Paper: arXiv 2404.02858

Authors: G. Apicella, A. Molent, M. Gaudenzi

Abstract

The state-of-the-art proposes Life Care Annuities, that have been recently designed as variable annuity contracts with Long-Term Care payouts and Guaranteed Lifelong Withdrawal Benefits. In this paper, we propose more general features for these insurance products and refine their pricing methods. We name our proposed product GLWB-LTC’’. In particular, as to the product features, we allow dynamic withdrawal strategies, including the surrender option. Furthermore, we consider stochastic interest rates, described by a Cox-Ingersoll-Ross process. As to the numerical methods, we solve the stochastic control problem involved by the selection of the optimal withdrawal strategy through a robust tree method, which outperforms the Monte Carlo approach. We name this method Tree-LTC’’, and we use it to estimate the fair price of the product, as some relevant parameters vary, such as, for instance, the entry age of the policyholder. Furthermore, our numerical results show how the optimal withdrawal strategy varies over time with the health status of the policyholder. Our findings stress the important advantage of flexible withdrawal strategies in relation to insurance policies offering protection from health risks. Indeed, the policyholder is given more choice about how much to save for protection from the possible disability states at future times.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 7.0/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 4.0/10
  • Quadrant: Lab Rats — high math complexity, limited empirical testing

Why this score: The paper employs advanced stochastic calculus (Cox-Ingersoll-Ross interest rates, American option pricing via tree methods) which demands high mathematical sophistication, but the empirical component is limited to theoretical pricing model comparisons and sensitivity analysis without backtests on historical financial data.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
  A["Research Goal:<br>Enhance Life Care Annuities & Refine Pricing"] --> B["Modeling Framework<br>Cox-Ingersoll-Ross for interest rates"]
  B --> C["Stochastic Control Problem<br>Optimizing withdrawal strategy"]
  C --> D{"Numerical Method"}
  D -- Traditional --> E["Monte Carlo Approach"]
  D -- Proposed --> F["Tree-LTC Method<br>(Robust Tree)"]
  E --> G["Analysis & Pricing"]
  F --> G
  G --> H["Key Findings<br>Optimal strategy varies by health status<br>Flexible withdrawals are advantageous"]
  
  style A fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
  style H fill:#bbf,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px

Evidence Card

What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card

Proposes

The paper proposes a more general GLWB-LTC product with dynamic withdrawal strategies including surrender, and refines its pricing by introducing the Tree-LTC numerical method.

Source sentence
In this paper, we propose more general features for these insurance products and refine their pricing methods. In particular, as to the product features, we allow dynamic withdrawal strategies, including the surrender option.

Assumes 6

  • Stochastic interest rates follow a Cox‑Ingersoll‑Ross (CIR) process. model
    Source sentence
    Furthermore, we consider stochastic interest rates, described by a Cox-Ingersoll-Ross process. 6 2.2 Dynamics of the mutual fund and of the interest rate Let us consider a risk-neutral measure Q. The risk neutral dynamics of the stochastic processes describing the mutual fund Ft and the interest rate rt are as follows: ( dFt = rtFtdt + σF FtdW 1 t , drt = kr(θ −rt)dt + σr√rtdW 2 t , (1) where the constant parameters
  • Transition probability matrices Qx0 are time‑homogeneous within each year. model
    Source sentence
    The matrices Qx0 are assumed to be time-homogeneous during each year, that is, for each n ∈N, Qx0(t) = Qx0(s) holds for all t, s such that n ≤s ≤t < n + 1.
  • Risk‑neutral valuation is used, assuming death and disability risks are diversifiable. market
    Source sentence
    In this framework, we assume that the risks associated with death and disability can be diversified, as supported by Milevsky and Salisbury (2006).
  • Maximum age of the insured is limited to 122 years. model
    Source sentence
    Following common practice, see e.g. Forsyth and Vetzal (2014) Gouden´ege et al. (2016), we limit the maximum age of the insured to 122.
Show 2 more
  • Fees are charged annually as proportional costs α on the account value A and β on the benefit base B. execution
    Source sentence
    Adopting the approach proposed by Hsieh et al. (2018), the decrement in the account’s value, owing to these fees, is regulated by two parameters, α and β. Consequently, on each anniversary of the contract, it is reduced by αA and βB as long as the account value remains positive.
  • The health state transition intensities are taken from Pritchard (2006) based on interval‑censored longitudinal data from the National Long‑Term Care Study. data
    Source sentence
    Furthermore, we obtain transition intensities Qx0(n) based on the parameter values shown in Pritchard (2006) (Table 8, page 68), that were obtained by applying the penalized likelihood methodology to the interval-censored longitudinal data from the National Long-Term Care Study.

Data

  • National Long‑Term Care Study macro public
    Source sentence
    Furthermore, we obtain transition intensities Qx0(n) based on the parameter values shown in Pritchard (2006) (Table 8, page 68), that were obtained by applying the penalized likelihood methodology to the interval-censored longitudinal data from the National Long-Term Care Study.

Costs

Unclear - sources disagree The platform classifier and the paper-text extraction give different answers, so no value is asserted.

