Paper: arXiv 2405.12982
Authors: Michele Azzone, Roberto Baviera, Pietro Manzoni
Abstract
A growing number of contributions in the literature have identified a puzzle in the European carbon allowance (EUA) market. Specifically, a persistent cost-of-carry spread (C-spread) over the risk-free rate has been observed. We are the first to explain the anomalous C-spread with the credit spread of the corporates involved in the emission trading scheme. We obtain statistical evidence that the C-spread is cointegrated with both this credit spread and the risk-free interest rate. This finding has a relevant policy implication: the most effective solution to solve the market anomaly is including the EUA in the list of European Central Bank eligible collateral for refinancing operations. This change in the ECB monetary policy operations would greatly benefit the carbon market and the EU green transition.
Complexity vs Empirical Score
- Math Complexity: 6.5/10
- Empirical Rigor: 7.0/10
- Quadrant: Holy Grail — high math complexity, high empirical rigor
Why this score: The paper employs advanced econometric techniques like cointegration and error correction models, and uses a custom-built Z-index proxy for credit spreads, indicating substantial mathematical complexity. The analysis is grounded in specific market data (Phase III EU-ETS) with robustness checks, making it data-heavy and backtest-ready.
Research Flowchart
flowchart TD R["Research Goal: Explain the persistent EUA cost-of-carry spread"] D["Data Inputs: EUA Futures, Risk-Free Rate, Corporate Credit Spreads"] M["Methodology: Cointegration Analysis & Econometric Modeling"] C["Computational Process: Time-series regression and statistical testing"] F["Key Finding: C-spread cointegrated with credit spread and interest rate"] P["Outcome: Policy Recommendation - Include EUA as ECB Eligible Collateral"] R --> D D --> M M --> C C --> F F --> P
Evidence Card
What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card
Proposes
The paper proposes that the persistent cost‑of‑carry spread in the EU‑ETS is explained by the credit spread of the corporates participating in the scheme.
Source sentence
We are the first to explain the anomalous C-spread with the credit spread of the corporates involved in the emission trading scheme.
Assumes 6
- The EUA pays no dividends and therefore its theoretical cost‑of‑carry should be zero. model
Source sentence
the C-spread (or the negative convenience yield) should be equal to zero as in any financial asset paying no dividend.
- Storing allowances has negligible cost and there is no benefit to hold spot allowances. market
Source sentence
The cost of storing allowances is negligible, and there is no obvious benefit to hold spot allowances as there is for physical commodities.
- Market participants cannot borrow at the risk‑free rate and must consider a credit spread in their funding cost. market
Source sentence
the majority of participants cannot borrow at the risk‑free rate, but need to consider a credit spread in their cost of funding.
- The C‑spread, Z‑index and three‑month risk‑free rate are integrated of order one. statistical
Source sentence
the C‑spread, the Z‑index, and the three‑month risk‑free rate are integrated of order one and cointegrated
Show 2 more
- The front December futures contract and overnight futures are the most liquid contracts for constructing the C‑spread. data
Source sentence
we consider a front contract time‑series of the C‑spread selecting the front December futures contract. We utilize the overnight futures as the spot price
- Bond Z‑spreads can be aggregated to form a proxy (Z‑index) for the credit spread of compliance entities. data
Source sentence
we compute the Z‑index (Zt) by taking the average of the issuers’ Z‑spread.
Data
- Euro OIS swaps macro public
Source sentence
Euro OIS swaps are employed to bootstrap the risk‑free rates’ curve.
- ICE ECX EUA futures other commercial
Source sentence
dataset consists of the daily closing prices and volumes of overnight futures and futures prices with December maturity, covering the period from January 2013 to December 2020.
- Compliance entity bond dataset (Z‑index) fundamentals commercial
Source sentence
a dataset of bonds of the compliance entities in the EU‑ETS is employed to estimate the Z‑index. Market data are obtained from Eikon Reuters.
Costs
Not applicable
Finds 5
- The C‑spread is cointegrated with the Z‑index (credit spread) and the risk‑free rate, indicating the credit spread is the main driver of the C‑spread. statistical
Source sentence
we obtain statistical evidence that the C‑spread is cointegrated with both this credit spread and the risk‑free interest rate.
