Paper: arXiv 2403.17095

Authors: David Ardia, Clément Aymard, Tolga Cenesizoglu

Abstract

We reassess Boehmer et al. (2021, BJZZ)’s seminal work on the predictive power of retail order imbalance (ROI) for future stock returns. First, we replicate their 2010-2015 analysis in the more recent 2016-2021 period. We find that the ROI’s predictive power weakens significantly. Specifically, past ROI can no longer predict weekly returns on large-cap stocks, and the long-short strategy based on past ROI is no longer profitable. Second, we analyze the effect of using the alternative quote midpoint (QMP) method to identify and sign retail trades on their main conclusions. While the results based on the QMP method align with BJZZ’s findings in 2010-2015, the two methods provide different conclusions in 2016-2021. Our study shows that BJZZ’s original findings are sensitive to the sample period and the approach to identify ROIs.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 4.5/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 8.0/10
  • Quadrant: Street Traders — empirical and applied, lower math complexity

Why this score: The paper focuses on empirical replication and robustness checks using real financial data, with moderate statistical analysis but no advanced mathematical derivations. It is highly data-driven with clear backtesting elements (e.g., long-short strategy profitability assessment), making it practical for implementation.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
  A["Research Goal<br>Replicate & Extend Boehmer et al.<br>2021: ROI Predictive Power"] --> B
  
  subgraph B ["Methodology & Data"]
      direction LR
      B1["Dataset 1: 2010-2015<br>(Original Period)"] --> B2["Dataset 2: 2016-2021<br>(Recent Period)"]
      B1 --> B3["Method A: Original Method"]
      B1 --> B4["Method B: QMP Method"]
  end

  B --> C{"Computational Analysis"}

  C --> D["Regression Analysis<br>ROI vs. Future Returns"]
  C --> E["Backtesting Strategy<br>Long-Short on ROI quintiles"]

  D --> F{"Outcomes"}
  E --> F

  F --> G["2010-2015: Significant<br>Predictive Power"]
  F --> H["2016-2021: Weakens Significantly<br>Large Caps: Insignificant<br>Profitability: Neutralized"]

Evidence Card

What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card

Proposes

The paper reassesses Boehmer et al. (2021) on the predictive power of retail order imbalance and examines an alternative quote‑midpoint (QMP) method.

Source sentence
We reassess Boehmer et al. (2021, BJZZ)'s seminal work on the predictive power of retail order imbalance (ROI) for future stock returns.

Assumes 5

  • Analyses focus on weekly horizons to reduce microstructure noise. statistical
    Source sentence
    focus on weekly horizons to reduce the impact of microstructure noise on [their] results
  • Standard errors are computed using Newey‑West with six (or five) lags. statistical
    Source sentence
    Newey and West (1987) standard errors with six lags
  • Trade frictions and transaction costs are ignored in the predictive analysis. execution
    Source sentence
    We ignore trade frictions and transaction costs here, and thus, the results do not have implications for whether outsiders can profit from these signals
  • Order imbalances are measured based on share volume (Mroibvol). data
    Source sentence
    all discussions pertain to order imbalances based on share volume (Mroibvol for Mroib)
Show 1 more
  • Retail order imbalance measures are used only as a signal, not to assess retail investors' own profits. other
    Source sentence
    Notice that this exercise uses marketable retail order imbalance measures merely as a signal to predict future stock returns, and thus, it provides no information on whether retail investors with marketable orders profit from their own trades

Data

  • NYSE Trade and Quote (TAQ) data · NYSE order-book commercial
    2010-2015 and 2016-2021 · large‑cap stocks (and other market‑cap groups)
    Source sentence
    introducing a novel algorithm for identifying retail trades within the NYSE Trade and Quote (TA…
  • CRSP closing price returns · CRSP market-prices commercial
    2010-2015 and 2016-2021 · U.S. equities
    Source sentence
    Using order imbalances based on the number of trades (Mroibtrd) and/or CRSP closing price returns does not fundamentally change the interpretation

Costs

Not modeled A trading or execution result is reported without costs.

Source sentence
We ignore trade frictions and transaction costs here, and thus, the results do not have implications for whether outsiders can profit from these signals

Finds 5

  • The predictive power of ROI weakens significantly in 2016‑2021; past ROI no longer predicts weekly returns on large‑cap stocks and the long‑short strategy is no longer profitable. negative
    Source sentence
    We find that the ROI's predictive power weakens significantly. Specifically, past ROI can no longer predict weekly returns on large-cap stocks, and the long-short strategy based on past ROI is no longer profitable.
  • The coefficient and t‑stat of the first lag (Mroibvol) drop about 50% and 20% respectively in the recent period. statistical
    Source sentence
    the coefficient estimate and the t-stat of the first lag, Mroibvol(i, w −1), are 50% (0.0983 vs. 0.1982) and 20% (57.30 vs. 71.81) lower in 2016-2021 period
  • Predictive regression coefficient for future returns falls 34% and its t‑stat 48% in 2016‑2021. statistical
    Source sentence
    the coefficient estimate of Mroibvol(i, w −1) and its t-stat are 34% (0.0006 vs. 0.0009) and 48% (7.95 vs. 15.14) lower
  • Alphas for one‑ and two‑week horizons are more than 65% lower in the recent period; many become statistically insignificant. performance
    Source sentence
    for one- and two-week horizons, 2016-2021 alphas are more than 65% lower (0.143% vs. 0.437% and 0.177% vs. 0.613%)
  • The QMP method yields similar conclusions for 2010‑2015 but shows stronger predictability for most subgroups in 2016‑2021 compared to the original method. other
    Source sentence
    both lead to similar conclusions and economic magnitudes in both periods (Panel (b) vs. (a) and Panel (d) vs. (c))—with some notable differences in the recent period such as significantly stronger one-week small…

Checked by others

No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 22 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.

Code

No repository by the authors found in the paper.

Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.