Paper: arXiv 2401.04702

Authors: Didier Sornette, Yu Zhang

Abstract

We study the temporal evolution of the holding-time distribution of bitcoins and find that the average distribution of holding-time is a heavy-tailed power law extending from one day to over at least \(200\) weeks with an exponent approximately equal to \(0.9\), indicating very long memory effects. We also report significant sample-to-sample variations of the distribution of holding times, which can be best characterized as multiscaling, with power-law exponents varying between \(0.3\) and \(2.5\) depending on bitcoin price regimes. We document significant differences between the distributions of book-to-market and of realized returns, showing that traders obtain far from optimal performance. We also report strong direct qualitative and quantitative evidence of the disposition effect in the Bitcoin Blockchain data. Defining age-dependent transaction flows as the fraction of bitcoins that are traded at a given time and that were born (last traded) at some specific earlier time, we document that the time-averaged transaction flow fraction has a power law dependence as a function of age, with an exponent close to \(-1.5\), a value compatible with priority queuing theory. We document the existence of multifractality on the measure defined as the normalized number of bitcoins exchanged at a given time.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 7.5/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 8.0/10
  • Quadrant: Holy Grail — high math complexity, high empirical rigor

Why this score: The paper employs a rigorous mathematical formulation (difference equations, distribution theory, multifractality) and leverages complete, public blockchain data to analyze transaction flows and holding times with strong empirical evidence.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
  A["Research Goal: Study Temporal Dynamics<br>Holding Times & Transaction Flows in Bitcoin"] --> B
  subgraph B ["Methodology & Data"]
      B1["Data Source: Bitcoin Blockchain"]
      B2["Key Metrics: Holding Times<br>Transaction Flows<br>Realized Returns"]
  end
  B --> C["Computational Analysis"]
  subgraph C ["Computational Analysis"]
      direction LR
      C1["Fitting<br>Power-Law Distributions"]
      C2["Analyzing<br>Price Regimes"]
      C3["Testing for<br>Multifractality"]
  end
  C --> D["Key Findings & Outcomes"]
  subgraph D ["Key Findings & Outcomes"]
      D1["Holding Time: Heavy-tailed<br>Power Law (t ≈ -0.9)<br>Multiscaling across regimes"]
      D2["Transaction Flow: Age-dependent<br>Power Law (t ≈ -1.5)<br>Matches Priority Queuing"]
      D3["Trader Performance:<br>Disposition Effect detected<br>Far from optimal"]
      D4["Market Structure:<br>Strong Multifractality present"]
  end

Evidence Card

What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card

Proposes

The paper presents a quantitative analysis of Bitcoin holding and transaction properties, including a mathematical formulation of transaction flows and the construction of age distributions of bitcoins.

Source sentence
8. Conclusion We have presented a quantitative analysis of the holding and transaction properties of bitcoins, building on the unique availability of the full record of transactions recorded on the public ledger of Bitcoin.

Assumes

No explicit assumptions found in the text.

Data

  • Bitcoin blockchain (blk files) · public Bitcoin ledger crypto-onchain public
    Jan 2009 to Aug 2022 · all bitcoins
    Source sentence
    We downloaded all these “blk” files that correspond to the history from January 2009 to August 2022 and formed the data set that is analyzed in this paper. These data are already parsed using the library Blocksci (Version 2The blocks stored inside the files are not necessarily ordered.

Costs

Not applicable The paper reports no trading or execution result.

Finds 5

  • The average holding‑time distribution follows a heavy‑tailed power law from one day to at least 200 weeks with an exponent around 0.9, indicating very long memory effects. statistical
    Source sentence
    We study the temporal evolution of the holding-time distribution of bitcoins and find that the average distribution of holding-time is a heavy-tailed power law extending from one day to over at least $200$ weeks with an exponent approximately equal to $0.9$, indicating very long memory effects. We find that the distribution of holding times is a power law extending over at least 200 weeks with an exponent
  • Sample‑to‑sample variations of holding‑time distributions exhibit multiscaling, with power‑law exponents ranging between 0.3 and 2.5 across different price regimes. statistical
    Source sentence
    We also report significant sample-to-sample variations of the distribution of holding times, which can be best characterized as multiscaling, with power-law exponents varying between $0.3$ and $2.5$ depending on bitcoin price regimes.
  • The time‑averaged transaction‑flow fraction decays as a power law of age with exponent close to –1.5, consistent with priority queuing theory. statistical
    Source sentence
    Defining age-dependent transaction flows as the fraction of bitcoins that are traded at a given time and that were born (last traded) at some specific earlier time, we document that the time-averaged transaction flow fraction has a power law dependence as a function of age, with an exponent close to $-1.5$, a value compatible with priority queuing theory.
  • Significant differences are observed between book‑to‑market (unrealized) returns and realized returns, with realized returns being smaller in the gain domain. statistical
    Source sentence
    We document significant differences between the distributions of book-to-market and of realized returns, showing that traders obtain far from optimal performance. We document significant differences between book-to-market and realized returns.
  • Strong qualitative and quantitative evidence of the disposition effect is documented in the Bitcoin blockchain data. statistical
    Source sentence
    We also report strong direct qualitative and quantitative evidence of the disposition effect in the Bitcoin Blockchain data.

