Paper: arXiv 2501.05299

Authors: Lennart Ante, Aman Saggu

Abstract

The Ethereum blockchain network enables transaction processing and smart-contract execution through levies of transaction fees, commonly known as gas fees. This framework mediates economic participation via a market-based mechanism for gas fees, permitting users to offer higher gas fees to expedite pro-cessing. Historically, the ensuing gas fee volatility led to critical disequilibria between supply and demand for block space, presenting stakeholder challenges. This study examines the dynamic causal interplay between transaction fees and economic subsystems leveraging the network. By utilizing data related to unique active wallets and transaction volume of each subsystem and applying time-varying Granger causality analysis, we reveal temporal heterogeneity in causal relationships between economic activity and transaction fees across all subsystems. This includes (a) a bidirectional causal feedback loop between cross-blockchain bridge user activity and transaction fees, which diminishes over time, potentially signaling user migration; (b) a bidirectional relationship between centralized cryptocurrency exchange deposit and withdrawal transaction volume and fees, indicative of increased competition for block space; (c) decentralized exchange volumes causally influence fees, while fees causally influence user activity, although this relationship is weakening, potentially due to the diminished significance of decentralized finance; (d) intermittent causal relationships with maximal extractable value bots; (e) fees causally in-fluence non-fungible token transaction volumes; and (f) a highly significant and growing causal influence of transaction fees on stablecoin activity and transaction volumes highlight its prominence.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 7.5/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 8.0/10
  • Quadrant: Holy Grail — high math complexity, high empirical rigor

Why this score: The paper employs advanced econometric methods like time-varying Granger causality analysis, which involves complex statistical modeling. It is highly data-driven, analyzing real-world Ethereum blockchain data across multiple subsystems (e.g., DEXs, bridges, stablecoins) with detailed empirical findings on causal relationships and temporal heterogeneity.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
  A["Research Goal<br>Dynamic causality between fees & subsystem activity"] --> B["Data Collection<br>Unique wallets, Tx volume per subsystem"]
  B --> C["Methodology<br>Time-Varying Granger Causality Analysis"]
  C --> D{"Computational Process<br>Temporal heterogeneity detection"}
  D --> E["Key Findings<br>Dynamic Outcomes"]
  E --> E1["Bidirectional: Bridge activity ↔ Fees<br>Diminishing over time"]
  E --> E2["Bidirectional: CEX activity ↔ Fees<br>Increasing competition"]
  E --> E3["Unidirectional: DEX Vol → Fees<br>Fees → User activity (Weakening)"]
  E --> E4["Intermittent: MEV Bots ↔ Fees"]
  E --> E5["Unidirectional: Fees → NFT Volume"]
  E --> E6["Strong & Growing: Fees → Stablecoin Activity"]

Evidence Card

What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card

Proposes

The paper proposes to examine the dynamic causal interplay between Ethereum transaction fees and economic activity of various subsystems using time‑varying Granger causality analysis.

Source sentence
By utilizing data related to unique active wallets and transaction volume of each subsystem and applying time-varying Granger causality analysis, we reveal temporal heterogeneity in causal relationships between economic activity and transaction fees across all subsystems. This includes (a) a bidirectional causal feedback loop between cross-blockchain bridge user activity and transaction fees, which diminishes over

Assumes 6

  • Transaction fee series are non‑stationary in levels and become stationary after first‑differencing. statistical
    Source sentence
    To investigate the time series properties of the transaction fee variable, we apply the ADFmax unit root test because it accounts for both forward and reverse realizations of the variable under scrutiny (Leybourne 1995; Otero and Baum 2018). The unit root tests indicate that fees are optimally represented in first differences, as the hypothesis of a unit root cannot be rejected for the log-transformed series.6 Table
  • Proxy addresses (3‑5 per system) adequately represent the economic activity of each subsystem. data
    Source sentence
    Given the chal-lenge of comprehensively identifying, extracting data from, and analyzing all six economic systems in question, we utilize proxy variables to approximate the economic activity of individual systems. This approach was replicated for all identified economic systems, yielding a range of three to five addresses or contracts as proxy variables per system, which are presented in Table 1.
  • The bivariate VAR framework with lag‑augmented VAR captures the Granger‑causal relationships among variables. model
    Source sentence
    The formal approach described in the following is adapted from the method described by Baum et al. (2021, 2022) to analyze the temporal stability of Granger-causal relationships. Toda and Yama-moto (1995) and Dolado and Lütkepohl (1996) suggest the use of a Lag-Augmented VAR (LA-VAR) model, which is an extension of the original VAR(m) model with the inclusion of d lags to account for the maximum order of integration
  • Weekly snapshots of the Ethereum network (1‑week intervals) are sufficient to identify relevant markets, wallets, and contracts. data
    Source sentence
    For the initial step, Ethereum and blockchain data providers such as Etherscan (Etherscan 2023b), Dune Analytics (Dune Analytics 2023), Glassnode (Glassnode 2020), and Flipside Crypto (Flipside Crypto 2023) are utilized to analyze the Ethereum network’s status at regular one-week intervals be-tween 1 August and 1 November 2022. This analysis aims at identifying and documenting relevant markets, wallets, contracts,
Show 2 more
  • Unique active wallet counts and transaction volumes are appropriate measures of subsystem activity. execution
    Source sentence
    These APIs allowed us to determine the number of unique active wallets and the corresponding volume, measured in USD, associated with transactions. The term “active” de-notes a wallet, specifically a blockchain address, which partakes directly in a successful transaction.
  • Bootstrap replications (499) provide reliable empirical quantiles for Wald test significance. statistical
    Source sentence
    Granger causality tests, with the 95th and 99th quan-tiles of the empirical distributions based on 499 bootstrap replications. *, **, and *** for 10%, 5%, and 1%, respectively.