- Error‑correction models show that only the lagged C‑spread terms and the cointegration relationship are significant; other financial variables are not significant at the 1% level. statistical
Source sentence
the other variables, such as the Z‑index and the risk‑free rate first differences, and the control covariates
- The C‑spread tends to revert to its long‑run equilibrium defined by the Z‑index and risk‑free rate, as indicated by a negative coefficient on the error‑correction term. theoretical
Source sentence
the estimated α3 –the coefficient of ψt−1– is negative, implying a correction mechanism when the C‑spread decouples from the Z‑index and the risk‑free rate
- No evidence is found that the C‑spread is correlated with EUA spot volatility or other financial asset classes. statistical
Source sentence
our analysis finds no evidence that the C‑spread is correlated with the EUA spot volatility and with other financial asset classes.
- The C‑spread and Z‑index have the same order of magnitude, while the risk‑free rate is significantly smaller, supporting a strong long‑run relationship. other
Source sentence
the C‑spread and the Z‑index have the same order of magnitude (while the rate is significantly smaller) and appear to have a strong long‑run relationship.
Checked by others
No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 39 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.
Code
No repository by the authors found in the paper.
Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.
Cited References (36)
- Corporate emissions-trading behaviour during the first decade of the EU ETS (2022)
- Modeling the price dynamics of $CO_2$ emission allowances (2009)
- Why is spot carbon so cheap and future carbon so dear? The term structure of carbon prices (2016)
- Introductory econometrics for finance (2019)
- How does the EU ETS reform impact allowance prices? The role of myopia, hedging requirements and the H otelling rule (2020)
- Is there a macroeconomic carbon rebound effect in EU ETS ? (2023)
- How to avoid history repeating itself: the case for an EU Emissions Trading System ( EU ETS ) price floor revisited (2020)
- Carbon futures and macroeconomic risk factors: A view from the EU ETS (2009)
and 28 more
- Market efficiency in the European carbon markets (2013)
- Modelling the convenience yield in carbon prices using daily and realized measures (2009)
- Mean reversion of stochastic convenience yields for $CO_2$ emissions allowances: Empirical evidence from the EU ETS (2013)
- Understanding the Z -spread (2005)
- Stress testing with multi-faceted liquidity: the central bank collateral framework as a financial stability tool (2023)
- Are the European carbon markets efficient (2008)
- The EU ETS : The first eight years (2014)
- Efficient tests for an autoregressive unit root (1992)
- Interest rate modelling in the multi-curve framework: Foundations, evolution and implementation (2014)
- Structural vector autoregressive analysis (2017)
- The handbook of fixed income securities (2005)
- Emission trading and regulation of financial markets. Final report (2022)
- Futures price dynamics of $CO_2$ emission allowances (2013)
- Estimation and hypothesis testing of cointegration vectors in G aussian vector autoregressive models (1991)
- Statistical analysis of cointegration vectors (1988)
- Testing market efficiency in the EU carbon futures market (2010)
- Efficiency of E uropean emissions markets: Lessons and implications (2011)
- Cointegration between oil spot and future prices of the same and different grades in the presence of structural change (2009)
- The interest of being eligible (2017)
- Credit spreads and interest rates: A cointegration approach (1998)
- Allocation, incentives and distortions: the impact of EU ETS emissions allowance allocations to the electricity sector (2012)
- EU carbon prices signal high policy credibility and farsighted actors (2023)
- Links between spot and futures allowances: ECX and EEX markets comparison (2011)
- Convenience Yields and Risk Premiums in the EU - ETS -Evidence from the Kyoto Commitment Period (2016)
- The inconvenience yield of carbon futures (2021)
- Futures price dynamics of $CO_2$ emission allowances: An empirical analysis of the trial period (2009)
- Price formation in electricity forward markets and the relevance of systematic forecast errors (2009)
- Are Stock Markets Costly Casinos-Disagreement, Market Failure, and Securities Regulation (1995)
0 of 36 cited works are in the corpus; resolved via arXiv source bundles, Semantic Scholar and OpenAlex. Corpus-wide: 2596 linked papers.