Paper: arXiv 2610.06504
Authors: Zhaojie Ren, Sheng Wang, Tak Kwong Wong, Sheung Chi Phillip Yam
Abstract
This article studies a retirement planning problem from a new perspective in which a retiree delegates an initial lump sum to a professional fund manager. The fund is managed dynamically to deliver lifelong benefits while satisfying a guarantee that, at all times, wealth remains above a prescribed solvency level and the benefit rate remains above a minimum level. We formulate this problem as a continuous-time stochastic control model, in which the controls are the benefit rate and the portfolio allocation, and the objective incorporates general utility functions over benefits, management fees, and terminal bequest. Conventional approaches such as standard viscosity solution and martingale methods are not immediately applicable here due to the simultaneous influence of (i) the control variable nature of the benefit rate; (ii) the guarantee constraints; and (iii) the running wealth-dependent utility. We develop a new approach that deals directly with the associated fully nonlinear Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman equation and establish the unique existence of a classical solution. One particular trick for resolving this equation is to apply an intricate transform that diverts the former to a semilinear auxiliary equation. A major contribution is to establish the existence of the solution to the auxiliary equation and characterize its precise growth, derivative, and boundary behavior. These results are crucial for establishing the verification theorems and deriving the optimal strategy. Besides, numerical experiments indicate that guarantee constraints induce more conservative policies, particularly at low wealth levels, while providing effective downside protection for both wealth and benefits. The associated well-being loss relative to the unconstrained framework remains small, suggesting that incorporating guarantees into retirement products is practically appealing.
Complexity vs Empirical Score
- Math Complexity: 9.0/10
- Empirical Rigor: 4.0/10
- Quadrant: Lab Rats — high math complexity, limited empirical testing
Why this score: The paper presents a highly complex mathematical framework for a novel retirement planning problem. While it includes numerical experiments, the empirical rigor is limited to these simulations rather than real-world backtesting or extensive data validation. The core contribution lies in its theoretical development.
Research Flowchart
flowchart TD
A["Research Goal: Optimize Retirement Planning with Guarantees"] --> B{"Methodology: Continuous-Time Stochastic Control Model"};
B --> C["Inputs: Initial Lump Sum, Utility Functions, Guarantee Levels"];
C --> D["Computational Process: Solve HJB Equation via Intricate Transform"];
D --> E["Key Findings: Unique Classical Solution, Optimal Strategies, Impact of Guarantees"];
Evidence Card
What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card
Proposes
The paper proposes a continuous‑time stochastic control model for retirement planning in which a retiree delegates an initial lump sum to a professional fund manager, with controls on benefit rate and portfolio allocation and guarantees on wealth and benefit levels.
Source sentence
This article studies a retirement planning problem from a new perspective in which a retiree delegates an initial lump sum to a professional fund manager. The fund is managed dynamically to deliver lifelong benefits while satisfying a guarantee that, at all times, wealth remains above a prescribed solvency level and the benefit rate remains above a minimum level.
Assumes 6
- The net interest rate for the retiree within the fund is positive (r > 0). market
Source sentence
From a mathematical perspective, however, the analysis in this article only requires r > 0 ; the comparison with r0 plays no role in the theoretical results.
- The discount rate ρ is arbitrary and may equal r0, r, or differ. model
Source sentence
The parameter ρ > 0 is the discount rate, used to evaluate the present value of future benefits and management fees.
- Utility function U1 is twice continuously differentiable on [b0,∞), strictly increasing, strictly concave, with U1'(∞)=0 and growth bound U1(b) ≤ C1,0 b^γ1 for γ1∈(0,1). other
Source sentence
(i) Assume that U1 ∈C2([b0, ∞)) . Moreover, U′ 1(b) > 0 and U′′ 1 (b) < 0 for all b ∈[b0, ∞) , and U ′ 1(∞) = 0 .