Data

  • Ethereum transaction fees (mean daily fees in USD) · Glassnode crypto-onchain public
    1 July 2020 to 14 November 2022 · Ethereum network
    Source sentence
    Transaction Fees on the Ethereum Blockchain We utilize Glassnode (Glassnode 2020) as our principal data source to acquire comprehensive time series data on transaction costs (fees) within the Ethereum network at daily intervals. The dataset covers the period from 1 July 2020 to 14 November 2022 and encompasses mean transaction fees in USD.
  • Economic system activity (unique active wallets and volume) · Flipside Crypto crypto-onchain public
    1 August to 1 November 2022 (weekly snap · Bridges, CEXs, DEXs, MEV bots, NFTs, Stablecoins
    Source sentence
    Underlying Economic Systems on the Ethereum Blockchain We utilized Flipside Crypto (Flipside Crypto 2023) as a data source to collect daily time series data on the economic systems within the Ethereum network. To achieve this, we developed and implemented custom application programming interfaces (APIs) for each distinct contract or address on the Ethereum blockchain defined in Table 1.
  • Proxy address labels for subsystems · Etherscan crypto-onchain public
    Bridge, CEX, DEX, MEV, NFT, Stablecoin contracts
    Source sentence
    Spe-cifically, we employed Etherscan’s Ethereum address labeling service, which facilitates the identifica-tion and classification of prominent actors on the Ethereum blockchain through the assignment of ac-count labels. For instance, a roster of all recognized bridges can be accessed through the account handle, “bridge” (Etherscan 2023a).
  • Weekly Ethereum network status · Etherscan, Dune Analytics, Glassnode, Flipside Crypto crypto-onchain public
    1 August to 1 November 2022 · Ethereum blockchain
    Source sentence
    For the initial step, Ethereum and blockchain data providers such as Etherscan (Etherscan 2023b), Dune Analytics (Dune Analytics 2023), Glassnode (Glassnode 2020), and Flipside Crypto (Flipside Crypto 2023) are utilized to analyze the Ethereum network’s status at regular one-week intervals be-tween 1 August and 1 November 2022. This analysis aims at identifying and documenting relevant markets, wallets, contracts,

Recognised sources: Glassnode Etherscan

Costs

Not applicable The paper reports no trading or execution result.

Finds 5

  • A bidirectional causal feedback loop exists between cross‑blockchain bridge activity and transaction fees, but its strength diminishes over time. statistical
    Source sentence
    This includes (a) a bidirectional causal feedback loop between cross-blockchain bridge user activity and transaction fees, which diminishes over time, potentially signaling user migration; (b) a bidirectional relationship between centralized cryptocurrency exchange deposit and withdrawal transaction volume and fees, indicative of increased competition for block space; (c) decentralized exchange volumes causally
  • Transaction fees and centralized exchange (CEX) deposit/withdrawal volumes exhibit strong bidirectional causality, indicating heightened competition for block space. statistical
    Source sentence
    This includes (a) a bidirectional causal feedback loop between cross-blockchain bridge user activity and transaction fees, which diminishes over time, potentially signaling user migration; (b) a bidirectional relationship between centralized cryptocurrency exchange deposit and withdrawal transaction volume and fees, indicative of increased competition for block space; (c) decentralized exchange volumes causally
  • Fees causally influence NFT activity and volume, while the reverse causal effect is weaker and less consistent. statistical
    Source sentence
    This includes (a) a bidirectional causal feedback loop between cross-blockchain bridge user activity and transaction fees, which diminishes over time, potentially signaling user migration; (b) a bidirectional relationship between centralized cryptocurrency exchange deposit and withdrawal transaction volume and fees, indicative of increased competition for block space; (c) decentralized exchange volumes causally
  • Transaction fees increasingly cause stablecoin activity and volume, and from Q2 2022 stablecoin activity also begins to cause fees, indicating emerging bidirectional causality. statistical figure from elsewhere in the paper
    Source sentence
    This includes (a) a bidirectional causal feedback loop between cross-blockchain bridge user activity and transaction fees, which diminishes over time, potentially signaling user migration; (b) a bidirectional relationship between centralized cryptocurrency exchange deposit and withdrawal transaction volume and fees, indicative of increased competition for block space; (c) decentralized exchange volumes causally
  • Overall, transaction fees serve as a significant causal determinant for nearly all investigated subsystems, though the direction and magnitude of causality evolve over time. statistical
    Source sentence
    The findings of this study indicate that transaction fees serve as a significant causal determinant for nearly all investigated subsystems, and the activity and volume of numerous subsystems causally influence overall network fees. Nevertheless, it is essential to recognize the dynamic character of cau-sality, which undergoes change over time and is plausibly attributable to various factors meriting addi-tional

Checked by others

No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 14 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.

Cited by 1 paper in the archive (1 by independent authors)

Code

No repository by the authors found in the paper.

Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.