Paper: arXiv 2311.07738

Authors: Ethan Ratliff-Crain, Colin M. Van Oort, James Bagrow, Matthew T. K. Koehler, Brian F. Tivnan

Abstract

In 2001, Rama Cont introduced a now-widely used set of ‘stylized facts’ to synthesize empirical studies of financial price changes (returns), resulting in 11 statistical properties common to a large set of assets and markets. These properties are viewed as constraints a model should be able to reproduce in order to accurately represent returns in a market. It has not been established whether the characteristics Cont noted in 2001 still hold for modern markets following significant regulatory shifts and technological advances. It is also not clear whether a given time series of financial returns for an asset will express all 11 stylized facts. We test both of these propositions by attempting to replicate each of Cont’s 11 stylized facts for intraday returns of the individual stocks in the Dow 30, using the same authoritative data as that used by the U.S. regulator from October 2018 - March 2019. We find conclusive evidence for eight of Cont’s original facts and no support for the remaining three. Our study represents the first test of Cont’s 11 stylized facts against a consistent set of stocks, therefore providing insight into how these stylized facts should be viewed in the context of modern stock markets.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 3.0/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 7.0/10
  • Quadrant: Street Traders — empirical and applied, lower math complexity

Why this score: The paper primarily involves empirical statistical analysis (distribution checks, autocorrelation, volatility clustering) using real financial data, rather than developing novel mathematical models or complex proofs. The empirical rigor is high due to the use of authoritative regulatory data (Oct 2018–Mar 2019), a specific asset universe (Dow 30), and the replication of established statistical tests.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
  Start["Research Goal: Do Cont's<br>Stylized Facts hold for<br>modern stock markets?"] --> Input["Data: Intraday returns<br>Dow 30 stocks (Oct 2018 - Mar 2019)"]
  
  Input --> Process["Computational Process:<br>Replicate 11 Stylized Facts<br>Statistical Analysis"]
  
  Process --> Outcomes{"Key Findings"}
  
  Outcomes --> Support["8 Facts Supported<br>e.g., Fat tails,<br>Volatility clustering"]
  Outcomes --> Fail["3 Facts Not Supported<br>e.g., Absence of<br>autocorrelations"]
  
  Support --> Conclusion["Conclusion: Most stylized<br>facts persist in modern markets,<br>but some require re-evaluation"]
  Fail --> Conclusion

Evidence Card

What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card

Proposes

The paper tests whether intraday returns of the Dow 30 stocks from October 2018 to March 2019 replicate each of Cont’s 11 stylized facts.

Source sentence
We test both of these propositions by attempting to replicate each of Cont's 11 stylized facts for intraday returns of the individual stocks in the Dow 30, using the same authoritative data as that used by the U.S. regulator from October 2018 - March 2019.

Assumes 4

  • The SIP consolidated trade data accurately reflect market activity despite latency and clock‑synchronization limitations. data
    Source sentence
    Due to the latency and limitations on clock synchronization mentioned in Section 2.2, the exact order of trades in the data is not definitive6, but our time series provides the perspective of an observer located in Carteret, NJ, viewing the events of the market as reported by the SIPs.
  • Return time series can be constructed using either clock‑time or event‑time views of trades. other
    Source sentence
    We consider two different views of time when constructing our return time series: clock-time based on timestamp and event time, with trades as the event. In either view, in order to aggregate to any level that is more granular than a single trade per unit of time, we define P (t, ∆t) as the price of the last trade to occur in that time period.
  • Log‑returns are used as the measure of returns. statistical
    Source sentence
    Any reference to returns going forward should be interpreted as meaning log-returns.
  • Periods with no trades have zero return and price unchanged from the previous trade. statistical
    Source sentence
    In clock-time, time points with no trades will be assumed to have the same price as the previous time point that had at least one trade, as no new price information has been received since then. Note that time points with no trades will have a return of 0.

Data

  • Dow 30 intraday trade data (SIP feeds) · Thesys Group Inc. market-prices proprietary
    18 Oct 2018 – 19 Mar 2019 · Dow Jones Industrial Average constituents (30 stocks)
    Source sentence
    We specifically looked at the individual stocks included in the Dow Jones Industrial Average as-of October 20185 [24]. Our data contains all trades reported for these symbols over the date range.

Costs

Not applicable The paper reports no trading or execution result.

