡cannot co-exist with acyclicity unless the constituent is excluded (leave-one-out) or the causal effect is zero.
  • Temporal priority holds: any genuine market‑to‑stock effect must respect time ordering (lagged or leave‑one‑out). model
    Source sentence
    Second, when a market→stock mechanism exists at all, it must respect time ordering (e.g., 𝑅𝑚,𝑡−1 →𝑅𝑖,𝑡) or a leave–one–out construction (𝑅−𝑖 𝑚,𝑡), and any such claim must be supported by lead–lag evidence rather than assumed.
Show 2 more
  • OLS beta is interpreted as a population projection slope under the specified DAG. statistical
    Source sentence
    OLS will always deliver a projection coefficient; whether that slope can be read as a causal path coefficient or merely as an associational proxy depends entirely on the underlying DAG and the time indices we feed it.
  • The sample consists of large‑cap U.S. equities and publicly available macro series. data
    Source sentence
    We use U.S. equities and macro data from public sources (ALFRED; Yahoo Finance), 2015–2025.

Data

  • U.S. large‑cap equity returns · public sources (Yahoo Finance, ALFRED) market-prices public
    2015–2025 · ≈100 large‑cap U.S. tickers, balanced across SPDR sectors
    Source sentence
    We use U.S. equities and macro data from public sources (ALFRED; Yahoo Finance), 2015–2025. Monte Carlo estimates (points) track the analytical values (dashed lines). comprises ∼100 large-cap U.S. tickers, balanced across the 11 SPDR sectors.
  • SPY log return (market proxy) · public (Yahoo Finance) market-prices public
    2015–2025 · S&P 500 index
    Source sentence
    The market proxy 𝑅𝑚is the SPY log return.
  • VIX daily change (ΔVIX) · public (CBOE) macro public
    2015–2025
    Source sentence
    As observable proxies for the driver 𝑍, we include the daily change in VIX (ΔVIX), the change in the 10y Treasury yield (ΔDGS10), and the DXY log return; we also add the corresponding SPDR sector ETF return as a coarse sector control.2 Consumer Price Index (CPI) release dates provide exogenous macro “shock” days.
  • 10‑year Treasury yield change (ΔDGS10) · public (FRED) macro public
    2015–2025
    Source sentence
    As observable proxies for the driver 𝑍, we include the daily change in VIX (ΔVIX), the change in the 10y Treasury yield (ΔDGS10), and the DXY log return; we also add the corresponding SPDR sector ETF return as a coarse sector control.2 Consumer Price Index (CPI) release dates provide exogenous macro “shock” days.
  • DXY log return · public (FRED) macro public
    2015–2025
    Source sentence
    As observable proxies for the driver 𝑍, we include the daily change in VIX (ΔVIX), the change in the 10y Treasury yield (ΔDGS10), and the DXY log return; we also add the corresponding SPDR sector ETF return as a coarse sector control.2 Consumer Price Index (CPI) release dates provide exogenous macro “shock” days.
  • CPI release dates (macro shock days) · public (ALFRED) macro public
    2015–2025
    Source sentence
    As observable proxies for the driver 𝑍, we include the daily change in VIX (ΔVIX), the change in the 10y Treasury yield (ΔDGS10), and the DXY log return; we also add the corresponding SPDR sector ETF return as a coarse sector control.2 Consumer Price Index (CPI) release dates provide exogenous macro “shock” days.

Recognised sources: Yahoo Finance

Costs

Not applicable The paper reports no trading or execution result.

