Paper: arXiv 2508.12419

Authors: Fabien Le Floc’h

Abstract

We revisit the stochastic collocation method using the exponential of a quadratic spline. In particular, we look in details whether it is more appropriate to fix the ordinates and optimize the abscissae of an interpolating spline or to fix the abscissae and optimize the parameters of a B-spline representation.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 9.0/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 6.0/10
  • Quadrant: Holy Grail — high math complexity, high empirical rigor

Why this score: The paper involves dense and advanced mathematics, including stochastic collocation, exponential splines, B-spline representations, and complex integral formulas, warranting a high math score. It demonstrates empirical rigor with backtest-ready calibration on real market data (TSLA options), regularization, and sensitivity analysis to initial guesses, though the excerpt lacks full implementation details like code or performance metrics.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
  A["Research Goal<br>Fix ordinates optimize abscissae vs. Fix abscissae optimize B-spline?"] --> B{"Evaluate Two Approaches"}
  B --> C["Approach 1<br>Fix Ordinates, Optimize Abscissae"]
  B --> D["Approach 2<br>Fix Abscissae, Optimize B-spline Weights"]
  C --> E["Computational Process<br>Minimize L-infinity distance<br>between implied volatilities"]
  D --> E
  E --> F["Data Input<br>Discrete market option prices<br>and implied volatilities"]
  F --> G["Key Findings & Outcomes"]
  G --> H["Approach 1 (Variable Abscissae)"]
  G --> I["Approach 2 (B-spline Optimization)"]
  H --> J["Simplifies inverse problem<br>but requires node sorting<br>and produces valid CDF"]
  I --> K["Better computational stability<br>via linear system solve<br>ensures arbitrage-free prices"]

Evidence Card

What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card

Proposes

The paper revisits stochastic collocation using the exponential of a quadratic spline and compares fixing ordinates versus fixing abscissae in spline interpolation.

Source sentence
We revisit the stochastic collocation method using the exponential of a quadratic spline. In particular, we look in details whether it is more appropriate to fix the ordinates and optimize the abscissae of an interpolating spline or to fix the abscissae and optimize the parameters of a B-spline representation.

Assumes 3

  • The asset is positive and absorption at zero is assumed for put‑call parity adjustments. model
    Source sentence
    For a positive asset, if we assume absorption at zero, the put‑call parity must be adjusted using the call option price at strike zero.
  • The first moment of the risk‑neutral density must be preserved. model
    Source sentence
    The simplest way to enforce the first moment condition is to shift the ordinates of the interpolation by lnF −lnC(0).
  • Continuity of the derivative at the spline boundaries is enforced by matching slopes to the spline derivative. model
    Source sentence
    In order to keep the continuity of the derivative at the boundaries, we choose sR = g′(xM) and sL = g′(x0).

Data

No dataset named in the text.

Costs

Not applicable The paper reports no trading or execution result.

Finds 5

  • Optimizing abscissae (or B‑spline knots) is not necessarily more appropriate than optimizing ordinates (or B‑spline coefficients) because the ordinates shift to satisfy the first moment condition. theoretical
    Source sentence
    Optimizing abscissae (resp. B-spline knots) is not necessarily more appropriate than ordinates (resp. B-spline coefficients) as the ordinates are not truly fixed in the former approach due to the enforcement of the first moment condition.
  • Using regular B‑spline collocation (instead of the exponential version) may be more appropriate for positive assets and yields smoother implied probability densities. theoretical
    Source sentence
    In general, for a positive asset, it may be more appropriate to use regular B-spline collocation, instead of the exponential version, and employ an exponential linear or quadratic extrapolation as in [8] to guarantee positivity.
  • Regular B‑splines allow easier increase of smoothness order while keeping the same analytical pricing formula for European options. theoretical
    Source sentence
    The use of a regular B-spline instead of the exponential of a B-spline leads to smoother implied probability density, and allows to easily increase the order of smoothness by increasing the B-spline degree, while keeping the same analytical formula for pricing European options.
  • Using fewer knots in the spline can be simpler and more efficient when fitting a dense set of market option prices. theoretical
    Source sentence
    Finally, instead of using a penalty it may be simpler and more efficient to use less knots in the spline representation when the goal is to fit a dense set of market option prices.
  • The conclusions are based on a very limited (but relevant) set of example market data, so they should be taken with care. negative
    Source sentence
    Those conclusions should be taken with some care as they are based on a very limited (but relevant) set of example market data.

Checked by others

No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 38 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.

Code

No repository by the authors found in the paper.

Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.

