Paper: arXiv 2611.19870

Authors: Takanori Adachi, Keisuke Hara

Abstract

This note develops a provisional admissibility framework for Aharonov-Bohm type arbitrage. Starting from a categorical filtration \(F:\mathcal T_{\mathrm{mic}}^{\mathrm{op}}\to \mathsf{Prob}\) and its distortion on microscopic histories, we ask when a favorable closed microscopic loop can be realized as an executable relative ordinal arbitrage over an open macro-time interval. The history endofunctor \(\mathsf{Hist}\) retains the staged decomposition of economic activities, while the twisted-arrow category \(\operatorname{Tw}(\mathsf{Hist}(\mathcal T_{\mathrm{mic}}))\) represents a microscopic loop as an arrow between distinct histories. An observable clock \(Π: \mathsf{Econ} \to \mathcal T_{\mathrm{mac}}\) and a microscopic realization functor \(J: \mathsf{Hist}(\mathcal T_{\mathrm{mac}}) \to \operatorname{Tw}(\mathsf{Hist}(\mathcal T_{\mathrm{mic}}))\) connect economic histories with their microscopic geometry. Executability is treated separately through configuration histories, capacity constraints, observations, and policies. This yields pathwise and almost-sure notions of execution. A finite foreign-exchange model illustrates stochastic execution, capacity failure, terminal settlement, and comparison with a benchmark strategy. A parameterized finite filtration is constructed whose nontrivial statewise distortion agrees exactly with the relative FX settlement multiplier. Hence the resulting filtration–policy model satisfies the bridge \(V_*(π^q)=dF(γ)V_*(π^p),\) and, under order compatibility, realizes relative ordinal arbitrage. The remaining problem is to identify the filtration parameters from independent market primitives and to study stability under refinement.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 9.0/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 3.0/10
  • Quadrant: Lab Rats — high math complexity, limited empirical testing

Why this score: This paper presents an extremely high level of mathematical abstraction, utilizing category theory and advanced concepts like twisted-arrow categories to define Aharonov-Bohm arbitrage. However, its empirical rigor is limited to a ‘finite foreign-exchange model’ as an axiom test, lacking real-world data, backtesting, or robust statistical validation. The novelty is high due to the unique application of these mathematical tools to finance.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
    A["Research Goal: Admissibility of Aharonov-Bohm Arbitrage"] --> B{"Key Methodology"};
    B --> C["Categorical Filtration F: T_mic^op -> Prob"];
    C --> D["Twisted-Arrow Category Tw(Hist(T_mic)) for Microscopic Loops"];
    D --> E["Realization Functor J & Observable Clock Π"];
    E --> F{"Executability Analysis"};
    F --> G["Pathwise & Almost-Sure Execution, Capacity Constraints"];
    G --> H["Finite Foreign-Exchange Model & Filtered Policy Model"];
    H --> I["Key Findings: Realizes Relative Ordinal Arbitrage, V*(π^q) = dF(γ)V*(π^p)"];
    I --> J["Future Work: Identify Filtration Parameters, Stability Analysis"];

Evidence Card

What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card

Proposes

The paper develops a provisional admissibility framework that links a geometric Aharonov‑Bohm‑type microscopic distortion to an executable relative ordinal arbitrage over a macro‑time interval, illustrated with a finite foreign‑exchange model.

Source sentence
This note develops a provisional admissibility framework for Aharonov-Bohm type arbitrage. A finite foreign-exchange model illustrates stochastic execution, capacity failure, terminal settlement, and comparison with a benchmark strategy.

Assumes 6

  • Two time categories are used: a microscopic category Tmic with a categorical filtration and a macroscopic category Tmac for observable dates. model
    Source sentence
    We use two time categories. The category Tmic carries the microscopic categorical filtration, whereas Tmac records the observable dates and intervals of economic activity.
  • The economic layer is a preorder‑enriched category Econ with an observable clock Π mapping to Tmac. model
    Source sentence
    The economic layer is described by a preorder-enriched category Econ, together with an observable clock Π : Econ →Tmac.
  • Five provisional admissibility conditions are required, including observable temporal compatibility, geometric realizability, predictable selection, executable and complete economic realization, and compatibility between other
    Source sentence
    These constructions lead to five provisional admissibility conditions: observable temporal compatibility, geometric realizability, predictable selection, executable and complete economic realization, and compatibility between microscopic distortion and economic comparison. The first four can be formulated using the categorical and execution data developed below.
  • A settlement bridge of the form V∗(πq)=dF(γ)V∗(πp) must hold and be compatible with the Econ hom‑preorder. model
    Source sentence
    For a benchmark policy πp and a candidate policy πq, one seeks an independently justified settlement bridge of the form V∗(πq) = dF(γ)V∗(πp), together with compatibility between settlement-value dominance and the hom-preorder of Econ. Under such a bridge, a geometric AB-arbitrage produces a relative ordinal arbitrage e(πp) ≺e(πq).
Show 2 more
  • The categorical filtration F does not assume that non‑trivial transport preserves the unit. model
    Source sentence
    In particular, we do not assume that a nontrivial transport preserves the unit. 5 A microscopic AB-loop is a history γ : m −→m in Hmic.
  • Economic histories must be executable from specified initial configurations and, for almost‑sure executability, a stochastic realization must be specified. execution
    Source sentence
    (A4) Executable and complete economic realization. The histories p, q : x0 →x1 have implementing policies executable from specified initial configurations under the convention of Section 8.