Finds 5

  • OLS beta in a same‑period CAPM regression does not measure a causal market‑to‑stock effect but serves as an attenuated proxy for the shared driver Z. theoretical
    Source sentence
    In this setting, OLS beta reflects not a causal transmission, but an attenuated proxy for how well $R_m$ captures the underlying driver $Z$. Using stylized models and large-cap U.S.\ equity data, we show that contemporaneous betas act like proxies rather than mechanisms; any genuine market-to-stock channel, if at all, appears only at a lag and with modest economic significance.
  • Beta‑neutral portfolios remain exposed to macro or sectoral shocks, and hedging on the market index can introduce index‑specific noise. theoretical
    Source sentence
    Consequently, ``beta-neutral'' portfolios can remain exposed to macro or sectoral shocks, and hedging on $R_m$ can import index-specific noise.
  • Simulation shows that in a fork graph the estimated beta attenuates smoothly as the market’s noise level (σX) increases, while the residual’s loading on Z grows; in a chain graph beta recovers the true causal coefficient and hedging removes the driver. statistical
    Source sentence
    In the fork, 𝛽attenuates smoothly with 𝜎𝑋and the residual’s 𝑍-loading grows toward 𝑏as 𝜎𝑋rises. In the chain, 𝛽recovers 𝑐for all 𝜎𝑋and the hedge removes the driver completely.
  • Empirical checks on U.S. equity data reveal that contemporaneous CAPM betas behave like proxies: adding observable shocks (VIX, rates, USD, sector) collapses the market slope on CPI days, and beta‑hedged residuals still load on macro/sector shocks. other
    Source sentence
    Figure 4: Pillar 1—contemporaneous CAPM behaves like a proxy. This is inconsistent with a stable same-day 𝑅𝑚→𝑅𝑖mechanism and consistent with a fork.
  • Any genuine market‑to‑stock transmission, if present, appears only with a lag and at a much smaller economic magnitude. other
    Source sentence
    Any genuine market→stock actuation, if present, appears only at a lag and at much smaller scale. This is exactly the empirical signature implied by the minimal DAG where 𝑍 drives both 𝑅𝑚and 𝑅𝑖.

Checked by others

No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 18 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.

Code

No repository by the authors found in the paper.

Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.

Cited References (42)

  1. Causality: Models, Reasoning, and Inference (2009)
  2. Causal Inference in Statistics: A Primer (2016)
  3. The conditional CAPM does not explain asset-pricing anomalies (2006)
  4. Dynamic conditional beta (2016)
  5. Event studies in economics and finance (1997)
  6. The effect: An introduction to research design and causality (2021)
  7. Asset pricing: A tale of two days (2014)
  8. An intertemporal capital asset pricing model (1973)
and 34 more
  1. Betting against beta (2014)
  2. The conditional CAPM and the cross-section of expected returns (1996)
  3. Analyzing investments whose histories differ in length (1997)
  4. Elements of Causal Inference: Foundations and Learning Algorithms (2017)
  5. Causation, Prediction, and Search (2000)
  6. Causal Inference: What If (2020)
  7. The Statistical Implications of a System of Simultaneous Equations (1943)
  8. Capital Asset Prices: A Theory of Market Equilibrium under Conditions of Risk (1964)
  9. The Valuation of Risk Assets and the Selection of Risky Investments in Stock Portfolios and Capital Budgets (1965)
  10. Equilibrium in a Capital Asset Market (1966)
  11. Efficient Capital Markets: A Review of Theory and Empirical Work (1970)
  12. Risk, Return, and Equilibrium: Empirical Tests (1973)
  13. A Critique of the Asset Pricing Theory’s Tests Part I: On Past and Potential Testability of the Theory (1977)
  14. Statistical inference in dynamic economic models (1950)
  15. Macroeconomics and reality (1980)
  16. Investigating causal relations by econometric models and cross-spectral methods (1969)
  17. Repeated least squares applied to complete equation systems (1953)
  18. The estimation of economic relationships using instrumental variables (1958)
  19. Causal Inference: What If (2020)
  20. The Arbitrage Theory of Capital Asset Pricing (1976)
  21. Estimating Betas from Nonsynchronous Data (1977)
  22. The Cross-Section of Expected Stock Returns (1992)
  23. Common Risk Factors in the Returns on Stocks and Bonds (1993)
  24. A Five-Factor Asset Pricing Model (2015)
  25. Statistical methods for climate scientists (2022)
  26. On the Estimation of Beta-Pricing Models: Standard Errors and Tests (1992)
  27. Quantitative Equity Portfolio Management (2007)
  28. Quantitative Equity Portfolio Management (2006)
  29. The Elements of Quantitative Investing (2025)
  30. Quantitative Portfolio Management: The Art and Science of Statistical Arbitrage (2021)
  31. Investigating Causal Relations by Econometric Models and Cross-Spectral Methods (1969)
  32. Causal factor investing: can factor investing become scientific? (2023)
  33. Active equity management (2014)
  34. Advanced Portfolio Management: A Quant’s Guide for Fundamental Investors (2021)

0 of 42 cited works are in the corpus; resolved via arXiv source bundles, Semantic Scholar and OpenAlex. Corpus-wide: 2596 linked papers.