Cited References (140)

  1. Calibration of the heston stochastic local volatility model: A finite volume scheme (2011)
  2. Parameter estimation and inverse problems (2018)
  3. Relaxation methods applied to determine the motion, in two dimensions, of a viscous fluid past a fixed cylinder (1955)
  4. Accuracy and stability of splitting with stabilizing corrections (2002)
  5. Stability of ADI schemes applied to convection–diffusion equations with mixed derivative terms (2007)
  6. The numerical solution of parabolic and elliptic differential equations (1955)
  7. A second-order Rosenbrock method applied to photochemical dispersion problems (1999)
  8. Unconditionally stable and second-order accurate explicit finite difference schemes using domain transformation: part I one-factor equity problems (2009)
and 132 more
  1. Not-so-complex logarithms in the Heston model (2005)
  2. C# for Financial Markets (2013)
  3. Differencing scheme for a differential equation with a small parameter affecting the highest derivative (1969)
  4. Multiquadric radial basis function approximation methods for the numerical solution of partial differential equations (2009)
  5. On the acceleration of explicit finite difference methods for option pricing (2009)
  6. Super-time-stepping acceleration of explicit schemes for parabolic problems (1996)
  7. RKC: An explicit solver for parabolic PDEs (1998)
  8. A stabilized Runge–Kutta–Legendre method for explicit super-time-stepping of parabolic and mixed equations (2014)
  9. An alternating-direction implicit scheme for parabolic equations with mixed derivatives (1988)
  10. Algorithm 832: UMFPACK V4. 3—an unsymmetric-pattern multifrontal method (2004)
  11. On the numerical solution of heat conduction problems in two and three space variables (1956)
  12. Alternating direction implicit finite difference schemes for the Heston-Hull-White partial differential equation (2012)
  13. A Fourier-based valuation method for Bermudan and barrier options under Heston’s model (2011)
  14. Numerical solution of time-dependent advection-diffusion-reaction equations (2013)
  15. Unconditional stability of second-order ADI schemes applied to multi-dimensional diffusion equations with mixed derivative terms (2009)
  16. Stability of ADI schemes for multidimensional diffusion equations with mixed derivative terms (2013)
  17. Convergence Analysis of Crank-Nicolson and Rannacher Time-Marching (2006)
  18. A simple efficient algorithm for the solution of heat conduction problems (1976)
  19. An alternating direction explicit (ADE) scheme for time-dependent evolution equations (2005)
  20. Finite element solution of diffusion problems with irregular data (1984)
  21. Prices of state-contingent claims implicit in option prices (1978)
  22. More than you ever wanted to know about volatility swaps (1999)
  23. Good parameters and implementations for combined multiple recursive random number generators (1999)
  24. Smoothing of initial data and rates of convergence for parabolic difference equations (1970)
  25. Pricing Financial Instruments - The Finite Difference Method (2000)
  26. A Theory of the Term Structure of Interest Rates (1985)
  27. Implementing 64-bit Maximally Equidistributed F 2-Linear Generators with Mersenne Prime Period (2018)
  28. A simple option formula for general jump-diffusion and other exponential L 'e vy processes (2001)
  29. Finite difference methods for ordinary and partial differential equations: steady-state and time-dependent problems (2007)
  30. The use of the L-curve in the regularization of discrete ill-posed problems (1993)
  31. GN–a Simple and Effective Nonlinear Least-Squares Algorithm for the Open Source Literature. (2013) — link
  32. Smooth-curve interpolation: A generalized spline-fit procedure (1966)
  33. B-spline techniques for volatility modeling (2016)
  34. The pricing of options and corporate liabilities (1973)
  35. Hedging with Stochastic and Local Volatility (2004)
  36. Stochastic Local Volatility (2008)
  37. Calibrating and pricing with embedded local volatility models (2007)
  38. Flexible smoothing with B-splines and penalties (1996)
  39. Levenberg-Marquardt methods for constrained nonlinear equations with strong local convergence properties (2004)
  40. On Multistep Stabilizing Correction Splitting Methods with Applications to the Heston Model (2018)
  41. Clamping Down on Arbitrage (2014)
  42. OSQP : An Operator Splitting Solver for Quadratic Programs (2017) — link
  43. CVXOPT: A Python package for convex optimization (2013)
  44. quadprog: Functions to solve quadratic programming problems (2007)
  45. Analysis of discrete ill-posed problems by means of the L-curve (1992)
  46. Sur un polynôme d’interpolation (1951) — link
  47. Degree of approximation by monotone polynomials I (1968)
  48. Cleve’s corner: Roots-of polynomials, that is (1991)
  49. Markov functional modeling of equity, commodity and other assets (2006)
  50. Implied Sampling: Properties and Pitfalls (2006)
  51. Closed form option valuation with smiles (1999)
  52. A practical method for the valuation of a variety of hybrid products (2005)
  53. The stochastic collocation Monte Carlo sampler: highly efficient sampling from ‘expensive’distributions (2018)
  54. Convex optimization (2004)
  55. Estimating option-implied distributions in illiquid markets and implementing the Ross recovery theorem (2017)
  56. FX options and structured products (2015)
  57. A Stochastic Collocation Algorithm for Uncertainty Analysis (2003)
  58. Extraction of market expectations from risk-neutral density (2015)