Finds 4

  • Eight of Cont’s 11 stylized facts are supported by the intraday Dow 30 data. statistical figure from elsewhere in the paper
    Source sentence
    We find conclusive evidence for eight of Cont's original facts and no support for the remaining three. As summarized Table 1, we find clear support for eight of the stylized facts and no support for the other three from the measures tested.
  • The remaining three stylized facts receive no empirical support in this sample. negative
    Source sentence
    We find conclusive evidence for eight of Cont's original facts and no support for the remaining three. As summarized Table 1, we find clear support for eight of the stylized facts and no support for the other three from the measures tested.
  • Aggregational Gaussianity (Fact #4) is more clearly expressed in event‑time than in clock‑time. statistical
    Source sentence
    We found positive correlation between volume and volatility (Fact #10) in clock-time but not in general for the trade-level returns. Meanwhile, aggregational Gaussianity (Fact #4) was more clearly expressed in event-time than clock-time, although the property is overall expressed in both clocks.
  • Positive correlation between volume and volatility (Fact #10) appears in clock‑time but not consistently for trade‑level returns. statistical
    Source sentence
    We found positive correlation between volume and volatility (Fact #10) in clock-time but not in general for the trade-level returns.

Checked by others

Qualified by

  • International Financial Markets Through 150 Years: Evaluating Stylized Facts (2025)
    On the question: Which stylized facts of financial markets receive empirical support?
    Compare the findings

    This paper: The remaining three stylized facts receive no empirical support in this sample.

    That paper: Empirical support is found for seven of the eleven stylized facts across the examined markets.

    A finds 0 support for the three remaining facts; B finds support for 7 of 11 facts across the examined markets.

Cited by 2 papers in the archive (1 by independent authors)

Code

No repository by the authors found in the paper.

Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.

Cited References (163)