- Utility function U2 is continuously differentiable on [x,∞), positive, with growth bound U2(x) ≤ C2,0 x^γ2 for γ2∈(0,1). other
Source sentence
(ii) Assume that U2 ∈C1([x, ∞)) . Moreover, there exist constants C2,0 > 0 and γ2 ∈(0, 1) such that 0 < U2(x) ≤C2,0xγ2 for all x ∈[x, ∞).
Show 2 more
- Minimum benefit guarantee b(t) ≥ b0 with b0 ≤ r x0 to ensure feasibility. model
Source sentence
The constraints in (1.3) impose minimum guarantees on the fund’s operation: • The condition b(t) ≥b0, with b0 ∈(0, rx0] , ensures that beneficiaries receive at least a guaranteed minimum benefit rate at all times. We require b0 ≤rx0 , since maintaining a constant minimum 9 benefit level must be financially feasible given the initial wealth x0 and the risk-free return r .
- The running management fee rate κ1 is less than the fund’s gross return r1 (κ1 < r1). market
Source sentence
Meanwhile, the fund manager charges a running management fee at rate κ1 ( κ1 < r1 ), reducing the net return experienced by the retiree; see [31], [44], [39] and [6].
Data
- Average interest rates observed in July 2026 (risk‑free r0 and fund return r1) other public
Source sentence
For instance, based on the average rates observed in July 2026, the short risk-free rate in the U.S. market is r0 = 3.7% , while the fund may achieve a higher return r1 = 5.3% by investing in long-term illiquid bonds that generate a liquidity premium; see [63] and [9]. With a management fee of κ1 = 0.4% , as documented in [48], the resulting net rate is r := r1 −κ1 = 4.9% , which exceeds r0 .
- PGIM Q1 2026 ten‑year capital‑market assumptions macro public
Source sentence
Rounding the figures reported in PGIM’s Q1 2026 ten-year capital-market assumptions, we set the expected return and volatility to µ = 0.08 (8%) and σ = 0.2 (20%) , respectively [54, p. 12].
- Investment Company Institute expense‑ratio data for management fee other public
Source sentence
With a management fee of κ1 = 0.4% , as documented in [48], the resulting net rate is r := r1 −κ1 = 4.9% , which exceeds r0 . The running management fee is set to κ1 = 0.004 (0.4%) , based on the expense-ratio data reported by the Investment Company Institute [48].
Costs
Not applicable
Finds 3
- Numerical experiments show that guarantee constraints lead to more conservative policies, especially at low wealth levels, while providing effective downside protection for wealth and benefits. theoretical
Source sentence
Besides, numerical experiments indicate that guarantee constraints induce more conservative policies, particularly at low wealth levels, while providing effective downside protection for both wealth and benefits.
- The associated well‑being loss relative to the unconstrained framework remains small, indicating practical appeal of guarantees. theoretical
Source sentence
The associated well-being loss relative to the unconstrained framework remains small, suggesting that incorporating guarantees into retirement products is practically appealing.
- The net interest rate within the fund (4.9%) exceeds the risk‑free rate (3.7%), confirming the fund’s ability to generate higher returns despite fees. performance figure from elsewhere in the paper
Source sentence
With a management fee of κ1 = 0.4% , as documented in [48], the resulting net rate is r := r1 −κ1 = 4.9% , which exceeds r0 . Consequently, the retiree’s net interest rate within the fund is r = r1 −κ1 = 0.049 (4.9%) , which remains above r0 .
Checked by others
No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 12 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.
Code
No repository by the authors found in the paper.
Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.
