Paper: arXiv 2505.15611

Authors: Emilio Barucci, Yuheng Lan

Abstract

We deal with the optimal execution problem when the broker’s goal is to reach a performance barrier avoiding a downside barrier. The performance is provided by the wealth accumulated by trading in the market, the shares detained by the broker evaluated at the market price plus a slippage cost yielding a quadratic inventory cost. Over a short horizon, this type of remuneration leads, at the same time, to a more aggressive and less risky strategy compared to the classical one, and over a long horizon the performance turns to be poorer and more dispersed.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 9.0/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 2.0/10
  • Quadrant: Lab Rats — high math complexity, limited empirical testing

Why this score: The paper is mathematically dense, featuring continuous-time stochastic calculus, HJB equations, and closed-form derivations typical of theoretical quantitative finance. It lacks empirical backtests, real-world data, or implementation details, relying solely on analytical solutions and theoretical analysis.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
  A["Research Goal:<br>Optimal Execution with Performance Barriers"]
  B["Methodology:<br>Dynamic Programming & HJB Equation"]
  C["Inputs:<br>Market Data, Slippage & Inventory Costs"]
  D["Computation:<br>Optimal Strategy via Lagrange Multipliers"]
  E["Outcome 1:<br>Short-term: Aggressive but Low Risk"]
  F["Outcome 2:<br>Long-term: Poorer & Dispersed Performance"]

  A --> B
  B --> C
  C --> D
  D --> E
  D --> F

Evidence Card

What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card

Proposes

The paper proposes an optimal execution model where the broker aims to reach an upper performance barrier while avoiding a lower barrier, incorporating wealth, market value of inventory and a quadratic slippage cost.

Source sentence
In this paper, we deal with optimal execu-tion when the broker aims to reach an upper performance barrier avoiding the downside barrier.

Assumes 6

  • The broker is risk neutral. model
    Source sentence
    The broker is risk neutral and the classical optimal execution problem concerns the maximization of the expected value of the performance by the terminal date T: J v(t, x, q, s) = E[X(T) + Q(T)(S(T) −γQ(T))|X(t) = x, Q(t) = q, S(t) = s].
  • The slippage cost γ is higher than the permanent impact b (2γ−b>0). model
    Source sentence
    As in the classical optimal execution problem, we assume 2γ −b > 0, i.e., twice the slippage cost be higher than the permanent effect of the broker’s order.
  • Inventory incurs a quadratic cost γQ^2 (quadratic inventory cost). execution
    Source sentence
    The performance is provided by the wealth accumulated by trading in the market, the shares detained by the broker evaluated at the market price plus a slippage cost yielding a quadratic inventory cost. We consider the following performance criterion: Y (t) = X(t) + Q(t)(S(t) −γQ(t)), which includes the wealth accumulated by trading on the market (X(t)), the shares de-tained by the broker evaluated at the market
  • The HJB solution assumes the value function is twice differentiable with ∂yyJ<0 and ∂yJ>0. other
    Source sentence
    Let us assume that the HJB equation admits a classical solution such that ∂yyJ < 0 and ∂yJ > 0.
Show 2 more
  • The optimal liquidation fraction is constant (2γ−b)/(2l). model
    Source sentence
    Therefore, selling the fixed fraction 2γ−b 2l of outstanding shares renders the highest expected increase in the performance.
  • The slippage cost γ is much higher than the temporary impact l. model
    Source sentence
    This implies that the broker has to find the right balance between quickly liquidating the shares and holding them with a penalization higher than the temporary price impact (γ is much higher than l).

Data

  • Baseline parameter set synthetic unknown
    Source sentence
    Parameter Value Interpretation b 0.001 permanent impact l 0.001 temporary impact γ 0.1 slippage cost σ 0.1 volatility Q0 1 quantity of shares Y0 1 initial target value k 0.95(Y0 −0.05) lower boundary h 1.05(Y0 + 0.05) upper boundary Table 1: Baseline set of parameters of the model.

Costs

Modeled Costs are part of the reported headline results.

Quadratic inventory cost γQ^2 and slippage cost (γ) are included; permanent impact b and temporary impact l also appear in the execution model.

Source sentence
The performance is provided by the wealth accumulated by trading in the market, the shares detained by the broker evaluated at the market price plus a slippage cost yielding a quadratic inventory cost. We consider the following performance criterion: Y (t) = X(t) + Q(t)(S(t) −γQ(t)), which includes the wealth accumulated by trading on the market (X(t)), the shares de-tained by the broker evaluated at the market

Finds 5

  • Over a short horizon the performance target scheme yields a more aggressive and less risky strategy compared to the classical execution, while over a long horizon performance is poorer and more dispersed. performance
    Source sentence
    Over a short horizon, this type of remuneration leads, at the same time, to a more aggressive and less risky strategy compared to the classical one, and over a long horizon the performance turns to be poorer and more dispersed.
  • The remuneration scheme based on a performance target induces short‑termism bias but does not lead to excessive risk taking. theoretical
    Source sentence
    In our analysis, we have shown that a fixed remuneration in case of success and a null one in case of poor performance leads to a shortermism bias but not excessive risk taking.
  • The optimal strategy with a performance target liquidates shares at a much higher rate than the classical solution. performance
    Source sentence
    The optimal strategy with a performance target foresees a liquidation of the shares at a much higher rate compared to the solution obtained according to the classical execution 21 problem.
  • For a short horizon the strategy with a performance target yields higher performance and smaller dispersion than the classical finite‑horizon solution; the reverse holds over a long horizon. performance
    Source sentence
    The strategy obtained with a performance target yields a higher performance and a smaller dispersion compared to the solution with a finite horizon over a short horizon, but over a long horizon the reverse is observed.
  • Problem P1 (performance target) leads to a high probability of reaching the upper barrier and a very low probability of hitting the lower barrier, unlike the classical problem which allocates significant probability to both extremes. statistical
    Source sentence
    As a consequence, there is a high probability of reaching the upper barrier and of remaining between the two barriers with a very low probability of reaching the lower barrier. Instead, the strategy obtained by solving the classical problem allocates a significant probability to reach the lower barrier.

Checked by others

No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 20 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.

Code

No repository by the authors found in the paper.

Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.