  1. Econophysics review: I . Empirical facts (2011) — link
  2. Stylized Facts (2008) — link
  3. The Estimation of Leverage Effect With High - Frequency Data (2014) — link
  4. From the bird’s eye to the microscope: A survey of new stylized facts of the intra-daily foreign exchange markets (1997) — link
  5. Symmetry alteration of ensemble return distribution in crash and rally days of financial markets (2000) — link
  6. The leverage effect puzzle: Disentangling sources of bias at high frequency (2013) — link
  7. Heterogeneity and feedback in an agent-based market model (2005) — link
  8. Toward an understanding of market resilience: market liquidity and heterogeneity in the investor decision cycle (2016) — link
and 155 more
  1. An agent-based model for financial vulnerability (2018) — link
  2. Aligning simulation models: A case study and results (1996) — link
  3. Three distinct kinds of empirically-relevant agent-based models (2005)
  4. Effects of Interaction Topology and Activation Regime in Several Multi - Agent Systems (2001) — link
  5. Growing artificial societies: social science from the bottom up (1996)
  6. The convergence and stability of cultures: Local convergence and global polarization (1995)
  7. Inverse statistics in economics: the gain–loss asymmetry (2003) — link
  8. Volatility Clustering in Financial Markets : Empirical Facts and Agent - Based Models (2007) — link
  9. Probability Distributions in Complex Systems (2009) — link
  10. Scaling and correlation in financial time series (2000) — link
  11. High frequency trading strategies, market fragility and price spikes: an agent based model perspective (2019) — link
  12. Introduction to Econophysics : Correlations and Complexity in Finance (1999) — link
  13. Volatilities of different time resolutions — Analyzing the dynamics of market components (1997) — link
  14. Financial markets as adaptive systems (1998)
  15. Empirical Distributions of Stock Returns : Between the Stretched Exponential and the Power Law ? (2005) — link
  16. Power law distribution in high frequency financial data? An econometric analysis (2011) — link
  17. Inverse cubic law for the distribution of stock price variations (1998) — link
  18. Scaling in Stock Market Data : Stable Laws and Beyond (1997) — link
  19. Learning, evolution and tick size effects in a simulation of the NASDAQ stock market (2001)
  20. Introduction to modern time series analysis (2007)
  21. Econometric analysis (2003)
  22. STL : A seasonal-trend decomposition (1990)
  23. The Convergence and Stability of Cultures : Local Convergence and Global Polarization \textbackslash textbackslashtextbar Santa Fe Institute — link
  24. A Multifractal Model of Asset Returns (1997) — link
  25. Multifractality of Deutschemark / US Dollar Exchange Rates (1997)
  26. Latency arbitrage, market fragmentation, and efficiency: A two-market model (2013)
  27. U. S . Equity Market Resiliency During Times of Extreme Volatility — link
  28. Volatility Stylized Facts (2011) — link
  29. Disentangling Autocorrelated Intraday Returns (2021) — link
  30. Stylized Facts on the Temporal and Distributional Properties of Daily Data from Speculative Markets by Clive W . J . Granger , Zhuanxin Ding :: SSRN — link
  31. Statistical Modeling of High Frequency Financial Data : Facts , Models and Challenges (2011) — link
  32. Largest American companies by market capitalization — link
  33. A Simple Long Memory Model of Realized Volatility (2004) — link
  34. Alternative Trading Systems : Description of ATS Trading in National Market System Stocks (2013) — link
  35. Equity market structure literature review Part II : High frequency trading (2014)
  36. ATS Transparency Data Quarterly Statistics \textbar FINRA .org — link
  37. Alternative Display Facility ( ADF ) \textbar FINRA .org — link
  38. Cboe U . S . Equities Exchanges Overview — link
  39. Bayesian inference for categorical data analysis (2005) — link
  40. Agent-based computational models and generative social science (1999)
  41. The Off Exchange Routing Decision (2019) — link
  42. Trading Participant Data - ATS Transparency Data — link
  43. OTC Trading Participant Data — link
  44. Regulation NMS (2005) — link
  45. Regulation of NMS Stock Alternative Trading Systems (2018) — link
  46. BIDS ATS Form ATS - N 013-00031 231104083 (2023) — link
  47. Order Routing Decisions for a Fragmented Market : A Review (2021)
  48. Effects of dark pools on financial markets’ efficiency and price discovery function: an investigation by multi-agent simulations (2015)
  49. Informational linkages between dark and lit trading venues (2014)
  50. A study of dark pool trading using an agent-based model (2013)
  51. Shades of darkness: A pecking order of trading venues (2017)
  52. Trading rules, competition for order flow and market fragmentation (2015)
  53. Towards a Model of the National Market System : Fragmented and Heterogenous Venues (2021)
  54. The flash crash: High -frequency trading in an electronic market (2017)
  55. Strategic market choice: Frequent call markets vs. continuous double auctions for fast and slow traders (2015)
  56. Agent-based model exploration of latency arbitrage in fragmented financial markets (2018)
  57. Ecological and Coevolutionary Dynamics in Modern Markets Yield Nonstationarity in Market Efficiencies (2022)
  58. Otc trading: Description of non-ats otc trading in national market system stocks (2014)
  59. Innovation in the Stock Market and Alternative Trading Systems (2020)
  60. Hidden liquidity: Some new light on dark trading (2015)
  61. Dark pool trading strategies, market quality and welfare (2017)
  62. Do dark pools harm price discovery? (2014)
  63. Cboe U . S . Equities Exchanges Overview — link
  64. SEC .gov \textbar Form ATS - N Filings and Information — link
  65. The History of NYSE — link
  66. Cboe U . S . Equities Exchanges Overview — link
  67. Point of Presence ( POP ) - Equinix NY11 Carteret — link
  68. US Equities / Options Connectivity Manual (2023) — link
  69. LTSE Very Simple Market ™ Connectivity Guide — link
  70. MIAX Pearl Equities Connectivity \textbar MIAX — link
  71. US Equities FAQ – MEMX Exchanges — link
  72. IEX Square Edge \textbar Updating the IEX Exchange Architecture for 2021 (2020) — link
  73. UTPPlan — link
  74. CTA - Overview — link
  75. High frequency market microstructure (2015)
  76. NYSE Pillar \textbar Integrated Trading Technology — link
  77. The value of off-exchange data (2021)