  59. Model-free stochastic collocation for an arbitrage-free implied volatility: Part I (2019) — link
  60. Fast and Accurate Analytic Basis Point Volatility (2016)
  61. Finite difference techniques for arbitrage-free SABR (2017)
  62. An adaptive Filon quadrature for stochastic volatility models (2018)
  63. ADI finite difference schemes for option pricing in the Heston model with correlation (2010)
  64. Interest Rate Modeling, Volume I: Foundations and Vanilla Models (2010)
  65. Fourier Transforms, Option Pricing and Controls (2011) — link
  66. Model-Free Stochastic Collocation for an Arbitrage-Free Implied Volatility, Part II (2019)
  67. Algorithm 748: enclosing zeros of continuous functions (1995)
  68. Implied risk-neutral probability density functions from option prices: a central bank perspective1 (2007)
  69. A new framework to estimate the risk-neutral probability density functions embedded in options prices (2010)
  70. Option-implied risk aversion estimates (2004)
  71. A study of implied risk-neutral density functions in the Norwegian option market (2002)
  72. A Simple and Reliable Way to Compute Option-Based Risk-Neutral Distributions (2014)
  73. Estimating Option-Implied Distributions in Illiquid Markets and Implementing the Ross Recovery Theorem (2016)
  74. Estimating the Implied Risk‐Neutral Density for the US Market Portfolio* (2010) — link
  75. Smiling at convexity: bridging swaption skews and CMS adjustments (2006)
  76. Swaption skews and convexity adjustments (2005)
  77. Lecture 1: Stochastic volatility and local volatility (2004)
  78. Quasi-Explicit Calibration of Gatheral’s SVI model (2009)
  79. Convexity conundrums: Pricing CMS swaps, caps, and floors (2005)
  80. Some concrete aspects of Hilbert’s 17th problem (2000)
  81. From arbitrage to arbitrage-free implied volatilities (2017)
  82. The collocating local volatility framework – a fresh look at efficient pricing with smile (2018) — link
  83. Towards a theory of volatility trading (2001)
  84. Robust replication of volatility derivatives (2008)
  85. Pricing with a smile (1994)
  86. An arbitrage-free interpolation of volatilities (2004)
  87. Volatility interpolation (2011)
  88. A closed-form solution for options with stochastic volatility with applications to bond and currency options (1993)
  89. Managing smile risk (2002)
  90. Arbitrage-Free SABR (2014)
  91. Cutting edges using domain integration (2006)
  92. Financial derivatives in theory and practice (2004)
  93. Algorithms: Algorithm 326: Roots of low-order polynomial equations (1968)
  94. On Halley’s iteration method (1985)
  95. Six myths of polynomial interpolation and quadrature (2011)
  96. The colleague matrix, a Chebyshev analogue of the companion matrix (1961)
  97. Algorithm 493: Zeros of a real polynomial [c2] (1975)
  98. On shape preserving quadratic spline interpolation (1983)
  99. Monotone and convex spline interpolation (1977)
  100. Fast and flexible methods for monotone polynomial fitting (2016)
  101. Partial differential equations, volume 1 of Applied Mathematical Sciences (1982)
  102. Jumps and stochastic volatility: Exchange rate processes implicit in Deutsche Mark options (1996)
  103. The shape and term structure of the index option smirk: Why multifactor stochastic volatility models work so well (2009)
  104. Let’s be rational (2015)
  105. An adaptive successive over-relaxation method for computing the Black–Scholes implied volatility (2011)
  106. Nonnegativity-, monotonicity-, or convexity-preserving cubic and quintic Hermite interpolation (1989)
  107. Accurate monotone cubic interpolation (1993)
  108. Arbitrage-free SVI volatility surfaces (2014)
  109. Monte Carlo methods in finance (2004)
  110. A practical guide to splines (1978)
  111. The smile calibration problem solved (2011)
  112. The Heston stochastic-local volatility model: efficient Monte Carlo simulation (2014)
  113. Accurate monotonicity preserving cubic interpolation (1983)
  114. Stochastic volatility with an Ornstein–Uhlenbeck process: an extension (1999)
  115. A novel pricing method for European options based on Fourier-cosine series expansions (2008)
  116. Optimal Fourier inversion in semi-analytical option pricing (2007)
  117. Why the rotation count algorithm works (2006) — link
  118. Moment Explosions (2010)
  119. Moment explosions in stochastic volatility models (2007)
  120. Analytic Formula for the European Normal Black Scholes Formula (2001)
  121. A second-order weak approximation of Heston model by discrete random variables (2015)
  122. Efficient simulation of the Heston stochastic volatility model (2007)
  123. Efficient numerical schemes for the approximation of expectations of functionals of the solution of a SDE, and applications (1984)
  124. Algorithm AS 241: The percentage points of the normal distribution (1988)
  125. Arbitrage free SABR (2014)
  126. Collocating Local Volatility: A Competitive Alternative to Stochastic Local Volatility Models (2018)
  127. Polynomial processes for power prices (2019)
  128. Valuation of electricity storage contracts using the COS method (2021)
  129. An energy-minimization framework for monotonic cubic spline interpolation (2002)
  130. Simple, Flexible, Analytic, Arbitrage Free Volatility Interpolation (2025)
  131. Monotone and convex quadratic spline interpolation (1990)
  132. Positive Stochastic Collocation for the Collocated Local Volatility Model (2021) — link

0 of 140 cited works are in the corpus; resolved via arXiv source bundles, Semantic Scholar and OpenAlex. Corpus-wide: 2596 linked papers.