Platform classifier: Not applicable

Paper text extraction: Modeled - Annual fees proportional to A and B with parameters α and β are deducted each anniversary while the account value remains positive.

Source sentence (the authors' words)
Adopting the approach proposed by Hsieh et al. (2018), the decrement in the account’s value, owing to these fees, is regulated by two parameters, α and β. Consequently, on each anniversary of the contract, it is reduced by αA and βB as long as the account value remains positive.

Finds 5

  • Dynamic withdrawal strategies significantly improve the value of the GLWB‑LTC product compared to static strategies. theoretical
    Source sentence
    Our findings stress the important advantage of flexible withdrawal strategies in relation to insurance policies offering protection from health risks. Through our numerical results, coming from the pricing of the GLWB-LTC product, we show that the dynamic withdrawal strategy acquires even more relevance within the GLWB annuity product that offers protection from disability risks.
  • The optimal withdrawal strategy varies over time with the policyholder’s health status. theoretical
    Source sentence
    Furthermore, our numerical results show how the optimal withdrawal strategy varies over time with the health status of the policyholder.
  • The Tree‑LTC method yields fair fee estimates α that lie within the confidence intervals of Monte Carlo methods, confirming consistency across techniques. other
    Source sentence
    The findings outlined in Table 3 indicate that the point estimate of α obtained via the Tree-LTC method lies within the confidence intervals established by the first two Monte Carlo methods. This consistency underscores the compatibility of the three numerical techniques in determining the estimated values of α.
  • When the account value is high, surrendering is the optimal choice; when interest rates are low and the account value is near the initial premium, not withdrawing is optimal. performance
    Source sentence
    Looking at the various cases analysed, we can see that when the account value takes high values, surrendering is the best choice: the cost of fees is not worth the insurance coverage provided by the contract. When analysing the effect of interest rates, we notice that the higher the interest rate, the more convenient the choice of surrender option.
  • The Tree‑LTC algorithm is computationally more efficient than Monte Carlo for long‑maturity contracts. performance
    Source sentence
    Furthermore, the method in Appolloni et al. (2015) proves to be robust and stable from a numerical point of view. So here we propose an updated version of that tree that allows us to limit the number of nodes considered in the discretization.

Checked by others

Supported by

  • On variable annuities with surrender charges (2024)
    On the question: When is surrender optimal for annuities based on account value, interest rates, and surrender charge?
    Compare the findings

    This paper: When the account value is high, surrendering is the optimal choice; when interest rates are low and the account value is near the initial premium, not withdrawing is optimal.

    That paper: For K=1.4% the surrender boundary starts at t*=0 with surrender only for large account values, while for K=2.2% surrender is never exercised before t*≈1.5 years.

    Both findings show surrender depends on account value and rates: A says high value → surrender, low rates near premium → no surrender; B shows K=1.4% triggers surrender only for large values at t*=0, while K=2.2% prevent

Code

No repository by the authors found in the paper.

Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.

Cited References (75)