Checked by others

Supported by

  • Do Short Exposure and Systematic Risk Exposure Drive Asymmetries in the Disposition Effect? (2026)
    On the question: What is the magnitude of the disposition effect observed in Bitcoin transaction data?
    Compare the findings

    This paper: Strong qualitative and quantitative evidence of the disposition effect is documented in the Bitcoin blockchain data.

    That paper: The average disposition effect in the sample is 0.20, closely matching Odean’s reported 0.21.

    A provides qualitative evidence of the effect; B quantifies it as 0.20, close to Odean’s 0.21.

Code

No repository by the authors found in the paper.

Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.

Cited References (34)

  1. Ideologie und Utopie (1929)
  2. Bitcoin: Economics, Technology, and Governance (2015)
  3. Blockchain offers applications well beyond Bitcoin but faces its own limitations (2019)
  4. Effects of Diversity and Procrastination in Priority Queuing Theory: the Different Power Law Regimes (2009)
  5. Power-law and exponential tails in a stochastic priority-based model queue (2008)
  6. Biased diffusion and universality in model queues (2006)
  7. Tail risk: What causes crashes? (2003)
  8. Limit Order Books (2016)
and 26 more
  1. A suggested interpretation of the quantum theory in terms of hidden variables, I (1952)
  2. A suggested interpretation of the quantum theory in terms of hidden variables, II (1952)
  3. What Drives the Disposition Effect? An Analysis of a Long-Standing Preference-Based Explanation (2009)
  4. Chapter 2 - Is Bitcoin a Real Currency? An Economic Appraisal (2015) — link
  5. Bitcoin as an alternative investment vehicle (2017)
  6. Bitcoin: Currency or Investment (2014)
  7. Robust dynamic classes revealed by measuring the response function of a social system (2008)
  8. Dissection of Bitcoin’s multiscale bubble history from January 2012 to February 2018 (2019)
  9. Multifractal analysis of financial markets: a review (2019)
  10. Prospect theory: An analysis of decision under risk (1979)
  11. Bitcoin: A peer-to-peer electronic cash system (2008)
  12. Global models for short-term earthquake forecasting and predictive skill assessment (2021)
  13. Magnitude-dependent O mori law: Theory and empirical study (2005)
  14. Multifractal O mori law for earthquake triggering: new tests on the California, Japan and worldwide catalogues (2009)
  15. Generation-by-generation dissection of the response function in long memory epidemic processes (2010)
  16. The disposition to sell winners too early and ride losers too long: Theory and evidence (1985)
  17. Critical phenomena in natural sciences (chaos, fractals, self-organization and disorder: concepts and tools) (2006)
  18. Endogenous versus exogenous origins of crises (2006)
  19. Endogenous versus exogenous shocks in complex networks: An empirical test using book sale rankings (2004)
  20. Endogenous versus exogenous shocks in systems with memory (2003)
  21. Volatility fingerprints of large shocks: endogenous versus exogenous (2004)
  22. Multifractal scaling of thermally activated rupture processes (2005)
  23. New empirical tests of the multifractal O mori law for T aiwan (2012)
  24. Are Bitcoin bubbles predictable? Combining a generalized Metcalfe’s law and the log-periodic power law singularity model (2019)
  25. Blocksci: Design and applications of a blockchain analysis platform (2020)
  26. The Rise of Rationality in Blockchain Dynamics (2023) — link

0 of 34 cited works are in the corpus; resolved via arXiv source bundles, Semantic Scholar and OpenAlex. Corpus-wide: 2596 linked papers.