Cited References (66)
- Eliciting Risk and Time Preferences (2008)
- Estimating Risk Preferences in the Field (2018)
- An elementary approach to the M erton problem (2021)
- Pension funds with a minimum guarantee: A stochastic control approach (2011)
- Continuous-time stochastic control and optimization with financial applications (2009)
- Stochastic differential equations and diffusion processes (1981)
- Continuous Martingales and Brownian Motion (1999)
- Continuous-Time Finance (1990)
and 58 more
- Unemployment risks and optimal retirement in an incomplete market (2016)
- Inter-temporal mutual-fund management (2022)
- Labor income, borrowing constraints, and equilibrium asset prices (1993)
- Optimization of consumption with labor income (1998)
- Pensions at a Glance 2023: OECD and G20 Indicators (2023) — link
- Pensions at a Glance 2025: OECD and G20 Indicators (2025) — link
- A history of British actuarial thought (2017)
- Lifetime Consumption and Investment: Retirement and Constrained Borrowing (2010) — link
- Duality for Optimal Consumption with Randomly Terminating Income (2021) — link
- An Analytical Study of Participating Policies with Minimum Rate Guarantee and Surrender Option (2022) — link
- Continuous-Time Optimal Reporting with Full Insurance under the Mean–Variance Criterion (2025) — link
- Optimal Loss Reporting in Continuous Time with Full Insurance (2025) — link
- Incentive fees and mutual funds (2003)
- Mutual fund fees around the world (2009)
- Pricing the commonality across alternative measures of liquidity (2008)
- How do you capture liquidity? A review of the literature on low-frequency stock liquidity (2020)
- Ordinary differential equations and dynamical systems (2012)
- A stochastic control problem with delay arising in a pension fund model (2011)
- Optimal control with state-space constraint. II (1986)
- A class of stochastic optimal control problems with state constraint (2002)
- Uncertain lifetime, life insurance, and the theory of the consumer (1965)
- Bequest motives and the annuity puzzle (2012)
- Merging asset allocation and longevity insurance: An optimal perspective on payout annuities (2003)
- Revisiting the risk-neutral approach to optimal policyholder behavior: A study of withdrawal guarantees in variable annuities (2016)
- Optimal reinsurance design under solvency constraints (2024)
- Pension benefit security: A comparison of solvency requirements, a pension guarantee fund, and sponsor support (2013)
- HJB equations for the optimal control of differential equations with delays and state constraints, I : Regularity of viscosity solutions (2010)
- HJB equations for the optimal control of differential equations with delays and state constraints, II : Verification and optimal feedbacks (2011)
- Income drawdown option with minimum guarantee (2014)
- An optimal control problem with state constraints in a spatio-temporal economic growth model on networks (2024)
- Transaction costs, trading volume, and the liquidity premium (2014)
- Hedge and mutual funds’ fees and the separation of private investments (2015)
- Optimal lifetime consumption and investment under a drawdown constraint (2008)
- Optimal portfolio management with American capital guarantee (2005)
- Consumption-investment models with constraints (1994)
- Cone-constrained continuous-time Markowitz problems (2013)
- Convex duality in mean-variance hedging under convex trading constraints (2012)
- Controlled Markov processes and viscosity solutions (2006)
- A risk extended version of M erton’s optimal consumption and portfolio selection (2022)
- 2025 Investment Company Fact Book (2025)
- Dusenberry’s ratcheting of consumption: Optimal dynamic consumption and investment given intolerance for any decline in standard of living (1995)
- Habit formation: A resolution of the equity premium puzzle (1990)
- Consumption and portfolio choice under loss aversion and endogenous updating of the reference level (2020)
- Modern actuarial theory and practice (2020)
- Vanguard Target Retirement Income Fund (2026)
- Vanguard Target Retirement Income Fund: Summary Prospectus (2026)
- S chwab M onthly I ncome F unds (2026)
- A merican F unds R etirement I ncome P ortfolio (2026)
- Utility maximization with current utility on the wealth: Regularity of solutions to the HJB equation (2015)
- Daily Treasury Bill Rates: July 2026 (2026)
- Nominal Yield Curve Data (2026)
- Trends in the Expenses and Fees of Funds, 2025 (2026)
- Actuarial Mathematics for Life Contingent Risks (2013)
- United States Life Tables, 2024 (2026) — link
- Consumption over the Life Cycle (2002)
- Estimating Discount Functions with Consumption Choices over the Lifecycle (2026)
- Optimal stochastic control, stochastic target problems, and backward SDE (2012)
- Capital Market Assumptions 2026 (2026)
0 of 66 cited works are in the corpus; resolved via arXiv source bundles, Semantic Scholar and OpenAlex. Corpus-wide: 2601 linked papers.