  78. NYSE Equities Market Information — link
  79. TRF Exchange Participants \textbar FINRA .org — link
  80. Quoting in Today ’s Market Favors the Primary Exchange Group — link
  81. IEX Square Edge \textbar Performance Files : How IEX ’s D - Peg Order Type Delivers Price Improvement and Markouts — link
  82. Nasdaq Trades NYSE Listings Even Better than NYSE (2020) — link
  83. IEX Square Edge \textbar Predicting the future, by just a few milliseconds — link
  84. powerlaw: a Python package for analysis of heavy-tailed distributions (2014)
  85. Theory-guided data science: A new paradigm for scientific discovery from data (2017)
  86. Process-guided deep learning predictions of lake water temperature (2019)
  87. Adaptive Agents and Data Quality in Agent - Based Financial Markets — → 2311.15974
  88. The End of Theory : The Data Deluge Makes the Scientific Method Obsolete (2008) — link
  89. Agent-based modeling in economics and finance: Past , present, and future (2022)
  90. Revisiting Stylized Facts for Modern Stock Markets (2023)
  91. Allocative efficiency of markets with zero-intelligence traders: Market as a partial substitute for individual rationality (1993)
  92. Zero is not enough: on the lower limit of agent intelligence for continuous double auction markets (1997)
  93. An open-source limit-order-book exchange for teaching and research (2018)
  94. Strategic bidding in continuous double auctions (2008)
  95. Behavior of trading automata in a computerized double auction market (2018)
  96. A standard protocol for describing individual-based and agent-based models (2006)
  97. Market 2000: An Examination of Current Equity Market Developments (1994)
  98. Equity trading in the 21st century (2011)
  99. Information transmission between financial markets in Chicago and New York (2014)
  100. A geographical model for the daily and weekly seasonal volatility in the foreign exchange market (1993)
  101. On the distribution of stock price differences (1967)
  102. Quadratic Hawkes processes for financial prices (2017)
  103. Time reversal invariance in finance (2009)
  104. Do stock exchanges specialize? Evidence from the New Jersey transaction tax proposal (2023)
  105. Equity market structure literature review part i: Market fragmentation (2013)
  106. Market Fragmentation and Its Impact : a Historical Analysis of Market Structure Evolution in the United States , Europe , Australia , and Canada (2013)
  107. US Equities Historical Market Volume Data — link
  108. Generalized word shift graphs: a method for visualizing and explaining pairwise comparisons between texts (2021)
  109. Staff report on equity and options market structure conditions in early 2021 (2021)
  110. How May Day Remade Wall Street (2015) — link
  111. Flattening the illiquidity curve: Retail trading during the COVID -19 lockdown (2021)
  112. Young, confident, digitally connected - meet America ’s new day traders (2021) — link
  113. Robinhood Has Lured Young Traders , Sometimes With Devastating Results (2020) — link
  114. Robinhood has 18 million accounts with $80 billion in assets after rapid growth, IPO filing shows (2021) — link
  115. Attention-induced trading and returns: Evidence from Robinhood users (2022)
  116. The revolution that wasn’t: GameStop , Reddit , and the fleecing of small investors (2022)
  117. Social Media , Market Sentiment and Meme Stocks (2023)
  118. Sundial Growers : The Truth About This Hot Meme Stock \textbar Nasdaq (2021) — link
  119. Allotaxonometry and rank-turbulence divergence: A universal instrument for comparing complex systems (2023)
  120. Volatility Stylized Facts (2011) — link
  121. Stylized Facts on the Temporal and Distributional Properties of Daily Data from Speculative Markets by Clive W . J . Granger , Zhuanxin Ding :: SSRN — link
  122. Statistical Modeling of High Frequency Financial Data : Facts , Models and Challenges (2011) — link
  123. Largest American companies by market capitalization — link
  124. The impact of the leverage effect on the implied volatility smile: evidence for the German option market (2021)
  125. The dependence between hourly prices and trading volume (1988)
  126. Heteroskedasticity in stock return data: Volume versus GARCH effects (1990)
  127. Statistical properties of share volume traded in financial markets (2000)
  128. Cross-correlations between volume change and price change (2009)
  129. A subordinated stochastic process model with finite variance for speculative prices (1973)
  130. Economic fluctuations and anomalous diffusion (2000)
  131. Stochastic volatility of financial markets as the fluctuating rate of trading: An empirical study (2007)
  132. The distribution of realized stock return volatility (2001)
  133. Intraday periodicity and volatility persistence in financial markets (1997)
  134. Statistical properties of the volatility of price fluctuations (1999)
  135. Development of an agent-based speculation game for higher reproducibility of financial stylized facts (2019)
  136. A multiscale view on inverse statistics and gain/loss asymmetry in financial time series (2009)
  137. Optimal investment horizons for stocks and markets (2006)
  138. How rigged are stock markets? Evidence from microsecond timestamps (2019)
  139. Synchronizing stock market clocks to UTC ( NIST ) (2020)
  140. Joint Industry Plan ; Order Approving the National Market System Plan Governing the Consolidated Audit Trail (2016) — link
  141. CTA — link
  142. UTP Unlisted Trading Privileges — link
  143. Cboe U . S . Equities Exchanges Overview — link
  144. Here’s how all 30 Dow Jones Industrial Average stocks performed as the benchmark set another record (2018) — link
  145. On the electrodynamics of moving bodies (1905)
  146. An investigation of transactions data for NYSE stocks (1985)
  147. Will the market fix the market?: A theory of stock exchange competition and innovation (2019)
  148. Heterogeneous volatility cascade in financial markets (2001)
  149. The fine-structure of volatility feedback I : Multi -scale self-reflexivity (2014)
  150. Dow Jones Industrial Average ® — link
  151. The flash crash: High -frequency trading in an electronic market (2017)
  152. The Zumbach effect under rough Heston (2020)
  153. Limit order books (2013)
  154. OTC Trading Participant Data — link
  155. Trading Participant Data - ATS Transparency Data — link

1 of 163 cited works are in the corpus; resolved via arXiv source bundles, Semantic Scholar and OpenAlex. Corpus-wide: 2596 linked papers.