Data

No dataset named in the text.

Costs

Not applicable The paper reports no trading or execution result; the cost the extractor found is a model parameter.

The paper-text extraction found a cost parameter inside a model (All relevant costs—including bid‑ask spreads, transaction costs, financing, collateral, and settlement—are recorded in the economic assessment of activities.); the classifier found no reported trading result, so costs are not applicable.

Finds 5

  • A geometric AB‑arbitrage loop with dF(γ)≥1 (μ‑a.s.) and μ(dF(γ)>1)>0 yields a relative ordinal arbitrage p≺q under the admissibility conditions. theoretical
    Source sentence
    10 Proposition 7.2 (Formal consequence of admissibility). Let γ : m →m be a geometric AB-arbitrage.
  • The constructed finite FX model exhibits stochastic execution, capacity failure, and terminal settlement, and matches the statewise FX settlement ratios via the holonomy of a three‑leg microscopic loop. theoretical
    Source sentence
    A finite foreign-exchange model illustrates stochastic execution, capacity failure, terminal settlement, and comparison with a benchmark strategy. It makes the macro schedule, capacity constraints, observations, stochastic execution lifts, and terminal settlement explicit, and it exhibits a genuine capacity-failure event.
  • A parameterized finite filtration is built whose non‑trivial statewise distortion exactly equals the relative FX settlement multiplier, satisfying the bridge V∗(πq)=dF(γ)V∗(πp). theoretical
    Source sentence
    A parameterized finite filtration is constructed whose nontrivial statewise distortion agrees exactly with the relative FX settlement multiplier. Hence the resulting filtration--policy model satisfies the bridge $V_*(π^q)=dF(γ)V_*(π^p),$ and, under order compatibility, realizes relative ordinal arbitrage.
  • The realization functor J and the twisted‑arrow category Tw(Hmic) allow a closed microscopic loop to be represented as an open arrow, preserving the domain of dF while linking macro histories to microscopic geometry. theoretical
    Source sentence
    The category Tw(Hmic) therefore associates an open arrow canonically with every based microscopic loop. The remaining question is whether an observable macro-time history of an economic strategy can be realized by such an opening.
  • Executable and complete economic realization requires that histories p and q share interfaces and that the bridge implies dF(γ)≥1 ⇒ p⪯q and μ(dF(γ)>1)>0 ⇒ p≺q. theoretical
    Source sentence
    (A5) Benchmark compatibility and distortion realization. The histories p and q have the same economic interfaces, and the realization identifies the geometric relative multiplier with the economic advantage of q over p. At minimum, the independently constructed bridge should imply dF(γ) ≥1m =⇒ p ⪯q, (B1) and, when the weak inequality holds, µm �dF(γ) > 1m  > 0 =⇒ p ≺q.

Checked by others

No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 13 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.

Code

No repository by the authors found in the paper.

Extracted 2026-11-17 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.

Cited References (8)

  1. Aharanov-Bohm Type Arbitrage and Homological Obstructions in Financial Markets — → 2604.10492
  2. Kerodon , Section 8.1, “Twisted Arrows and Cospans (2018)
  3. Specify the readings available before each decision and the policies that act on those readings
  4. A3) Predictable selection
  5. Realize the macro history microscopically and construct the probability spaces and compatible stochastic execution variables
  6. Observable temporal compatibility
  7. Value fully settled terminal configurations and represent the policies economically
  8. Use execution lifts and failure events to test executability

1 of 8 cited works are in the corpus; resolved via arXiv source bundles, Semantic Scholar and OpenAlex. Corpus-wide: 2596 linked papers.