  1. Health at a G lance: E urope 2022: S tate of H ealth in the EU C ycle (2022)
  2. Ageing and D isability A ccording to the P erspective of C linical P sychology of D isability (2022)
  3. Ageing in E urope - S upporting P olicies for an I nclusive S ociety (2015) — link
  4. Building ‘implicit partnerships’? F inancial long-term care entitlements in E urope (2020) — link
  5. The effectiveness of social protection for long-term care in old age (2020) — link
  6. Public and P rivate S ector R elationships in L ong-term C are and H ealthcare I nsurance (2021)
  7. Help W anted? P roviding and P aying for L ong- T erm C are (2011) — link
  8. Don’t T hey C are? O r, A re T hey J ust U naware? R isk P erception and the D emand for L ong- T erm C are I nsurance (2010) — link
and 67 more
  1. The P rivate M arket for L ong- T erm C are I nsurance in the U nited S tates: A R eview of the E vidence (2009) — link
  2. Valuation of long-term care options embedded in life annuities (2022) — link
  3. Health C ost R isk: A P otential S olution T o the A nnuity P uzzle (2017) — link
  4. The A nnuity P uzzle and an O utline of I ts S olutions (2018) — link
  5. Survival P essimism and the D emand for A nnuities (2023)
  6. Demand for annuities: P rice sensitivity, risk perceptions, and knowledge (2020) — link
  7. Testing methods to enhance longevity awareness (2022) — link
  8. Product and S trategies for the D ecumulation of W ealth during R etirement: I nsights from the L iterature (2023) — link
  9. Insurance D emand and H eterogeneity in R isk P erception (2016) — link
  10. The impact of individual-level heterogeneity on estimated infectious disease burden: a simulation study (2016) — link
  11. Research on long-term care insurance: status quo and directions for further research (2019) — link
  12. The L ife C are A nnuirty: A N ew E mpirical E xamination of an I nsurance I nnovation T hat A ddresses P roblems in the M arkets for L ife A nnuities and L ong- T erm C are I nsurance (2013) — link
  13. In S ickness and in H ealth: A n A nnuity A pproach to F inancing L ong- T erm C are and R etirement I ncome (2001)
  14. Longlife insurance: A prototype for funding long-term C are (1988 Winter)
  15. Asymmetric I nformation, L ong- T erm C are I nsurance, and A nnuities: T he C ase for B undled C ontracts (2009) — link
  16. Valuation of variable long-term care A nnuities with G uaranteed L ifetime W ithadrawal B enefits: A variance reduction approach (2018) — link
  17. Life insurance and life settlement markets with overconfident policyholders (2020) — link
  18. Life I insurance and L ife S ettlements: T he C ase for H ealth- C ontingent C ash S urrender V alues (2020) — link
  19. The V aluation of G uaranteed L ifelong W ithdrawal B enefit O ptions in V ariable A nnuity C ontracts and the I mpact of M ortality R isk (2011) — link
  20. GMWB for life an analysis of lifelong withdrawal guarantees (2012) — link
  21. Regression-based M onte C arlo methods for stochastic control models: variable annuities with lifelong guarantees (2016) — link
  22. Variable annuities: A unifying valuation approach (2011) — link
  23. Pricing and hedging GLWB in the H eston and in the B lack- S choles with stochastic interest rate models (2016)
  24. The valuation of GMWB variable annuities under alternative fund distributions and policyholder behaviours (2016) — link
  25. Pricing life insurance contracts with early exercise features (2009) — link
  26. A robust tree method for pricing American options with the C ox- I ngersoll- R oss interest rate model (2015) — link
  27. Valuing variable annuities with guaranteed minimum lifetime withdrawal benefits (2015) — link
  28. Health S hocks and the D emand for A nnuities: Technical Paper 2004-09 (2004)
  29. Actuarial models for disability insurance (1998) — link
  30. Modeling D isability in L ong- T erm C are I nsurance (2006) — link
  31. Managing longevity and disability risks in life annuities with long term care (2012) — link
  32. Multidimensional smoothing by adaptive local kernel-weighted log-likelihood: A pplication to long-term care insurance (2013) — link
  33. Multistate A ctuarial M odels of F unctional D isability (2015) — link
  34. Product pricing and solvency capital requirements for long-term care insurance (2017) — link
  35. Calibration of T ransition I ntensities for a M ultistate M odel: A pplication to L ong- T erm C are (2021) — link
  36. Actuarial models for pricing disability benefits: T owards a unifying approach (1995) — link
  37. Heterogeneity and uncertainty in a multistate framework (2021) — link
  38. Insuring longevity risk and long-term care: B equest, housing and liquidity (2023) — link
  39. Rischi demografici nelle assicurazioni Long Term Care (2002)
  40. An E mpirical T ransition M atrix for N on- H omogeneous M arkov C hains B ased on C ensored O bservations (1978)
  41. Calculation of LTC P remiums B ased on D irect E stimates of T ransition P robabilities (2005) — link
  42. Application of survival analysis methods to long-term care insurance (2002) — link
  43. A health insurance pricing model based on prevalence rates: A pplication to critical illness insurance (2014) — link
  44. Estimates of C hange in C hronic D isability and I nstitutional I ncidence and P revalence R ates in the U.S. E lderly P opulation from the 1982, 1984 and 1989 N ational L ong T erm C are S urvey (1993)
  45. A theory of the term structures of interest rates (1985)
  46. An optimal stochastic control framework for determining the cost of hedging of variable annuities (2014)
  47. Financial valuation of guaranteed minimum withdrawal benefits (2006)
  48. A new premium principle for equity-indexed annuities (2011)
  49. Risk-neutral valuation of GLWB riders in variable annuities (2023)
  50. Variable annuities: Market incompleteness and policyholder behavior (2021)
  51. Indifference pricing of a GLWB option in variable annuities (2017)
  52. An analysis of the guaranteed withdrawal benefits for life option (2008)
  53. Simple binomial processes as diffusion approximations in financial models (1990)
  54. Gaussian process regression for pricing variable annuities with stochastic volatility and interest rate (2021)
  55. Backward Hedging for American Options with Transaction Costs — → 2305.06805
  56. High order discretization schemes for the CIR process: application to affine term structure and Heston models (2010)
  57. Interest rates calibration with a CIR model (2019)
  58. A hybrid tree/finite-difference approach for Heston-Hull-White -type models (2017)
  59. Pricing and hedging GMWB in the Heston and in the Black–Scholes with stochastic interest rate models (2019)
  60. A flexible lattice framework for valuing options on assets paying discrete dividends and variable annuities embedding GMWB riders (2022)
  61. Valuation of general GMWB annuities in a low interest rate environment (2023)
  62. M 'e moire d’Actuariat-Promotion 2014 (2014)
  63. Euro Medium Term Note Programme (2004)
  64. Calibrating short interest rate models in negative rate environments (2017)
  65. Affine term-structure models: Theory and implementation (2001)
  66. The effects of a low interest rate environment on life insurers (2015)
  67. Select saving for retirement in Europe : the long-term risk-return tradeoff (2024)

1 of 75 cited works are in the corpus; resolved via arXiv source bundles, Semantic Scholar and OpenAlex. Corpus-wide: 2596 linked papers.